Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Warning on Ancestry (and other) DNA tests?

241 replies

MLMshouldbeillegal · 01/12/2021 08:41

Ancestry, My Heritage and the other DNA testing companies are all pushing their tests as the ideal Christmas gift, and they are cheaper than ever. Ancestry had a black Friday offer for £50, My Heritage even cheaper at £39.

AIBU to think these tests should come with a wee health warning? That although it's marketed as a "find out your ethnicity" tool, in fact it might reveal some long-hidden family secrets?

I have tested with Ancestry and uploaded my data to other sites too. No surprises on my tree, matches with distant cousins who all fit into the picture as I know it. But I also go genealogical client work and I'm currently working with a man in his 70s who was given one of the tests for father's day back in June and is trying to process the fact that he is not matching with other descendants of his grandfather. Or at least the man he thought was his grandfather. So in later life, he's trying to come to terms with his much loved grandfather, who his father absolutely adored, is probably not his biological relative. It's a lot to deal with.

The testing companies really push the "find out if you're part Viking, part Native American" in their marketing but that aspect isn't really very accurate - My Heritage says I'm >2% Iraq/Iran/Turkey and I'm definitely not. Ancestry is more accurate given what I know about my tree.

Taking one of these tests could open up a whole can of worms in terms of relationships in the family, in this generation or further back with people who are long dead, and who you can't get answers from. For some people it can be a lot to process and I dont think the implications are properly laid out.

OP posts:
MLMshouldbeillegal · 01/12/2021 12:43

@Ylfa

I’m not really sure what your point is - nobody should find out about their ancestors in case it exposes infidelity?
Not al all. I am a huge fan of DNA testing when used in conjunction with more traditional genealogy. And if you're adopted, or all you have is a mother's name on a grandparent's birth certificate, then DNA can provide the answers.

I just think lots of people go into it without thinking through the implications of perhaps finding their dad isn't their dad, or that their mother doesn't match with any of the people she thinks are her cousins.

I also agree that a lot of genetic genealogists do get very zealous about the whole thing. Everyone has the right to know where they come from and do that DNA test to find relatives. But if there's ambiguity in a result, such as determining which of several brothers are a potential father, then the test taker has no right to start demanding other people test for them to clarify matters. I have seen this so many times of the forum - just test your brother/cousin/aunt, pay for the test for them. And lots of upset and disbelief when the aunt says thanks but no thanks, she'd rather not.

OP posts:
GremlinDolphin4 · 01/12/2021 12:42

Absolutely agree with you OP! I did it for fun and to find out if my grandpa had any Viking heritage but discovered my Dad is not my bio Dad among other things! It’s all fine and I’m glad I know but it was all a bit of a shock!

drspouse · 01/12/2021 12:34

My DCs are adopted and their birth fathers have refused to be named on their original birth certificates/do letter box/anything. However DD birth mum told us enough information that we think her birth father has other children, a little older than DD who is 7. DS we don't know (his birth mum doesn't think so but who knows). Given the potential age of DD siblings, we may do this when she is in her late teens because she has, I feel, the right to know if she has siblings and to contact them if they want contact BUT if we did it while they are all children, we would possibly get an uncle or cousin who would potentially tell under age children that their father had been unfaithful. We need to be certain that all the children (that we know of/suspect) are adults.

Ylfa · 01/12/2021 12:33

Sorry that was to RollaColla

Ylfa · 01/12/2021 12:31

I’m not really sure what your point is - nobody should find out about their ancestors in case it exposes infidelity?

Fink · 01/12/2021 12:28

I don't know for every single one of these companies, but for most of them the ethnicity estimates are just based on a database of other people whose DNA analysis is publicly available or has been purchased by the company. So when it says you're x % from a certain country, all it means is that you have a match with the DNA of people who currently live in that country, it doesn't historically analyse where your actual ancestors were from - which is how most lay people are led to believe it works. So in terms of ethnicity, most proper geneticists think that this sort of DNA testing is useful for population-wide analysis, but pretty much meaningless for an individual.

Of course, the individual matches between family members are much more accurate, so if that's what people want them for then they work fine. But all this 40% French, 2% Algerian stuff is absolute crap.

RollaCola84 · 01/12/2021 12:23

@Ylfa (b)These tests are great for establishing genetic relationships and for illuminating lies and gaps in the paper trail (b)

Which not everyone wants to know, there is a difference between people who are adopted wanting to know where they came from. I have a friend and a relative by marriage who have both sought out birth parents. But these tests can throw a whole family into turmoil and I don't think it's right for one individual to make that decision for their parents, grandparents, siblings etc.

We now know that either my granddad or one of his brothers had a child that they probably never knew anything about. My Dad didn't ask to find out that he might have a half sibling, my Dad's other cousin didn't ask to find out that her father might have been unfaithful to her mother.

catandcandle · 01/12/2021 12:21

I found out who my biological father is (confirming what I thought) and I am glad I did. I am not planning to contact him, but it is interesting to know my heritage.

My DH has found out an even more important piece of information, which is that both his mother and grandmother died of breast cancer. DH has daughters and so needs to give them this information. This information came from someone we would not have been in contact with at all had she not shown as a match to DH. She contacted us after seeing she was a match with DH, whose surname is a branch of the family she is actively researching. So potentailly life-saving information.

DaisyNGO · 01/12/2021 12:21

@Alltheblue

11:03DaisyNGO

I can't remember the details, I think it was the context of a 23 and me test which flagged someone up for either Parkinson's or Alzheimer's. While you might think knowing you're at risk would help you make lifestyle changes to avoid it, apparently this is not the case for some illnesses as the anxiety increases vulnerability.

I had a feeling this would be anxiety related. Thanks.
EmotionalSupportBear · 01/12/2021 12:18

i agree, i did mine but refused the option of them matching you genetically to anyone else, so haven't had to deal with that side of it.

Chocolatewheatos · 01/12/2021 12:16

They tell you what they give you. If you don't want that then that's on you. Would them giving a warning "by the way, the dna test you bought might tell you your dad isn't your dad." Actually change anything?

NowEvenBetter · 01/12/2021 12:16

‘Genetic tests may have results’. Basic common sense. Do people need warning signs for everything?

AdmiralCain · 01/12/2021 12:13

@MLMshouldbeillegal Thank you for confirming what I said

Justilou1 · 01/12/2021 12:12

A friend of mine is a genetic counsellor. She warns everyone she knows against doing these tests because the medical information is stored and sold on to insurance companies to affect future generations. It’s very “Gattaca” or “The Island”, but that’s where the real money is.

OVienna · 01/12/2021 12:11

Found my birth father on a commercial DNA test (I knew I was adopted.) I expected to be one of those people who only got second and third cousins back and that I'd have the chance to take my time and slowly consider if I wanted to dig any deeper. It was shock when BF appeared immediately and overall, traumatic. I really feel for late discovery adoptees and NPEs who will really not know what's hit them.

The kits do come with warnings though - that require people to READ them properly. But the upshot seems to be - no one without any prior suspicions expects it to happen to THEM.

There is also the added nuance that people deep into this sort of genetic geneaology (who got into it for a variety of reasons) IME can often see their trees almost like a legal document that must be correct at all costs, regardless around the emotions of the people involved (adoptees, their adoptive families, the birth families, NPEs etc.) This whole universe of people can be super helpful when you're searching but also seems to have it's own moral codes/way of working that is not always aligned with people not into it all. If that makes sense.

AdmiralCain · 01/12/2021 12:10

@MintMatchmaker The DVLA sell our information, Google sell it, Facebook sell it. We teach our kids to be safe online, this is a continuation of that, I choose to be safe online and not give my genetic information to a company run for profit.
Ok so maybe I'm clutching at straws saying insurance companies greedily want our information (which they do). Some other company will want it.

Ylfa · 01/12/2021 12:09

These tests are great for establishing genetic relationships and for illuminating lies and gaps in the paper trail. I think the ethnicity estimates are spot on at the continental level but, having tested with ancestry, 23andme, MyHeritage and ftdna (and more) there is some variation between which bits of each continent appear in the results. The genetic communities on ancestry and MyHeritage are very similar for me and both my parents (who are in two distinct groups) and the migrations have been fascinating to research. It was good to match with my biological dad even if we don’t have much of a relationship and to identify my maternal grandfather and his lineage.

I don’t see how it’s possible to construct a family tree based only on records which might be false, destroyed or have key info missing, and without establishing which regional groups you should start looking into.

Lockdownbear · 01/12/2021 12:08

@RedToothBrush

Just for your info Scotland had two pieces of case law related to Common Law wife. Around 1909 a lady moved in with her partner, took his name, and they presented themselves as Husband and wife. He died months later, the court ruled she was Common law wife.
The second case was in the 60s they'd lived together for years but didn't have a pretence of marriage the court rules they were co-habitees.

So I don't think it was that unusual for a couple in 1910 not to have the formal paperwork for marriage.

KrisAkabusi · 01/12/2021 11:57

@irishfarmer

God, hopefully the adult DS of a friend of mine never does one. His dad is not his bio dad, and he has no clue! Even if he read a warning I don't think for one second he would think that would be him. He has no reason to think his dad is not his bio dad.
But if you know, other people will know. It's likely to happen whether he does a test or not.
PleaseGoDontGoAgain · 01/12/2021 11:57

@DeadoftheMoon

When I got my results, I told my dad 'It says [his name] is your father.' He insisted on seeing for himself. Apparently, he'd never believed I was his child. I was 62 or 63 ...
Ouch that must've stung a bit
JSL52 · 01/12/2021 11:51

Surely it would occur to you, you may find something you didn't already know ?

WhatsWrongWithMyUsername · 01/12/2021 11:50

I’ve thought about doing it, partly because my great uncle got a girl pregnant in the war and his mother ‘paid her off’ (I don’t know how, they were very poor). I’m not sure if even my great uncle knew. And maybe if that baby or it’s descendants were looking I could help them piece it together.

But then maybe it would come as a shock to them. So maybe best not to meddle!

MintMatchmaker · 01/12/2021 11:46

@AdmiralCain

I'm often shot down on mumsnet as being a tin foil hat wearer but don't do these tests!! They give all your DNA data to a private company and very alarmingly with your Genome they'll know all your genetic disorders etc. When it comes to health insurance / travel insurance they'll void it if you have an underlying condition and don't declare it. I KNOW there's the Genetic Information Nondiscrimination Act prevents insurance companies obtaining genetic information but yeah like companies don't sell your data...
You don’t have to use your real name!

Don’t scaremonger and tell people they will have their insurance voided, that’s absolute rubbish!

You honestly think that the data will be sold, the people traced and then they will have their insurance voided because they have a genetic predisposition to an illness that they don’t even know about and may not go on to develop? That’s just ridiculous.

StarryGazeyEyes · 01/12/2021 11:42

You definitely need to go into it with your eyes open. I have the same reservations as many about handing over my dna, but it was my best shot at finding out the truth about my parentage, and it did that. It confirmed my sister and I are half siblings as we long suspected but no-one would tell us the truth. It has enabled me to track down my biological father who is as big a waste of space as my step-father, but at least I know who he is and where I come from. That has put to bed a lot of demons, so i'm glad I did it.

MLMshouldbeillegal · 01/12/2021 11:38

I wonder what the DNA of someone from Strasbourg who's family have been there generations would reveal?

Most people who have border ancestry have a large circle on the Ancestry maps crossing both countries. My paternal side is all Scottish borders, centred on Kelso which is only about 5 or 10 miles from the border with England. Many of my ancestors were from Northumbria. So on the ethnicity map, although it says "Scottish", the circle goes down as far as about Middlesbrough in England and also includes the Isle of Man and a good chunk of Northern Ireland too.

Similarly, their "Ireland" group includes Brittany in France and some of the Outer Hebrides.

Wales has a good chunk of Merseyside, border counties like Hereford and Gloucester, and Somerset across the Bristol Channel.

So I would imagine someone from Strasbourg would have something like "western European DNA". Lots of people are fixated on the percentages within the UK and it's really fairly meaningless. According to Ancestry I have no "English" DNA but the paper trail confirms dozens of ancestors from Northumbria, but they are lumped in with Scottish DNA.

OP posts: