Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Breaking point with 5 year old

60 replies

Mummypig7 · 01/12/2021 09:30

Sorry if this is in the wrong place, I wasn’t sure where to post. But I’m pretty much at breaking point with my 5 year old. He’s awkward, won’t listen, won’t do as he’s told. He’s just a nightmare. This morning on the way to school he takes my phone out of my pocket and runs off with it with his friends. I couldn’t get it back off him as I was in the school line with my pram. He then throws it on the wet grass twice now my volume is a bit hit and miss. He then throws himself onto the wet floor saying “ouch my leg” even though there was nothing wrong with it. A mum who I have got quite friendly with at school has a 2 year old in a buggy and he tries to kick him and she tells him not to do it (which is totally fine I don’t blame her, I could have strangled him) I was mortified. I haven’t brought him up to do things like that. I nearly ended up crying to her in frustration. I just don’t know what else I can do with him. I have tried all sorts. I’ve tried taking his tablet off him, no treats, naughty step, sticker chart for good behaviour. Nothing I do makes him behave. When I shout he will laugh and say “I’m not bothered” I’m just so exhausted with himSad

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Confusedandworried321 · 02/12/2021 12:48

I completely agree with regards to the playtime, thankfully my DS' school doesn't use that as a punishment until Y3 and older as far as I know.

Primary education in the UK seems very old fashioned though, I'm sure it depends on the school and teacher, but my DS' teacher could easily have taught me back in the 90's.

Icebreaker99 · 01/12/2021 16:09

@Wondergirl100 the trouble is what is the alternative with so little time for focus on emotional and social skills and resources? I agree it's not ideal and pointless when it doesn't work but if teachers don't do anything then what example does it set to the other children?

Wondergirl100 · 01/12/2021 15:50

@Icebreaker99 I completely agree that the pressure schools are put under is ridiculous - but if a 5 year old has their playtime taken away as a punishment that is a decision made by a teacher.

I'm not knocking teachers or schools - I am a big fan of them! But it is not the fault of a 5 year old if they are struggling with behaviour and not all schools owuld respond by taking away play time

orangina01 · 01/12/2021 13:57

I completely agree about limiting tablet screen time in particular. My kids aren't allowed any YouTube at all and tablets are only for long car journeys of an hour or more. They are allowed TV but when I say turn it off they know they have to do something else. My eldest does get grief from friends for not 'having' YouTube or Tiktok but I honestly think they can't self regulate and it's easier once the expectation of being able to sit on a tablet is removed. My younger one loves art and we have tons of art related activities that are mess free and not too stressful for me if they just get them out ok their own and start playing. Also, does he watch TV in the morning? Once we did away with this years ago, mornings became do much easier!!

Flockameanie · 01/12/2021 13:47

I haven’t read all the posts, but I suggest getting rid of the tablet altogether. DS’s behaviour is noticeably worse when he’s been on it - and not necessarily directly afterwards. We didn’t let him have it at all last week and his behaviour was so much better, so we’ve made it a permanent thing. Not as a punishment, but because I don’t think it was doing him any favours to let him use it. He was using only educational stuff and watching some tv on it. I know it’s hard because the iPad keeps them occupied and out of your hair, but it’s amazing how quickly he’s adapted to entertaining himself and playing more with his toys. He’s so much nicer too!

Icebreaker99 · 01/12/2021 13:24

we shouldn't have to explain to schools and teachers that children in Year 1 were 3 years old when we went into lockdown!

Your anger should be directed to the Government and DoE they are the ones holding schools and teachers to the same expected outcomes for pupils if there had not been a pandemic.

Wondergirl100 · 01/12/2021 12:45

sorry to keep posting but this makes me so cross. OP your 5 year old is a 'covid kid' - two really important years disrupted and damaged - I think you need to get the school on board with being supportive, if he finds it hard to sit etc, can he go and fiddle with a toy or something - make sure he doesn't miss playtimes.

Get lots of play and social time and then lots of chilling out - I would praise praise praise.

Wondergirl100 · 01/12/2021 12:44

And - surely we shouldn't have to explain to schools and teachers that children in Year 1 were 3 years old when we went into lockdown! They have had two incerdibly important developmental years heavily disrupted, lost huge amounts of play and social time and are now being given the same expectations as a child who had never been through any of that - and then on top of that the expectations were ludicrous even before the pandemic!

Wondergirl100 · 01/12/2021 12:42

@Confusedandworried321 that sort of thing makes me so sad. Children are just trying to be playful and how completely boring is times tables to a 5 year old. There will always be children who struggle with rules - the others are compliant it doesn't mean that it's optimal at all for them to be sitting there doing that at their age

I would personally push back very hard at school for removing playtimes - it's always wrong but it's very specifically wrong at that age and for a child who is having trouble regulating behaviour and sitting still.

Bunnycat101 · 01/12/2021 12:34

I think you have to separate out some of the general awkward behaviour and kicking a 2 year old in a buggy. The latter is really awful and needs dealing with as it a step up from all of the other stuff which is probably more common.

There has been a lot of disruptive behaviour in our year 1 class but there is a spectrum. A lot of the boys in particular seem to be struggling with the transition and the teacher has said to me that there are socialisation issues and really lots of the children aren’t ready for year 1. There could be an element of that with your son. But, there has been other more aggressive behaviour that led me to complain very heavily to the school about my daughter being hit, kicked etc that seems to have gone unnoticed. If your son is kicking a 2 year old, is he aggressive in other ways with the other children?

GrandTheftWalrus · 01/12/2021 11:17

Yeah they take playtime and lunchtime away from my dd as well. Which ends up in her being more annoyed.

Bananabrush · 01/12/2021 11:16

I would suggest:

  • less screen-time, given in clear amounts eg 30 minutes a day.
  • a few clear, firm boundaries. Have the rules pinned up on a wall to help you remember. Implement them immediately: eg if you’re in the line at school, the priority is still discipline. Step out of the line, take him somewhere quiet for time out and explain how you expect him to behave. I also recommend counting: eg stop by the time I’ve counted to 3, if you haven’t stopped I take away 5 minutes of screen-time (make sure you do). Avoid taking away all of it because then they have nothing to lose!
  • MOST IMPORTANT: praise and positive attention. Not special treats but regular daily time with you. Eg every night before bed 20 minutes where you play together and he chooses the game. Notice everything good that he does: “thank you for standing quietly in the line with me”, “you’re being so gentle with your sister” etc etc. Feels forced at first but is really important. Be specific and truthful in your praise - if you don’t know what to say just describe what you see: “you brushed your teeth” with a warm tone and smile.

If you do the above consistently (even if it doesn’t appear to work at first - give it a few weeks) you will hopefully notice an improvement. It’s hard so well done for asking for help.

TheOccupier · 01/12/2021 11:14

I'd be permanently removing the tablet and access to anything like Youtube. Half an hour of CBeebies a day is ample screentime for a 5yo. And if he can't be trusted not to run off or to come back when called, put a wrist strap on him and make sure his friends at school see it.

authenticforgery · 01/12/2021 11:10

Don't underestimate the effect of things like certain YouTube channels and games like Roblox on children's behaviour. The change can be astonishing when these things are removed. My 6.5 year old still doesn't have Roblox at all. My 9 year old has very limited use of it.

Confusedandworried321 · 01/12/2021 11:08

@Wondergirl100 my DS was put on the naughty storm cloud for shouting out something silly instead of reciting his times tables with the rest of the class. While I was mortified to hear this and wish he hadn't (and I wish he was one of the other children who just sat quietly, doing what he was told, as I would worry a lot less about him), I do find the expectation of reciting times tables as a whole class at age 5...unrealistic.

Apparently I am the one who's wrong though, and most children that age can manage it.

Wondergirl100 · 01/12/2021 11:01

God it does upset me how children are treated at the age of 5 and 6 in this country. In other countries (really, most other countries) formal education ie. sitting and reading and writing - starts at 7! At this age a child would be running round a kindergarten learning through play - having exercise instead of feeling constantly shamed and judged for not wantitng to sit still

A friend of mine was a TA in year one and said she couldn't bear it as she spent so much time 'shaming' children for not being able to sit still. Children should be moving, it's healthy and natural.

Sadly this is the reality of school in this country but I would focus on giving him ltos of exercise after school - my son was better behaved in summer as he got more exercise after school so the day wasn't as disaastrous for him

HarrisMcCoo · 01/12/2021 11:00

Poor you 😩 you have my sympathies and I have a 6yo who tripped over and fell this morning. Even though I said don't run, before we left for school. Doesn't listen. He is very intense.

Watching thread for advice!

Wondergirl100 · 01/12/2021 10:59

and please - there seem to be peopel having a go at the OP for a pretty normal amount of screen time - while I'm sure it's admirable that some children come home from school and play with toys, there are some very high ideals on mumsnet - most kids watch an hour or two of tv especially when they are tired on dark winter nights.

IDrinkFromTheKegOfGlory · 01/12/2021 10:59

Isn't there a surge of testosterone about the age of 5? My kids are older now but I'm sure I read that around 5 (and again at 7) boys can be affected by these surges?

Wondergirl100 · 01/12/2021 10:58

woah, he should NOT be missing playtime! 'playtime' is when he gets exercise and fresh air - that is a totally unacceptable punishment for a 5 year old. How is he expected to sit still and listen if he isn't given time to destress/ unwind - be a child in fact.

Please talk to the school and say he is struggling with the structure - and needs more slack not more punishment.

mbosnz · 01/12/2021 10:57

I had a 'runner' too. I kept a wrist strap in my bag, and let her know loud and clear that if she ran, then she would be caught and put on the baby lead, in front of all her friends. That stopped that issue.

Icebreaker99 · 01/12/2021 10:53

DS won’t play with his toys either. He likes to colour and draw now and then but he will get bored after a short while. I’ll look on the App Store and see if there is anything more calmer for him.

I'm sorry but you need find him activity and play which isn't around a screen not finding him more apps, I expect he'd play with his toy if that was the only option! He needs to be active in his play for his development he's only 5. If he likes being creative set up more crafts for him. Does he not even like lego? Perhaps he needs to be shown how to play, rather than taking him out or giving him treats can you and his dad take time to sit and talk to him and show him how to play?

I think it might well be telling that he tried to kick a toddler in a pram and may be redirecting feelings about his new sibling so I wouldn't dismiss how much the new baby has affected him.

girlmom21 · 01/12/2021 10:51

[quote Mummypig7]@girlmom21 He said he had to miss playtime[/quote]
Ah and I've seen similar punishments don't work at home.

How good is his understanding? Can he tell you why he behaves in the way he does?

Maybe ask him what would happen at school if he behaved that way and what he thinks his punishment should be. He might start to understand his behaviour is bad when he's deciding his own punishments.

Instead of taking things away, could you replace his free time with a chore?
He's misbehaved so instead of playing on his tablet for the evening he can tidy his bedroom instead, for example?

Mummypig7 · 01/12/2021 10:42

@girlmom21 He said he had to miss playtime

OP posts:
girlmom21 · 01/12/2021 10:41

What punishment did they give him at school that worked?

Swipe left for the next trending thread