Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DD's friend needing new underwear

137 replies

smilingthroughgrittedteeth · 01/12/2021 18:32

Putting this here for traffic as i need a quick reply.

DD age 4 made friends with a little girl the first day of reception and they have been firm friends ever since. This little girl comes from a family that are really struggling for money, her mum has confided in me about how hard they are finding things financially after she lost her Job during the first lockdown and various other reasons. We have invited this little girl over for tea several times, tonight being one of them, DD has just come to me and said friend has told her that her knickers are digging in and asked if its ok friend takes them off. Having spoken to friend it turns out her knickers are way to small and she has nasty red marks where they have dug in apparently mummy says they cant buy her new ones until daddy gets paid (I have no idea when this is)

Dad will be here to collect any time now on his way home from work, would i be unreasonable to put DD's knickers (new a week ago and clean) in to a bag and say she has outgrown them so would they be any use? I can go and buy DD some new ones tomorrow. Id happily buy this little girl new ones but i cant get to the shops until tomorrow and that would mean she would have to wear small ones that dig in again tomorrow. I am 99% certain mum and dad wouldnt be offended and if it was any other item of clothing i wouldnt think twice but is it really grim to gift used knickers even if they are fairly new and clean. Also i dont have cash in the house so i cant give cash and tell dad to stop at the shops on the way home.

YABU just buy her new ones tomorrow one more day in small ones wont hurt her.

YANBU gift her DD's old (new ones) so she can be comfortable

DD is the same size as her and friend is wearing size 3-4, DD is in 5-6 so DD's would definitely fit her better.

OP posts:
smilingthroughgrittedteeth · 02/12/2021 13:44

Mum was embarrassed friend had told me she wasnt embarrassed about being passed on clothes

OP posts:
smilingthroughgrittedteeth · 02/12/2021 13:39

I spoke to the mum at drop off this morning and she said that friend had mentioned she had told me her knickers were hurting her, she was embarrassed and said she was waiting for dad to get paid next week to buy new ones and really appreciated the gift of dd's old ones, i just said it was no problem and changed the subject. I popped to the shops straight after and bought DD some identical ones which ive cut the labels out of and put in her drawer so she will be unaware and not accidentally mention it to anyone causing any embarrassment to friend or parents.

I have a younger daughter too so a lot of DD's clothes get passed down to her, they are total opposites though with DD1 being ultra girly and DD2 being a complete tomboy so friend is passed all the girly things my DD2 refuses to wear, its interesting to read people saying they dont pass clothes on as in my circle of friends its very normal and i dont think twice about passing clothes along i just have never passed on or recieved underwear apart from as spares to preschool.

OP posts:
EmeraldShamrock · 02/12/2021 13:13

You're very thoughtful.

Times are really tough for lots of families.

Buying new might be a grey area.

ShrinkingViolet9 · 02/12/2021 13:09

@flymetothezoo

"DD is the same size as her and friend is wearing size 3-4"

wearing

I think you are well intentioned but you would be wide open to allegations if you keep changing your story like this.

Just stay away from this child and her underwear. Report to agencies if you are concerned.

I see you posted the above, too.

There was no "change of story".

Why on earth should the OP "stay away from this child" and "report to agencies if [she is] concerned" in preference to a simple act of kindness towards her daughter's friend?

NovemberNovemberDarkNights · 02/12/2021 13:02

@smilingthroughgrittedteeth

I think 'in general' people feel ok about second hand childrens underwear, but I imagine most people would be fine with it, it's not the same as adults.

Anyway, her mum seems to be grateful for your help. 💐

Lilolily · 02/12/2021 12:45

If I was the mum (or kid in question) I would be so so grateful. Sensitively handled and just plain lovely 😊

ShrinkingViolet9 · 02/12/2021 12:42

And don't let visiting children remove their underwear in your home.

So you'd prefer to let a young child sit in wet or dirty pants until she was collected?

Bookworm20 · 02/12/2021 12:42

You did the right thing and including other clothes too would not have singled out the knickers issue.

When my dds were little we went through a very bad financial patch and a friend gave me a bag of clothes her older DD had outgrown. It included knickers and socks etc. I was very grateful and had no issue using the underwear, it had all been washed and was perfectly fine. And very much appreciated at a time when money was very very tight.

MarshmallowSwede · 02/12/2021 12:41

I just want to say OP how kind this is for you to do this. There are so many families struggling right now and many are really not able to have friends or extended family help them. It is really kind and a really wonderfully nice thing to do for this family that are trying to do their best.

This is a very lovely example of how small acts of kindness can make a huge impact on those who might be in a less than ideal place in their life.

mincepiesallround · 02/12/2021 12:21

Gosh I’ve lost track of the number of times my DD and her friends have come/gone home from play dates in each other’s clothes, including pants. Less so now they’re 7/8 but certainly at age 4!

OP thank you for being a kind and thoughtful person, YANBU at all. One of the local charities I support did an appeal not long ago specifically for underwear, kids wearing too small/no underwear being a huge problem.

ShrinkingViolet9 · 02/12/2021 12:15

@flymetothezoo

I keep returning to this thread as I used to be in a role that required a high degree of awareness of children's safeguarding.

I think it's a safeguarding issue if the child's underwear is hurting her and you should probably speak to the school if concerned. And don't let visiting children remove their underwear in your home.

I absolutely get that this is all coming from a good place but you sound very naive. This family's financial problems aren't for you to solve, you need to signpost them to agencies that can support them effectively.

You sound as cold as ice.

So you've never passed on bags of no longer needed children's clothing to friends, relatives, neighbours or acquaintances?

You've never had a toddler or a 3 to 4 year old have an "accident" or unexpected tummy upset whilst playing at your house that required the provision of a spare pair of pants?

Are you suggesting that if a child is visiting someone else's home and were to complain, for example, that her welly boots were too tight and hurting her but her mummy can't buy new ones for a week or two, that her school should be informed about a potential safeguarding issue?

As kids in the 50s and 60s, we wore a mixture of new and second hand clothing. Friends and aunties would pass bags of grown out of clothing between themselves. No-one thought anything of it.

We lived in a village 5 and 7 miles from the nearest towns for clothing and shoe shops. I can remember very occasionally wearing shoes that pinched for a week or two before we could get into town on a Saturday (on the bus, as we had no car) to be fitted for a new pair of Clarks shoes.

Is wearing underwear that is a little tight for a couple weeks really a red flag for raising a safeguarding issue with a child's school?

stuckinarut21 · 01/12/2021 20:34

V kind OP. Well done x

Cellobear · 01/12/2021 20:33

My god what is the world coming too when people are giving the OP the 3rd degree about helping put a child in need. She clearly said multiple times that the child stayed in her uncomfortable undies OP was just trying to make sure the child was more comfortable tomorrow. I think it's incredibly kind and I would hope that most people would do the same thing (but reading some of these comments it's depressing).

georgarina · 01/12/2021 20:31

Just rtft. Well done OP! Nice thoughtful gesture.

OutwiththeOutCrowd · 01/12/2021 20:31

I think this was a thoughtful gesture. Another possibility with minimal risk of causing embarrassment - you could look out for 3 for 2/bogof type deals on girl's clothes and pass on something to DD's friend that way.

When my DS was that age, I'd get bags of old clothes, including underwear, given to me by a friend with a same age but slightly larger DS. It didn't make me feel like a charity case. I was just grateful to have the clothes.

georgarina · 01/12/2021 20:29

YANBU!!

I grew up neglected and this type of kindness would have been so so so appreciated by me.

Mum is unlikely to be offended, she will probably be grateful.

NotMyDayJob · 01/12/2021 20:26

I have a four year old OP and this makes me want to cry. You are a lovely, kind person

canyoutoleratethis · 01/12/2021 20:25

OP, ignore @flymetothezoo who is being some kind of mad pedant. You’ve done a lovely thing, and have done it carefully and respectfully, with real thought, and it makes me feel happy that there are people like you in the world!

Pawprintpaper · 01/12/2021 20:24

Not sure what the issue is with second hand clean pants… we got through loads when potty training. Do people get upset with using a hotel towel, must have been near loads of strangers bottoms?

Lemonysherbet · 01/12/2021 20:16

Op you're a wonderful person

smilingthroughgrittedteeth · 01/12/2021 20:09

flymetothezoo i didnt see the underwear she was wearing i have been very clear on that i saw a spare pair in a bag and a red mark on the childs hip, i am assuming the pair she was wearing are the same size as the pair in the bag but i obviously cant be 100% certain as i didnt look. Nothing inappropriate happened you just seem to be determined to make it sound like it did, im going to chose to believe you are just offering me advice from concern rather than that you are accusing me of anything and assure you that after many many years doing the job i do that i am always using good safeguarding practices when with other peoples children!

OP posts:
Terminallysleepdeprived · 01/12/2021 20:07

You did a lovely thing OP and I am sure the family appreciate it.

My dd has a friend who's family have also had a very rough tome through covid. I have done similar and passed on clothes that dd had outgrown and a few brand new ones that I "found" buried in the back of the wardrobe and have bought some cheap packs of pants from asda to pass on. I regularly clear out dd's bits as she grows faster than clothes wear out so it isn't unusual for there to be brand new items.

It doesn't hurt to be kind

echt · 01/12/2021 20:07

[quote flymetothezoo]**@echt* she has described the child as wearing* size 3-4 knickers yet has also claimed that she hasn't looked at the child's knickers. That was my point. I've no idea what your point is.[/quote]
She saw the size of knickers in the spares she brought with her.

She had a bag of spare clothes which i looked in and saw the spare ones were a 3-4

Paddingtonthebear · 01/12/2021 20:05

I would message her mum and say you are having a clear out and have some bits that might fit her DD, would she like them? I think she is likely to say yes, I’ve passed on clothes to friends before with younger kids and they are happy to have them and they have more money than we do! I would then buy some new pants and put them in a bag with anything else you have at home that might fit. I wouldn’t mention what her DD said.

echt · 01/12/2021 20:03

[quote flymetothezoo]**@echt* she has described the child as wearing* size 3-4 knickers yet has also claimed that she hasn't looked at the child's knickers. That was my point. I've no idea what your point is.[/quote]
You didn't make that point in your post. Hence mine.