Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Aibu to be horrified at the thought of mandatory vaccinations

294 replies

TracyLords · 01/12/2021 15:51

I’m not anti vax. I’ve had my jabs and will get booster this week.

There have been countries in the EU insisting on mandatory vaccination: this concerns me: surely it is up to the individual to decide to get vaccinated (or otherwise)

OP posts:
JaninaDuszejko · 05/12/2021 16:35

The smallpox vaccination is not the only vaccination to have been mandated.

It is the only one to have been mandated in the UK. There is no strong evidence to support a mandate, and we don't need one in this country anyway. 81% of the eligible population are fully vaccinated with no mandate. We are a pro-vaccination country and we don't like things being mandated. It will not achieve anything, targetted education campaigns will have more of an effect.

ImmyMc · 05/12/2021 15:57

@GreenWhiteViolet

The smallpox vaccination is not the only vaccination to have been mandated. There have been plenty of mandatory vaccinations throughout history, including recent history, all over the world. It is not a new thing at all, and it has not led to the collapse of democracy in the past. On the contrary, it has actually saved millions of lives.

Obviously, it is better if people are allowed the choice. However, if not enough people choose to be vaccinated to stop a pandemic from killing millions, then something needs to be done because saving millions of lives is more important than being allowed to refuse a vaccine.

ImmyMc · 05/12/2021 15:52

@sst1234

No, this is not true. As I said above, the unvaxxed are not just putting themselves at risk, they are putting the clinically vulnerable at risk, they are putting those who need life-saving treatments that need to be postponed at risk, and they are putting burnt-out doctors and nurses at risk.

The clinically vulnerable are only protected in society once collective immunity is reached. This is only likely to happen when enough people in society are vaccinated. Until then, transmission is more frequent among the unvaccinated than among the vaccinated, making it difficult to drive down transmission rates. There are studies on this if you want me to post them. Vaccinated people can still transmit the disease but with Delta it was something like 80 times less likely. With Omicron, I suspect that number will have decreased again, but this is also why the next vaccination wave is probably going to include an Omicron-specific vaccine - it's possibly going to be the first strain that the original vaccines don't work all that well for. Unless the uptake of annual booster shots is high enough, Covid is going to be with us at epidemic levels for many years, which is a huge problem.

The unvaxxed also put others at risk because ICU units are mostly full of the unvaccinated right now. Though some vaccinated people end up in hospital, these are mostly the clinically vulnerable (who, as above, would be far less likely to get ill with Covid if more people were vaccinated in the first place, as collective immunity would protect them). For the rest in the ICU, they are unvaccinated. The larger numbers of unvaccinated people in ICU mean that ICU units are full. This means that spaces cannot be held for those who might need a place in ICU after a surgery, i.e. if you need surgery to remove a brain tumour, you are likely to need an ICU spot for a few days afterwards to be monitored, or in case something goes wrong in the surgery. This means that life-saving cancer treatments need to be postponed because the ICU units are still full of the unvaxxed. Postponing cancer treatments causes deaths, as cancer needs to be treated as soon as possible to stop it from spreading. Sometimes, the delay of even a week or two is the difference between life and death for a person. So in these situations, a person's choice not to be vaccinated impacts on another person's right to life. If vaccination rates were higher, the ICU units wouldn't be overwhelmed and surgeries need not be cancelled.

Finally, doctors and nurses have the right to a break. They are on the brink of burnout and collapse. They have had two years of this, with very little respite, because the number of their patients have tripled or more. ICU doctors and nurses are exhausted. There needs to be an end in sight - they cannot be expected to continue like this just because a large portion of the country refuse to be vaccinated. If they leave (as many are doing), then that impacts all of us, as we all need to have doctors and nurses when we are ill.

So, I think you are wrong: the decision not to be vaccinated does not just affect the person refusing the vaccination. It affects all of us during this pandemic.

GreenWhiteViolet · 05/12/2021 15:42

[quote ImmyMc]@GreenWhiteViolet

The difference between all of those examples that you have given and the Covid-19 example is that none of those things are infectious. Giving blood might help save another's life, but going outside without giving blood does not endanger those around you. That's the difference.

All of these arguments about bodily autonomy fail to address the context of a pandemic - an infectious disease, more easily passed on by people who are unvaccinated and which can kill more vulnerable people in society, is not comparable to those things you listed for that very reason.[/quote]
The case would be stronger if being vaccinated meant that you would never catch Covid or pass it on. It doesn't. If you're vaccinated, you can still get infected and pass that infection on to vulnerable people - and the protection it does afford you doesn't even seem to last very long!

A more general point re: mandatory vaccines. The smallpox vaccine is the example people like to use for precedent, but at the time that law was enforced (1867 - the 1853 requirement was very easy to avoid) the vaccine was over 70 years old. Plenty of time for data collection to prove its safety, etc. It only applied to new babies, not the adult population, so it was parental rights and not bodily autonomy that was being infringed. And there were still plenty of people who objected on libertarian grounds, so much so that a conscience clause was added in the 1890s.

ImmyMc · 05/12/2021 15:33

@OMG12

I suspect that you would talk theoretically about this until you or a loved one are being denied cancer treatment because the unvaxxed are taking up hospital space and resources. But let's give you the benefit of the doubt and assume that you would feel the same if you were in that situation.

This isn't about eradicating disease. It's about getting it to the stage that we are able to "just live with it", as you say (i.e. the endemic stage where hospitals are no longer overwhelmed and there is enough collective immunity to protect the clinically vulnerable). The whole point about any of this is that we cannot "just live with it" until we reach that stage and we can't reach that stage until people are vaccinated. The vaccinations you mention from the past have got us to that stage now with other diseases! Measles still exists, for example, and so does Polio, but outbreaks are very rare.

You are being hyperbolic. Losing the individual freedom to refuse a vaccine does not inevitably lead to dictatorship. And this is the problem with your argument. Maybe it might do, but it is unlikely to be this slippery slope that you imagine it to be. Vaccines have been mandated many times in the past and have not led to dictatorships! Yes, it is possible that losing one individual liberty could result in losing more, but it is, as I have said, a "might". History tells us it hasn't led to that in the past so it probably won't now. The possible threat of a dictatorship in the future (which, again, is imo hyperbolic considering historically vaccine mandates have never led to this before) is not enough to justify overwhelming the health system, allowing the vulnerable to die, and bringing doctors and nurses to their knees with exhaustion.

Of course the problems in the NHS have been propelled by chronic underfunding, but 12-hour waits for ambulances are the result of Covid, and postponed operations largely the result of the unvaxxed in this wave. Chronic underfunding is also not the sole issue - even well funded health systems around the world are unable to cope with the weight of the pandemic. Vaccines vastly reduce hospitalisations. Vaccines will relieve the pressure on the health system and save lives.

As to the objections you raise, rules have existed for certain groups to opt out of mandated vaccines in the past, and they undoubtedly would again.

Human life is precious. I repeat: the freedom to refuse a vaccine is not more important than the freedom to live.

sst1234 · 05/12/2021 15:31

@thegreenlight

It’s against the law to not wear a seatbelt - surely if people are too stupid to make a sensible decision themselves using all the information provided by science and their action can have a detrimental effect on others then yes, we should make it a legal responsibility. I don’t see any difference.
Come on, if you must use an analogy, use one that at least use one that makes sense. Wearing a seatbelt is not the same as being injected.
sst1234 · 05/12/2021 15:29

[quote ImmyMc]@sst1234

I have many years of university education at post-degree level on the subject of propaganda, politics, and, more recently, psychological research. I am more than qualified on this subject.

Individual liberties are not more important than the collective functioning of society. I understand you believe that this sets a precedent for future government control, but it is quite normal, and always has been, that in terms of national crisis the government has to infringe on individual liberties for the collective good. This has always been the case, for example, in wartime and so on.

At present, there is a global crisis, not even just a national one. Whatever slippery slope you believe that mandatory vaccinations might bring, the "might lead to the worst-case scenario" argument is not strong enough to justify infringing on the actual human lives of real people living now - those who are immuno-compromised, those who need surgeries currently postponed, and healthcare workers who are burnt-out. This is because, when all is said and done, it is a "could possibly happen" and not a "will happen" whereas the lives of those groups above are definitely being affected right now by this. As I said before, nothing is more important than people's actual human lives.

Mandatory vaccinations have existed around the world for literally centuries (i.e. smallpox in the UK; vaccine mandates for school children in many, many countries; literally mandates for dozens of types of vaccines in the U.S. in the 70s). This is nothing new. Your fear about what could happen regarding government control is just that - it's a "what if". It is NOT a strong enough argument to sacrifice thousands of lives on a "what if".[/quote]
Thanks for taking the time to write a considered, respectful reply. The issue with your argument, though is that not getting vaccinated is not really infringing on anyone’s rights. Those of us that want to be vaccinated, sure go ahead, as we have done. Those that do not are mostly putting themselves at risk. Hospitalizations are higher among those not vaccinated.
Your argument would make sense only if the unvaccinated were preventing you from being vaccinated.

thegreenlight · 05/12/2021 14:20

It’s against the law to not wear a seatbelt - surely if people are too stupid to make a sensible decision themselves using all the information provided by science and their action can have a detrimental effect on others then yes, we should make it a legal responsibility. I don’t see any difference.

OMG12 · 05/12/2021 13:49

@ImmyMc

YABU

The right not to be vaccinated is not greater than the right of every individual to have a functioning health service. Unvaccinated people are now indirectly causing the deaths of the clinically vulnerable, for whom the vaccine isn't as effective, and anybody who has had to have life-saving surgery postponed because Covid takes up hospital space and time. All those ambulances not arriving on time are also the partial indirect result of the unvaxxed at this stage. And someone's right to not be vaxxed doesn't trump the rights of nurses and doctors to be able to go to work and not be worked to burnout and exhaustion.

So, no, individual liberties are not more important than the collective good. Who fucking cares if someone doesn't want to be vaccinated? What possible real reason can they actually have anyway that isn't just either wrong or mental? And does anybody even believe that reason is more important than saving people's actual lives? I certainly don't.

But can’t you see that individual freedoms are inseparably linked to the greater good? Without individual freedoms society becomes a dictatorship, freedoms over self are the checks and balances in deciding what the greater good is, without these individual freedoms being exercised who is to decide what the greater good is?

This point is far bigger than a single disease. People talk about medical exemptions, but what are these? Going into anaphylactic shock? The multitude of reactions which have been reported on the first and second jab that the medical profession refuse to acknowledge but make the person reluctant to get a booster? Psychological issues meaning people can’t cope with medical intervention, losing autonomy over their bodies, fear of needles? Who is to decide where the cut off lies? Religious belief? Some people believe that medical intervention goes against gods will, who are you to decide they are wrong? People with philosophical beliefs against medical intervention mandated by the state? Should philosophical beliefs be seen are less worthy because they don’t have an attached deity?

What about those people who think it’s ethically wrong for a young person in the west to be taking a booster vaccine 3months after their initial jab whilst vulnerable people in the third world can’t even get a first dose?

All of the diseases mentioned with exception of small pox still exist, there is not 100% vaccination but we have learned to live with it all without stripping away individual freedoms.

What we are doing is creating a sub group acting as scape goats. The nhs was fucked well before covid, every winter we were told flu was about to bring down the nhs, cancer ops cancelled, waiting lists infinite, ambulances taking hours to reach patients. The vast vast majority of unvaccinated people will just get a mild case. What is bringing down the nhs is that it’s a model not fit for purpose. Is it truely the unvaccinated who are stopping a doctor seeing a patient and feeling their breast to find a lump?

NannyOggsWhiskyStash · 05/12/2021 12:55

@Sparklybanana

It's not a medical procedure ffs. It's a vaccination that has been proven to severely reduce liklihood of severe illness and death and has saved more lives than its taken. So many people just don't understand the entire pandemic and the response to it and are lapping up advice from people who really know nothing. One of the key anti vax people is a hairdresser - how could she possibly know more about this vaccination than hundreds of scientists and doctors who have been studying viruses and vaccinations for years. Would you trust a doctor to give you a great colour and haircut after watching a few YouTube videos? Because it's the same. Although hair will recover. Too many people are believing random people on the Internet, most of whom, are MAKING MONEY, from their stance through books and Web traffic to their own potential detriment. It's like flat earth. I wonder how many people actually believe that the earth is flat despite all evidence to the contrary, and how many people are just making money off peddling this crap from gullible people. Nobody should have to have a mandatory vaccine, but if people cannot be trusted to make a sensible decision that will save lives, using actual data and not youtube, then this is the inevitable result. It's a tragic state of affairs that we have come to this.
Well said. And oddly enough the most rabid anti-vaxxer I know is a hairdresser who apparently knows more than virologists
ImmyMc · 05/12/2021 12:35

@GreenWhiteViolet

The difference between all of those examples that you have given and the Covid-19 example is that none of those things are infectious. Giving blood might help save another's life, but going outside without giving blood does not endanger those around you. That's the difference.

All of these arguments about bodily autonomy fail to address the context of a pandemic - an infectious disease, more easily passed on by people who are unvaccinated and which can kill more vulnerable people in society, is not comparable to those things you listed for that very reason.

ImmyMc · 05/12/2021 12:29

@sst1234

I have many years of university education at post-degree level on the subject of propaganda, politics, and, more recently, psychological research. I am more than qualified on this subject.

Individual liberties are not more important than the collective functioning of society. I understand you believe that this sets a precedent for future government control, but it is quite normal, and always has been, that in terms of national crisis the government has to infringe on individual liberties for the collective good. This has always been the case, for example, in wartime and so on.

At present, there is a global crisis, not even just a national one. Whatever slippery slope you believe that mandatory vaccinations might bring, the "might lead to the worst-case scenario" argument is not strong enough to justify infringing on the actual human lives of real people living now - those who are immuno-compromised, those who need surgeries currently postponed, and healthcare workers who are burnt-out. This is because, when all is said and done, it is a "could possibly happen" and not a "will happen" whereas the lives of those groups above are definitely being affected right now by this. As I said before, nothing is more important than people's actual human lives.

Mandatory vaccinations have existed around the world for literally centuries (i.e. smallpox in the UK; vaccine mandates for school children in many, many countries; literally mandates for dozens of types of vaccines in the U.S. in the 70s). This is nothing new. Your fear about what could happen regarding government control is just that - it's a "what if". It is NOT a strong enough argument to sacrifice thousands of lives on a "what if".

Bucanarab · 05/12/2021 11:51

I wish there was a vaccine against swallowing propaganda.

That would be awesome! If there was such a thing you can guarantee anyone who had it would be happy to have the covid vaccine too and we wouldn't be having these discussions.

EllaVaNight · 05/12/2021 11:51

I find this interesting as many people say they wouldn't want their loved one cared for by an unvaccinated carer, and are happy for them to either get jabbed or leave. Many carers have been carers their whole lives and are not qualified to do anything else so have essentially been forced into it. It has also worsened the staffing crisis in this sector. But they themselves wouldn't want to be forced to be vaccinated. Interesting.

sst1234 · 05/12/2021 09:20

@ImmyMc

YABU

The right not to be vaccinated is not greater than the right of every individual to have a functioning health service. Unvaccinated people are now indirectly causing the deaths of the clinically vulnerable, for whom the vaccine isn't as effective, and anybody who has had to have life-saving surgery postponed because Covid takes up hospital space and time. All those ambulances not arriving on time are also the partial indirect result of the unvaxxed at this stage. And someone's right to not be vaxxed doesn't trump the rights of nurses and doctors to be able to go to work and not be worked to burnout and exhaustion.

So, no, individual liberties are not more important than the collective good. Who fucking cares if someone doesn't want to be vaccinated? What possible real reason can they actually have anyway that isn't just either wrong or mental? And does anybody even believe that reason is more important than saving people's actual lives? I certainly don't.

Well done for missing the point spectacularly, after 10 pages of people explaining why this sets a frightening precedence. I wish there was a vaccine against swallowing propaganda.
MarieG10 · 05/12/2021 09:06

Look at the hospitals that are still full in ITUs of covid unvaccinated. They are dying but they are also preventing other routine operations for people that can be life and death..cancer for example that could become inoperable.

Plus they spread it to the vulnerable who are vaccinated but have lower immunity. All of this convinces me it is necessary but 7 likely in the U.K. currently.....until it is shown to be successful elsewhere anyway and after the utter shitshow and stupidity of the Covid regulations anything is possible

bumblingbovine49 · 05/12/2021 09:04

@ImmyMc

YABU

The right not to be vaccinated is not greater than the right of every individual to have a functioning health service. Unvaccinated people are now indirectly causing the deaths of the clinically vulnerable, for whom the vaccine isn't as effective, and anybody who has had to have life-saving surgery postponed because Covid takes up hospital space and time. All those ambulances not arriving on time are also the partial indirect result of the unvaxxed at this stage. And someone's right to not be vaxxed doesn't trump the rights of nurses and doctors to be able to go to work and not be worked to burnout and exhaustion.

So, no, individual liberties are not more important than the collective good. Who fucking cares if someone doesn't want to be vaccinated? What possible real reason can they actually have anyway that isn't just either wrong or mental? And does anybody even believe that reason is more important than saving people's actual lives? I certainly don't.

This
GreenWhiteViolet · 05/12/2021 09:02

@ImmyMc

YABU

The right not to be vaccinated is not greater than the right of every individual to have a functioning health service. Unvaccinated people are now indirectly causing the deaths of the clinically vulnerable, for whom the vaccine isn't as effective, and anybody who has had to have life-saving surgery postponed because Covid takes up hospital space and time. All those ambulances not arriving on time are also the partial indirect result of the unvaxxed at this stage. And someone's right to not be vaxxed doesn't trump the rights of nurses and doctors to be able to go to work and not be worked to burnout and exhaustion.

So, no, individual liberties are not more important than the collective good. Who fucking cares if someone doesn't want to be vaccinated? What possible real reason can they actually have anyway that isn't just either wrong or mental? And does anybody even believe that reason is more important than saving people's actual lives? I certainly don't.

Individual liberties are absolutely more important than the collective good when the 'liberty' in question is declining to have something injected into your body. What makes you so great and important that you can decide everyone's reasons are wrong (or 'mental'? Nice bit of ableism thrown in, for someone who supposedly cares so much about the vulnerable) and therefore they should be forced to do what you want them to?

Forcing everyone to donate blood would save people's actual lives. So would mandatory organ donation. Or banning all alcohol and junk food. Or a whole range of other things that we don't do, because individual rights and liberties matter.

Yournamehere007 · 05/12/2021 08:53

I think state mandated compulsory medical procedures are the thin edge of a wedge. Bodily autonomy is sacred.

WeisheitNurInWahrheit · 05/12/2021 05:57

@2Gen

The Pope disagrees with you very strongly on that matter. And it’s not an extraordinary dispensation; Pfizer, Moderna & AZ do not contain stem cells.

When this research was undertaken no vaccines were yet available; & the unvaccinated now are choosing to put themselves in a position where their loved ones will be [doing their equivalent of] seeking the intercession of St Rita & St Jude. If you were to survive [or, please God, be less unwell] but then get Long Covid you'd have a Litany-of-Saints-length list of intercessions to request - and struggle to pray, because Brain Fog robs you of thoughts & words; & reading is too tiring.

You are of course absolutely free to say you simply do not wish to have it, despite all the vaccines having completed the usual clinical trials before they were rolled out. Please, though, don’t spread misinformation about the vaccines being “abortion tainted”*; & trying to use Catholicism as a shield is really rather silly given how well-publicised the Pope’s remarks on the matter have been.

(As a side, but related, note: don’t forget the Church’s position supports ethically acceptable stem cell research [apologies for date of article, but I’m too tired to trawl for one equally concise but more recent - position is still same though] so ensuring you know, where stem cells are used, what their source is, rather matters.)

  • On which note, if you’re not actually meaning they contain stem-cells but are hoping others will simply assume that so you’ve not actually lied (still a lie of omission; still a sin; and now you can’t claim it’s unintentional if ever it was) but you can deter more people, that is dreadful. If, however, you’re “just” being very purist, I hope you don’t use medication of any kind (given the way funding, research & researchers work; plus so many companies making oral contraception &/or the MAP); & indeed live in splendid & self-sufficient isolation because you cannot guarantee you’re not coming into contact with people who have had or have provided abortions & are thus, by your logic, Tainting All The Things. Whatever your reasoning, however, as noted above, the Church does not consider the vaccines to be “tainted” in any way.
daisydoh · 04/12/2021 23:53

@ImmyMc

YABU

The right not to be vaccinated is not greater than the right of every individual to have a functioning health service. Unvaccinated people are now indirectly causing the deaths of the clinically vulnerable, for whom the vaccine isn't as effective, and anybody who has had to have life-saving surgery postponed because Covid takes up hospital space and time. All those ambulances not arriving on time are also the partial indirect result of the unvaxxed at this stage. And someone's right to not be vaxxed doesn't trump the rights of nurses and doctors to be able to go to work and not be worked to burnout and exhaustion.

So, no, individual liberties are not more important than the collective good. Who fucking cares if someone doesn't want to be vaccinated? What possible real reason can they actually have anyway that isn't just either wrong or mental? And does anybody even believe that reason is more important than saving people's actual lives? I certainly don't.

👆this
Meadowlands · 04/12/2021 23:39

@ImmyMc Well said !
OP YABU

ImmyMc · 04/12/2021 22:58

YABU

The right not to be vaccinated is not greater than the right of every individual to have a functioning health service. Unvaccinated people are now indirectly causing the deaths of the clinically vulnerable, for whom the vaccine isn't as effective, and anybody who has had to have life-saving surgery postponed because Covid takes up hospital space and time. All those ambulances not arriving on time are also the partial indirect result of the unvaxxed at this stage. And someone's right to not be vaxxed doesn't trump the rights of nurses and doctors to be able to go to work and not be worked to burnout and exhaustion.

So, no, individual liberties are not more important than the collective good. Who fucking cares if someone doesn't want to be vaccinated? What possible real reason can they actually have anyway that isn't just either wrong or mental? And does anybody even believe that reason is more important than saving people's actual lives? I certainly don't.

SammyScrounge · 04/12/2021 19:45

[quote CaptSkippy]@JohnDee007

The "con" crowd are the people who are contra is this discussion. They oppose mandatory vaccinations. I am pro. The right to choose in this case is outweighting the right of a lot of people not to be put at undue risk from this disease.

At this point, not getting vaccinated other than for a medical exemption is directly and indirectly causing the deaths and suffering of other people. This is unacceptable to me.[/quote]
I agree. I am against unvaccinated people working in care homes, schools, or anywhere near hospital wards. I think anti-vaxers are selfish, perhaps relying on everyone else being vaccinated to protect them, and not caring much if they spread Covid.
I'm old enough to remember children in calipers thanks to polio, a sight never seen now because of the polio vaccine. I recall a girl in my class deafened by German measles contracted by her mother in pregnancy, also rare now because of vaccines. And the girl who died of diphtheria in our street because
her Dad thought vaccines were poison.
All of you have grown up in a society which is largely free of hellish infectious diseases and you have no fear of illness and think vaccinations are a matter for debate.There isn't time.

Newrumpus · 04/12/2021 17:28

@Drumshambo

There's talk about Europe wide mandatory vaccinations. Including for 5-11 year olds.Sooner the better..Pity this country doesn't have the balls to do it!
There is talk of this in ‘Europe’ because many of those governments were themselves vaccine hesitant and are now paying the price for that in that they have a larger population percentage unvaccinated than the UK does. Now they know how wrong they were, they are foolish to try to force people. They need to persuade them. Threatening will only make the hesitant more concerned.