Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Aibu to be horrified at the thought of mandatory vaccinations

294 replies

TracyLords · 01/12/2021 15:51

I’m not anti vax. I’ve had my jabs and will get booster this week.

There have been countries in the EU insisting on mandatory vaccination: this concerns me: surely it is up to the individual to decide to get vaccinated (or otherwise)

OP posts:
Chocaholic9 · 02/12/2021 10:50

I believe in bodily autonomy. We should be able to choose whether we will have a medical procedure or not. I think it's going down a dark path if we do not allow people to choose.

Chocaholic9 · 02/12/2021 10:48

YANBU.

Angel2702 · 02/12/2021 10:41

Ordinarily yes, but if it’s a choice between lockdown and compulsory vaccines, both of which impede our freedom I would choose compulsory vaccine which affects the freedom of a few rather than compulsory lockdown for all.

TheReluctantPhoenix · 02/12/2021 10:39

@YungWaffle,

Well the consequences if no one took up the vaccine are very knowable: they would be devastating.

And the amount of taxes we pay these days are unprecedented. Go back 100 years, and taxes were a tiny fraction of what they are today, as was the state’s control over our lives.

The vast majority of people, even in my lifetime, would have been horrified at the size of the state budget, the redistribution of wealth, and the way we are constantly monitored.

The reality is, if the vaccine is mandated, within a few years, it will just be an accepted part of normal life, in the same way speed cameras, seat belts, constant CCTV surveillance etc are today.

brighousepres · 02/12/2021 10:29

Mandatory vaccination won’t end this mess though will it?

It isn’t stopping transmission either and we have to have vaccines pretty regularly…

It’s illogical to enforce something that is already ineffective.

The thought of being MADE to have a vaccine makes me very uneasy.

I came to a decision to have the vaccines because I didn’t want to die and didn’t want family members to die… it’s only (briefly) helpful with one of those but that’s just the way it is.

If the government is going to make me have it - it’s suddenly much less appealing and benign seeming! NO BLOODY THANKS!

Fuuuuuckit · 02/12/2021 10:23

There are plenty of countries you can’t travel to without having had certain vaccinations. Plenty of jobs where certain vaccinations are compulsory.

I know 2 doctors who have gladly had mandatory vaccines for their job and voluntary vaccines for exotic travel now refusing the covid vaccine despite being frontline for the last 2 years.

Yes I do judge their capacity to practice when their actions defy what they've spent a decade in training and 10 years in practice.

YungWaffle · 02/12/2021 10:21

Sometimes, based on a democratic vote, we give up our individual freedoms in order to benefit society.

We also draw lines on what freedoms we give up. You could make a good argument about mandatory abortion or sterilisations for all sorts of groups, but we generally draw a line and look derisively at countries that have gone down that route.
Mandating an injection is mandating an invasive medical procedure. If this thread is reflective at all, even most people who have been vaccinated would not vote for vaccines to be mandatory (myself included).
Taxes are probably the worst example you could have used. Taxes are mandated by the state and the state cannot exist without mandating taxation (becaus people will not give freely).
The truth is, you don't know whether they are "detrimental to you". You do not know what your day to day life would be like if the people around you didn't have access to free education and subsidised public transport. You don't know what it would be like if you had a private, profit-driven police force to deal with.
The implications and interactions stemming from taxation are much more complex than those from vaccination, but ultimately you pay taxes because you do not want to be surrounded by desperate people. That would be detrimental.

MrsFin · 02/12/2021 10:13

I am pro vaccine, but anti compulsion too.

But I do think there should be consequences for not having the vaccine (any vaccine, not just Covid). ie, no access to certain places or events, children not allowed to go to school if not vaccinated, maybe not covered by NHS if you actually get the disease (need medical insurance), not prioritised if ill over people with other serious illnesses etc.

Sloth66 · 02/12/2021 10:13

The vaccine is not guaranteed to stop anyone getting Covid. There are side effects. But people who’ve had it, are statistically far less likely to need hospital admission, and become seriously ill.

MyDcAreMarvel · 02/12/2021 10:05

Yabu I am horrified that people can choose to cause the deaths of others with zero consequences. Either someone contracting covid from them. Or more likely someone dying because no intensive care bed is available to them, or an ambulance doesn’t come in time as it’s taken up with someone unvaccinated with covid.
Tell me how much you believe in free choice when your relative dies due to preventable lack of nhs treatment available.

Rainbowsew · 02/12/2021 10:01

[quote TracyLords]@Waxonwaxoff0 that’s it! I considered the risks and benefits and decided to take the vaccination. I’ll be honest and say I think anyone not taking it is being a bit silly in my opinion. But I don’t think that the state should have the right to vaccinate people against their will[/quote]
Absolutely agree with you

TheReluctantPhoenix · 02/12/2021 09:35

@IHateFlies,

Well I have paid A LOT of taxes in my llifetime. I have not used anything like that amount of state aid, so I can categorically say they are detrimental to me!

That is kind of the point of taxes. They take from those able to pay more and give to those who need to receive more. They are an averaging mechanism, not a wealth creation mechanism.

And, talking about trust diminution, enriching Boris et al's cronies is certainly diminishing my trust on how public money is spent.

In the same way, I could, were I a healthy 19 year old, say the vaccine was (v slightly) detrimentally to me personally. But I would take it to benefit everyone else.

The equation (or, in the case of a vaccine, more like inequality) is pretty simple. Sometimes, based on a democratic vote, we give up our individual freedoms in order to benefit society.

Sloth66 · 02/12/2021 09:20

A friend worked in an ITU full of patients who had chosen not to be vaccinated.
It sounded horrific, and she has now left.

IHateFlies · 02/12/2021 09:14

How are taxes detrimental to the individual? If you add up everything you get from taxes, like healthcare, policing, street lights, libraries, defence and so on, it’s a huge benefit.
Vaccines are a huge benefit too. What you’re seeing is a diminish in trust. They trust in established vaccines.
If this was a vaccine that was eradicating covid, or covid was highly dangerous to all there would be more trust in it.

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 02/12/2021 09:13

[quote TheReluctantPhoenix]@daimbarsatemydogsbone,

That it is a total cop out.

Both taxes and vaccines are something which, whilst maybe detrimental to the individual are a boon to society.

Whether it is a ‘medical procedure’ or a ‘financial procedure’ is pretty irrelevant.[/quote]
Utter bollocks. They are very different.

TheReluctantPhoenix · 02/12/2021 08:53

@daimbarsatemydogsbone,

That it is a total cop out.

Both taxes and vaccines are something which, whilst maybe detrimental to the individual are a boon to society.

Whether it is a ‘medical procedure’ or a ‘financial procedure’ is pretty irrelevant.

wingingit987 · 02/12/2021 08:42

I'm not 100% sure about the COVID vaccine being mandatory but I do believe all Children’s vaccines should be a parent shouldn't be able to decide if their child has a vaccine or not.

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 02/12/2021 08:40

@TheReluctantPhoenix

So, should taxes be mandatory or voluntary?

In my (obviously expert) analysis, I would be so much better off personally and prefer to neither take from or give to the state.

And the risks to me of paying tax (dying poor) are far greater than the risks of not paying tax.

Has nothing to do with tax. That's money, not a medical procedure.

In any case, making tax theoretically mandatory doesn't stop people dodging it. It actually is voluntary for rich people and large companies.

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 02/12/2021 08:38

YANBU and I have been jabbed and boosted.

The State doesn't own people.

It would be impossible to enforce here (UK) anyway.

TheReluctantPhoenix · 02/12/2021 08:36

So, should taxes be mandatory or voluntary?

In my (obviously expert) analysis, I would be so much better off personally and prefer to neither take from or give to the state.

And the risks to me of paying tax (dying poor) are far greater than the risks of not paying tax.

gofg · 02/12/2021 08:24

@SheikhMaraca wow. I find your view on a society where we abandon medical care of the elderly much scarier than one with mandatory vaccinations.

I totally agree. A disgusting sentiment.

GreenWhiteViolet · 02/12/2021 07:48

@Brieandcamembert

It's not enforced vaccination as you can opt out you just lose privileges if you do. Problem is it's generally low educated people that can't read and understand scientific evidence and weigh up risk and benefit -and love the "look at me" drama- that are refusing. They and society need protecting.

Fascinatingly it doesn't appear to be medical staff refusing ...

Do as you're told or the goverment will take away your 'privileges' because you need to be protected from yourself? That's not okay either. Especially when we're talking about things like having a job, using public transport, going to shops. In what dystopian nightmare are they considered 'privileges'?
Cheshirewife · 02/12/2021 07:44

I’m probably against mandatory vaccination but do think that those who refuse vaccination (rather than medically advised against it) should be denied nhs treatment for covid.

We have a situation in my area where life saving operations (eg cancer) are being postponed because of unvaccinated covid patients filling icu. Some of those non-covid patients are dying as a result of having urgent surgery delayed multiple times, which can’t be right.

NollaigNollaig · 02/12/2021 07:04

Sorry typo *84 now 85. My point being she was old in her eighties when she got it and she’s even older now and doing fine. You can discriminate medical care based on age.

NollaigNollaig · 02/12/2021 07:01

@SheikhMaraca wow. I find your view on a society where we abandon medical care of the elderly much scarier than one with mandatory vaccinations. My grandmother is 85. When she was 83 she was hospitalised with covid , treated and is fine now. Your preference was for her to be left to die do hospitals don’t get over whelmed rather than some idiot conspiracy nuts taking a perfectly harmless injection.

And no. Vaccines by their very nature of triggering a temporary immune response cannot have long term side effects. You clearly have no scientific background so don’t make statements you don’t understand.