Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I want to tell people I have a 1st class even though I don’t?

504 replies

plieddried · 01/12/2021 03:56

It bothers me so much to see my actual degree classification. On my cv I don’t even bother to write my degree classification but I still feel embarrassed. I want to start telling people (and myself) that I graduated with a 1st class honours even if it’s not true. It makes me feel happier to tell myself I got a first class. It also makes me feel more confident and secure in my ability to work. It makes me feel accomplished. Wondering if AIBU?

OP posts:
Floofsquidge · 01/12/2021 10:06

@dangerrabbit

I understand as am also a perfectionist who didn't get a first, however if you lie about it you will have the anxiety of being caught, and if you get caught it will be humiliating for you.
Absolutely this. I couldn't give a monkeys what classification someone got for their degree but if they lied and comes up in background checks we'd withdraw the offer over dishonesty. Many many years ago my dad would if anything reject people with firsts for sales positions unless there was anything else compelling on the CV as it tended to suggest they hadn't lived their life to the full at university. Not sure I agree with that but it's another perspective.
daimbarsatemydogsbone · 01/12/2021 10:04

@ErrolTheDragon

No they do it in the USA too. They have GPA scores and then there's all that weird business with the greek letters for really high flyers.

The Greek letters are something different I think... fraternities/sororities.

No, confusingly there are two lots of daft Greek letters in use in the USA

On is to do with Frat/Sororities but the other is absolutely to do with degree ratings

registrar.uconn.edu/latin-honors/

dangerrabbit · 01/12/2021 09:46

I understand as am also a perfectionist who didn't get a first, however if you lie about it you will have the anxiety of being caught, and if you get caught it will be humiliating for you.

burnoutbabe · 01/12/2021 09:44

@RandomLondoner

Are degree classifications a purely British thing?

I came to the UK as a young adult in the 1980's and I think in my first round of interviews was asked once about my degree classification, and didn't have an answer. To me a degree was something you either did or didn't have, grades did not matter. (If they did, I would have scraped a pass, but in subjects that 99% of my age cohort could not have passed, so my self-esteem wasn't particularly at stake.)

Ever since I've wondered if I wrongly went through university thinking grades did not matter as long as you passed, or if they really were only a "thing" in the UK.

(I worked in IT, sometimes alongside people who had no degree at all, so my lack of a classification was never really an issue.)

Most graduate schemes want a 2.1 or higher to get on them (exceptions exist obviously) and in careers like law, it's highly competitive so a first or 2.1 from a good university is pretty much the bare minimum to get a good law firm who pays your exams. Then you probably need work experience plus involved in university societies in a leadership role etc. I am glad I did my law degree for interest, I couldn't face the sheer ambition of most students.
NotSoNewAndShiny · 01/12/2021 09:44

I come from a country where first degrees, second degrees, masters, 1st class, 2.1, etc are big deals. Most people who have a 1st class will either tell everyone or their family and/or friends will tell everyone. Just people being proud of their achievements and isn't seen as 'boasting'. They're usually high-achieving students from the get-go too, like OP. Everyone lauds you for it too. I don't know where OP is from but I understand the "big deal".

Still, @plieddried I don't think you should lie about it if you didn't get it. It's only going to be a temporary feeling of satisfaction before you start getting paranoid that you'll be found out. If people know you're a 'high-achiever', 1st class or not won't affect that. Not every high-achiever gets a 1st class anyway but they still go on to do greater things. I'm sure you will too if you focus on that instead.

Cryalot2 · 01/12/2021 09:42

Op what you achieved is better than lying.
You got your degree, the result may not be what you wanted. But that in itself is better than a lie.

Most lies are eventually found out, and once someone is found out about one thing it is thought what else have they lied about and get the name of a liar and not to belived.
No one wants that.

Get help with your self esteem, but under no circumstances lie about your degree or anything else.

squee123 · 01/12/2021 09:34

In my company they run background checks. You'd be found out and your job offer withdrawn. Or if it came out later you'd be fired for lying

HesterShaw1 · 01/12/2021 09:32

[quote NollaigNollaig]**@ErrolTheDragon* @HesterShaw1* it’s true. I got a 1st degree in a course I ended up being a teaching assistant in around ten years later when doing my PhD. When I was grading papers I was called in by the lecturer who told me I was grading too harshly and I quote “a 2.1 in my day is a 1st now” this was one of the top universities in the country.

Seems to be all part of mollycoddling the younger generations. I met so many students who insisted they must have a first as they wanted one.[/quote]
I'm afraid this is true. I had a student on a placement at work. She wasn't great when she was with us - very passive and lacking in initiative. I had to write up the report which then fed back into her degree and I did so honestly. She got back in touch begging me to change a few answers because with it as it was, it meant she was missing out on a First by just a percentage point. Now way did I have her down as First material.

I did change it though. I reasoned it would be hard enough nowadays for young people to get ahead, particularly in that field which is very competitive. The problem is then, a First isn't enough, so then more of them go onto do Masters especially in a competitive field. And then in turn the Masters get devalued.

I'm sure there will be people who disagree with me, but I take lots of students on placements and we work closely with the local universities so this is what I have seen first hand.

maofteens · 01/12/2021 09:30

I can't for the life of me remember anyone telling me whether they got a first, second or third class degree here! I don't think anyone cares.

ErrolTheDragon · 01/12/2021 09:30

No they do it in the USA too. They have GPA scores and then there's all that weird business with the greek letters for really high flyers.

The Greek letters are something different I think... fraternities/sororities.

rainyskylight · 01/12/2021 09:29

To be honest first class degrees are two a penny these days so A) if you didn’t get one, you didn’t deserve one, and B) even if you did it’s basically just a 2:1 in today’s terms. You’re delusional.

ErrolTheDragon · 01/12/2021 09:29

Are degree classifications a purely British thing?

At some point they came up in a discussion with an American colleague who asked 'oh, is a First like Magna cum Laude'. (Or maybe Summa cum Laude).like that was more obvious and normal than a simple numbering grade.Grin

SofaKingKnotBovvered · 01/12/2021 09:29

What is the point of lying?

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 01/12/2021 09:28

@RandomLondoner

Are degree classifications a purely British thing?

I came to the UK as a young adult in the 1980's and I think in my first round of interviews was asked once about my degree classification, and didn't have an answer. To me a degree was something you either did or didn't have, grades did not matter. (If they did, I would have scraped a pass, but in subjects that 99% of my age cohort could not have passed, so my self-esteem wasn't particularly at stake.)

Ever since I've wondered if I wrongly went through university thinking grades did not matter as long as you passed, or if they really were only a "thing" in the UK.

(I worked in IT, sometimes alongside people who had no degree at all, so my lack of a classification was never really an issue.)

Are degree classifications a purely British thing?

No they do it in the USA too. They have GPA scores and then there's all that weird business with the greek letters for really high flyers.

tailspin21 · 01/12/2021 09:26

Focus on becoming accomplished by continuing your development. Do you have a Masters? If not, I'd start there before a PhD. I say this with kindness OP but as someone with a First, a Merit at Masters and a second post-grad and now doing a PhD there is a world of difference between undergraduate and PhD. I don't care what class of degree colleagues got, but if I found out one of them had lied about it I would think much, much less of them. In academia, and many professions tbf, integrity is everything. Focus on what you can achieve going forward rather than ruminating on the past.

OutwiththeOutCrowd · 01/12/2021 09:26

I do understand these sort of feelings. Our competitive educational system is set up to make people feel grades are more significant than they really are.

A good reason for doing a degree is to learn about a subject, have new experiences, find out what your interests are - and what they definitely are not! A bad reason is to use it to place yourself in some essentially meaningless hierarchy.

Not everyone that's fantastic at doing their job, whether related or unrelated to their degree, was great at cramming and performing under pressure in the exam room and vice versa. The skills are very different - I wish this was realised by more people.

In addition, not everyone had a life that was settled enough to allow them to study and concentrate when they were doing their degree.

You are worth more than a flimsy sheet of paper with a grade on it!

Flowers
ChequerBoard · 01/12/2021 09:25

I'm struggling to understand what sort of social situations require you to have conversations about your degree classification?!?

It's been almost 30 years since I graduated and ai can't think of a single occasion when my classification has come up socially since my grad party.

The only time it is relevant is on my CV or when I present my certs to a new employer.

Cas112 · 01/12/2021 09:25

So in other words you want to become an untrustworthy person OP?

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 01/12/2021 09:24

@TellingBone

Just told the postie I'm a brain surgeon and that I speak ten languages [including Jedi] and now I feel GREAT
Grin
NollaigNollaig · 01/12/2021 09:21

@ErrolTheDragon @HesterShaw1 it’s true. I got a 1st degree in a course I ended up being a teaching assistant in around ten years later when doing my PhD. When I was grading papers I was called in by the lecturer who told me I was grading too harshly and I quote “a 2.1 in my day is a 1st now” this was one of the top universities in the country.

Seems to be all part of mollycoddling the younger generations. I met so many students who insisted they must have a first as they wanted one.

RandomLondoner · 01/12/2021 09:21

Are degree classifications a purely British thing?

I came to the UK as a young adult in the 1980's and I think in my first round of interviews was asked once about my degree classification, and didn't have an answer. To me a degree was something you either did or didn't have, grades did not matter. (If they did, I would have scraped a pass, but in subjects that 99% of my age cohort could not have passed, so my self-esteem wasn't particularly at stake.)

Ever since I've wondered if I wrongly went through university thinking grades did not matter as long as you passed, or if they really were only a "thing" in the UK.

(I worked in IT, sometimes alongside people who had no degree at all, so my lack of a classification was never really an issue.)

DysmalRadius · 01/12/2021 09:20

What would be worse/more embarrassing: people knowing you got a 2:1, or people finding out you got a 2:1 after you'd lied about getting a first?

MrsMadderRose · 01/12/2021 09:19

It’s interesting that people would think like this - it kind of shows how this whole “I am my feelings”/“who I say I am”/“I get to decide what I deserve” ethos that has seeped through society is affecting basic logic and understanding.

What about people who do have a first? You know the rating exists to show they did really well and to recognise that? By just feeling like you can just claim that when it’s not true, it weakens the meaning of it.

If you don’t want to be rated by a system, you don’t have to engage with that system but you don’t get to just change it because you don’t like what you got.

Also agree that it’s a life skill to learn to accept you’re not perfect. No one is. It would be better to concentrate on improving and doing your job as well as possible, rather than trying to rearrange reality.

ErrolTheDragon · 01/12/2021 09:19

@HesterShaw1

A first used to be something only the top top graduates got. The next best got 2:1s and most got 2:2s. A few got thirds. On my course of over seventy there were only six Firsts.

Now the proportion seems far higher, but still, there's nothing wrong with a second class degree.

Snap.

Seems like they're giving out too many firsts if people seem to feel they're entitled to one rather than them being the exception.

Idroppedthescrewinthetuna · 01/12/2021 09:18

Most people do not judge others by their degrees but on their morals and what kind of personality they have.

You could have said to me you have a 1st however I would probably judge you on the fact you need this 1st to validate yourself and question what are important personality traits for you to base your judgments on.

Having a 1st is not the most important thing. I am concerned about the children if any in your life, sons, daughters, nieces or friends children...do you judge them on their academic ability?

So yes YABU, and to be honest you sound pompous, immature and just a bit of an idiot. I guess even if you feel like you would have got a 1st you are still not that clever....not on what is important anyway.