Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Warning on Ancestry (and other) DNA tests?

241 replies

MLMshouldbeillegal · 01/12/2021 08:41

Ancestry, My Heritage and the other DNA testing companies are all pushing their tests as the ideal Christmas gift, and they are cheaper than ever. Ancestry had a black Friday offer for £50, My Heritage even cheaper at £39.

AIBU to think these tests should come with a wee health warning? That although it's marketed as a "find out your ethnicity" tool, in fact it might reveal some long-hidden family secrets?

I have tested with Ancestry and uploaded my data to other sites too. No surprises on my tree, matches with distant cousins who all fit into the picture as I know it. But I also go genealogical client work and I'm currently working with a man in his 70s who was given one of the tests for father's day back in June and is trying to process the fact that he is not matching with other descendants of his grandfather. Or at least the man he thought was his grandfather. So in later life, he's trying to come to terms with his much loved grandfather, who his father absolutely adored, is probably not his biological relative. It's a lot to deal with.

The testing companies really push the "find out if you're part Viking, part Native American" in their marketing but that aspect isn't really very accurate - My Heritage says I'm >2% Iraq/Iran/Turkey and I'm definitely not. Ancestry is more accurate given what I know about my tree.

Taking one of these tests could open up a whole can of worms in terms of relationships in the family, in this generation or further back with people who are long dead, and who you can't get answers from. For some people it can be a lot to process and I dont think the implications are properly laid out.

OP posts:
Starcaller · 01/12/2021 18:17

@DaisyNGO At the moment it gets outsourced to genetic genealogy experts and specific companies. Essentially you provide the company with a sample of your suspect DNA and they build a profile that they can then run through their databases to find relatives, who might end up being very distantly related to the perpetrators. Then genetic genealogists have the job of combing through the family trees forensically to unpick everything and find where the trail likely leads. It can be quite intricate and gruelling work as families can have a lot of branches.

Once they have a likely name, officers then obtain DNA samples from the suspects, often by going through their rubbish or surveilling them and picking up old cups and things they've used. Sometimes they will test a closer relative of the suspect to narrow it down to a specific lineage.

It's in the small print of most of these DNA collection things that they can be used for law enforcement purposes.

There have been a not insignificant number now of murders and rapes solved by genetic genealogy. Sometimes the perpetrator is deceased, but sometimes they are still alive and able to be prosecuted.

Starcaller · 01/12/2021 18:11

There's an excellent article on it here (quite long but really interesting)

DaisyNGO · 01/12/2021 18:10

@Starcaller

On the flip side, genetic genealogy has been solving cold cases, many from decades ago, thanks to people uploading their results to these websites. Rapes, murders, etc. solved many years later because a relative of the perpetrator has uploaded their DNA results and experts can trace back through family trees to find the owner of their unknown DNA sample. So it's not all bad!
So police experts are using the sites to do this?
Starcaller · 01/12/2021 18:09

On the flip side, genetic genealogy has been solving cold cases, many from decades ago, thanks to people uploading their results to these websites. Rapes, murders, etc. solved many years later because a relative of the perpetrator has uploaded their DNA results and experts can trace back through family trees to find the owner of their unknown DNA sample. So it's not all bad!

WhatAWasteOfOranges · 01/12/2021 18:05

Yes and it’s going to cause a lot of angst and hurt in children that have been conceived via donor egg/sperm in the next few years as a generation where this has become more commonplace gets older and more able to access these sites

DaisyNGO · 01/12/2021 17:26

@Suzanne999

I’ve always thought why the hell would anyone want to do this? But maybe it’s just me. I wouldn’t want to find out I had any more relatives, the ones I had were awful enough.
This made me 😂 My family is tiny in this country. They are lovely. I definitely don't want to hear of anyone else. The ones abroad, from what I know of them, aren't nice. My parents try to ignore them.

My best friend is adopted and her parents want her to go for genetic tests. She said no, as would I.

Suzanne999 · 01/12/2021 17:12

I’ve always thought why the hell would anyone want to do this? But maybe it’s just me. I wouldn’t want to find out I had any more relatives, the ones I had were awful enough.

ToffeeNotCoffee · 01/12/2021 17:09

@Lockdownbear
@loislovesstewie

Thanks

MLMshouldbeillegal · 01/12/2021 17:07

@Lockdownbear

If 100 years ago common law marriages were common. What's to say 'adoptions' didn't happen in a similar manner, child needs a home through bereavement or whatever, and either they go to an Auntie or a childless couple?

That would throw a lot of people's search out.

This is also very true. The legal process of adoption wasn't introduced in the UK until 1926. Before then there is often no paper trail and quite often that's exactly what happened, a child was given to parents who couldn't have their own babies, or a distant relative.

I also don't know how I would feel if I was someone who had donated eggs/sperm in the 80s or 90s and had been promised complete anonymity forever. That's really not the case any more and you can't argue that they should have known how science was going to develop.

OP posts:
waltzingparrot · 01/12/2021 16:29

Yes beware of what it could throw up. DH's cousin recently found out his dad was not his dad. Both his parents have died so there's no answers for him. He'll never know if his dad was aware or not.

Xenia · 01/12/2021 16:00

I think most people have a very good understanding. Also it helps confirm more recent work yo may be doing on your family tree. Eg everyone on my tree on all sides back to the 1700s was born in the UK or Ireland (as the DNA infers too) so all the elements help confirm other each other.

Plusfiftytwo · 01/12/2021 15:25

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

HalfSiblingsMadeContact · 01/12/2021 15:16

@KrispyKale

Anyone involved in donor egg or sperm arrangements today or for a past number of years knows that DNA testing will be procureable in the future.
In our family's case the sperm donations were part of ongoing infertily treatment research in the early 70s well before successful IVF. DNA testing to the extent we now have it was in science fiction territory.
DowagerDuchess · 01/12/2021 15:06

Even if you go into the DNA process well informed, if you do discover that a close relative is not a biological relative, that information is likely to be something you will then share with other family members. They did not make a decision to find this out / take a risk, and so you have removed their opportunity to consent and potentially had a significant impact on them. Personally I probably wouldn't welcome a cousin unexpectedly announcing that my much loved grandfather was not in fact a biological relation.

PerkingFaintly · 01/12/2021 15:00

AdmiralCain, there are some laws in the US about insurance companies using certain types of investigation to avoid paying out, but I don't know details.

What it's important to recognise is that any laws on data use are holding back the sea. The motivation to use personal healthcare data to increase profits will always be there.

It doesn't mean that every single action by every single for-profit company will be driven by this (and hats off to the staff in pharmaceutical companies who worked so hard and are still working hard to find treatments for and vaccines against Covid). But the motivation will always exist, and any slight legal opportunity to use data will be snapped up.

Idony · 01/12/2021 14:55

So you basically think people buy DNA kits but are too thick to know what a DNA kit is?

Lockdownbear · 01/12/2021 14:54

If 100 years ago common law marriages were common.
What's to say 'adoptions' didn't happen in a similar manner, child needs a home through bereavement or whatever, and either they go to an Auntie or a childless couple?

That would throw a lot of people's search out.

TheRealHousewife · 01/12/2021 14:52

Actually I’ve done mine with 23&me with the hope I’ll connect with birth siblings. I was adopted out of my birth family as was a brother. I’d love to connect with my blood brother ❤️

PerkingFaintly · 01/12/2021 14:50

Oh, and the posters squabbling above about insurance and healthcare data?

It was to the insurance industry that the HSCIC gave UK patient data.

Care.data is in chaos. It breaks my heart
www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2014/feb/28/care-data-is-in-chaos

On Monday, the Health and Social Care Information Centre admitted giving the insurance industry the coded hospital records of millions of patients, pseudonymised, but re-identifiable by anyone with malicious intent, as I explained last week. These were crunched by actuaries into tables showing the likelihood of death depending on various features such as age or disease, to help inform insurance premiums.

We can reasonably disagree on whether you find this use of your medical records acceptable, but the process must be competent and transparent. The HSCIC has now told the BBC that this release of your medical records broke the rules, and that there may have been other similarly erroneous releases

AdmiralCain · 01/12/2021 14:50

@MintMatchmaker More than enough people on this thread have backed me up on how dangerous these data companies are, in America, insurance companies have teams of investigators to void peoples insurance. Insurance companies don't want to pay out every policy. These investigators will go through every scrap of paper and social media site they can to find a reason to void your insurance.

GrimDamnFanjo · 01/12/2021 14:47

@MissAmbrosia

I had one for Xmas last year. I have spent nearly 20 years on my family tree and have a huge worry of that if one person is not correct, then huge swathes of it could be wrong, so it's put me off doing it a bit. I should sent mine off.
Lol happened to me! My dad took a test to help my research. The first clue was a massive % of dna in common with Mayo residents (no connection in the tree at that point). Then around 60 dna marches with no paper connection to the tree, including a 2nd cousin. I had to dump all my previous paternal g grandfather connections, it turns out my ggrandfather was one of 3 brothers living nearby to my grandmother. I'll not find out which one now but it was a bit of a surprise!
BeaMends · 01/12/2021 14:47

I've done a fair amount of family history research but haven't done one of these tests so far.

It is really interesting reading all of the stories in the thread. What surprises me the most is that the question of inheritance hasn't been mentioned so far. What would happen if, after the death of both parents, you discover that one of your siblings is not biologically related to your father after all, or a stranger turns out to be a half-sibling? What would you do about the will, or especially if they died intestate? What if the estate had already paid out?

PerkingFaintly · 01/12/2021 14:41

At the risk of going off at a tangent, do people understand that one of the motives behind privatising parts of the NHS is to sell our personal healthcare data?

US companies have been baying for it, because the UK has such comprehensive patient data held in compatible formats rather than the fragmentation of other countries with fragmented health services.

This was explicitly stated at the time, and well covered during the care.data debacle. I think the body involved which had been selling data, the HSCIC, has now changed its name and been brought under NHS Digital.

This was a few years ago. I haven't kept up with what has happened since. Our UK healthcare data is definitely still shared "with carefully selected partners" (sometimes for valid reasons which many of us would happily agree to, were we asked) and was being mentioned as important to any US trade deal the UK struck after Brexit.

Pickles89 · 01/12/2021 14:40

I always feel like you might have this sort of experience:

I saw something on Youtube the other day where a married couple did it and discovered they were (not terribly distantly!) related! Apparently it's not that uncommon!

MLMshouldbeillegal · 01/12/2021 14:39

@Chakraleaf

We had a bit of a brick wall in my tree with my nans father being adopted. So many people who thought I should donate test my nan with dementia, just awful. She can't consent!!!
Yes informed consent is essential. My dad has dementia too, although at early stages. I have ordered a Y DNA kit for him to explore the deep ancestry along the male line. I don't have a brother and neither does he, so we're doing it soon when he can still understand what it's all about.

Ancestry will allow adults to order DNA kits for their children under the age on 18 which I think is a bit dubious too, children can't give informed consent on the matter. I'd also agree that it's unwise to go ahead and order kits for adopted children as soon as they become adults and would always strongly advise people in this situation to speak to adoption charities or specialist counsellors first.

OP posts: