Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Aibu to be horrified at the thought of mandatory vaccinations

294 replies

TracyLords · 01/12/2021 15:51

I’m not anti vax. I’ve had my jabs and will get booster this week.

There have been countries in the EU insisting on mandatory vaccination: this concerns me: surely it is up to the individual to decide to get vaccinated (or otherwise)

OP posts:
maddening · 02/12/2021 17:32

@mumda

"I know more people who've been vaccinated and had covid that unvaccinated."

If 89% are vaccinated of course you know more people that are vaccinated that have had it. I also doubt that your position is garnered from true analytical review of your anecdotal data.

Ps I don't agree wit mandatory vaccinations, I don't disagree with requirements placed on unvaccinated - eg testing

maddening · 02/12/2021 17:27

I agree in bodily autonomy, I feel that using testing where people are unwilling to vax is a suitable alternative eg at events or work. How that should apply in the future really depends on how this virus plays out over the next year or 2. Chances are it will peter to a position similar to the flu which would not require vat beyond the most vulnerable and not require testing at the same level we see currently.

mumda · 02/12/2021 17:22

I know more people who've been vaccinated and had covid that unvaccinated.
They haven't stopped transmission or catching it or vaccine escape.
I'm deeply concerned that a booster is offered just three months after the second jab. It's insane. If they don't last very long and do very little than they're useless.
Buying more vaccines means more vaccine escape as they'll spend all the time between variations making a new vaccine for the about to be superceded version.

They drew blood on my second jab too and I'm therefore grateful they didn't kill me because of the clot risk.

Deisogn · 02/12/2021 17:21

@theworldsgonefeckingmad the two aren't comparable in cost by miles....the additional beds and expanding NHS capacity especially ICU beds is astronomically expensive.

theworldsgonefeckingmad · 02/12/2021 17:11

@Deisogn if people don't want the vaccine but get fined and don't pay, then end up in court etc taxes go up, so that won't change the tax increases.

Deisogn · 02/12/2021 16:38

If we do not mandate the vaccine and the uptake isn't high enough then we will need to raise taxes and fund more hospitals. It's really as simple as that. I know which I prefer.

IHateFlies · 02/12/2021 16:20

How about forced sterilisation? Why not? Israel admitted it was doing it to their Ethiopian Jewish immigrants.
Lots of scenarios where that could be cost effective and benefit society.

theworldsgonefeckingmad · 02/12/2021 15:52

@XenoBitch

Stage 3 - Arrestment of earning/reduction in benefits

All the people who said they had the vaccine for "the greater good", yet would see people who are hesitant made homeless and turfed out on the streets. Seems very hypocritical to me.

I agree @XenoBitch I find it shocking that people can't see how this will affect everyone in the end, as soon as a precedent is set for forcing a vaccine on someone what's to stop forced abortion on the unemployed, forced diets on the obese with fines if they don't lose weight, no cancer treatment if you smoke, all in the name of "saving the NHS" and "for the greater good"
Waxonwaxoff0 · 02/12/2021 15:14

@Drumshambo

Germany has just confirmed that unvaxxed people will be excluded from non essential stores, cultural and recreational venues. Hopefully. More countries will follow!
To be fair I wouldn't have a problem with that as it still gives people a choice. I would have a problem with mandatory vaccinations for all.
Drumshambo · 02/12/2021 14:50

Germany has just confirmed that unvaxxed people will be excluded from non essential stores, cultural and recreational venues. Hopefully. More countries will follow!

soredust · 02/12/2021 14:31

If you choose not to be vaccinated, then you should forfeit your right to enjoy the benefits of the nhs

In that case, all the taxes paid by those that are not receiving NHS treatment because they choose not to be vaccinated should be refunded to them so they can pay for private treatment. You can't exclude people from having NHS care when they have paid into the system that is meant to provide care to everyone, regardless of health status and if you are going to discriminate against the unvaccinated then you must discriminate against anyone whose unhealthy lifestyles impact the NHS and take up more bedspace and nursing care such as the obese, smokers, those who do dangerous sports, those who decide to have multiple children etc. The whole point about the NHS is that it serves everyone without prejudice!

PurpleDaisies · 02/12/2021 13:46

It has to be mandated because a significant minority are selfish entitled fuckers who don't care about anyone but themselves!

I don’t agree. Anti vaxxers exist, yes. We need to make better arguments for the vaccine instead of making it illegal not to be vaccinated.

People can change their minds. There were 30k first doses done yesterday.

At what age do you want to start this vaccine mandate from?

Drumshambo · 02/12/2021 13:41

@PurpleDaisies

The mark of a civilised society is how well we look after the most vulnerable members of it. We do not live in a vacum. There are people and children who are CEV. Who are relying on the rest of us to do the right thing and get vaccinated.

Absolutely. We are relying on people to choose to do the right thing. Mandating it in law is a whole different matter.

It has to be mandated because a significant minority are selfish entitled fuckers who don't care about anyone but themselves!
PurpleDaisies · 02/12/2021 13:33

The mark of a civilised society is how well we look after the most vulnerable members of it. We do not live in a vacum. There are people and children who are CEV. Who are relying on the rest of us to do the right thing and get vaccinated.

Absolutely. We are relying on people to choose to do the right thing. Mandating it in law is a whole different matter.

XenoBitch · 02/12/2021 13:29

Stage 3 - Arrestment of earning/reduction in benefits

All the people who said they had the vaccine for "the greater good", yet would see people who are hesitant made homeless and turfed out on the streets. Seems very hypocritical to me.

Drumshambo · 02/12/2021 13:20

@PurpleDaisies

I notice you’re just attacking me personally here rather than trying to explain how mandatory vaccination would work in a civilised society.
The mark of a civilised society is how well we look after the most vulnerable members of it. We do not live in a vacum. There are people and children who are CEV. Who are relying on the rest of us to do the right thing and get vaccinated.
Drumshambo · 02/12/2021 13:08

There's talk about Europe wide mandatory vaccinations. Including for 5-11 year olds.Sooner the better..Pity this country doesn't have the balls to do it!

Bucanarab · 02/12/2021 13:06

I notice you’re just attacking me personally here rather than trying to explain how mandatory vaccination would work in a civilised society.

Stage 1 - Fine
Stage 2 - Enforcement action
Stage 3 - Arrestment of earning/reduction in benefits.

No need to put people in jail and guaranteed that once it hits someone in the pocket they'll loose their objections to having it, in 99.9999999% of cases.

Let's be honest the vast, vast majority of people who refuse it aren't doing so out of any long standing objection to medical intervention and vaccinations. They're objecting because they're gullible sheep who use anecdata and social media to form their opinions. I frequently hear those that refuse say things like "they don't want to risk the side effects however small" yet they never, ever apply that logic to anything else. 100% guarantee if a refuser broke their leg or arm they wouldn't go into hospital and say "please doc, no surgery or pain medication for this, I can't risk the side effects, I'll just let it heal naturally". I'd really love to see the stats on how many people who are against the vaccine regularly take prescription meds

YungWaffle · 02/12/2021 12:43

@Deisogn
You could take that mindset to it's logical conclusion and ask why someone who earns more than you should pay for your "selfish decision" to not earn more money.
Without taxes we could just not have this conversation. Everyone could make their own choices and pay their own way.
Think about why you wouldn't want that and yours probably on your way to answering your own question.

PurpleDaisies · 02/12/2021 12:30

[quote TheReluctantPhoenix]@PurpleDaisies,

The last thing anyone wants is to put people in jail who are at high risk of spreading COVID. It can spread like fire in a prison population.

If people don't pay their fine, it can be passed to the bailiffs to confiscate goods to the value of the fine.[/quote]
This article is talking about mandatory vaccination in Austria.

Those refusing to be vaccinated are likely to face administrative fines, which can be converted into a prison sentence if the fine cannot be recovered.

amp.theguardian.com/world/2021/nov/19/austria-plans-compulsory-covid-vaccination-for-all

YungWaffle · 02/12/2021 12:25

@TheReluctantPhoenix
It is also an extraordinarily callous way of looking at those over 60, as if they are far less important.

They're not less important at all. They're just more at risk of dying in general (all-cause mortality). Covid is not new in this respect, so I don't think it requires state overreach to specifically protect them. That was literally my concluding point in my previous post.

If there is not enough voluntary uptake (luckily, most be in the UK are grateful to get their vaccine), it will have to be mandatory.

Again, almost literally what I said. I don't think the benefit of the remaining population being vaccinated is worth the cost of mandating it.

Just so we're clear, because you seem to be struggling to understand, this does not mean that I think people over 60 should not be treated or deserve to die. If they're sensible, they'd get vaccinated because they're most likely to die if they catch covid. The analysis is less clearcut for most younger people.

Deisogn · 02/12/2021 12:25

I'd be fine with saying if you refuse without medical grounds you forfeit your right to free care on the NHS. School place should be contingent on vaccines as well. Even place like the US, where they are arguably far more in favour of personal liberties, it's mandatory to have childhood jabs to start school. Do what you like but do it to your own cost. Why should we pay for other peoples selfish decisions?

Seasidemumma77 · 02/12/2021 12:21

In some countries deeming a vaccination as 'mandatory' simply means people can receive it for free via their insurance rather than paying, doesn't always mean people will be forced to have vaccination.

PurpleDaisies · 02/12/2021 12:20

I notice you’re just attacking me personally here rather than trying to explain how mandatory vaccination would work in a civilised society.

CaptSkippy · 02/12/2021 12:19

@PurpleDaisies
Do you know what a logical fallacy is?

If you don't I recommend you Google it. They are quire fascinating