Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the school policy is outrageous?

91 replies

wonderstuff · 01/12/2021 19:05

Ds came home yesterday and told me he’d spent the day in isolation because he had forgotten his planner twice. Turns out he’d lost it. The planner is used to record times the kids have forgotten equipment or infringed uniform expectations.

Sent email to school as surely this was wrong, had my son intact sworn or been disruptive? School replied that it is indeed policy to isolate for a day for forgetting a planner twice.

I’m raging. All the missed schooling and they’re happy to exclude a child from more schooling for forgetting something. He’s very forgetful, I have adhd and suspect he has too, he’s not trying to be difficult or subvert the system. He’s in year 7.

I’ve been a teacher 20 years and never know isolation to be used for such a minor infringement. The same punishment for fighting and forgetting a book seems mad?

I’m not sure what to do, this is our local school, we live rurally so not many alternatives. I work at a great, inclusive school and could put him on the waiting list there but it’s 40 minutes away.

The school he’s had recently set for core subjects and he’s in bottom sets as well I’m worried this school is going to break him.

OP posts:
AmberArtichoke · 01/12/2021 21:20

This is my son's school - no more detentions and no isolation rooms, as they don't work and no one benefits. There are several children with SEN (ADHD / ASD) too who certainly didn't benefit from being 'punished'.

www.lythamstannes.news/news/top-fylde-independent-school-abolishes-detentions/?amp

Lady1576 · 01/12/2021 21:19

Totally disproportionate and wrong. Challenge it! It’s not just wrong for your child if they have adhd but for any child. I’m pretty sure I don’t have adhd but I was always forgetful and never wanted to be! It was never deliberate or thoughtless - just something my brain couldn’t get around.

fourminutestosavetheworld · 01/12/2021 21:16

I agree that it's a harsh punishment but presume all of the kids understand that this is the consequence for forgetting a planner twice. Surely he was told this when he forgot it the first time?

Instead of being livid with the school why not put your energies into supporting your son to remember what he needs each morning? A list on his bedroom door, a big reminder on the door he leaves the house by, or you could remind him? He is going to need strategies and that would be more useful than showing him that you are furious with them for enforcing this policy.

I don't think it's discriminatory if he isn't on their SEN register, hasn't got a diagnosis and hasn't started the referral process.

NessieMcNessface · 01/12/2021 21:15

I support very clear rules and sanctions but this is certainly a step too far! The school I worked in would have issued a detention, but whole day isolations were reserved for more serious behaviours such as refusing to comply, or using inappropriate language.

Santaischeckinglists · 01/12/2021 21:11

I removed ds in May.. Apparently 18 hours in isolation over 3 days was acceptable.. Took him out on day 2 and he never went back..
In a new school awaiting adhd /autism referral.

DrCoconut · 01/12/2021 21:06

It's nonsense and makes things worse for children with additional needs. DS1 had completely disengaged from school by year 11 and left with next to no qualifications. He didn't really settle at college because his experience of education was so tainted and he's now NEET other than some voluntary work for a local charity. That is my least worry really, as long as his improved mental health stays that way I'm happy. He has a diagnosis of autism and the removal of pressure to fit in, go places, do things etc has been an unexpected godsend from covid.

BlankTimes · 01/12/2021 21:00

Why can't they? Serious question

Because schools would be asked to make provisions for all sorts of things for children based only on their parents' concerns.

Some parents would be correct in the interventions they requested, but some would be way off beam. How cold school tell?

Mamajunebugjones · 01/12/2021 20:59

Is this something you could raise with the school governors? Isolation is an extreme form of punishment.

Other public bodies eg mental health, police / judiciary have to make sure their responses are proportional due to human rights infringements.

Why should schools be any different? If you don’t get any joy from school head or governors about their use of isolation- I would raise with your local MP

AmberArtichoke · 01/12/2021 20:57

Pull him out. Simple. Schools shouldn't be using isolation rooms these days. They need to review their behaviour policy urgently.

Notmoresugar · 01/12/2021 20:54

Why don't you put him on the waiting list to go to your school; you go there everyday anyway and it sounds far more suitable for him?

Doublevodka · 01/12/2021 20:53

I think that’s is far too harsh. If you think he has ADHD definitely pursue a diagnosis. My daughter was diagnosed at 15. No amount of isolation, detentions or punishment made the slightest difference to her ability to remember, organise, time manage, not lose things and still wouldn’t. She tries really hard too but it is extremely difficult to manage. Meds help but only with focusing on particular tasks. I feel so sad for you son that he is being punished for something he potentially really really cannot help.

Melroses · 01/12/2021 20:47

if they accidentally on purpose lose their planner then the evidence for their misdemeanours is lost.

LOL - in my day they would have been forged, altered, never mind lost lol🤣

ViceLikeBlip · 01/12/2021 20:47

It's 2021 - what schools are still using planners?!!

But more seriously- I'm a teacher, and I hate bullshit like this. Like you say, a severe punishment like isolation should be reserved for something with malicious intent. I know some people are huge believers in "zero tolerance" policies, but I'm a big believer in being kind to children 🤷‍♀️

CurlyhairedAssassin · 01/12/2021 20:38

Sounds very harsh. And unfair. My kids' school did away with planners during the pandemic, think they saw them as a COVID risk if teachers had to touch multiple kids' planners. It's not changed anything, and probably saved school a lot of money every year.

Your son's school has probably gone down this harsh route because kids have got wise to the fact that if they accidentally on purpose lose their planner then the evidence for their misdemeanours is lost.There are better online ways for teachers to record behaviour system infringements, and they are better for informing parents too. Plus, in some schools where behaviour is a real problem, kids don't get penalised if someone in the class takes their planner to get them on trouble on purpose. (Sadly, this does happen in some school, particularly to the less streetwise or self-assured kids).

That said, if you knew there was such an emphasis on planners and you knew your son had some organisational problems, why didn't you do your utmost to help him with a routine to make sure he had it every day? And give him advice about always keeping it in his bag apart from when he is writing in it, and putting it back in his bag immediately afterwards?

If this were me, though, and you think the behaviour system could do with changing a bit, I would email the head of year and express my thoughts (in a reasonable manner) that you view isolation as a bit harsh for forgetting a planner. I bet you any money the heads of year would agree with youuf they could, and this is isolation punishemnt is something dreamed up by SLT......But if enough reasonable and supportive parents (not ranty) email in, SLT can't ignore and may think of a better alternative.

bizboz · 01/12/2021 20:37

My DC's secondary school is like this. Really strict on uniform and equip but still don't seem to have a grip on recurrent bad behaviour in lessons. I have voiced my feelings but they were ignored. Sadly no other schools with spaces that would be practical to get to.

TatianaBis · 01/12/2021 20:32

40 minutes is nothing OP, I’d do it in a heartbeat.

Some boys are a bit all over the place whether ADHD or not. They need support not isolation.

MrsKDB · 01/12/2021 20:32

I know two schools like this, one in Bristol one in Sheffield. Totally OTT on the isolation / punishments. There are yr 7 children already suffering from increased anxiety as a result. Think triple detention in week one of their secondary education for forgetting an exercise book or a ruler.

I’d put him on the waiting list for your school and move him. Environments like this are not good for learning.

silkience · 01/12/2021 20:32

To me it seems excessive but I assume you knew the behaviour policy when you signed him up? I don't think you can moan about it now

Six posts in and it already starts!

Why the fuck do people trot this out like there is actually a choice when it comes to going to school?'

  • school is compulsory- if child doesn't go you are breaking the law and can go to prison - fact!
  • good luck getting a place at a school out of catchment unless it's graded inadequate
  • if you exercise your right to "choose" and go out of area the cost of travel can run into thousands so it's yet another "choice" that is the privilege of the wealthy
Drunkpanda · 01/12/2021 20:30

My dc has adhd and to be honest I have to be in charge of filling the schoolbag at night, or it won't be done.
OP do you think you might have the money for a private diagnosis? (Between £1 and 2 thousand where I live).
The 40 min drive to your school isn't really an issue since you would do it too, but the being apart from friends might be.

TheCallerWithheldTheirNumber · 01/12/2021 20:29

@gofg

Wow, things have changed since my school days (admittedly many decades ago!). What happened to punishments such as detention and lines? It sounds ridiculously harsh for such a minor misdemeanor Shock
@gofg what happened to detention is that it was re-branded as "activities" or "after school care". If you're trying to convince children that staying after school is somehow exciting and fun, and offering this as a great service to parents, you shoot yourself in the foot when it comes to trying to impose a detention on a pupil.
tsmainsqueeze · 01/12/2021 20:29

Totally over the top .
I can't get my head around some schools policies , how to put a kid off education in one easy step !
I hate these types of petty rules , i think i would look at the other school , if your lad is a square peg in a round hole he will never thrive where he is.
Why on earth would a school of all places assume everyone is the same and that making a simple mistake is unacceptable .
I have gone in to school only once to complain,a teacher was in the wrong and i stood up for my child .
I would be going in for your reasons too , may be if they listen to you they may treat your son with a bit more understanding and in time make the school a better fit for him.

TheCallerWithheldTheirNumber · 01/12/2021 20:27

That sounds like a ridiculous policy for this particular "crime" (regardless of ADHD or not, and it seems as if pretty much every child mentioned on MN either has or is suspected of having additional needs). I would question with the school whether it will actually achieve what they hope it will. My guess is that it would tend to demotivate Year 7s, who then become really annoying Year 8s and 9s (which are annoying year groups anyway).

I'm not sure what your point is about your DS being in the bottom sets, though. Are these the right sets for him? If so, you can't really complain. If not, the school exams will presumably demonstrate that he should be in a higher set. Not all children can be in the top sets.

gofg · 01/12/2021 20:24

Wow, things have changed since my school days (admittedly many decades ago!). What happened to punishments such as detention and lines? It sounds ridiculously harsh for such a minor misdemeanor Shock

BungleandGeorge · 01/12/2021 20:24

The reason that schools give for not assessing and screening for SEN is that they don’t need a diagnosis to obtain help and that measures are based on need and not diagnosis. Can’t have that both ways!
There seems to be a craze for schools introducing these sort of extreme policies. If you’re rural it’s not as if you have a huge choice so there’s no point in saying if you don’t agree you shouldn’t have sent them there! I’d pull him out tbh, he’s only year 7 it will get worse over the years. Schools that use these tactics usually make no allowances for SEN

pointythings · 01/12/2021 20:20

Secondary schools in the UK are just going completely batshit crazy. I have friends with teens in various European countries and they are amazed - not in a good way - when I tell them how things are in many schools over here. I'm so glad my local secondary is proportionate and sensible and that my kids are now out of the system because it's insane. I hate the assumption that kids are inherently bad and must therefore be treated harshly for the slightest thing.