Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Aibu to be horrified at the thought of mandatory vaccinations

294 replies

TracyLords · 01/12/2021 15:51

I’m not anti vax. I’ve had my jabs and will get booster this week.

There have been countries in the EU insisting on mandatory vaccination: this concerns me: surely it is up to the individual to decide to get vaccinated (or otherwise)

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
ImmyMc · 13/12/2021 20:34

[quote bakebeans]@ImmyMc
Very true. I’m aware of what they are.

My point is that this is a free country and are neither under a communist or facist dictatorship. If people are to be start being dictated to have mandatory vaccinations, what next? Where does it stop! And Yes some countries have mandatory childhood vaccinations but you need to remember these work differently. They are not vaccinations that are still being researched and new strains and developments coming out all the time.
The NHS and mental health promote patient autonomy and include them
In decision making processes. Mandatory vaccinations go against this especially when they future facts are still not clear.[/quote]
Plenty of new vaccines were made mandatory in the past. It didn't lead to the collapse of democracy. I understand being opposed to mandatory vaccination on ideological ground, but I think it's hyperbolic to suggest that it will lead to a slippery slope - historically, it's just never been the case

ImmyMc · 13/12/2021 20:33

[quote bakebeans]@ImmyMc
Very true. I’m aware of what they are.

My point is that this is a free country and are neither under a communist or facist dictatorship. If people are to be start being dictated to have mandatory vaccinations, what next? Where does it stop! And Yes some countries have mandatory childhood vaccinations but you need to remember these work differently. They are not vaccinations that are still being researched and new strains and developments coming out all the time.
The NHS and mental health promote patient autonomy and include them
In decision making processes. Mandatory vaccinations go against this especially when they future facts are still not clear.[/quote]
Plenty of new vaccines were made mandatory in the past. It didn't lead to the collapse of democracy. I understand being opposed to mandatory vaccination on ideological ground, but I think it's hyperbolic to suggest that it will lead to a slippery slope - historically, it's just never been the case

bakebeans · 13/12/2021 20:21

@ImmyMc
Very true. I’m aware of what they are.

My point is that this is a free country and are neither under a communist or facist dictatorship. If people are to be start being dictated to have mandatory vaccinations, what next? Where does it stop! And Yes some countries have mandatory childhood vaccinations but you need to remember these work differently. They are not vaccinations that are still being researched and new strains and developments coming out all the time.
The NHS and mental health promote patient autonomy and include them
In decision making processes. Mandatory vaccinations go against this especially when they future facts are still not clear.

ImmyMc · 13/12/2021 19:31

@CatsArePeople

Communist fascist?! Is that supposed to be a deliberate oxymoron, or are you serious?

History 101. Both regimes were totalitarian and not much different from one another is essense.

Which regimes do you mean? Plenty of different communist regimes - Cuba v.different to China, for example.

Fascist regimes are right-wing; communist regimes are left-wing, @bakebeans.

As I've pointed out elsewhere on this thread, mandatory vaccinations are nothing new and have not led to the collapse of democracy before!

SoItWas · 13/12/2021 19:10

I'm double jabbed. But that was a choice I made. I don't agree with mandatory vaccination at all.

CatsArePeople · 13/12/2021 19:08

Communist fascist?! Is that supposed to be a deliberate oxymoron, or are you serious?

History 101. Both regimes were totalitarian and not much different from one another is essense.

CatsArePeople · 13/12/2021 19:05

I would happily have a vaccine if it was safe or at least worked. Not with a side effect of death though.

bakebeans · 13/12/2021 18:57

ImmyMc ?? You don’t make sense!

ImmyMc · 13/12/2021 09:07

[quote bakebeans]@NollaigNollaig mandatory vaccinations are not the answer. This is a free country. We are not being ruled by a communist facist dictatorship and by implementing mandatory vaccinations, it will take away people’s choice and autonomy. I’m staggered the amount of people who have supported this!
Let’s remove the freedom of choice in Britain that we fought for and start with mandatory vaccinations and see what we can change next! Austria’s famous dictator will be smiling in his grave![/quote]
@bakebeans

Communist fascist?! Is that supposed to be a deliberate oxymoron, or are you serious? If you are serious, I think this surely shows why your views can't be trusted!

bakebeans · 09/12/2021 08:08

@NollaigNollaig mandatory vaccinations are not the answer. This is a free country. We are not being ruled by a communist facist dictatorship and by implementing mandatory vaccinations, it will take away people’s choice and autonomy. I’m staggered the amount of people who have supported this!
Let’s remove the freedom of choice in Britain that we fought for and start with mandatory vaccinations and see what we can change next! Austria’s famous dictator will be smiling in his grave!

tttigress · 05/12/2021 22:50

Could be a very dangerous first step to all kinds of medical interventions.

Really bad idea to start down this route.

Kendodd · 05/12/2021 22:39

I'm sick to death of people too stupid to get the vaccine. I even know someone unvaccinated, who recently died from covid, even then, I struggled to feel much sympathy and my first thought was being pissed off someone could be so stupid.
Having said all that, I still don't think they should be forced to be vaccinated. They can just take their chances against covid, fuck 'em.

IHateFlies · 05/12/2021 22:07

Are we allowed to be pro choice or just pro vax or anti vax?

ImmyMc · 05/12/2021 22:05

@OMG12

I’m sorry if you have misunderstood my post, which I must admit I thought was fairly clear. To clarify, your points about those you consider to be most impacted by people not being vaccinated. This is covered in the first part of my post, as a recap, all these things were issues pre covid and in certain cases also a combination of issues built up during the first 18 months of the pandemic. ICU beds are always at a premium this time of year, in the pandemic pandemonium we seem to have forgotten that.

I raised the point about scans as a response to how I would respond to your (I must say, unnecessarily emotive) query about how I would respond in you prescribed scenarios. As you seemed concerned about less than definite views on the future consequences of actions I considered it more appropriate to comment on the nearest approximation based on my past or current experience, ie a scan.

Again to make clear, I don’t think it is the issue of a stand alone vaccine mandate that is the issue, I believe the real danger lies in the demonisation, blaming, ostracising and potentially criminalisation of a group of people exercising their personal freedoms, you speak of the fact there will be a release from a mandate where the is a “conscionable objection” herein lies the crux of the problem, the definition of this will be subjective, and who’s subjectivity should we be subject to?

I think we will have to agree on the tipping of the scales regarding individual v societal importance (although I actually believe you can’t have one without the balancing influence of the other) , but that is the beauty of individual freedom having the right to disagree without living in fear of the consequences.

No, they were not. It is a statistical fact that ICU units and ambulance services are under strain now as a result of unvaccinated people and Covid-19. Yes, the NHS is underfunded and this has caused problems, but the current problems with ICU beds are Covid-19 related. This is also true of better-funded health systems all over the world. If you think that the current situation in ICU units is anything like in previous years, you are very much mistaken.

With regards to the conscionable objection, see my previous comments. There is a precedent for this throughout history, so whichever government introduced it would most likely draw from that. That's for any government to decide, should it bring in a vaccine mandate. But it is certainly possible, and it has happened before. As I've also said many times, this is nothing new.

I agree that there is a danger in ostracising groups of people, which is why it is always better that it is a choice. But my point is that if it gets to the stage where the health service buckles and vulnerable people continue to die as a result of unvaccinated groups, then the balance scales may tip in the other direction.

Alltheblue · 05/12/2021 21:49

Yes you are a bit. You're not an island. People can be depressingly self interested and we just can't afford that right now.

ILoveHuskies · 05/12/2021 21:45

Yanbu

And I'm pro vax

XenoBitch · 05/12/2021 21:42

[quote whenwillthemadnessend]www.google.co.uk/amp/s/amp.theguardian.com/world/2021/nov/09/singapore-to-start-charging-covid-patients-who-are-unvaccinated-by-choice#cobssid=s[/quote]
Singapore charges for all healthcare. They let it go for Covid related stuff though due to the pandemic.
It is not the same as being in a country with free healthcare, such as the UK. Totally different system.

dohrgitdb · 05/12/2021 21:39

@whenwillthemadnessend
Yep it’s frightening.

What’s the alternative though??

OMG12 · 05/12/2021 19:46

I’m sorry if you have misunderstood my post, which I must admit I thought was fairly clear. To clarify, your points about those you consider to be most impacted by people not being vaccinated. This is covered in the first part of my post, as a recap, all these things were issues pre covid and in certain cases also a combination of issues built up during the first 18 months of the pandemic. ICU beds are always at a premium this time of year, in the pandemic pandemonium we seem to have forgotten that.

I raised the point about scans as a response to how I would respond to your (I must say, unnecessarily emotive) query about how I would respond in you prescribed scenarios. As you seemed concerned about less than definite views on the future consequences of actions I considered it more appropriate to comment on the nearest approximation based on my past or current experience, ie a scan.

Again to make clear, I don’t think it is the issue of a stand alone vaccine mandate that is the issue, I believe the real danger lies in the demonisation, blaming, ostracising and potentially criminalisation of a group of people exercising their personal freedoms, you speak of the fact there will be a release from a mandate where the is a “conscionable objection” herein lies the crux of the problem, the definition of this will be subjective, and who’s subjectivity should we be subject to?

I think we will have to agree on the tipping of the scales regarding individual v societal importance (although I actually believe you can’t have one without the balancing influence of the other) , but that is the beauty of individual freedom having the right to disagree without living in fear of the consequences.

LexMitior · 05/12/2021 19:22

I don't think we will end up with "mandatory" vaccination, but it does seem likelier that people who have not been vaccinated will be treated differently because of the risk they present; the evidence grows that this is the case, and supports a change in policy for schools, medical treatment, access to shops, bars, etc. That is what it may come down to, because there is actually not a right to access a bar or a shop but that may be up to the owner, and for public services, you could say that owing to the risk, there would be a case for treating people differently.

When it is the case that people cannot get routine health treatment, schools close or social spaces are shut because of COVID and there still being a residual non vaccinated population, then there will be pressure on the Government to act on the perceived problem.

ImmyMc · 05/12/2021 19:00

@OMG12

I said nothing about scans. I said the unvaccinated are creating definite pressures on ICU and ambulance services - that is a fact, and that is what I am talking about. I gave three specific examples - immuno-compromised people, postponement of necessary surgery because of no ICU space, and ICU doctor and nurse burnout. Those are all directly attributable to unvaccinated people - the statistics are there.

As to what you are going to do with people who refuse, well that would depend on the country and the government. In the past, people have been able to opt-out on conscionable grounds etc. so presumably that may also be the case - it would be up to the government. In Austria, I believe they are fining people. In the U.S. I believe they used to imprison people - that's a political decision, and would be up to any government that imposed the rule.

To those who are saying the smallpox mandate was only for children and the only one in the UK, I'm not sure what your point is. My point was that there have been plenty of vaccine mandates throughout history in western, developed countries and democracy didn't collapse (which is what one poster was suggesting would be the ultimate outcome of this). It's not a new thing, and I very much doubt democracy would collapse if it happened.

I actually don't have particularly strong feelings either way about mandatory vaccination, but I'm certainly not "horrified" by it as the OP is. It's neither a new thing nor a particularly shocking thing, in my opinion. I can see plenty of benefits to doing it, particularly if things continue the way they are - there needs to be a route of this, and it might get to the stage where this, along with other more draconian measures, is the only way out of it. I wouldn't be surprised if that were the case, but I guess we will all see.

As I've said before, I think that protecting the lives of the people at risk from Covid is more important than protecting the rights of the people who are anti-vaccines. While someone should have the right to object to something on, for example, conscionable grounds, that right is not more important than the right of the clinically vulnerable to life, to the general population of having a functioning ICU service, or to the ICU doctors and nurses to work a job with reasonable hours and rest.

OMG12 · 05/12/2021 18:16

[quote ImmyMc]@OMG12

I suspect that you would talk theoretically about this until you or a loved one are being denied cancer treatment because the unvaxxed are taking up hospital space and resources. But let's give you the benefit of the doubt and assume that you would feel the same if you were in that situation.

This isn't about eradicating disease. It's about getting it to the stage that we are able to "just live with it", as you say (i.e. the endemic stage where hospitals are no longer overwhelmed and there is enough collective immunity to protect the clinically vulnerable). The whole point about any of this is that we cannot "just live with it" until we reach that stage and we can't reach that stage until people are vaccinated. The vaccinations you mention from the past have got us to that stage now with other diseases! Measles still exists, for example, and so does Polio, but outbreaks are very rare.

You are being hyperbolic. Losing the individual freedom to refuse a vaccine does not inevitably lead to dictatorship. And this is the problem with your argument. Maybe it might do, but it is unlikely to be this slippery slope that you imagine it to be. Vaccines have been mandated many times in the past and have not led to dictatorships! Yes, it is possible that losing one individual liberty could result in losing more, but it is, as I have said, a "might". History tells us it hasn't led to that in the past so it probably won't now. The possible threat of a dictatorship in the future (which, again, is imo hyperbolic considering historically vaccine mandates have never led to this before) is not enough to justify overwhelming the health system, allowing the vulnerable to die, and bringing doctors and nurses to their knees with exhaustion.

Of course the problems in the NHS have been propelled by chronic underfunding, but 12-hour waits for ambulances are the result of Covid, and postponed operations largely the result of the unvaxxed in this wave. Chronic underfunding is also not the sole issue - even well funded health systems around the world are unable to cope with the weight of the pandemic. Vaccines vastly reduce hospitalisations. Vaccines will relieve the pressure on the health system and save lives.

As to the objections you raise, rules have existed for certain groups to opt out of mandated vaccines in the past, and they undoubtedly would again.

Human life is precious. I repeat: the freedom to refuse a vaccine is not more important than the freedom to live.[/quote]
Thanks for your response. It’s interesting about the initial point you raise being a “theoretical” argument, long before covid I have been in a very non-theoretical situation of being denied help from the NHS for ptsd because there were not enough resources in the NHS, presumably there would have been sufficient resources in the nhs had people not been selfish enough to be obese, smoke, drunk alcohol etc etc. the NHS has been overwhelmed seasonally for years. Every year it’s hit the headlines but people appear to be forgetting this.

Yes tge erosion of individual freedoms might not lead to a dictatorship, just as mandatory vaccination might lead to the NHS not being overwhelmed but the latter is just as uncertain as the former.there’s such a backlog built up within the nhs now that was built up both before vaccination and,yes, before covid that there is probably no chance of the nhs going back to how people want it to be (it it was ever there before) as I mentioned before, treatment being curtailed through lack of resources is not something which as appeared because of unvaccinated people.

Even with mandatory vaccinations not everyone will be vaccinated. What are you going to do to those with those people? Find them? Imprison them? Hold them down and forcibly inject them?

All the problems which existed in the nhs for years have been highlighted by covid. Not to put too finer point on things, those who would potentially have been in hospital beds with flu this year have probably been greatly reduced by the deaths last year.

Although the is undoubtedly some additional pressure on the nhs, it’s become easy to say “because of covid” for so many things and blame a small group of people for the failures of a system already in collapse. People like somewhere to focus their anger.

So whilst we wait for a brain scan for my son, I’m not blaming those exercising person freedom, I’m looking at the long established failures of the system. I realise that establishing the causative effect (rather than correlative effect) of adult people being unvaccinated against a respiratory illness the availability of paediatric scanning services will be a perpetual state of “might”, “what ifs?” Society is always going to be too complicated for over simplified cause and effect. What you can do is look at historical patterns, where you have state sanctioned limitation of personal freedoms, media (and its historical counterpart, the Church) whipping up popularist scapegoating and linked ostracisation it has very rarely worked out well. This significantly leans the might into the probably.

XenoBitch · 05/12/2021 16:49

@JaninaDuszejko

The smallpox vaccination is not the only vaccination to have been mandated.

It is the only one to have been mandated in the UK. There is no strong evidence to support a mandate, and we don't need one in this country anyway. 81% of the eligible population are fully vaccinated with no mandate. We are a pro-vaccination country and we don't like things being mandated. It will not achieve anything, targetted education campaigns will have more of an effect.

It was also only mandated for babies. Totally different to the Covid vaccine mandates going on, where people are losing jobs, access to places, and facing potential fines.
JaninaDuszejko · 05/12/2021 16:45

People who are vaccinated can catch COVID and therefore create a mutation.

Mutations arise spontaneously in both vaccinated and unvaccinated people. And as has been said repeatedly vaccination isn't 100% effective against infection or transmission (although it does reduce both) and so there is only minimal selection pressure applied by vaccination on the virus.