Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why do people let their kids tantrum to then give in when they’ve had enough?

63 replies

LittleBirdy1 · 01/12/2021 12:21

I can’t understand why people put themself and everyone around you through the screaming, leg kicking, hitting, spitting, throwing things, biting and all the other nonsense that goes with it just to give in after 30 minutes or so. My friend who I have known for over 15 years is like this with her youngest and it’s getting to the point where I don’t want to meet up with them. He is 5 just started reception so not a baby or a toddler and old enough to know that his behaviour is not acceptable. Yesterdays meet up he wanted her phone, she said no (he has a history of smashing the screens) he tantrums. During the tantrum he, bite his sister, head butted his mum, throw all the cushions off the sofa, throw his sisters switch and smashed the screen, knocked a hot drink off the coffee table smashing the mug, punched and slammed the living room door, unrolled a couple of toilet rolls from the downstairs loo and tore them up and lastly kicked me twice. After he kicked me she gave in and gave him the phone! She asked if he was hot and bothered and needed a cuddle! A telling off is what he needed but what I don’t get is why we have to endure that for over 30 minutes for her to just give him the phone, surely it would be a lot easier to give it to him in the first place? He goes and goes and goes until she gives in so he has be taught to tantrum to get his own way. Her phone rang and she asked for it back leading to him starting up again throwing the phone up the fireplace and smashing it. So my AIBU here to say I only want to meet up when he is at school and after school for the other kids when he is at his dads?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
MyGhastIsFlabbered · 05/12/2021 09:29

My 9yo still tantrums...he was referred 2 years ago and we are still on the waiting list for an initial assessment for ADHD/ASD. His tantrums go on for hours at times and it's exhausting at times. I can imagine she was totally embarrassed by his behaviour and eventually gave in to avoid that. I'm absolutely mortified when mine behaves like that.

SalmonEile · 04/12/2021 20:32

I wonder is the child getting mixed messages at his Dads, sure he’s 5 and not a baby but he’s still the only one out of a family of five that has to go and stay somewhere else for whatever amount of time he goes for. I wonder do they let him run riot or are overly strict or whatever?

Your friend sounds exhausted, I can’t imagine she lets him smash things for the fun of it. She probably hoped he’d stop and then once he attacked you she had to be seen to do something and make it stop

Doona · 04/12/2021 20:19

That poor Mum! At least she gets a break when he goes to his Dad.

TheSnowyOwl · 04/12/2021 20:14

@LittleBirdy1

Yes I have 3 dc and they certainly have never acted in this way. My 3 dc are the same school years as her older dc and good friends. Her older 3 NEVER acted like this either, so good knows what’s going on with this one.
Maybe he had SEN and she could do with your support instead of judgement?
Chasingaftermidnight · 04/12/2021 20:06

Possibly because she’s human. I can’t imagine being a single mother to four kids is a walk in the park.

Justheretoaskaquestion91 · 04/12/2021 19:59

I only ever give in if I have a friend or someone else with me. She probably in the end felt embarrassed or like you were not having a good time/judging her parenting and so decided to just give in.

KangSaeByeok · 04/12/2021 19:56

Probably because not everyone is as perfect as you.

RobertaFirmino · 04/12/2021 19:50

Crisps are a standard bribe but offering ket just to get to the supermarket is a step too far, you're right

It might cheer the moany little buggers up a bit though @KarmaViolet

RobertaFirmino · 04/12/2021 19:47

@Seeline

Have you got kids OP?
What on earth does that have to do with anything? I am not a pilot but if I see a jumbo jet in the sea, I know something's gone tits up somewhere.
Phewthatwasclose · 01/12/2021 17:30

@SirensofTitan

Crisps are a standard bribe but offering ket just to get to the supermarket is a step too far, you're right

In what world are children bribed to behave with crisps? I've never come across that. Having said that I've never bribed my children with anything so maybe not the best person to ask Smile

In the OP's case I'd be concerned that a child behaving like that needs some professional help, that is totally not on for a 5 year old imo

Whoooosh - missed the point of the post me thinks!
twoshedsjackson · 01/12/2021 14:08

Children do indeed suss out how to get the result they want! I remember one nine-year-old launching a whining campaign at me; she was keen to take some brand-new music home to practise, which had arrived that day and wasn't yet stamped and checked into the system, until I said, "Look, you won't change my mind, you're just making me cross!" ; she stopped, gave me a beaming smile, and said, "It works with Mummy!" "Well it doesn't work with me!" was my reply, and the lesson proceeded...
Obviously, there may be underlying causes, but any NT child can learn the "extinction burst". Ordinary grizzling doesn't get results - up the ante. If that works, they have learned what get results, and that will be the starting point for next time.

BlankTimes · 01/12/2021 14:07

There's a vast difference between a tantrum and a meltdown caused by AN.

A tantrum stops when the object they want is offered. it really is that simple.

MindyStClaire · 01/12/2021 13:57

Because they're human, essentially.

Agree with everyone else that with three older well behaved children, that implies either some wider issues or that she is on her knees as a single parent of four.

Both of those surely deserve some compassion from a friend.

I suspect that she realised his tantrum just wasn't going to resolve and chose the path of least resistance. I can understand that.

Behaving with you and at school doesn't mean he has no SEN or is capable of behaving all of the time, read a bit about masking.

EmergencyHydrangea · 01/12/2021 13:35

@sashh

Was this at your house or hers?

If it was me at my house I'd tell the 5 year old to behave and if he kicked me I would tell him that if he did it again I would kick him harder.

If it was at mum's I'd leave, but I would still tell the 5 year old why.

And yes I have threatened to kick a child in front of a parent.

You would no longer be my friend if you did that, and I'd tell everyone that their children were not safe around you
GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 01/12/2021 13:21

You can’t blame kids for doing it when they’ve been allowed to learn that it works! It’s maddeningly frustrating, though. I used to have a friend who’d say no, no, no, no, for 20 minutes, while her dd (at least 7 or 8 on one occasion I particularly remember) would scream and roar at full volume.

Her mother would then helplessly shrug and say, ‘Oh, go on, then..’ to whatever it was.
Cue instant beam of triumph from the dd.

Made me want to shake the mother, especially when my non-tantruming dd (same age) had been equally sanctioned for the same misbehaviour - and I wasn’t going to give in.

Also I used to work in a library, where a particularly pathetic mother of twin girls would invariably tell them that if they didn’t behave nicely (no screaming or running around bashing into old ladies) they would not be allowed to choose a DVD.

They would invariably misbehave anyway, and then start a full-volume wailing when told no DVD, then.
5 minutes of that, and she’d invariably do the helpless shrug/eye roll - and give in.
Cue smugly triumphant twins, every time.

Some parents really do deserve a good slap!

Blondeshavemorefun · 01/12/2021 13:19

Has Pre school or now school picks up on his behaviour

Tho sounds like he need boundaries. Like you gave him

Parents do give in for a quiet life but in the long term it’s not quiet

If he is breaking items , kicking you or others and throwing breaking stuff he needs to be told no and ideally removed from situation

SirensofTitan · 01/12/2021 13:18

@sashh

Was this at your house or hers?

If it was me at my house I'd tell the 5 year old to behave and if he kicked me I would tell him that if he did it again I would kick him harder.

If it was at mum's I'd leave, but I would still tell the 5 year old why.

And yes I have threatened to kick a child in front of a parent.

I hope I never meet you, you sound vile. Who in their right mind threatens to kick children?
skodadoda · 01/12/2021 13:18

@LittleBirdy1

I do support her and when I’ve looked after him for her he behaves, he knows I won’t give into his nonsense so doesn’t try it. I once removed him off my sofa for jumping on it, told him no and if he did it again he would have to sit on my bottom step in timeout. You guessed it he did it again, I sat him on the step closed the living room door and ignored his crying went to get him after his time and since then he hasn’t tried it on. He was terrible at school for the first week or so but soon realised that the teacher wouldn’t put up with it and now behaves like a normal 5 year old in reception. My point is he can behave so knows his behaviour is naughty but he also knows his mum gives him what he wants if he kicks off enough.
I think that demonstrates that he does not have special needs. The longer she allows him to get what he wants the worse he’s going to be. He will grow up to be someone who can’t control his temper and someone in a few years’ time will be telling us how abusive he is.
megletthesecond · 01/12/2021 13:18

As her other 3 kids are OK it's probably more of an issue with extra needs for her 5yr old. I expect her spirit and energy are long broken. I've managed to not fuck up my eldest (15yrs) with boundaries but my youngest will keep going for ages and break everything.

And a 30 min tantrum as a lone parent is awful especially when they happen every day. It impacts on the other dcs and running of the house.

TheCanyon · 01/12/2021 13:17

Why didn't you tell him off?

SirensofTitan · 01/12/2021 13:16

Crisps are a standard bribe but offering ket just to get to the supermarket is a step too far, you're right

In what world are children bribed to behave with crisps? I've never come across that. Having said that I've never bribed my children with anything so maybe not the best person to ask Smile

In the OP's case I'd be concerned that a child behaving like that needs some professional help, that is totally not on for a 5 year old imo

sashh · 01/12/2021 13:13

Was this at your house or hers?

If it was me at my house I'd tell the 5 year old to behave and if he kicked me I would tell him that if he did it again I would kick him harder.

If it was at mum's I'd leave, but I would still tell the 5 year old why.

And yes I have threatened to kick a child in front of a parent.

BogRollBOGOF · 01/12/2021 13:10

At 5, going for 30 minutes with that intensity and being an experienced parent with "normal range" children I'd be brewing towards suspecting additional needs.

At 5, DS could easily stand his ground for a couple of hours. He was 7 when the aggravation of SATs tipped me towards assessment after a series of intense meltdowns that lasted 3-4 hours. My shins have not forgotten. He was diagnosed at 9.

It's exhausting standing your ground in circumstances like that, especially if it's not private. As he's got older, he's got easier to read and diffuse. Removing stimulation works best and that includes my input into his behaviour. Then he needs comfort to recover. Then we can talk about it and any consequences or how to deal with the situation. Putting on a performance at the time is just more stimulation and more overwhelm.

Wanting to meet seperately is understandable, although in our case it means DS hasn't seen one grandma in two years which stings somewhat. Different with friends that are an adult to adult relationship.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 01/12/2021 13:09

Very few children can actually keep going however long it takes for the adult to give in

For what it’s worth my exMIL said exh was like that - she said it made her worry about if a kid like that got abusive parents as you’d have been able to do anything and he wouldn’t back down

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 01/12/2021 13:05

You are right of course, but it’s so hard to hold that line, especially with an audience. She must have been mortified that he kicked you!

I wonder if he does have SEN because that’s very extreme - has she thought about an assessment?