Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Breaking point with 5 year old

60 replies

Mummypig7 · 01/12/2021 09:30

Sorry if this is in the wrong place, I wasn’t sure where to post. But I’m pretty much at breaking point with my 5 year old. He’s awkward, won’t listen, won’t do as he’s told. He’s just a nightmare. This morning on the way to school he takes my phone out of my pocket and runs off with it with his friends. I couldn’t get it back off him as I was in the school line with my pram. He then throws it on the wet grass twice now my volume is a bit hit and miss. He then throws himself onto the wet floor saying “ouch my leg” even though there was nothing wrong with it. A mum who I have got quite friendly with at school has a 2 year old in a buggy and he tries to kick him and she tells him not to do it (which is totally fine I don’t blame her, I could have strangled him) I was mortified. I haven’t brought him up to do things like that. I nearly ended up crying to her in frustration. I just don’t know what else I can do with him. I have tried all sorts. I’ve tried taking his tablet off him, no treats, naughty step, sticker chart for good behaviour. Nothing I do makes him behave. When I shout he will laugh and say “I’m not bothered” I’m just so exhausted with himSad

OP posts:
Mummypig7 · 01/12/2021 10:36

@Wondergirl100 He is in year 1. He turned 5 at the end of august. He will come home and say he’s been doing phonics and maths, sometimes he will say they have sat on the carpet watching something. He has PE twice a week. At parents evening they told me his is a little behind on reading and writing but he is on the right track with maths. I don’t have time to take him to the park before school but I could after school. He does have a lot of energy to burn, he can’t seem to keep still

OP posts:
Confusedandworried321 · 01/12/2021 10:36

@Wondergirl100 I completely agree with you about the expectations of school. My DS is in year 1 and he complains all the time that there’s no playing, too much writing. Most of the naughty behaviours his teacher has told me about, she has told me a few times that “the other children do what they’re told” etc, which is first of all really unhelpful and means I’ve taken a dislike to her (so god help my 5 year old) but also, I was genuinely surprised, that in a class of 30, the rest of the children do what they’re asked straight away/listen/aren’t fidgety and sometimes cheeky.

FfsAlexa · 01/12/2021 10:34

What has he been like as a child generally. Shouting can be a way to regulate sensory processing difficulties. After school meltdowns could indicate this too. Is he quite sensory seeking? Demand avoidant? Is he high energy? Sleeping enough? Try and focus on triggers more than punishments and see if that helps. Eg if you see the signs you get him out of the playground asap. Give him space and no demands ... a chance to decompress. Hand him a big snack straight away and sit him in same spot to eat it. A routine. Get OT to assess him for sensory needs. This time of year difficult. Is he having to sit really still whilst class rehearsing for school play etc.

GrandTheftWalrus · 01/12/2021 10:33

I've banned my daughter from YouTube as well. It was affecting her behaviour. Now if she's good she's allowed 10 mins on Netflix . She doesn't play any games on the tablet etc. She loves jigsaws and can sit for hours doing them.

I think she's getting overwhelmed with school and takes to lashing out.

I am getting to the point where I dread picking her up incase she's done something again. They also seem to only speak to me and not her dad which is starting to affect my mental health.

The other night they decided to try and call me at 5pm!

magicstars · 01/12/2021 10:31

Yes @Mummypig7 I totally agree with what PPs are saying about the impact of screen time. Our TV conveniently 'broke' & can now only be used by control of my phone. The monitor is even turned to face the wall when I'm not present to monitor its use.
My dc were totally hooked on Netflix. There has been a huge improvement, though the first couple of weeks were hard.
It's been a good few days since Ds has asked for tv (I put a film on for him last week).
They do have tablets but again, only use for short periods & No interactive games.

As well as highlighting concerns to school (rest assured they will be dealing sit far worse behaviour) you may want your Screens to 'break' too for a few weeks. See if it helps.

It does also sound like he gets a lot from his peers finding him funny, which is more challenging to manage!

I expect he will grow through this regardless. You care & you're there for him, that's what really matters x

Mummypig7 · 01/12/2021 10:31

@EL1984 I have insta so I will have a look at that. Thank you for the ideas

@Rosieposie79 DS won’t play with his toys either. He likes to colour and draw now and then but he will get bored after a short while. I’ll look on the App Store and see if there is anything more calmer for him. I do think some of the games he plays aren’t good for him. When he comes off his tablet he seems to become more hyper

OP posts:
Wondergirl100 · 01/12/2021 10:28

Hi op - is he year 1 or reception? I always say this on threads as I feel it so strongly but the leap to Year 1 / Year 2 is horrendous for some children - what is his day like? Is he sitting down a lot? Is he controlled/ his behaviour 'managed' constantly all day long? Is he having to do a lot of reading and writing?

I have a very energetic boy ! When he was in year 1 and 2 he was a nightmare - he needed to run around wildly !

IS there anyway he could get execrise before school? Breakfast club/ 20 mins in the park? I know it sounds bonkers but its such a tough day.

Big snack after school then instead of snack you take him for fresh air until dark, even tea out - then he can have the tv later, I would ban the roblox and just do kids tv.

Really the day is so so tough at that age for an energetic physical child - dont blame the child, blame the system. He may well be behaving at school but find it totally exhausting.

Mummypig7 · 01/12/2021 10:25

@tpmumtobe I have wondered if he is too young for roblox. I think I’ll delete it for now. He has lots of other games on his tablet more suitable for his age but he says they are ‘baby games’ He sometimes watches Minecraft videos on YouTube so getting him the game sounds a good idea

OP posts:
Rosieposie79 · 01/12/2021 10:24

I got into giving my 4 yr old youtube kids to watch recently and her behaviour went downhill dramatically. We had tantrums on the way too and from school, constant shouting, whining and baby talk. It was like the flashing screen and the constantly changing images frazzled her brain, and shortened her concentration span. It was also clearly quite addictive.
Strangely it just doesn't have the same effect on my other daughter - I don't know if being 3 years older makes the difference or whether they are just wired differently.

Instead now if I need to occupy her for 30 mins and she just won't play with toys, I put on something longer and less flashy like Stickman / The Snowman etc. Or I give her a drawing programme on my tablet where she has to create or colour something and then I give her lots of praise and print off the finished artwork to stick up.

I had to completely ban youtube for her to accept the change. Her behaviour is massively better though.
Could the tablet 'break' and 'go away for repair' for a couple of weeks and see if there is a change?

Mummypig7 · 01/12/2021 10:22

@Ceecee30 When we are walking to school on our own he is fine. Well most of the time. Sometimes he will run off from me and hide. It’s when he spots his friends he starts turning silly. It’s like he wants to show off or be the class clown. I have been called in a couple of times since September because he hasn’t listened or has been being cheeky. I think I will speak to his teacher at home time and see if she can suggest anything. Thank you x

OP posts:
EL1984 · 01/12/2021 10:21

I have a younger toddler and have been following Big Little Feelings on insta and have purchased their course. It might be useful but check the age range is appropriate.
Strategies like focusing 1 on 1 attention with them every day, praising good behaviour, explaining it's ok to be angry but suggest alternative outlets than kicking/hurting others rather than punishment.
Lots of prepping to avoid 'surprises' e.g it's bath time in 5 mins, bath time in 1 min, now it's bath time.

tpmumtobe · 01/12/2021 10:20

@Mummypig7 I would seriously rethink the Roblox at age 5. I have two boys who had plenty of managed screen time from a young age but I banned the oldest from Roblox until age 9 and then younger one still isn't allowed on it. The difference in their behaviour when they were on Roblox was incredible compared to other games. It's so addictive, even the games aimed at younger kids, it's PEGI7 for a reason. They couldn't moderate their behaviour once they came off it, they were rude, snappy, shouty it was grim. Once I banned it their behaviour improved massively. Don't get me wrong, they still get loads of screen time, I think it's impractical to ban it completely, but you should try him on Minecraft or something a bit less frantic, see if it helps?

Mummypig7 · 01/12/2021 10:17

@GrandTheftWalrus That sounds a good idea. I’ll see if they have anything like that in place.

@coronafiona thank you x

@User5252727 That’s interesting. There’s so much to parenting that I don’t know. I will try and find that book thank you

OP posts:
Ceecee30 · 01/12/2021 10:16

Is it constant or just at specific times? Maybe some things are triggering him. What's he like at school?

I ask because you mention the school line at drop off. My own Ds would get very overwhelmed at both drop offs and pick ups with the amount of parents and kids. He would start thrashing himself around, playing up, throwing things around etc. I had to speak to the shcool and ask if he could enter and leave by the main reception for a while. It's fine now he's older though.

Other than that, I don't have much advice. Just set clear boundaries and hope it's just a passing phase. You have my sympathy though 💕

Confusedandworried321 · 01/12/2021 10:16

@User5252727 that’s really interesting as I think that’s a big thing for my DS. Consequences and rewards do work for him, but it has to be worth his while and pretty immediate. I met with his teacher and SENCO at school and they suggested changing tack and using language around “good/bad choices” to try and encourage him to take responsibility for making these choices himself. It’s working well at home, so far, I don’t know about school.

I’ll give that book a read!

Mummypig7 · 01/12/2021 10:13

@Confusedandworried321 That has crossed my mind but I’m not sure. I did mention that to his teacher at parents evening, she said it could be a possibility and to keep monitoring him from both ends. And I’m very much familiar with having to ask him to do things several times! Drives me mad.

OP posts:
User5252727 · 01/12/2021 10:11

It sounds like the framework of punishment and reward isn't working for him. It is very often the case that the carrot and stick approach fails, because it teaches children to behave for the purpose of obtaining external validation, rather than developing their internal motivation to be kind, helpful etc. This means that when the external reward isn't available (because no one is watching or good behaviour is expected without a reward) the child has no motivation to behave and so they misbehave to get attention, or the promise of a reward if they do then start behaving.

I really recommend a book called 'the unconditional parent' by Alfie Cohn. It has really helpful advice on parenting without the use of punishments and rewards, and helping children to develop their own internal motivation for behaving.

coronafiona · 01/12/2021 10:11

At this time of year children are exhausted over stimulated and excited. I tend to view December as survival until Christmas holidays. Don't worry yourself too much he will be ok and this will pass- I'm not saying don't discipline him but don't worry yourself over this x

GrandTheftWalrus · 01/12/2021 10:06

We are being told we need a meeting with the headteacher as well. She's got a smiley fave reward chart and they get stars in school with rewards and she's had 2 rewards etc so she can be good.

Confusedandworried321 · 01/12/2021 10:06

My DS is cheeky at school too. I think he’s got ADHD and am starting the assessment process.

He isn’t as “naughty” at home as you’ve described yours, but he is very defiant, I always have to ask several times for him to do things.

Mummypig7 · 01/12/2021 10:06

@tpmumtobe He has an hour after school on his tablet then half an hour watching tv later on. He sometimes plays roblox but I keep an eye on what he is playing. Other times he will play football games. He watches Ryan’s toys on YouTube mainly or films. I ban him for the rest of the day if he’s being naughty and if he is good in the mornings getting ready for school he can have his hour when he gets home

OP posts:
tpmumtobe · 01/12/2021 10:00

How much screen time does he have and what is he watching/ what games is he playing? When you take the tablet off him, how long do you ban him for?

magicstars · 01/12/2021 10:00

Ah so perhaps he's getting the positive reinforcement for his behaviours from peers, & doesn't know where the 'silly' behaviour is appropriate.
Yes request the meeting with the head now so the school are fully on board x

Mummypig7 · 01/12/2021 09:55

@magicstars They laugh and tell him he’s funny

OP posts:
Mummypig7 · 01/12/2021 09:55

@magicstars I don’t think he’s being bullied, he’s never mentioned anything and he seems to have a lot of friends from what I’ve seen in the playground. I’m not sure of any groups but I’ll ask. He’s been cheeky more than once in class, I’ve been called in twice now and the teacher told me if this keeps happening then I’ll have to have a meeting with the headteacher. But since that they haven’t mentioned anything. Maybe that’s what needs to happen

OP posts: