Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

In not wanting to use a dummy with DC?

221 replies

21dolly · 01/12/2021 07:57

I never used a dummy with DD because I didn't see any reason too. She had a bit of reflux when she was a baby but that settled quite quickly with gripe water and so on.
DP always wanted to use a dummy as he said 'that's just what you do with babies.'
We always had comments from his side of the family like 'why doesn't she have a dummy' and blah blah blah.

I'm currently pregnant again and DP is ADAMANT he wants this baby to have a dummy. I personally don't see the obsession with a dummy as some babies are able to be soothed without one (no judgment for parents who choose to use dummies btw and I'd definitely use one if I felt it would help DC!)

I really don't understand the dummy thing and why he's pushing for it so much without DC even being born yet. I'm not sure what I'm actually asking but I just thought I'd come on MN to hear opinions and see if I'm missing something here!

OP posts:
SBAM · 01/12/2021 19:34

My brother still sucks his thumb. He’s 31. He’s tried so often to stop but struggles and there’s nothing the GP can recommend that he hasn’t tried.
So, my children have dummies, because I can bin a dummy but I can’t cut their thumbs off! My oldest got rid of hers on her 3rd birthday, it wasn’t much of a trauma, we spoke about it beforehand for a few weeks, the first night took her a little longer than usual to fall asleep and then after that was fine. My youngest we’ll do the same when he gets to 3. He had fairly serious reflux as a baby, and even now sometimes suffers and the dummy definitely helps.

EmotionallyWeird · 01/12/2021 19:10

I never wanted to use a dummy with either of my DC, but considered it in the end for DC1 because he was constantly comfort sucking, sometimes until he was sick, and I thought it might be comforting for him. Guess what - he wouldn't keep a dummy in for more than 5 seconds. For the first 3 months or so of his life, until he was capable of being entertained, only a warm nipple would do. DC2 was a very contented baby from the start. I gave him a dummy once just to see what would happen, and he kept it in for a couple of hours, but then he would have been perfectly happy without it too. So in my very limited experience, the sort of baby who might benefit from a dummy is unlikely to accept one anyway, and I couldn't really see the point of giving one regularly to a baby who didn't seem to need comforting.

For what it's worth, neither of them was ever remotely interested in sucking their thumbs or fingers. I wouldn't have forbidden it but I don't see much point in positively encouraging that either.

Riverlee · 01/12/2021 19:01

Never used dummies for either the dc.

shrunkenhead · 01/12/2021 18:59

I don't claim to be a "better parent" - I just felt that if I gave my dd a dummy I'd failed at yet another hurdle, I had to get breastfeeding right and didn't want any temptations to stop. They breastfeed on demand and a dummy is a substitute I didn't need to up my milk production.

elbea · 01/12/2021 18:33

@shrunkenhead what’s wrong with the easy choice though, are you somehow a better parent for picking the hard choice?

Before we used a dummy I used to spend hours walking up and down the hallway because it was the only thing that stopped my colicky baby screaming. She screamed between about 5 and 8 every single night, whatever we did. She stopped immediately when we introduced a dummy. It was win win, she didn’t scream for hours, I wasn’t exhausted from spending hours pacing the hall.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 01/12/2021 18:24

@colourfulpuddles

YANBU. People give babies dummies to shut them up and all they do is mask what the real issue is, affect their speech development and ruin their teeth.

But we were EBF so I was all the comfort my baby needed and I didn’t want to shove a dummy in her mouth just so I could put her down and bugger off.

I EBFd as well. But I wasn't all the comfort my baby needed because she turned out to have horrendous issues with dairy. So she got a dummy because after feeding constantly for her to be even more in pain, my nipples were bleeding to the point where the thought of doing it all again 5 minutes later was reducing me to considering where the most convenient cliff was and I was hallucinating that there were flocks of birds in the flat from not having slept more than 22 minutes in three months, I decided that my sanity and her physical comfort was far more important than the pursed lips of people like you and her grandmother, who was gleeful about how she deliberately taught her children to suck their thumbs, fingers and one their hand because it looked cute. The children who all needed extensive orthdontic treatment later because they were still sucking thumbs/fingers/hand aged 10, by the way.

The other advantage I found was that I could sterilise a dummy and, possibly even more useful, I could take it away. But the main one was that I didn't kill myself.

shrunkenhead · 01/12/2021 18:24

I breastfed as long as could and was so worried about nipple/teat confusion I daren't use a dummy. They don't look nice and it's a battle you can avoid when they're of walking age and still got it stuck in their mouths.
There is a lot of snobbery because it's seen as the "easy choice" - put the plug in and it'll be quiet for a bit. I guess sometimes it's necessary and useful so parents just give in.

User5252727 · 01/12/2021 17:50

@21dolly

So neither you nor your husband are right, because it's silly to have a determined idea about something which depends entirely on the kind of baby you have.

I never said, 'I absolutely refuse to give a dummy to our second baby as I'm so against it' or whatever. So I'm not sure where you got the idea of me being determined from. As another poster said, I'm actually very neutral to the idea especially as I tried it with my DD when she was a bit younger.
I just don't understand DPs obsession with both kids needing the dummy. That's all

Apologies. When you said you didn't want to use a dummy for your DC, I assumed you meant you didn't want to use a dummy for your DC.
21dolly · 01/12/2021 17:31

Thank you for all the comments all.

No insights into why DPs so obsessed with dummies but really interesting to hear people's personal experiences! I was quite naive and thought people used dummies just to keep their kids quiet and would use it at any given opportunity. Really interesting to hear about the benefits of reducing SIDS, helping/soothing colicky babies and so on. Thank you:)

OP posts:
BunsOfAnarchy · 01/12/2021 17:26

I think there are other ways of soothing a baby. Dummy should be a last resort IMHO. So making the decision before baby is born is bloody bizarre!
I'm inclined to think his family don't like babies unless they are silent...
I prayed to all the gods that DD would take to one as she was incredibly hard to settle. In the end she stayed dangling off a boob for 9 months Grin
Shes nearly 4 now, and I do see some of her nursery class mates with dummies and Shock inside a little, and I wonder how hard it must be to get them to give it up if they insist on keeping it till that age.
But its definitely worth a try if you find baby just will not settle otherwise.

CoffeeDay · 01/12/2021 15:47

DD point blank refused a dummy since birth. So I have no idea how life is like with one! We actually have more dummies at home that anyone else because I bought every single brand and variation possible in hopes of getting her to take one! She has a favourite stuffed toy to take around as a soother and that seems to work just fine. She also never sucked her thumb and grew out of mouthing things quite early (18-20months).

SammyScrounge · 01/12/2021 15:41

Never used one for any of my three. They were very laidback babies, though.

Ionlydomassiveones · 01/12/2021 15:07

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn at the poster's request.

LovesColourGreen · 01/12/2021 14:58

My mum never gave them to me or my brother and my nan never gave them to my mum or her brother either. I don't think I will want to use them either in fear of poor speech/dental development... but come to think of it, my brother and I sucked our thumbs as toddlers...

Youseethethingis · 01/12/2021 14:20

My DS breastfed like he'd been here before from the word go, perfect teeth, speech very well developed for his age. He's always had a dummy, still has it at night aged 2 although he often just likes to hold it "just in case mummy". Fair enough. Not sure what all the angst is about. Better than sucking a thumb as those aren't made to be teeth friendly and can't be taken away.

TwoDogs9 · 01/12/2021 14:09

@CityMumma78 me too! I have a bent index finger from sucking it as a child. My mother was against using dummies. I have not used dummies for my DC but I breastfeed whereas my Mum did not. I think maybe a dummy would have been preferable to my finger in that case!

AudHvamm · 01/12/2021 14:06

@hotmeatymilk too true, I need to up my entertainment value Grin

StevieNicksscarf · 01/12/2021 13:52

Loving all the judgemental horror on here from all the perfect parents.

FWIW as a retired Speech and Language Therapist I always used to joke with my colleagues that my registration would be rescinded because both my DC had dummies.

Can also remember one snotty woman giving me her unsolicited "advice" in M&S about how my DD shouldn't have a dummy. It never ceases to amaze me how people are so keen to judge others when knowing zero about their circumstances.

My DC never had speech problems due to dummies but then as DC of a Speech Therapist they were subjected to non-stop language stimulation which is one of the perils of being born to an SLT Grin

Oneforthemoneytwo · 01/12/2021 13:43

I far prefer a dummy to a thumb. I haven’t seen teeth issues from dummies but the blasted thumb pushes the palate forward and changes the shape of the front teeth resulting in major orthodontics at a later date.

Babyshadows · 01/12/2021 13:38

I didn't want my baby to have a dummy because 1) I don't like they way they look 2) I breastfed and didnt want to miss feeding ques. She did have one when she was nil by mouth as she needed something to suckle for comfort but as soon as she could feed the dummy was gone! I had them if desperately needed (in the car) but then she was never really interested.

Tibtab · 01/12/2021 13:09

I breastfed my DD for a year, she had a dummy for the first few months to help her settle when she didn’t need a feed. She stopped using it about 5/6 months old by herself.

hotmeatymilk · 01/12/2021 12:44

@AudHvamm Agreed. But don’t let’s be reasonable so early in the thread, there’s 35 pages of frothing vitriol to get through first!

Strokethefurrywall · 01/12/2021 12:41

I ebf both my boys and used a pacifier for both to help them settle.

DS1 took one from a month, DS2 was such a sucky baby that he had one about 9 hours after he was born! He could suck milk out of a rock, that kid.

Both slept well, both nursed well, neither had trouble giving them up, DS1 when he was a year, DS2 when he was 3 (at night).

There doesn’t seem to be any judgment about using pacifiers here though 🤷🏽‍♀️

Just see what helps your baby, some get great comfort to suck when they’re not hungry and a pacifier helps them not use your nipple as that comfort. Before pacifiers, people used to use little fingers so it’s not a new thing giving babies something to help soothe them.

Frankzappa22 · 01/12/2021 12:10

I didn’t use a dummy for either of mine and my main reason was that I was worried they would refuse to sleep without it and would constantly wake up when it fell out of their mouth at night and that I’d be constantly woken up to put it back in

stayignorant · 01/12/2021 12:10

I'm ok with using a dummy as it's just to get my baby off to sleep and then he spits it out, I'm sure he'll grow out of needing it. It's a lifesaver sometimes as it really helps him go off to sleep quickly as well as using a comforter.
Different story if they're sucking on it all the time.. that's probably when it could badly impact their speech/teeth

Swipe left for the next trending thread