Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Annoyed by my friends comment tonight...

311 replies

Tomato345 · 30/11/2021 23:10

My best friend of 11 years and I occasionally have our disagreements but I love her like a sister, however a comment she made tonight has really pissed me off and has made her look like a snob imo.

We were with our kids, talking about different careers as we've both recently changed jobs, when her eldest son announced that he wanted to be a bin man when he's older. Friend turned to him and said "aim a little higher please" and started laughing. I made a comment about how bin men earn a pretty decent wage (in our area at least) and that the perks of working for the council, such as weekends off/decent pension etc are good. She was adamant that it's a shit job and that the only reason someone would do it is if they didn't have any qualifications. It certainly came across that she would be embarrassed if her son ever becomes one.

Her reaction was the same last year when her partner showed an interest in becoming a HGV driver, so it's not the first time this has happened. I'm not sure why it's got my back up, maybe because I use to be a delivery driver and now I work for a cleaning company, so I'm wondering what she thinks of me as I would say those types of jobs are linked. We both only want the best for our kids at the end of the day, but what's wrong with it if it makes someone happy and provides them a living? Perhaps I could understand her point if she was earning mega bucks herself, but she earns minimum wage, which is actually less than what a bin man earns...

A job is a job in my eyes, but I'm not sure if I'm being sensitive or not. After all, we're all allowed to have an opinion... so AIBU?

OP posts:
Heartofglass12345 · 01/12/2021 16:20

My son wants to have a shop where he gives everything away for free, a museum man (as he calls it lol) and a librarian.

I just want my kids to be happy and I'd rather they were a refuse collector than on the dole!

I scrubbed shit off toilet walls in a nursing home for money when I was a student, I didn't care, I was earning my own money!

Bluesheep8 · 01/12/2021 13:46

Retail and hospitality are MUCH worse than refuse collector as there's so little autonomy and you have to work face to face with the nobhead public

Yep.
And my BIL has been a bin man all his life. He has just retired at 50.

Teatoast00 · 01/12/2021 13:25

Someone who has been a bin man for 40 years will have a decent LGPS pension at 60. Yes, it's not megabucks and would be reduced as paid early but still the option of a nice lump sum and annual pension, better than a lot of jobs. I used to work in public sector pensions for 5 years and it is common, suppose as job is quite physically intensive.

SturminsterNewton · 01/12/2021 13:16

@Blueeyedgirl21

As for the ‘sewer man’ comments, my friend manages a waste water treatment site and is on big bucks, she has a very very comfortable life, working in water treatment can be lucrative so nothing to look down on. You can even be a lawyer for water companies Wink
Oh, I wasn't being snobby Blueeyedgirl21. Sewage treatment is a vital job and one that seems impossibly glamorous to a 6 year old! Grin

I was just making a point that children's interests/aspirations will change massively over 15-20 years, from wearing big wellies to being stuck behind a desk (and in reverse order too).

Nillynally · 01/12/2021 13:11

I know it probably did sound snobby but I would hope my children would want to aim higher than a refuse collector. I have no problem with the job at all and I'm sure they are paid well but it's hardly a pleasant job, lobbing rubbish around, early starts, freezing cold weather, hard physical labour, not very much career progression (I would imagine- I have no idea!)
You sound a bit chippy.

roarfeckingroarr · 01/12/2021 12:59

YABU

it's snobby to want your child to have a professional or vocational job with decent pay.

5128gap · 01/12/2021 12:58

I think there's a lot of romanticising going on with regards to the less desirable low paid jobs. Its the who cares about money if you're happy cheery road sweeper trope. The reality is that few people who know first hand what it's like to do the dirty, cold, unpleasant, invisible and thankless jobs in society for minimum wage want their children to have to do them if they have a choice. Suggesting you would be delighted with it for your child, assuming they had other options, demonstrates either a naivety as to the reality, or a misguided (and somewhat insulting to those who have to do them and hate it) attempt to pretend these jobs are more desirable than they are.

thinkfast · 01/12/2021 12:50

My cousin was a "bin man" for a couple of years. She always said she really enjoyed it. Lots of excercise, relatively well paid, started and finished early so had the rest of the day to enjoy.

I doubt there any many employed by local councils nowadays though - don't most councils subcontract work like this?

IntermittentParps · 01/12/2021 12:47

[quote HyphenCobra]@IntermittentParps Thanks don't need your pity 😂

I think it's great if your children can LOVE their job. But equally they need to be able to provide financially for themselves without help from a man or their parents. That's life. And tbh how many people truly LOVE their job?? And also are able to be financially dependant from doing said amazing job?

What i find sad is that we expect young children to have to KNOW what they want to do for the rest of their lives and make decisions based on this that will potentially impact them massively for ever more. I made decisions i thought were best when i was younger and then realised I'd need to change career path - which is VERY challenging when you are mid thirties with children and a mortgage.

What would be better would be if university etc etc was the norm for people in their later twenties once they'd had a chance to have a bit of life experience first. As that's not the case, i have to try to impart my life lessons onto my children and hope for the best.

Obviously if they chose to go on and do minimum wage jobs etc i have no control over that. But as a parent i definitely want the best for them and in my opinion, that'sa careerwhich pays well and has great prospects.[/quote]
Well, I find it sad that you want for your daughter what is best in your own opinion, rather than her passion.

Starcaller · 01/12/2021 12:46

But hairdressers can become business owners, open chains of stores, employ others. They aren't all working down at the local shop on the corner doing blue rinses for £5. Almost every job can lead to other things if the person doing it has the ambition and to push themselves. I have a friend who is a hairdresser and a very successful business owner with two award-winning salons.

The important thing is to instil a passion and zest for life and learning in your child, not push them towards careers that you think are a good idea. People with passion and drive and the support of the people around them are more likely to excel in whatever their chosen path is. People without won't. You can lead a horse to water ...

ufucoffee · 01/12/2021 12:45

@Teatoast00

Chances are a bin man will be retired at 60 with a nice pension to boot
Why do you think they will retired at 60. You only get the big pensions in the public sector if you get the big salaries.
Teatoast00 · 01/12/2021 12:43

Chances are a bin man will be retired at 60 with a nice pension to boot

HyphenCobra · 01/12/2021 12:36

@IntermittentParps Thanks don't need your pity 😂

I think it's great if your children can LOVE their job. But equally they need to be able to provide financially for themselves without help from a man or their parents. That's life. And tbh how many people truly LOVE their job?? And also are able to be financially dependant from doing said amazing job?

What i find sad is that we expect young children to have to KNOW what they want to do for the rest of their lives and make decisions based on this that will potentially impact them massively for ever more. I made decisions i thought were best when i was younger and then realised I'd need to change career path - which is VERY challenging when you are mid thirties with children and a mortgage.

What would be better would be if university etc etc was the norm for people in their later twenties once they'd had a chance to have a bit of life experience first. As that's not the case, i have to try to impart my life lessons onto my children and hope for the best.

Obviously if they chose to go on and do minimum wage jobs etc i have no control over that. But as a parent i definitely want the best for them and in my opinion, that'sa careerwhich pays well and has great prospects.

HyphenCobra · 01/12/2021 12:28

@5128gap

I also think that many people who know the reality of living long term on minimum wage might hope their children could enjoy the benefits a higher income can bring.
Completely agree @5128gap

I've had the life of minimum wage, the life of a very good salary in a service industry and a good salary in a non service industry.

My work life balance and prospects were best in the non service industry. I got the most money in the service industry but had to sacrifice all bank holiday's etc so when i started a family i became miserable doing that. The minimum wage job was bloody dismal as always stressed about money.

I want my children to not have to deal with the challenges i had to.

HyphenCobra · 01/12/2021 12:24

@MattDillonsEyebrows yes it's a trade/skill. If she wanted it as a part time job to see her through uni that's fine. But it's hard work, being on your feet all day, having a sore throat but still needing to make conversation with clients, working long hours and every weekend. It's maybe fine when you're young, but not as you age and certainly not if you have physical health conditions.

I think nowadays there's way too much propaganda being spread about how we can all do whatever we want and be happy. But actually life is far more complex than that nowadays, and everything is so much more expensive. You have to make sensible choices if you want to have the most options available to you in life.

My DH was extremely lucky his passion led to a six figure salary. I very much doubt being a hairdresser would lead my daughter to the same financial outcome.

5128gap · 01/12/2021 12:22

I also think that many people who know the reality of living long term on minimum wage might hope their children could enjoy the benefits a higher income can bring.

IntermittentParps · 01/12/2021 12:20

[quote HyphenCobra]@IntermittentParps

Yes i guess she could, but realistically?? Ummm, don't think so 😂😂😂 Just like my youngest who wants to be an actor!

I have no problem with her having a passion on the side, but actually having a well paid career as a main job[/quote]
That's a bit sad.
I wish your DD all the best and I hope she's happy and fulfilled.

HyphenCobra · 01/12/2021 12:17

@IntermittentParps

Yes i guess she could, but realistically?? Ummm, don't think so 😂😂😂 Just like my youngest who wants to be an actor!

I have no problem with her having a passion on the side, but actually having a well paid career as a main job

5128gap · 01/12/2021 12:14

I'm about as far from a snob as you could get, but bin man would not be my first choice of occupation for my DS. Its not being snobby to say that objectively its not the most pleasant job in the world. Its cold, its dirty and its smelly, and I'd be surprised if apart from the money, many people really love doing it. If my DS was making an informed decision I'd obviously be supportive, but it wouldn't stop me from hoping he'd choose something he may find more enjoyable/rewarding. Not sure where she's coming from with the HGV thing though other than as you say, snobbery.

MattDillonsEyebrows · 01/12/2021 12:12

@HyphenCobra

I agree with your friend, sorry OP.

My eldest is really clever but her aspiration is to be a hairdresser. I am actively trying to suggest other careers that i think would play to her talents and give her a great paycheck. DH tells me i should let her follow her passion as it worked out for him. I have told him he is the only person i know who truly loves their job AND gets paid handsomely to do it.

My reason being, today's world is bloody hard enough without being on minimum wage!! House prices are ridiculous, so is everything else - fuel, energy, food.

Do i want her still living at home when she's 40 because she can't afford to move out or do any fun activities etc all because she wasted her natural talents and now earns the same amount an hour as a large starbucks coffee costs?? Er, no thanks.

I had friends that were sooooo bright, could have done anything! They ended up dosing during teenage years and now live near the breadline.

Plus, speaking as someone who did do minimum wage jobs early on, many of those jobs involve unsociable hours, weekend working etc and deal with the public face to face who are absolute c*s most of the time.

I want better for my children. Equally, it's possible to wish that for them whilst not looking down on others who do those jobs.

I can't help but think you're not seeing the wood for the tree here @HyphenCobra

Hairdressers use their brains a lot more than you're giving them credit for and if she enjoys it and is good at it, why would you want her not to do it?
Even if she only does it for a few years after leaving school, I'd say learning a trade like hairdressing is invaluable. It's a trade, that means she'll never be out of work, whether working for a top salon or doing small mobile work to local people, she will always have that skill in her back pocket.

Ajl46 · 01/12/2021 12:11

Is anyone else reading this thread with the recent thread about how the OP struggled to comprehend huge salaries in mind? One poster said on that thread that if it were Dadsnet, people would be piling on asking for tips on how to progress & increase their salaries rather than apologising for being a high earner. What is wrong with exploring options & encouraging aspiration? Surely we should all be encouraging & supporting others to maximise their potential in whatever form, eg someone might start off as a bin man and choose to progress to management and then on to starting their own refuse disposal company.

In my view we should focus on ensuring children learn the skills they need to maximise their potential and consider all of their career options (including what lifestyle implications they might have), rather than limiting their options.

IntermittentParps · 01/12/2021 12:09

@HyphenCobra

I agree with your friend, sorry OP.

My eldest is really clever but her aspiration is to be a hairdresser. I am actively trying to suggest other careers that i think would play to her talents and give her a great paycheck. DH tells me i should let her follow her passion as it worked out for him. I have told him he is the only person i know who truly loves their job AND gets paid handsomely to do it.

My reason being, today's world is bloody hard enough without being on minimum wage!! House prices are ridiculous, so is everything else - fuel, energy, food.

Do i want her still living at home when she's 40 because she can't afford to move out or do any fun activities etc all because she wasted her natural talents and now earns the same amount an hour as a large starbucks coffee costs?? Er, no thanks.

I had friends that were sooooo bright, could have done anything! They ended up dosing during teenage years and now live near the breadline.

Plus, speaking as someone who did do minimum wage jobs early on, many of those jobs involve unsociable hours, weekend working etc and deal with the public face to face who are absolute c*s most of the time.

I want better for my children. Equally, it's possible to wish that for them whilst not looking down on others who do those jobs.

Well, for starters, I agree you should let her follow her passion.

But also, being a hairdresser doesn't necessarily mean she'll be on minimum wage/living at home when she's 40.
She could get into something really exciting and perhaps lucrative and/or offering lots of opportunities for travel and living overseas (working in film/telly/personal styling etc)
She could be the next Daniel Field or Rita Rusk; eminently respected
and looked up to.

AllTheUsernamesAreAlreadyTaken · 01/12/2021 12:07

This thread has inspired me to give our bin men a generous Christmas tip.
I didn’t realise people were so snobbish about such an important job!

IntermittentParps · 01/12/2021 12:07

@AllTheUsernamesAreAlreadyTaken

How can posters seriously be simultaneously saying that they don’t believe they’re above bin men yet they want their children to aim higher? If you’re not above them, how can something be higher?

To the PP whose son is a bin man, you’re right to be proud of him. We’d all be up shit creek without bin men. They’re worth their weight in gold.

Couldn't agree more. The cognitive dissonance here is really weird.
AllTheUsernamesAreAlreadyTaken · 01/12/2021 12:05

How can posters seriously be simultaneously saying that they don’t believe they’re above bin men yet they want their children to aim higher? If you’re not above them, how can something be higher?

To the PP whose son is a bin man, you’re right to be proud of him. We’d all be up shit creek without bin men. They’re worth their weight in gold.