Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Warning on Ancestry (and other) DNA tests?

241 replies

MLMshouldbeillegal · 01/12/2021 08:41

Ancestry, My Heritage and the other DNA testing companies are all pushing their tests as the ideal Christmas gift, and they are cheaper than ever. Ancestry had a black Friday offer for £50, My Heritage even cheaper at £39.

AIBU to think these tests should come with a wee health warning? That although it's marketed as a "find out your ethnicity" tool, in fact it might reveal some long-hidden family secrets?

I have tested with Ancestry and uploaded my data to other sites too. No surprises on my tree, matches with distant cousins who all fit into the picture as I know it. But I also go genealogical client work and I'm currently working with a man in his 70s who was given one of the tests for father's day back in June and is trying to process the fact that he is not matching with other descendants of his grandfather. Or at least the man he thought was his grandfather. So in later life, he's trying to come to terms with his much loved grandfather, who his father absolutely adored, is probably not his biological relative. It's a lot to deal with.

The testing companies really push the "find out if you're part Viking, part Native American" in their marketing but that aspect isn't really very accurate - My Heritage says I'm >2% Iraq/Iran/Turkey and I'm definitely not. Ancestry is more accurate given what I know about my tree.

Taking one of these tests could open up a whole can of worms in terms of relationships in the family, in this generation or further back with people who are long dead, and who you can't get answers from. For some people it can be a lot to process and I dont think the implications are properly laid out.

OP posts:
Lindy2 · 01/12/2021 09:18

I'm on Ancestry and I find it quite interesting.

There were very clear warnings and disclaimers about what might be revealed by taking part. I think I even remember a warning that the Police could use pubic dna records.

It doesn't bother me at all.

Volterra · 01/12/2021 09:16

Another problem is some people test for ethnicity then forget about it and change email addresses over time so don’t get emails that they have messages.

Then someone new tests and finds someone unexpected they match and have to deal with the whole not expected relative situation and struggle to find their biological relative as people who match closely don’t see the messages - or say that they aren’t related as don’t understand how the DNA matches work and don’t get that it doesn’t mean they aren’t related if they don’t recognise the name.

kikipie · 01/12/2021 09:15

Of course you might find out something that has been hidden. It’s obvious. I don’t think anyone could be surprised by that

MLMshouldbeillegal · 01/12/2021 09:15

I don't think people shouldn't do them, @TreeSmuggler. I do think though that the risks need to be clearly spelled out.

I understood those risks and implications which was why I was happy enough to go ahead and submit my DNA for testing.

OP posts:
MLMshouldbeillegal · 01/12/2021 09:12

@Peccary

I work in a related scientific field and haven't done it, I feel weird about it too.

A small percentage in the ethnicity data just means you share some mutations mostly found in those populations. Those could go back a long way.

The way they present the data as "you are x% something" is not accurate

Yes, they use a reference panel of people whose DNA has been tested, and who have a properly researched to genealogy standards tree going back several hundred years. That's fine.

But the rest of it in terms of ethnicity matching is less scientific and looks at other people who have tested and what they have in common with you. Ancestry has had many more UK people which is why my ethnicity match on there is actually pretty good and matches what I have paper records to back up. (Apart from 2% scandinavian which is very distant). My Heritage has a higher percentage of North American test takers which I am assuming is where the Middle East in my estimate comes from, there is nothing in the records which suggests this.

OP posts:
Volterra · 01/12/2021 09:11

I think people do need to be more aware that it could throw up something unexpected in the results. I’m helping one of my matches on 23andme find his biological parents (really hard as only low matches) so joined a FB group that helps people with DNA results and have seen a fair few where people have found (often quite late in life) that a parent isn’t biologically related to them, huge shock.

I had a bit of a surprise in that my GG Grandfather isn’t who he was on paper. Have found the right one now with some help from my newly found 3rd cousin and it’s no big deal as such a distant relationship. I went into it with my eyes open and it still felt a bit strange for a moment so I can only imagine how it must be with someone closer to you.

TreeSmuggler · 01/12/2021 09:06

These tests don't appeal to me, the heritage stuff is not necessarily accurate, potential for family secrets etc, and you are giving away your DNA to be later accessed by who knows who.

However I think YABU worrying about others getting the tests when you got it yourself. Clearly you can see the appeal and wanted to take the above risks, so why shouldn't others?

Strawberry0909 · 01/12/2021 09:04

I agree, a relative of mine did one of these and discovered he had another brother, a man he grew up with,

MLMshouldbeillegal · 01/12/2021 09:01

@LIZS

You don't have to follow up the personal connections results may generate if all you want is ethnic background.
This is true. But who is not going to click on the DNA matches button, especially if it says it's found close relatives?

I do also agree that there is a degree of personal responsibility. But everyone's heard stories about someone not knowing they were adopted until adulthood, or never suspecting for one second that their Dad wasn't their biological father and everything being blown apart by a DNA test. It's just a bit shady that the companies are marketing these as "find your ethnicity" and not pointing out that it might also reveal close relatives you didn;t know about.

OP posts:
ToffeeNotCoffee · 01/12/2021 09:00

I'm a wee bit sceptical of this i.e. I'll only have their word for it.

Also, I don't want to invoke strangers into my family tree. Even though they are already there on account that anyone's family tree with have squillions of dead people in it !

Peccary · 01/12/2021 09:00

I work in a related scientific field and haven't done it, I feel weird about it too.

A small percentage in the ethnicity data just means you share some mutations mostly found in those populations. Those could go back a long way.

The way they present the data as "you are x% something" is not accurate

poopyface · 01/12/2021 08:59

There was quite a lot of info/warning about it when I did mine

LIZS · 01/12/2021 08:55

You don't have to follow up the personal connections results may generate if all you want is ethnic background.

Littleants · 01/12/2021 08:55

I was furious in a cafe once because a man behind me reckoned he needed counselling for discovering he had a black ancestor.

I think they are dangerous because you are giving your genetic information to a private company and God knows how it may be used in the future (looking at you history, and your cyclical ways).

Cocomarine · 01/12/2021 08:53

I think people need to take personal responsibility and engage their brain 🤷🏻‍♀️
It’s bloody obvious that you might discover something unexpected.
The sort of person who doesn’t think of that would read the warning (well, if they bothered to read it) and never assume it could apply to them anyway.
Why do you think people should be absolved of using their own brains?

Swirlywoo · 01/12/2021 08:51

I agree. I haven't done it because I feel weird about a company holding my data and that of my family's. I have enjoyed finding stuff out from records data but as you say, the heritage DNA test is not accurate. If I had any chance of a can of worms too, I personally wouldn't want to know.