Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think removing Analogue phone systems by 2025 is too soon?

137 replies

bigbluebus · 01/12/2021 12:19

I know many on MN don't have phones plugged into landlines but many of us who are in slightly older demographic probably still do as our older relatives like to ring on landlines and also mobile reception is not always brilliant in more rural areas.

We were one of the unfortunate households who suffered recent power loss for 3 days and nights in freezing temperatures so keeping in touch with elderly neighbours and relatives was quite important. Of course our cordless phones don't work without power so, as advised, we have an old phone which plugs into a phone socket in such circumstances.

BT plan to get rid of this option by 2025 and landline services will only be available via broadband. As far as I'm aware the plan is to bring in a cheap basic broadband option for those who have no broadband service. But broadband needs electricity. So all those elderly and vulnerable who only have an 'electrically powered' phone line will be totally without any means of communication if the power goes off and they don't have a mobile phone.

The last 3 days here have taught us that the powers that be don't give a shiny sh*te about those on their supposed welfare list in times of crisis. My elderly neighbour (all electric) was not offered any assistance by the energy company and if she had lost her phone line too it would have made life even more difficult.

Whilst we are rural enough to have so many overhead power lines that the storm caused major disruption we are far from being out in the sticks. I feel that once again those not in towns/cities are not being considered in the name of 'progress'.

I appreciate there will come a time when the 'new' older generation will all have mobile phones but don't think that time is here yet nor will it be by 2025.

And don't get me started on the all electric agenda being pushed in the name of global warming - without our open fire we would have been frozen at the weekend!

OP posts:
RufustheFloralmissingreindeer · 02/12/2021 09:08

I have a landline

A number of my mobiles haven’t worked at important times and I therefore prefer the landline for important stuff like hospital appointments and waiting in massive GP appointment queues

Dh really wants to get rid off it but I’m not letting him…seems that he’ll get his way in the end 😀

Octavia174 · 02/12/2021 09:04

@RandomLondoner

You would need an inverter UPS to power a router with wifi and an NTE

I don't think you would need an inverter. My broadband and router both have external power supplies which I think supply low-voltage DC to the devices. The broadband has built-in battery backup of penlight batteries, so clearly it doesn't need mains voltage to work.

and if you wanted something that might last 72 hours, your looking at a lot of money

I admit that when I googled power supplies after posting, none of the ones I saw were designed to last days. But remember that 99% of people don't need anything, because they can cope with the power cuts they get without a landline. (The longest cut I've had in 35 years in London is about 4 hours.) The aggregate cost of a solution for a small number of people who need it should be affordable.

How many people (a) currently have a landline and (b) live where there is no mobile signal and (c) repeatedly experience power cuts lasting days rather than hours and (d) would have their life endangered if they couldn't communicate from home for a few days?

The newer BT nte's dont have battery backup (mine doesn't) Still need to power the router...

For ease of use, having equipment plugged into an inverter means everything just keeps working in the event of a power cut.

Plenty of rural areas have non existent mb signal and plenty of people use emergency alarms for medical reasons that go through a landline & for many elderly with things like Parkinsons, they will need a single press button/sudden fall activation solution that is line powered.

I read the BT pdf on this switch over and they completely failed to mention medical alarms.

mogsrus · 01/12/2021 19:32

Car batteries are very cheap but reducing 12 volts to 2 or 3 requires a voltage dropper then you need the actual plug for the router. In theory it works

RandomLondoner · 01/12/2021 19:05

After doing a back-of-the-envelope calculation, I think a car battery might be able to power broadband and router for several days. Car batteries are relatively cheap.

VeganCheesePlease · 01/12/2021 19:00

Its not BT getting rid, it's Openreach so all companies will be the same by then.

StCharlotte · 01/12/2021 18:59

I heard an "infomercial" about it the other day. I'm fairly tech-savvy (or I thought I was) but it was utterly incomprehensible and might as well have been in a foreign language.

I don't fancy 90 yo MIL's chances...

RandomLondoner · 01/12/2021 18:52

You would need an inverter UPS to power a router with wifi and an NTE

I don't think you would need an inverter. My broadband and router both have external power supplies which I think supply low-voltage DC to the devices. The broadband has built-in battery backup of penlight batteries, so clearly it doesn't need mains voltage to work.

and if you wanted something that might last 72 hours, your looking at a lot of money

I admit that when I googled power supplies after posting, none of the ones I saw were designed to last days. But remember that 99% of people don't need anything, because they can cope with the power cuts they get without a landline. (The longest cut I've had in 35 years in London is about 4 hours.) The aggregate cost of a solution for a small number of people who need it should be affordable.

How many people (a) currently have a landline and (b) live where there is no mobile signal and (c) repeatedly experience power cuts lasting days rather than hours and (d) would have their life endangered if they couldn't communicate from home for a few days?

Octavia174 · 01/12/2021 18:45

@TheHateIsNotGood

Thank you mogrus for confirming why LLs are very useful, as you quite rightly state "they work in a power cut".

Thank you also for your knowledge-based advice as you seem to know what you're talking about.

You may be in luck, open reach do already use hybrid cables, fibre and copper in one cable, so no reason why a media converter couldn't be used in the exchange/cab to give an analog line to those that either don't have internet or without mb reception or indeed a mb.
Trivium4all · 01/12/2021 18:42

neither ELECTRICITY nor internet nor mobile, that should have said!

Trivium4all · 01/12/2021 18:41

To those saying to use a mobile for back-up (assuming your home gets mobile signal, which many rural areas don't): this particular storm knocked out a bunch of mobile masts as well, so quite a few of my friends had neither a LL, nor internet, nor mobile. I'm all in favour of modernising and upgrading the infrastructure, as I think is the OP: we'd just like the new infrastructure to be fully reliable in case of emergencies, before the old one is turned off. Many of rural dwellers have little faith in BT's ability to deliver this reliability of infrastructure, which isn't surprising, given how left-behind many areas are generally, in terms of technology (open fires and back boilers, anyone?)!

TheHateIsNotGood · 01/12/2021 18:31

correction to above should read fresh, sewerage and run-off water.

TheHateIsNotGood · 01/12/2021 18:30

I wish your dd well, maybe I can encourage you also to design a mobile phone for UK manufacture, they've found Lithium in Cornwall.

Rather than tear down an old but functioning telephone system, I'd rather money was spent dividing our water systems into fresh, water and run-off.

But that would require quite a bit of econo-political upheaval.

mogsrus · 01/12/2021 18:20

Thank you for those words of encouragement. My daughter had to ghost write a article for her company & it was published in a specialised publication for the phone industry but having said that, my background is electronics etc

TheHateIsNotGood · 01/12/2021 18:16

Thank you mogrus for confirming why LLs are very useful, as you quite rightly state "they work in a power cut".

Thank you also for your knowledge-based advice as you seem to know what you're talking about.

mogsrus · 01/12/2021 18:06

That is absolutely correct, 50 volts is supplied via the exchange that’s why the work in a power cut.

Octavia174 · 01/12/2021 18:06

@mogsrus

For goodness sake. Copper wires cannot carry the information fast enough.all the world is going digital, copper has been with us since the dawn off time. We had dialup internet once upon a time who has that now? Internet is permanently connected, fibre is cheaper to install,and doesn’t get hot as do wires. Digital & fibre pass information at the speed of light, wire cannot do that and the switching gear in exchanges cannot keep up, the gear is outdated,,it’s over 60 yrs old
Well its not really, main exchanges went digital (PCM) in late 80s and have been upgraded to fibre backbone more recently, only the local network is copper and even that is only from a local cab for most places.

TXE4 went out years ago... twisted pair do not get hot.

No one is objecting to FTTP, what they object to is losing the ability to make calls in the event of a power failure.

Octavia174 · 01/12/2021 18:01

@TheHateIsNotGood

Mogrus maybe so, but whenever there's been a power cut my plug-in landline telephone has worked.
Yes thats because when you pick up the handset, the line is supplied with 50v from the local exchange, so with a conventional wired handset, you don't need any electricity at your home (you do for a cordless h/s)

This has saved me a few times when there has been a power cut, i can report it! OR even report a BT internet or line fault......

Mobile reception is non existent.

mogsrus · 01/12/2021 17:59

For goodness sake. Copper wires cannot carry the information fast enough.all the world is going digital, copper has been with us since the dawn off time. We had dialup internet once upon a time who has that now? Internet is permanently connected, fibre is cheaper to install,and doesn’t get hot as do wires. Digital & fibre pass information at the speed of light, wire cannot do that and the switching gear in exchanges cannot keep up, the gear is outdated,,it’s over 60 yrs old

TheHateIsNotGood · 01/12/2021 17:52

Mogrus maybe so, but whenever there's been a power cut my plug-in landline telephone has worked.

KrispyKale · 01/12/2021 17:49

Chargers powered by rain! That's what I need.

KrispyKale · 01/12/2021 17:43

Solar panel chargers where I live right now would not be adequate.

Octavia174 · 01/12/2021 17:42

@mogsrus

Why is 2025 too soon.? It’s got to be done sometime when would be the right time
Why has it "got" to be done?

Its just another example of technology that is less reliable, that many don't want, its also hugely costly, which means higher bills, they aren't doing this for our benefit.

Funny how they can find the money to move us all onto fibre but there is no money to stop pumping shit into rivers...

mogsrus · 01/12/2021 17:40

[quote TheSecondMrsAshwell]@malmi

Would you not rather hope for a reliable internet connection by 2025?

Hope for? No, I would like it delivered solidly before analogue is turned off.[/quote]
As I wrote before. Analogue cannot handle the bandwidth down copper wires but in the meantime it has to be kept going in some form or other it’s all progressive

TheSecondMrsAshwell · 01/12/2021 17:34

@malmi

Would you not rather hope for a reliable internet connection by 2025?

Hope for? No, I would like it delivered solidly before analogue is turned off.

FunnyInjury · 01/12/2021 17:28

Yes Krispy! My thought exactly 🤷‍♀️