Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Warning on Ancestry (and other) DNA tests?

241 replies

MLMshouldbeillegal · 01/12/2021 08:41

Ancestry, My Heritage and the other DNA testing companies are all pushing their tests as the ideal Christmas gift, and they are cheaper than ever. Ancestry had a black Friday offer for £50, My Heritage even cheaper at £39.

AIBU to think these tests should come with a wee health warning? That although it's marketed as a "find out your ethnicity" tool, in fact it might reveal some long-hidden family secrets?

I have tested with Ancestry and uploaded my data to other sites too. No surprises on my tree, matches with distant cousins who all fit into the picture as I know it. But I also go genealogical client work and I'm currently working with a man in his 70s who was given one of the tests for father's day back in June and is trying to process the fact that he is not matching with other descendants of his grandfather. Or at least the man he thought was his grandfather. So in later life, he's trying to come to terms with his much loved grandfather, who his father absolutely adored, is probably not his biological relative. It's a lot to deal with.

The testing companies really push the "find out if you're part Viking, part Native American" in their marketing but that aspect isn't really very accurate - My Heritage says I'm >2% Iraq/Iran/Turkey and I'm definitely not. Ancestry is more accurate given what I know about my tree.

Taking one of these tests could open up a whole can of worms in terms of relationships in the family, in this generation or further back with people who are long dead, and who you can't get answers from. For some people it can be a lot to process and I dont think the implications are properly laid out.

OP posts:
Ubiquery · 01/12/2021 10:59

@Ceecee30 it could still be the right parentage, just the parents got married later. DNA might, might help clarify one way or the other.

HalfSiblingsMadeContact · 01/12/2021 10:58

Actually, there is a way in which it is significantly WORSE than most posters here are acknowledging. Doing DNA tests and allowing matches to be made doesn't just open you up to discovering "family secrets" or things you might not have wanted to know. It also opens up your own close relatives to these things regardless of whether they have been tested or know that you are doing so.

A while back I was contacted by half siblings conceived through sperm donation - they tracked me down because one of my late father's (long-estranged) siblings had done a test. Now, at the time of these donations, my parents agreed only because anonymity was assured and no records were kept. I have not followed up on this contact for the time being, in respect for my mother (we had had discussions on this topic and she has remained concerned that she does not want contact to arise).

There are far far wider implications of DNA testing currently being made freely available, than most people are considering.

StrychnineInTheSandwiches · 01/12/2021 10:57

Anyone who hands over their DNA data to a private company, and what is more pays for the privilege of doing so, is a bit of a fool.

cupofdecaf · 01/12/2021 10:54

Given the way my DF has put it about my family is complicated it enough. I'm sure he has other kids but I don't need any more complications. One of my half siblings doesn't want anything to do with me because I'm in contact with DF. I can't help it he kept some minimal contact with me as a child and not her. That's not my fault.
I'd rather not know frankly it just causes problems.

RollaCola84 · 01/12/2021 10:53

People buying these tests should also remember it goes wider than them. One of my Dad's cousins did one and discovered a match overseas. It seems their Dad or one of his brothers (including my Dad's dad) fathered a child overseas during the war. The cousin was really excited at the idea of new relatives, my Dad has absolutely no desire in his 70s to find out whether or not he has a half sibling.

Ceecee30 · 01/12/2021 10:53

I've really wanted to do one of them but been hesitant as I don't know my fathers side. Although I know his name and area he lives and could find him pretty easily, so that's not the issue but I do know that he has older kids than me he's never seen either. I get a bit spun out if I'll be potentially linking to them if they have done it. I'm not against finding them, but it's really nerve wracking.

On another note, after my grandfather died last year and going into lockdown I signed up to ancestry myself to do my family tree - just with the research part. I find that really interesting.

But I think I discovered that my grandads brother wasn't his full brother which in this day and age is pretty normal... I always knew my great uncle to have the same surname as my grandad but I learnt great uncle was actually born with his mothers mothers maiden name and lived in another household as a baby (I think babies were often sent to a relatives if born out of wedlock? ). and they must have changed it to my grandads dads name at a later date and moved back with his mum! I already knew my grandad had another older brother born out of wedlock that was sent to live with relatives. My grandad was the only one born in marriage and his dad died when he was small. I also found my grandads dad was married and widowed before marrying my great grandmother which explain more so that my great uncle had a different father because great grandad married someone else the year great uncle was born! Unless it was some kind of weird affair! I couldn't work out if great grandad had kids with his first wife who died fairly young. The info wasn't clear. There was a lot of people living in the household with younger ages too and the same and different surnames but I couldn't work it out.

My grandad died last year, my great uncle died died this year. I will never knew if they knew. In hindsight it doesn't mean if they were half or full. But I just wonder if they knew. I haven't repeated this to anyone apart from Dp.

DaisyNGO · 01/12/2021 10:52

@Cocomarine

I think people need to take personal responsibility and engage their brain 🤷🏻‍♀️ It’s bloody obvious that you might discover something unexpected. The sort of person who doesn’t think of that would read the warning (well, if they bothered to read it) and never assume it could apply to them anyway. Why do you think people should be absolved of using their own brains?
Where's the "like" button?
mam0918 · 01/12/2021 10:47

The beloved grandfather that raised him is STILL his grandfather... DNA wouldn't change his memories and the love he received. Literally, nothing has changed.

As someone with a stepfamily and foster family, it's pretty offensive to suggest that that's a trauma or suffering and somehow less than blood relatives.

These tests have in the last year solved dozens of decade-old missing person cases, kidnapping and doe cases that are worth their weight in gold.

Xenia · 01/12/2021 10:46

I think most people know that. I did it in full knowledge it means if a relative rapes someone they might more easily be found. I am fine with that and to take the responsibility for myself on that (and am not worried about long lost half siblings or something like that).

It does work well eg it showed by DNA my connection to relatives of both my mother and my father which shows it is very very likely I am the genetic child of both parents.

I think it is a huge force for good. The interesting ethical point is the fact you are linked to your relatives so in a sense making a possible decision (in my rape example above) for them. However DNA is a fact so you are doing no more than easing a process that already exists ie the police might take DNA from a relative anyway to show they were involved in a crime.

Ubiquery · 01/12/2021 10:39

I think on balance that secrets and lies do far more damage than truths.

Helpstopthepain · 01/12/2021 10:39

This is why I would never do one. I think my family probably does have secrets and I would rather not know (head in the sand).

MLMshouldbeillegal · 01/12/2021 10:34

After her mother had given my friend up for adoption within the family, she'd had another daughter a couple of years later who she'd given up for adoption to the authorities.

Another case I came across was someone who had done a test and found an older half-sibling, born to his mother before she had got together with his father.

Turns out the mother was raped as a teenager and told only immediate family who were sworn to secrecy, concealed the pregnancy and immediately gave the baby up for adoption. Upsetting for the son to find out his mum had gone through that, even more upsetting for the older half-sibling to find out the circumstances of their conception.

I think we all like to think a potential "not the father expected" event is an affair or something consensual. But it might not be.

OP posts:
Melroses · 01/12/2021 10:31

It does raise some uncomfortable ethical considerations. Apart from the obvious social ones, there are people born of abuse, incest and rape unknowingly connecting and getting sucked into their 'families'. How do they know and what precautions should be taken?

Practicebeingpatient · 01/12/2021 10:31

my ethnicity match on there is actually pretty good and matches what I have paper records to back up. (Apart from 2% scandinavian which is very distant). My Heritage has a higher percentage of North American test takers which I am assuming is where the Middle East in my estimate comes from

There you highlight one of the problems you are warning about. It might be that the paper records for you don't record the full story. A female ancestor might have a baby by someone other than her husband, either through infidelity or rape but on paper he would have been recorded as the natural father. Or there could have been an informal adoption when a unrelated or distantly related child was recorded as the child of a marriage. These things happened a lot back then particularly when the primary records were church records. So your paper records have at least as much margin for inaccuracy as the DNA tests. Who can say which is more accurate?

That being said, you are quite right that people should approach these tests prepared to find things they might not like or expect.

Einszwei · 01/12/2021 10:27

Ancestry DNA testing revealed many unexpected skeletons in our family tree.

Whilst yes, it has been an awkward situation to navigate, it actually allowed a close family member to discover he had a different biological father (who had a hereditary health condition). This in turn allowed him to get treatment for a disease that he didn't know he had.

Wannakisstheteacher · 01/12/2021 10:25

I’ve done one. It probably revealed to a few members that my Grandfather cheated on his wife, impregnated my teenage Grandmother and then left her pregnant and alone in the 1940’s. Good.

HopeHappy · 01/12/2021 10:25

I agree. I'd only give a gift of one of these to someone that had either asked for it and was aware of what could happen, or was certain of at least their immediate family history.

A friend of mine was adopted by family members after her mother gave her up, but she has known both her parents throughout her life, although never lived with them. She got an Ancestry kit for Christmas, just to find out her ethnic makeup really and it was exactly as she expected.

Shortly afterwards she got a notification of a match that said she was a cousin of someone, or possibly (more unlikely) as a half-sibling. New contact got in touch with her and it transpired that they were half siblings. After her mother had given my friend up for adoption within the family, she'd had another daughter a couple of years later who she'd given up for adoption to the authorities. The new sister knew nothing of her family history, and her bio mum is long dead, but she has been able to get in contact with her other half siblings (there are a few!) and a great new blended family has emerged.

In my friend's case it didn't come as a huge surprise given her mum's past, but in other families that could have dropped a massive bombshell.

Marvellousmadness · 01/12/2021 10:24

I would be delighted to know a family secret/discovering true genetics. Honesty at last!

Yabu it all comes with disclaimers and warnings. So people should use their own brain and decide what they wanna do/know.

Ubiquery · 01/12/2021 10:20

I love all of this stuff, absolutely fascinating. I've started helping others with their family trees and DNA results as a hobby.

The ethnicity stuff is very unreliable. And there's a bit of a misunderstanding that it tells you where your ancestors came from. That's not quite true, it tells you where people with common DNA as you are currently living. They use a panels of people who meet certain geographical requirements, as representatives of certain areas. Ancestry has me pin-pointed accurately to one area of my home county.

WorraLiberty · 01/12/2021 10:19

AIBU to think these tests should come with a wee health warning? That although it's marketed as a "find out your ethnicity" tool, in fact it might reveal some long-hidden family secrets?

Because it's painstakingly, blindingly obvious?

2389Champ · 01/12/2021 10:18

I have a positive story about Ancestry.

DH’s parents divorced when he was very young and his father moved on and appeared to have made no attempt to stay in contact. DH knew his father had remarried and had a daughter but no details of when or where. I had bought us both a DNA kit, out of curiosity, and very quickly he got result indicating a very close match of a sibling with a potentially shared parent.

We thought long and hard about whether to contact this woman as we didn’t want to open a can of worms for her as we weren’t sure if she even knew of her older brother’s existence. Adult DD was very keen and composed a beautiful email explaining the background but that if she didn’t want to make contact, we would understand too. By sheer coincidence, DH’s half sibling was going through exactly the same dilemma and her email literally crossed with ours. All the generation that had been involved in the originally break up had died so we felt the time was right.

We’ve met up and gained another branch of the family. Everyone gets on so well and it’s actually spooky how parallel our lives have been without knowing each other. We also discovered that DH’s dad had tried on many occasions to contact him but had been prevented by circumstances so sadly, he never got to know of his two grandchildren.

The ethnicity has been a bit off though. DH’s grandmother was definitely Spanish and there is a clear family line plus photos etc but his DNA says he has only Northern European and no Southern European ancestry whatsoever - which we know isn’t a fact,

KrispyKale · 01/12/2021 10:17

Kenny pretty sure you can have anonymous settings.

KrispyKale · 01/12/2021 10:16

loislovesstewie: very true.

TwoLeftSocksWithHoles · 01/12/2021 10:16

I've not taken a test but based on what I was told at school I'm related to Adam AND Eve!

And they got a shout out (whatever that is) in the bible!

oftenbaffled · 01/12/2021 10:16

It is something you purchase.
No requirement to
Surely that when you purchase you know what you are buying - trying to find out information about your family history, so surely you must know that you may find out information you didn't previously know and yes... that may be surprising / upsetting etc

Perhaps they just come with a warning...

YOU MAY FIND OUT SOMETHING YOU DID NOT WANT TO KNOW!