Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I want to tell people I have a 1st class even though I don’t?

504 replies

plieddried · 01/12/2021 03:56

It bothers me so much to see my actual degree classification. On my cv I don’t even bother to write my degree classification but I still feel embarrassed. I want to start telling people (and myself) that I graduated with a 1st class honours even if it’s not true. It makes me feel happier to tell myself I got a first class. It also makes me feel more confident and secure in my ability to work. It makes me feel accomplished. Wondering if AIBU?

OP posts:
ErrolTheDragon · 01/12/2021 09:16

Would committing fraud really help your self-esteem, OP?
Better an honest 2:1 than be a liar.

The only circumstances where your degree classification is relevant to anyone else is in applying for jobs or further study, in which case they'll probably want your transcript too so they'll be able to see the full picture.

CouncilHousedAndViolentBaby · 01/12/2021 09:15

@TellingBone

Just told the postie I'm a brain surgeon and that I speak ten languages [including Jedi] and now I feel GREAT
🤣🤣🤣
Birdsnesting · 01/12/2021 09:15

@Hello6732

OP I was also a straight A* student and ended up getting a 2:1 at uni being very close to a 1st within 1.5%. I'm actually convinced that they lost half of one of my exam answer booklets because it was so strange that my mark was so low for a particular module but my lecturer was not having any of it when I asked them to double check. They actually got insulted I "suggested they couldn't do their job properly". I wouldn't be surprised if I did actually get a 1st and the uni was so disorganised they just ballsed stuff up due to multiple dodgy things that happened there. This is a Russell group uni for what it's worth.

Was a very sad time for me actually, but I still didn't lie about my 2:1 on my CV or to anyone. But also my graduate employer required me I get at least a 2:1 to secure my job. That ended up being the only time I had to share my degree classification with any employer and since then no one's even asked me or batted an eyelid and it's never come up again. My career experience now speaks for itself.

I get the disappointment OP but you're going to come off far worse if you say you got a 1st and it's found out you didn't. Did you get a 2:1 instead? Just embrace it for what it is and a few years into your career the classification will be meaningless. It's just a stepping stone to the next part of your life.

That’s what the university appeals and complaints process is for, though — if you think there’s been an irregularity like some of your work not being corrected, or some admin error in that a mark has been omitted and has impacted on your degree classification. It isn’t n the gift of the lecturer who taught and marked the module, it’s handled by an official university process, entirely independently.
HesterShaw1 · 01/12/2021 09:13

A first used to be something only the top top graduates got. The next best got 2:1s and most got 2:2s. A few got thirds. On my course of over seventy there were only six Firsts.

Now the proportion seems far higher, but still, there's nothing wrong with a second class degree.

bonfireheart · 01/12/2021 09:12

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

Camembear · 01/12/2021 09:11

it’s best to be honest op. As others have said there are lots of successful people around who don’t have the best degree.

What will lying achieve? A moment or two of fantasy? It’s not going to change reality.

HesterShaw1 · 01/12/2021 09:11

Are we self identifying our degree classifications now? Wanting something makes it so, after all.

ClementineWardobe · 01/12/2021 09:09

I do have a first - I've never said those words out loud since I told DH the day I got it. It's a non issue. Getting found out lying about it is a huge issue though OP.

SavageBeauty73 · 01/12/2021 09:08

Weird.

TellingBone · 01/12/2021 09:08

@bonfireheart

Just told the postie I'm a brain surgeon and that I speak ten languages [including Jedi] and now I feel GREAT

OP has said that they were going through stuff at the time...this is affecting their mental health...you instead just come across as an idiot.

Oh do giveover

😄

ahola · 01/12/2021 09:07

I think you need some form of counselling if lying to yourself makes you feel accomplished when you haven't actually achieved that qualification. I also think you need to examine why you're pinning your entire self worth on one qualification. People are far more than pieces of paper, particularly once they've been in a job/career for a while and people you meet judge you upon what you did most recently in your role, whether it's a project that went well, a deal you negotiated, a shift you managed well etc. Many outstanding and invaluable employees do not even have a degree at all.
People will mainly judge you by your words and actions and not on your qualifications!

That said, a good degree course really sorts the sheep from the goats. Just because you got A throughout school does not mean you're 1st class degree calibre. Lots of (mainly girls) pupils are well supported, spoonfed in independent schools and naice leafy comps and get A all the way through their school careers when really they're not particularly intellectual, certainly not brilliant, but rather they attend well, are hard working, biddable, act upon advice given, and generally allow education to be done to them which is how the English school system is set up currently. When they go to university, where learning is done independently, it all falls apart as they haven't got the necessary skills and resources to take responsibility for their own learning.

mumofmunchkin · 01/12/2021 09:07

I do have a first. The only time I've ever 'told' anyone was on my CV when I went for a professional job, and I had to show my degree certificate to prove it. It's just not something that comes up in conversation! And if I'd lied on my CV I wouldn't have got my job.

DeepaBeesKit · 01/12/2021 09:07

No one cares.

In the workplace your qualifications only matter to the extent they (or lack thereof) impact your work performance. The further you progress in your career the less important it becomes and soft skills like people management become more important, together with executive capabilities - ability to make a clear headed judgement, weigh up risks, shoulder responsibility for the performance of a team.

My academic record is littered with slight failings. I do not have a first class degree!

Nonetheless I have done well in the workplace because I am diligent, learn fast, and most important work well in a team.

Grumpasaurus · 01/12/2021 09:05

@plieddried like others have said, I think the issue here is around your self esteem, and taking the time to reassess what it actually means for you long term. Likely- absolutely nothing.

For context, I graduated from my BA with an honours with distinction, and my MA with distinction. Or was it honours? I don't think we had firsts, 2:1, or 2:2 at the MA level; it was either honours/distinction, pass, or fail. I think.

I am writing that because, as you can see, it is SO unimportant now that I can't even remember the right terms. Since graduating not one person has asked me about my marks. Not one.

What seemed hugely important at the time is now totally inconsequential. Focus on achieving in your career and exploring why this is so important to you that you would consider lying and putting your future job at risk should anyone find out... time much better spent!

bonfireheart · 01/12/2021 09:04

Just told the postie I'm a brain surgeon and that I speak ten languages [including Jedi] and now I feel GREAT

OP has said that they were going through stuff at the time...this is affecting their mental health...you instead just come across as an idiot.

Swirlywoo · 01/12/2021 09:02

@TellingBone Grin

Grida · 01/12/2021 09:01

I know a lot of extremely successful, very clever people who didn’t get great degrees. Grades aren’t everything. It is not embarrassing or pathetic to get bad grades but it is embarrassing and pathetic to lie about them.

Hello6732 · 01/12/2021 09:01

OP I was also a straight A* student and ended up getting a 2:1 at uni being very close to a 1st within 1.5%. I'm actually convinced that they lost half of one of my exam answer booklets because it was so strange that my mark was so low for a particular module but my lecturer was not having any of it when I asked them to double check. They actually got insulted I "suggested they couldn't do their job properly". I wouldn't be surprised if I did actually get a 1st and the uni was so disorganised they just ballsed stuff up due to multiple dodgy things that happened there. This is a Russell group uni for what it's worth.

Was a very sad time for me actually, but I still didn't lie about my 2:1 on my CV or to anyone. But also my graduate employer required me I get at least a 2:1 to secure my job. That ended up being the only time I had to share my degree classification with any employer and since then no one's even asked me or batted an eyelid and it's never come up again. My career experience now speaks for itself.

I get the disappointment OP but you're going to come off far worse if you say you got a 1st and it's found out you didn't. Did you get a 2:1 instead? Just embrace it for what it is and a few years into your career the classification will be meaningless. It's just a stepping stone to the next part of your life.

TellingBone · 01/12/2021 09:01

Just told the postie I'm a brain surgeon and that I speak ten languages [including Jedi] and now I feel GREAT

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 01/12/2021 09:00

That’s nuts!

We’d all like to have got a first, would feel proud if we had got one, I expect.

I got a 2:1. That’s what I got so that’s what I tell people!

AliceAldridge · 01/12/2021 09:00

I got straight As at school and a 2:2. I also didn't submit my probably extenuating circumstances. But hey ho. I'd never lie about it, that would never make me feel better as it would not be true.

burnoutbabe · 01/12/2021 08:59

I am as lucky and got a covid 1st!
I did a second degree over last 2 years and one of my goals was to get a first if possible and exams being online helped that. I do tell everyone :-) (though I was quite happy with my 2.1 from the 1990s)

Not so fussed on my masters results, no one cares about them. But in law, the degree class is very important as to getting next jobs (not that I want to do that)

So yes, do another degree if you feel that urge. Mine was 2 years, so cheaper to do. Or can do open university, part time whilst working.

My dad is also doing a second degree at over 70! Think he'll be happy if he finishes it.

WhenSepEnds · 01/12/2021 08:57

@plieddried

It bothers me so much to see my actual degree classification. On my cv I don’t even bother to write my degree classification but I still feel embarrassed. I want to start telling people (and myself) that I graduated with a 1st class honours even if it’s not true. It makes me feel happier to tell myself I got a first class. It also makes me feel more confident and secure in my ability to work. It makes me feel accomplished. Wondering if AIBU?
Why don't you just tell them you're a Dr too then, would that make you feel more secure?! 😂😂😂 I might take a leaf out of your book and tell myself I'm a Duchess today so I feel more secure 😂😂 really hope this is a joke
Abigail12345654321 · 01/12/2021 08:57

We tend to assume a first or a 2:1 is ‘normal’, a 2:2 usually a sign of partying too hard or there were some life difficulties, and a 3rd we would assume the persons life had imploded in some way. We do ask at interview what happened if the grade seems low (relative to their other accomplishments and people tend to be quite honest about which of the above it is. Doesn’t tend to put us off. Nobody has ever said they were a bit thick and that’s why they got a low grade!

theDudesmummy · 01/12/2021 08:57

People do lie about their qualifications. Doesn't make it a good idea though. Some don't get found out. Some do.