Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DD's friend needing new underwear

137 replies

smilingthroughgrittedteeth · 01/12/2021 18:32

Putting this here for traffic as i need a quick reply.

DD age 4 made friends with a little girl the first day of reception and they have been firm friends ever since. This little girl comes from a family that are really struggling for money, her mum has confided in me about how hard they are finding things financially after she lost her Job during the first lockdown and various other reasons. We have invited this little girl over for tea several times, tonight being one of them, DD has just come to me and said friend has told her that her knickers are digging in and asked if its ok friend takes them off. Having spoken to friend it turns out her knickers are way to small and she has nasty red marks where they have dug in apparently mummy says they cant buy her new ones until daddy gets paid (I have no idea when this is)

Dad will be here to collect any time now on his way home from work, would i be unreasonable to put DD's knickers (new a week ago and clean) in to a bag and say she has outgrown them so would they be any use? I can go and buy DD some new ones tomorrow. Id happily buy this little girl new ones but i cant get to the shops until tomorrow and that would mean she would have to wear small ones that dig in again tomorrow. I am 99% certain mum and dad wouldnt be offended and if it was any other item of clothing i wouldnt think twice but is it really grim to gift used knickers even if they are fairly new and clean. Also i dont have cash in the house so i cant give cash and tell dad to stop at the shops on the way home.

YABU just buy her new ones tomorrow one more day in small ones wont hurt her.

YANBU gift her DD's old (new ones) so she can be comfortable

DD is the same size as her and friend is wearing size 3-4, DD is in 5-6 so DD's would definitely fit her better.

OP posts:
MrsSkylerWhite · 01/12/2021 20:02

Not sure. If you do, please make it clothing generally, not just underwear, bit too obvious.

SaltedCaramelIcedLatte · 01/12/2021 20:02

You sound absolutely lovely OP and it's a shame there aren't more people as thoughtful as you

flymetothezoo · 01/12/2021 20:01

@Fridafever

At 4 of course you might need to see their underwear! DS’ friend wet himself on a play date here when he was nearly 6. What should I have done?
But the OP is swearing blind that she didn't see the child's underwear.
flymetothezoo · 01/12/2021 20:00

@echt she has described the child as wearing size 3-4 knickers yet has also claimed that she hasn't looked at the child's knickers. That was my point. I've no idea what your point is.

itsgettingwierd · 01/12/2021 20:00

You sound lovely.

I think people who've never been in that situation where it's a choice of bread and milk or a £1 pack of new pants just don't get it.

Those who do really appreciate the kindness and compassion of others (in most cases I know not everyone's the same).

I've been at both ends and I now try and help those in need having been the one grateful for any donations!

RosieLemonadeAndSugar · 01/12/2021 19:59

Little girls friends* mom

Fridafever · 01/12/2021 19:59

At 4 of course you might need to see their underwear! DS’ friend wet himself on a play date here when he was nearly 6. What should I have done?

echt · 01/12/2021 19:59

@flymetothezoo

"DD is the same size as her and friend is wearing size 3-4"

wearing

I think you are well intentioned but you would be wide open to allegations if you keep changing your story like this.

Just stay away from this child and her underwear. Report to agencies if you are concerned.

The OP has not changed her story. The 3-4 are the tiny knickers, the 5-6 worn by her same size DD.
MakingTheBestOfIt · 01/12/2021 19:59

You did a lovely thing OP. I’ll always remember my Mum giving my brother’s nearly-new shoes to his friend because they were “too small”. I was about to say that we only bought them a few weeks ago but she shot me a Look so I kept quiet.

Much later (as an adult) I reminded her of this and she said DB’s friend’s family had a long run of bad luck and DB would often ‘outgrow’ his nearly new clothes. I do hope they never realised she was doing it to help them out. She had nothing but respect for them as a family.

RosieLemonadeAndSugar · 01/12/2021 19:59

The OP CLEARLY just guessed that the age 3-4 pair in the bag were going to be the same size as what she was wearing.

Honestly can't a nice deed on Mumsnet ever be just that without people questioning!!

If it was a small top would anyone be questioning!?

Well done OP. Your little girls mom is very lucky to have a friend like you.

smilingthroughgrittedteeth · 01/12/2021 19:57

Your right it doesnt prove that they were the same size but from what i saw on her hip the ones she was wearing were digging in, that may very well be because she had pulled them up twisted rather than them being to small i wouldnt know since i didnt look but the fact she told me mummy said she would buy bigger ones when daddy gets paid makes me think they probably were. My aibu was based on whether passing on used knickers was acceptable like passing on outgrown trousers or whether it was a real no no.

OP posts:
echt · 01/12/2021 19:57

I think the mixed bag of clothes is a good way forward, and avoids the safeguarding issues.

I was given clothes by parents of a couple of friends when I was younger and my family was poor. They were always "she's grown out of them", and I was and am grateful for their tactful charity.

You're a good person, smilingthroughgrittedteeth

flymetothezoo · 01/12/2021 19:55

"DD is the same size as her and friend is wearing size 3-4"

wearing

I think you are well intentioned but you would be wide open to allegations if you keep changing your story like this.

Just stay away from this child and her underwear. Report to agencies if you are concerned.

Hairyfairy01 · 01/12/2021 19:55

I have received used knickers for my DD (in good condition) along with other clothing before. Times were hard at the time, I was very grateful and not offended at all.

crazymare20 · 01/12/2021 19:55

My daughters best friends mother is vulnerable and never has much money. I always buy her daughter clothes and offer them to mum saying I’ve ordered online for mine and don’t fit and now missed time to send them back. I’m sure she’s realised now that it isn’t the case with the amount I’ve given her over the past few years but she is always great full and I would hate to think she has to go with out as me and my family are very fond of her.

flymetothezoo · 01/12/2021 19:53

@smilingthroughgrittedteeth

I just want to be very clear again that no underwear was removed she went home in the knickers she was wearing
Yes, you claimed that was the case later on after you posted the OP.

You also claimed that you KNOW the ones she were wearing were age 3-4 because the spares in her bag were that size. That doesn't prove the ones she was wearing were age 3-4 at all.

HikingforScenery · 01/12/2021 19:51

I wouldn’t give her your daughter’s used knickers.

Clymene · 01/12/2021 19:51

@JessicaPipsqueak

I think I'd have slight concerns over a parent putting a child in underwear small enough to be A leaving red welts and B hurting the child. I get that times may be very hard indeed but a 5 pack of knickers from any supermarket / Primark is a couple of pounds.

And I'm sure you'll now say that this family don't have a single penny but underwear that's not cutting in is a basic requirement so I'd argue that the parents weren't meeting the basic needs of the child right now

However I'd have done what you have. I'd have put in enough pants to cover a week and any other bits and pieces and said I was charity shopping these bits but thought they may like to have a look and keep what they want and feel free to pass anything not wanted on. Something like that

This really isn't neglect.

When you're living in poverty, every 'couple of pounds' is difficult. If you have to choose between giving your children dinner or leaving them in pants that are a bit tight, you're going to feed them.

smilingthroughgrittedteeth · 01/12/2021 19:49

I just want to be very clear again that no underwear was removed she went home in the knickers she was wearing

OP posts:
BiscuitLover3679 · 01/12/2021 19:49

I'd be honest. So and so her knickers were digging in. Here are some others. No harm done.

Mandy63l · 01/12/2021 19:47

Sorry I think you misunderstood - I meant that, at that age, the child could have had an accident whilst in the care of the OP, and needed to change as a result. She may have undergone safer recruitment practices in her employment, who knows, but as the adult with responsibility for the friend at that time, would it not be most appropriate to do what’s possible to make the little girl comfortable, even if that involves offering a change of underwear, whether that’s because they’re too small, because of a fault with them, because they’d been soiled or whatever else?

JessicaPipsqueak · 01/12/2021 19:45

I think I'd have slight concerns over a parent putting a child in underwear small enough to be A leaving red welts and B hurting the child. I get that times may be very hard indeed but a 5 pack of knickers from any supermarket / Primark is a couple of pounds.

And I'm sure you'll now say that this family don't have a single penny but underwear that's not cutting in is a basic requirement so I'd argue that the parents weren't meeting the basic needs of the child right now

However I'd have done what you have. I'd have put in enough pants to cover a week and any other bits and pieces and said I was charity shopping these bits but thought they may like to have a look and keep what they want and feel free to pass anything not wanted on. Something like that

flymetothezoo · 01/12/2021 19:43

@Mandy63l

I also get the caution from some quarters around safeguarding, but we’re talking about a little girl who is 4 years old and in some discomfort due to something that an adult who currently has responsibility for her can fix - surely not helping her to be more comfortable would be worse?

At 4, in reception, it’s not beyond the realms that she could have an accident, for instance. What then, would it still be inappropriate to allow her to change her underwear? Would leaving her uncomfortable in soiled clothing be preferable to offering her something to change into so she’s not in discomfort?

The people in the situations you hypothetically describe would have been subject to Safer Recruitment practices which - although not infallible - provide some form of protection to the child in question.

I am just trying to explain to the OP that her actions, which sound well-meaning, could easily be seen in a different light.

OP recognises the child is vulnerable, invites her round weekly, next thing the child's underwear has been removed - was it returned to the parent, btw? Because if not it could look as though you've disposed of it which is a red flag in itself.

There are agencies that can help, the school for one, in a safe and boundaried way.

This approach puts OP at risk.

smilingthroughgrittedteeth · 01/12/2021 19:43

@ftw163532

Or for her to see this thread re-published on some trashy news site.
Thats a good point im happy for the thread to be removed although i know the mum isnt on here as we have discussed MN before and she said the couple of times she looked on here she found it a bit to scary so she hasnt been back 🤣
OP posts:
Mandy63l · 01/12/2021 19:42

@bevelino

I am sure OP means well but if I were the mother of the friend and read this thread I would not be happy that OP was discussing this on the internet.
If I was the mother of the friend, stumbled across this thread and made the connection, I think I’d be genuinely touched that my DD’s friends mum had gone to so much trouble to try and spare my feelings and not offend me, whilst at the same time cares so much for my DD.

Honestly this shows the OP and her DD in such a good light. I’d be making an effort to become more friendly with her, because she’s clearly a lovely person with a very kind heart.