Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Warning on Ancestry (and other) DNA tests?

241 replies

MLMshouldbeillegal · 01/12/2021 08:41

Ancestry, My Heritage and the other DNA testing companies are all pushing their tests as the ideal Christmas gift, and they are cheaper than ever. Ancestry had a black Friday offer for £50, My Heritage even cheaper at £39.

AIBU to think these tests should come with a wee health warning? That although it's marketed as a "find out your ethnicity" tool, in fact it might reveal some long-hidden family secrets?

I have tested with Ancestry and uploaded my data to other sites too. No surprises on my tree, matches with distant cousins who all fit into the picture as I know it. But I also go genealogical client work and I'm currently working with a man in his 70s who was given one of the tests for father's day back in June and is trying to process the fact that he is not matching with other descendants of his grandfather. Or at least the man he thought was his grandfather. So in later life, he's trying to come to terms with his much loved grandfather, who his father absolutely adored, is probably not his biological relative. It's a lot to deal with.

The testing companies really push the "find out if you're part Viking, part Native American" in their marketing but that aspect isn't really very accurate - My Heritage says I'm >2% Iraq/Iran/Turkey and I'm definitely not. Ancestry is more accurate given what I know about my tree.

Taking one of these tests could open up a whole can of worms in terms of relationships in the family, in this generation or further back with people who are long dead, and who you can't get answers from. For some people it can be a lot to process and I dont think the implications are properly laid out.

OP posts:
loislovesstewie · 01/12/2021 10:12

I will do the DNA BTW as l can't find my grandfather by the usual routes.

loislovesstewie · 01/12/2021 10:11

BTW if you do any sort of investigations into your family tree then you are bound to find something distressing or potentially distressing. I've found out that my dad and his older brother don't have the same father, other aunts/uncles have had stillbirths, my grandmother's first husband died of syphilis, another ancestor was transported for having sex with a sheep(!), another was found guilty of manslaughter, another was sentenced to death for theft. And lots more. I'm just waiting to find the witches in the family.

If anyone does their family tree you really have to be prepared for shocks/surprises.

Kennykenkencat · 01/12/2021 10:10

I would like to do one because I have so many ethnicities in my family.
Neither parents or grandparents came from the same 2 countries.

However I really don’t want to be contacted by anyone. I am NC with my family and I have done years of work in making myself untraceable.

BungleandGeorge · 01/12/2021 10:09

I agree it’s not appropriate present and should only be done if you’ve chosen to. I had no idea they did the family testing before reading it on here so it’s probably true that their general marketing isn’t geared towards that, I don’t know what happens when you actually sign up though.
Personally I don’t want my DNA on some private companies register and won’t be partaking!

AdmiralCain · 01/12/2021 10:09

I'm often shot down on mumsnet as being a tin foil hat wearer but don't do these tests!! They give all your DNA data to a private company and very alarmingly with your Genome they'll know all your genetic disorders etc. When it comes to health insurance / travel insurance they'll void it if you have an underlying condition and don't declare it. I KNOW there's the Genetic Information Nondiscrimination Act prevents insurance companies obtaining genetic information but yeah like companies don't sell your data...

Jaffajiffy · 01/12/2021 10:04

My brother did one. All fun and games until he was contacted by someone who’d been adopted and was trying to locate her birth mother. Yes, our mum’s cousin. What a ruckus. All the decisions about whether to help, how to help, and what to say/divulge. Not so fun. He agreed to send a letter from the daughter to the mum. The daughter told him that the mum wrote back saying “I don’t want to know you.” So now we all know that as well. The daughter is in a different country and, coincidentally, our aunty is there too, so that’s been a nice outcome - for her to meet someone connected.
I agree that the “a bit of fun” should be tempered.

MissAmbrosia · 01/12/2021 10:03

I had one for Xmas last year. I have spent nearly 20 years on my family tree and have a huge worry of that if one person is not correct, then huge swathes of it could be wrong, so it's put me off doing it a bit. I should sent mine off.

irishfarmer · 01/12/2021 10:02

God, hopefully the adult DS of a friend of mine never does one. His dad is not his bio dad, and he has no clue!
Even if he read a warning I don't think for one second he would think that would be him. He has no reason to think his dad is not his bio dad.

Electriq · 01/12/2021 09:56

My mums did, literally said something along the lines of finding skeletons in the closet.

starrynight21 · 01/12/2021 09:54

A friend of mine found out that he had a daughter he'd never known of. He couldn't be happier .

MLMshouldbeillegal · 01/12/2021 09:47

I sincerely hope that is a typo for public.

Ooops! Yes, typo for public.

OP posts:
MLMshouldbeillegal · 01/12/2021 09:45

@PinkWednesdays

My Heritage says I'm >2% Iraq/Iran/Turkey and I'm definitely not

But how do you know? Less than 2% is really small, so either it goes back many centuries that you haven’t identified yet, or a male ancestor isn’t actually your ancestor?

Well the discrepancy between estimates on two separate websites is the big clue that My Heritage is probably wrong saying I have 2% middle eastern.

These are autosomal DNA tests which look at your DNA from both parents. Autosomal DNA really can only take you back 6 to 8 generations at the very most as beyond that the percentages of DNA are so tiny. Also because of the way DNA recombines - you won't have exactly 25% from each grandparent - by the time you get back to several times great grandparents there might be no detectable DNA link at all.

Without getting too technical, the better option here is for men to take a Y DNA test which traces the son to father link. Because Y doesn't mutate much between generations, it can go back very far indeed.

OP posts:
ChocolateChipMuffin2016 · 01/12/2021 09:45

I have a horrible feeling my DFIL might find out his brother is in fact a half brother and both parents are dead so couldn't even try and find anything out! I told my DH it was a bad idea (they all wanted to do them). DH wanted me to do one but I don't want to do it because I don't want to find out anything that could cause massive upset, I would rather be blissfully ignorant! People should be more careful!

TreeSmuggler · 01/12/2021 09:43

@MLMshouldbeillegal

I don't think people shouldn't do them, *@TreeSmuggler*. I do think though that the risks need to be clearly spelled out.

I understood those risks and implications which was why I was happy enough to go ahead and submit my DNA for testing.

OK but if you understand, why assume everyone else getting the test can't understand and consent also?
afrikat · 01/12/2021 09:43

Several years ago I was building a family tree on Genes Reunited and I got contacted by a woman who ended up being my half sister. My mum had her at 16 and gave her up for adoption. Absolutely no one in the family knew (grandparents had passed away by this point). So that was a shock!

Minceandonions · 01/12/2021 09:42

Agreed. A friend bought one for every member of her family as a Christmas gift!!
But I have an adult cousin who doesn't know that her dad isn't her birth father. It would be catastrophic to find out without him getting a chance to tell her first.
Very dangerous!

Linning · 01/12/2021 09:38

I honestly think they are a bit crap.

My boss gifted me one for Christmas as she was curious about my heritage (I am mixed). The initial answer I had already stated that I was 50% European 48% African (accurate) and then went on to say I was mostly French/German (my mom’s side is French and has been for as long as we can tell) and on the African side my dad’s country wasn’t listed. They then had an update and the 40% French suddenly dropped to 8% and I am now 42% Spanish and Portuguese, 8% French and still no percentage of my dad’s bio country.

Considering they dropped my French heritage by 32% after an updated it’s very unlikely that those test are accurate. Now according to the current results I would barely be related to my mom and neither to my dad. And considering my mom had me at 17, the chances of her adopting me are pretty null and since I am mixed the chances of her being given the wrong baby at hospital are also pretty low.

So I am just going to assume those tests are fairly inaccurate and would advise people to take them with a big grain of salt. I very much wish I wasn’t related to my parents but it’s very unlikely and so I find sad that those tests have managed to make people feel less close to people in their life just because the test suggest that they aren’t related.

sashh · 01/12/2021 09:36

@Lindy2

I'm on Ancestry and I find it quite interesting.

There were very clear warnings and disclaimers about what might be revealed by taking part. I think I even remember a warning that the Police could use pubic dna records.

It doesn't bother me at all.

I sincerely hope that is a typo for public.

There's a really interesting film on YouTube, it's a US TV reporter and her identical twin who take the tests with various companies.

It looks at why there are inaccuracies, and how the information people add and how as the databases grow they become more accurate.

But there are people who are stupid. Someone arguing on Twitter that they knew they were English and that if 'English' wasn't a race then the company wouldn't say he was whatever %, no amount of people telling him that it's not accurate could convince this guy.

Then there is the issue of chimeras, that would not show up in a DNA test, so the test could show your mother is not related to you when in fact she is your biological mother but is a chimera.

Inquisitivearchitect · 01/12/2021 09:36

They must have changed their marketing / literature because when I did mine years ago there was plenty of warnings about it all.

And my ethnicity was exactly as expected (based on stories from grandparents etc!)

KrispyKale · 01/12/2021 09:34

It's an obvious possibility (I would have thought!) when you do a DNA test.

mugoftea456 · 01/12/2021 09:32

My father walked out when I was a child, no huge trauma to me. However i do know he went on to have more children, none of which know i exist. I would never to one of these test, it would be awful for the other children to find out about their fathers previous life in this way.

PinkWednesdays · 01/12/2021 09:29

My Heritage says I'm >2% Iraq/Iran/Turkey and I'm definitely not

But how do you know? Less than 2% is really small, so either it goes back many centuries that you haven’t identified yet, or a male ancestor isn’t actually your ancestor?

MLMshouldbeillegal · 01/12/2021 09:24

I think I even remember a warning that the Police could use pubic dna records.

Not in the UK. Ancestry in the US does not allow routine law enforcement access to DNA, the police have to go to court to get an order to access details.

GedMatch is a different matter, they allow police to access profiles which have been marked public to help narrow down the identity of a criminal, or unidentified human remains. The arrest of the Golden State Killer is the most famous example of this. www.verdict.co.uk/golden-state-killer/ It's s very controversial topic in DNA and genealogy communities.

OP posts:
Theunamedcat · 01/12/2021 09:24

I'm fine with it last year I tested myself and my children we are various amounts of English Scottish Welsh and a touch of Swedish the only suprise was one of my sons is more Scottish than his brother they have the exact same parents! But they do explain how that happens

RedToothBrush · 01/12/2021 09:20

Ive done a lot of family history and discovered that my husbands great grandfather wasn't married to his great grandmother.

Theres a long saga involved which i found out without DNA but it was still delicate. Ive been in touch with the other side and they said their father was never aware of the secret and they only became aware of it themselves through another family member after his death.

I had a good idea there was a secret there and i just found out the details of it. I really wouldn't like to find out, out of the blue by dna.

This secret goes back to 1910 so its not recent and was still difficult to process.

Fascinating but sensitive.

I wouldn't go near dna tests for a whole host of other reasons too... We don't know where that data is going to end up nor what it will be used for in 100 years time.

Knowing how the family secret has echoed down 3 generations, i just think it a can of worms which doesn't do good for the vast majority.