Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Warning on Ancestry (and other) DNA tests?

241 replies

MLMshouldbeillegal · 01/12/2021 08:41

Ancestry, My Heritage and the other DNA testing companies are all pushing their tests as the ideal Christmas gift, and they are cheaper than ever. Ancestry had a black Friday offer for £50, My Heritage even cheaper at £39.

AIBU to think these tests should come with a wee health warning? That although it's marketed as a "find out your ethnicity" tool, in fact it might reveal some long-hidden family secrets?

I have tested with Ancestry and uploaded my data to other sites too. No surprises on my tree, matches with distant cousins who all fit into the picture as I know it. But I also go genealogical client work and I'm currently working with a man in his 70s who was given one of the tests for father's day back in June and is trying to process the fact that he is not matching with other descendants of his grandfather. Or at least the man he thought was his grandfather. So in later life, he's trying to come to terms with his much loved grandfather, who his father absolutely adored, is probably not his biological relative. It's a lot to deal with.

The testing companies really push the "find out if you're part Viking, part Native American" in their marketing but that aspect isn't really very accurate - My Heritage says I'm >2% Iraq/Iran/Turkey and I'm definitely not. Ancestry is more accurate given what I know about my tree.

Taking one of these tests could open up a whole can of worms in terms of relationships in the family, in this generation or further back with people who are long dead, and who you can't get answers from. For some people it can be a lot to process and I dont think the implications are properly laid out.

OP posts:
ToffeeNotCoffee · 01/12/2021 13:59

Just for your info Scotland had two pieces of case law related to Common Law wife. Around 1909 a lady moved in with her partner, took his name, and they presented themselves as Husband and wife. He died months later, the court ruled she was Common law wife.

This^

I was in the Rabbie (Robbie) Burns centre a few years ago. Scotland's poet was only formally married later in his his life. Prior to that he had, I think, a 'marriage' similar to that above. Back then, it seemed there were three ways of getting married:

  1. Formal marriage ceremony, probably in church. (Or in the Minister's residence next door as happened to my DH's Grandad who in the 1930's was a widower who married his 2nd wife, a spinster. She was Christian but not Presbyterian. Or was it because he had already been married, I forget the reasoning but the details on, 'place of marriage' is clearly written on their marriage certificate !)
  1. Formal marriage ceremony at home. The Minister/celebrant or whatever was required at that time would be in attendance.
  1. No formal marriage ceremony but you presented as a married couple and were just that to all intents and purposes.
ivykaty44 · 01/12/2021 13:48

MLMshouldbeillegal I didn't say you were making assumptions or being silly. This 70 year old seems, from what you've written to be jumping to conclusions with possibly not all the facts, from what you wrote

Terfydactyl · 01/12/2021 13:45

@mugoftea456

My father walked out when I was a child, no huge trauma to me. However i do know he went on to have more children, none of which know i exist. I would never to one of these test, it would be awful for the other children to find out about their fathers previous life in this way.
Similar story with me, but I'm the one who doesn't want to find any more siblings or other family. I want nothing to do with my father ever. Also rules around sharing DNA with police forces/whoever can be changed later. Too late when you've voluntarily given your DNA already.
MLMshouldbeillegal · 01/12/2021 13:42

@LolaButt

I am intrigued about these tests. Particularly the health aspect as I do not know my Father’s information.

I would like to see the extent of my family tree that side but I wouldn’t want them to identify me. Presumably you can’t hide your own information but see others?

You won't get any health information from Ancestry or My Heritage. They are purely for matching you with genetic cousins.

You'd have to do a 23 and Me test for the genetic health information and a separate Ancestry or My Heritage test for the genealogy and cousin matching.

OP posts:
RedToothBrush · 01/12/2021 13:42

Going back to what this data can be used for and by whom, I also would stress that once you've found this information out, a record exists.

This information is incredibly valuable to a wide range of groups - from insurance companies to hostile foreign powers.

So the scope for data to be stolen / hacked etc etc is very much there. And has implications for people you are related to, who haven't done a test too.

I am extremely wary.

RedToothBrush · 01/12/2021 13:39

[quote Lockdownbear]@RedToothBrush

Just for your info Scotland had two pieces of case law related to Common Law wife. Around 1909 a lady moved in with her partner, took his name, and they presented themselves as Husband and wife. He died months later, the court ruled she was Common law wife.
The second case was in the 60s they'd lived together for years but didn't have a pretence of marriage the court rules they were co-habitees.

So I don't think it was that unusual for a couple in 1910 not to have the formal paperwork for marriage.[/quote]
@lockdownbear in the case in DH's family, the great grandfather and mother never divorced so legally, neither could have been regarded as that with their new partners as they were still married.

I know its not that unusual for a couple not to formally marry, but the issue in this case is that they were married to other people and the local community for the great grandmother were aware of this (she ended up being destitute with another baby and was supported by her new partners family (who were her husband's aunt and uncle) whereas her husband moved away and somewhat escaped this notority and had a 'respectable' middle class life and was able to pretend he was married.

Its a sad story as the man the great grandmother ended up with was, by all accounts, not a catch and seems to have frequently walked out and got into trouble with the law (including being charged with being caught in a compromising situation with a man though he was found not guilty of this). I don't really know what happened to the eldest two boys, as they were in the workhouse in 1911 and I've had a long wait on the 1921 census to find out what happened next to them.

MLMshouldbeillegal · 01/12/2021 13:38

Like I said, @ivykaty44, this is still at very preliminary stages. I am not making assumptions or "being silly". Just explaining to a previous poster that it's perfectly possible to work out what is going on with parentage even though the people involved are dead. And the client has yet to share all his information with me - we have an initial meeting set up for next week.

OP posts:
Kennykenkencat · 01/12/2021 13:36

We know from the Cambridge Analytica scandal that CA and Facebook were processing data to produce behavioural profiles. They were using it to tell political parties and lobbies how to "nudge" individuals' behaviour by targeting them each of them with different ads

My Dd found my Facebook profile. I never post anything. But she found it hilarious that I had on there a lot of random groups that are at odds with each other just to f**k with their profile of me.😃

LolaButt · 01/12/2021 13:32

I am intrigued about these tests. Particularly the health aspect as I do not know my Father’s information.

I would like to see the extent of my family tree that side but I wouldn’t want them to identify me. Presumably you can’t hide your own information but see others?

ivykaty44 · 01/12/2021 13:32

So there's something weird going on, and the most likely explanation he believes is that his grandfather wasn't his father's biological father.

It could be that his cousins aren't related to his grandfather and he and his father are related.

It's a very big assumption without factual evidence, which is a silly thing to do.

Unfortunately many people researching family history do jump to conclusions that are wildly wrong, without gaining facts and looking at all the information. Ive found that to be the case on more than one occasion

CovidCorvid · 01/12/2021 13:21

@Justilou1

A friend of mine is a genetic counsellor. She warns everyone she knows against doing these tests because the medical information is stored and sold on to insurance companies to affect future generations. It’s very “Gattaca” or “The Island”, but that’s where the real money is.
I guess you could give the company false details? Slightly different name, burner email account, etc? Try and make it non traceable to you?
MLMshouldbeillegal · 01/12/2021 13:06

I've not delved into it that deeply though, @ivykaty44. The older man has tested through something like Ancestry. He has presumably found matches with people he knows to be cousins on his maternal side. On his paternal side, there are people who he knows to be cousins of his father and who have tested, but who don't share DNA with him at all.

So there's something weird going on, and the most likely explanation he believes is that his grandfather wasn't his father's biological father.

OP posts:
Itsnotallaboutyoubaby · 01/12/2021 13:05

@PerkingFaintly

It's not even a case of what they might do with the data in the future. This is what they're doing with the data right now:

www.ancestry.co.uk/cs/legal/privacystatement
Genetic Information
[...]
We also process your DNA Data to provide you information about your degree of relatedness to other users in our DNA database and any genetic markers associated with certain biological, physiological, or behavioral traits, such as hair thickness and eye color or traits associated with wellness.

Behavioural traits?

We know from the Cambridge Analytica scandal that CA and Facebook were processing data to produce behavioural profiles. They were using it to tell political parties and lobbies how to "nudge" individuals' behaviour by targeting them each of them with different ads.

Combine the Facebook data with Ancestry DNA behavioural data, add in the fact this affects people merely related to the person who takes the DNA test, and we're well into dystopia already. We just haven't seen it yet.

The icing on the cake is that the person being tested often hands the identities of other people sharing their DNA on a plate to Facebook & Ancestry. Upload your family tree to Ancestry? Add friends and family on FB? It's all data to them.

That’s the only reason I haven’t had one. I actually really want to do one because I’m curious but I resent what they will do with the data.
ivykaty44 · 01/12/2021 13:01

so if the older gent tested his DNA and some of his family have test DNA come back as not related to him...

but the grandfather (if the gent is 70) will be long deceased - how have you go his DNA to confirm he is not a relative?

How have you concluded that the other relatives are related to the grandfather and the gent of 70 is not?

PerkingFaintly · 01/12/2021 12:59

BTW it's not just Facebook and Ancestry. They're the tip of the iceberg of a huge data processing industry in which our personal data has been described as "the new oil" for its value to profit-making companies and political bodies.

Red flag: look out for organisations trying to sooth you by saying they won't pass on your data... but will pass on the products of processing your data. Yeah, no.

PerkingFaintly · 01/12/2021 12:58

It's not even a case of what they might do with the data in the future. This is what they're doing with the data right now:

www.ancestry.co.uk/cs/legal/privacystatement
Genetic Information
[...]
We also process your DNA Data to provide you information about your degree of relatedness to other users in our DNA database and any genetic markers associated with certain biological, physiological, or behavioral traits, such as hair thickness and eye color or traits associated with wellness.

Behavioural traits?

We know from the Cambridge Analytica scandal that CA and Facebook were processing data to produce behavioural profiles. They were using it to tell political parties and lobbies how to "nudge" individuals' behaviour by targeting them each of them with different ads.

Combine the Facebook data with Ancestry DNA behavioural data, add in the fact this affects people merely related to the person who takes the DNA test, and we're well into dystopia already. We just haven't seen it yet.

The icing on the cake is that the person being tested often hands the identities of other people sharing their DNA on a plate to Facebook & Ancestry. Upload your family tree to Ancestry? Add friends and family on FB? It's all data to them.

crystaltips98 · 01/12/2021 12:58

I think they are illegal in France for the very reasons explained above

AdmiralCain · 01/12/2021 12:57

@Justilou1 Thank you for confirming what I said

JinglingHellsBells · 01/12/2021 12:56

OP I thought everyone knew that any tracing of ancestry could potentially show up things they didn't know and might not wish to know?

I did a DNA test to discover my heritage but have never used it for anything else. It's up to the individual to use it as much or as little as they want to.

Also, in terms of collecting data, you would be shocked at what is known about you already. if you have a credit card and shop online, a huge amount of data is kept already and has been for 10 years or more. Companies build profiles and all Facebook does it use data from people's accounts and activities to sell to other organisations.

Pinksloth · 01/12/2021 12:54

@Strawberry0909

I agree, a relative of mine did one of these and discovered he had another brother, a man he grew up with,
We had this in our family too, although with us it was a complete stranger. Not a surprise, really, that the now deceased relative had had a child outside of his immediate family set up, as he had form. Luckily it wasn't his wife that found out, as she'd be devastated but a younger member of the family who's kept schtum, but was a bit shaken.
Xenia · 01/12/2021 12:53

MLM thanks. I thought it was extremely unlikely - not that many women cheat!

MLMshouldbeillegal · 01/12/2021 12:46

I wonder if any of these sites have been able to check if the much quoted statistic that a third of babies born within a marriage are not their father's child is correct or wildly out?

That's been fairly roundly debunked.

They reckon 1-2% and that percentage has remained fairly static for a while.

www.kqed.org/science/11450/new-dna-studies-debunk-misconceptions-about-paternal-relationships

OP posts:
Ylfa · 01/12/2021 12:44

“ I don't think it's right for one individual to make that decision for their parents, grandparents, siblings etc” yeah I do understand this, but one individual already made that decision for everyone when he decided to inseminate whoever wherever?

Xenia · 01/12/2021 12:43

Rolla, that is in the interesting moral issue - that something you do a DNA test or of course something more traditional like buying older birth certificates or looking at family letters (or just having a chat with a great aunt) affects other people. In my view it is fine to look into things even if that affects others. However I can certainly understand the other position of some people who disagree.

I wonder if any of these sites have been able to check if the much quoted statistic that a third of babies born within a marriage are not their father's child is correct or wildly out?

pigsDOfly · 01/12/2021 12:43

@Cocomarine

I think people need to take personal responsibility and engage their brain 🤷🏻‍♀️ It’s bloody obvious that you might discover something unexpected. The sort of person who doesn’t think of that would read the warning (well, if they bothered to read it) and never assume it could apply to them anyway. Why do you think people should be absolved of using their own brains?
Because not everyone is able to 'use their own brain' in the best possible way.

This why so many people are so easy to scam and will give thousands of pounds to complete strangers or pass over their bank details to someone on the phone because they claim to be calling from their bank or utility company.

Just be thankful that you are able to use your brain well enough to make sure you read the small print or in order to protect yourself from scams, not everyone is as lucky as you.