Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think parents shouldn't get preferential treatment when it comes to time off work?

993 replies

KwestTurkey · 30/11/2021 22:38

I just read an article on Facebook about this. A parent had asked a childfree colleague if she could have some of her saved holiday days and was refused (understandably).

That's obviously a CF request. But in general, what do you think about parents and holiday requests Vs childfree colleagues?

I don't believe parents should be given priority when it comes to time off on any holiday, be it summer or Christmas etc.. I think it should always, generally, work on a first come first served basis. The amount of times I was refused any sort of time off in the summer because every single parent in the office had booked off the summer and they were given first dibs on those dates used to annoy me.

I'm a parent now but my opinion hasn't changed on that. I think if someone childfree has gotten there with the request before you then that's tough.

Same with Christmas, if you work a job that requires Christmas working, I don't think it's fair to allow the same people off every Christmas year in year out.

It's definitely something I've experienced in my workplace before and after having DC and it feels very unfair.

I really don't think it's anyone elses responsibility to ensure you get time off during school holidays or things like Christmas and that a childfree colleague has as much right to book the time off as any parent.

So...

YANBU - parents shouldn't get preferential treatment or priority when it comes to time off work.

YABU - they should.

OP posts:
KaycePollard · 03/12/2021 13:17

Presumably no one has to volunteer if it's errrr voluntary?

The work is not voluntary, as I said in my post above, these are required duties.

So the person who organises these events first of all asks for volunteers to do the Saturday work. Parents rarely offer, while those without children do. The parents tend to rely on this, and feel they're doing their "fair" share by doing these duties when they fall on an ordinary week day working day.

But it's not actually fair, and we've had to start to record how many Saturdays everyone is responsible for.

Cattipuss · 03/12/2021 12:50

But I have noticed how our unit's required duties on some Saturdays throughout the year tend always to be staffed by those of us without children. It's done mostly on a volunteer basis with a rota of extra work - Saturdays and normal working week days, so the total amount of time people do s equal - but the parents in the unit are the ones whonevervolunteer for the Saturday work.

Presumably no one has to volunteer if it's errrr voluntary?

CateJW · 03/12/2021 12:45

@PurpleDaisies that certainly wasn't the tone of my reply.
That said, I can't think of many jobs, that someone who do for their whole life, that would require Xmas day working, except for parts of the armed forces, police and NHS, which people go into knowing that is one of the downsides of the job. (Still sucks I know) I was simply talking about my personal experience in one of the industries that does, which, even without kids I managed to choose not to work Xmas, by working other days that a lot of people wanted off, but I wasnt bothered about.
And of our experience with the military, another job that goes all round. Like I said our thoughts on the matter were for the kids not the grown ups.
If you don't want to work on Christmas, tell your boss so when you sign your contract.

Lalalablahblahblah · 03/12/2021 12:23

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

PurpleDaisies · 03/12/2021 12:17

So I lean to yes, parents should get preferential treatment, for Christmas at least (but I say that for the kids, not the grown ups)

What if people never go on to have their own children? Do they get the pleasure of working Christmas Day forever? That’s an extra kick in the teeth when you wanted them but couldn’t have them.

CateJW · 03/12/2021 11:53

It may depend on the job, but even before I had kids I made it clear that I wouldn't work Christmas day and boxing day, but I was more than happy to do Christmas Eve and New year's Eve. Luckily it was a job with loads of youngsters who would rather new year's eve off!
(I am now self employed, so don't have to work any hours I don't want and luckily my job is term time.)
My partner however is military and has missed 2 of our kids Christmases, and many before, but before kids, we were happy for the dads with kids to get the Xmas leave. As much as he would have also loved to be home for Christmas, we would rather the kids got their dads home. So I lean to yes, parents should get preferential treatment, for Christmas at least (but I say that for the kids, not the grown ups)

KaycePollard · 03/12/2021 11:51

But what I don't understand is why people without kids would want to take holiday when the kids are off! I'd be avoiding it like the plague

It's a bit of a lack of imagination to ask this question ... There are loads of obvious reasons.

Main one is that school summer holidays are quite long and cover the nicest months of the year. Same at Easter. And some things I like to do, only happen in the summer or at Easter. And so on.

And not all teachers have children, but all teachers can only take holidays outside of teaching terms.

julieca · 03/12/2021 11:39

I know there will be exceptions. but Christmas Day would have been the easiest day of the year for childcare for me. My partner would be off, my parents, in-laws, aunties and uncles, even friends would have looked after our children.

Zyana · 03/12/2021 11:20

This reply has been withdrawn

Withdrawn at the poster's request.

Couchbettato · 03/12/2021 11:17

@LittleMysSister

It's such a tough subject isn't it as I know lots of parents really have little choice but to try and get certain times off for childcare, but equally it's not fair for childfree people to never be able to have premium times off themselves - thinking of Christmas, Easter and August BH really.

I don't have any children yet so I do try and be considerate where I can - for instance, I don't tend to book off Christmas Eve if I don't need to, even though it would be nice.

Quite honestly though, all the problems I have seen re quibbling over holiday time has been between parents, not between a parent and a childfree person.

In one workplace, there were only 2 people with school-aged children and one of them would come in with their holiday dates for the whole year on Jan 1st every year. Always included every half term, Easter, Christmas week, etc. It used to drive the other parent mad and management wouldn't handle it beyond saying that he had submitted his dates first so what could they do?

This is the sort of attitude that makes it work.

Parents don't deserve first dibs, but parents need to be conscientious of non parents, and just as this poster has said they're conscientious of parents and their needs.

It's got to be give and take on both sides, but no single person should have priority and we all need to respect any one can take time off for any reason they like.

PurpleDaisies · 03/12/2021 11:15

It’s irrelevant - an employee has as much right to time off work during the school holidays as any employee. No one has to give a reason

@Parker231 did you miss what question I was answering? Confused

AudacityBaby · 03/12/2021 11:14

Yep, unfortunately there’s no such thing as discrimination against non-parents as it’s not a protected characteristic. Neither is parent but there’s a strong indirect discrimination argument that if you don’t favour parents you’re discriminating against women on the basis of sex. Someone referred to a successful employment tribunal case earlier in the thread, brought on that basis. My employer is really alert to that possibility, knows that non-parents can’t bring legal challenges, and so uses them as old reliables to do all the stuff parents don’t fancy doing.

Yes it’s a management problem and yes I’m trying to leave. But there are people at my work and on this thread with serious levels of entitlement and I also think that needs to be pointed out. ”Bad management” is just a way of shifting focus from bad behaviour, and propagating the notion that childless people need to be kind, put up and shut up.

Another reflection I had… whenever there’s a thread where a parent has ended up doing unilateral one-way favours for another, there’s a categorical response from MN that she’s dealing with a CF, nobody is entitled to have a stranger help with their kids etc etc. Then you get threads like these, where it’s clear that actually, there is an entitlement to have strangers help with your kids. It just only falls on childless people. Parents mustn’t be burdened by other parents needing childcare, but childless people? Well it’s their role in life!

Parker231 · 03/12/2021 11:01

@PurpleDaisies

But what I don't understand is why people without kids would want to take holiday when the kids are off! I'd be avoiding it like the plague

Married to a teacher. You never get time off together otherwise.

It’s irrelevant - an employee has as much right to time off work during the school holidays as any employee. No one has to give a reason
PurpleDaisies · 03/12/2021 10:56

But what I don't understand is why people without kids would want to take holiday when the kids are off! I'd be avoiding it like the plague

Married to a teacher. You never get time off together otherwise.

LittleMysSister · 03/12/2021 10:52

It's such a tough subject isn't it as I know lots of parents really have little choice but to try and get certain times off for childcare, but equally it's not fair for childfree people to never be able to have premium times off themselves - thinking of Christmas, Easter and August BH really.

I don't have any children yet so I do try and be considerate where I can - for instance, I don't tend to book off Christmas Eve if I don't need to, even though it would be nice.

Quite honestly though, all the problems I have seen re quibbling over holiday time has been between parents, not between a parent and a childfree person.

In one workplace, there were only 2 people with school-aged children and one of them would come in with their holiday dates for the whole year on Jan 1st every year. Always included every half term, Easter, Christmas week, etc. It used to drive the other parent mad and management wouldn't handle it beyond saying that he had submitted his dates first so what could they do?

Jackofallsorts · 03/12/2021 10:51

If I was forced to work days to facilitate other on an ongoing basis without any reciprocation, I'd simply announced I'm a parent and would insist on having the preferential treatment. If I was challenged on this, I'd go so legal on them they'd back down (or change policy)

wannabeamummysobad · 03/12/2021 10:46

@Mfsf

I know my team personally , we have each other’s backs apart from the odd occasion where we have a junior .. I’ve never been in a situation where a person workout kids wanted the same time off as a colleague and we close all main holidays so these are not a issue . Being a good manager or team leader is not treating everyone the same , it’s doing it fairly , I also gave a big chunk of paid leave to someone doing ivf recently as a example and made sure her leave was available on top of that despite not having to do it . Takes time to make people realise equality first mean we all need the same
Now you are conflating/confusing two separate things.

If your team is happy to defer to those with specific issues and give up leave/switch leave then that's fine.

This threads focus/purpose for set up was specifically to address the question of if it's fair that parents be given preferential treatment.

KaycePollard · 03/12/2021 10:42

@AudacityBaby

We know everything is done to care for your child. It’s not some kind of weird fact of life that only parents have discovered - we can imagine the need to care for something that is fully dependant on you. We’re childless, not sociopathic.

What it isn’t is our job. I am not co-parenting with you. I did not sign up to join in with your family and make it possible for you to stay at home with your children. To the extent that it’s not possible for you to do that then you’ll have to figure something out.

(She says, about to work her 7th consecutive Christmas because her employer will force childless staff to do just that.)

This.

I'm lucky, we don't have to work in the office over Christmas - we WFH. But I have noticed how our unit's required duties on some Saturdays throughout the year tend always to be staffed by those of us without children. It's done mostly on a volunteer basis with a rota of extra work - Saturdays and normal working week days, so the total amount of time people do s equal - but the parents in the unit are the ones who never volunteer for the Saturday work.

User1055 · 03/12/2021 10:15

So if an employer gives Christmas and New Year off to parents (at the expense of non-parents) because its a special time of year for children, when does this privilege stop? When the child is 5? 10? 15? Never, because the child is alway the parent's child?
And once a precedence has been set of that parent never needs to work at Christmas because someone else will, how do the employers and/or non-parents claim back the right for the employee to work and someone else get the chance to spend Christmas with their loved ones?

Intercity225 · 03/12/2021 10:12

But what I don't understand is why people without kids would want to take holiday when the kids are off! I'd be avoiding it like the plague

In some industries, the work is seasonal, and at the busy times of year, staff are not allowed to take annual leave at all!

I worked for reinsurance brokers for instance, and I was told at the interview, that if I liked going skiing, it was not the place to work, as nobody was allowed time off in the winter - that is the renewals season!

Accountancy is another! DH works flat out from January to mid August - he has always had to take the last 2 weeks of August off, as that was his slackest time of year. January is tax returns, April 5th is the tax year end, and then there are all the December and March year end accounts and tax returns to do....He has other deadlines in October, with particular clients. The last few years, we have gone in the first half of September and every time, he gets back and complains that he should never have gone in September, because he's got too much to do, in not enough time for the end of October. Likewise, where DS works, the audit staff are not allowed to go on holiday between January and July - and these are usually young people in their 20s.

Mfsf · 03/12/2021 10:04

I know my team personally , we have each other’s backs apart from the odd occasion where we have a junior .. I’ve never been in a situation where a person workout kids wanted the same time off as a colleague and we close all main holidays so these are not a issue . Being a good manager or team leader is not treating everyone the same , it’s doing it fairly , I also gave a big chunk of paid leave to someone doing ivf recently as a example and made sure her leave was available on top of that despite not having to do it . Takes time to make people realise equality first mean we all need the same

LivinginWFHlimbo · 03/12/2021 10:01

[quote wannabeamummysobad]@LivinginWFHlimbo the dictionary definition of discrimination "the unjust or prejudicial treatment of different categories of people"

Disadvantaging those without child-caring responsibilities at the expense of/for the benefit of those with child caring responsibilities is textbook discrimination.

[/quote]
But it isn't discrimination that you can cite in an employment tribunal - you can see that, clearly, you posted the list of protected categories just now!

Again, I agree with you it's wrong and unfair, I was just pointing out that there wouldn't be a legal case to bring before an employment tribunal as another poster claimed.

It might constitute bullying/a hostile work environment - especially if there's only one person without children and so they bear the brunt of the policy - but it isn't the basis of a discrimination case.

wannabeamummysobad · 03/12/2021 09:58

@LivinginWFHlimbo the dictionary definition of discrimination "the unjust or prejudicial treatment of different categories of people"

Disadvantaging those without child-caring responsibilities at the expense of/for the benefit of those with child caring responsibilities is textbook discrimination.

LivinginWFHlimbo · 03/12/2021 09:57

Not having appropriate childcare is a personal problem that can can taken into consideration but not at the expense of other people. I.e if your manager sympathises with your not having childcare that manager can swap shifts with you/take on your role responsibilities etc. It's not for your colleagues to pick up the proverbial slack. Your manager can't force someone without your issues/problems to cover for you all the time.

But this is just your opinion of how things should work. I actually agree with you that that's how it should work, but that isn't the law. It isn't discrimination if your manager denies you leave at a specific time because they give it to colleagues with children any more than it is if they deny you leave at a specific time for any other reason.

SleepingStandingUp · 03/12/2021 09:56

@KwestTurkey

But what I don't understand is why people without kids would want to take holiday when the kids are off! I'd be avoiding it like the plague ;)

Well it's still summer, it's still a nice time of year to do other things, go on holiday yourself, see friends, enjoy the only bit of sun we'll get for the year or whatever.. I don't think childfree people should be unable to take any time off between the months of July and September. That was how it always was though in my workplace, just a given that you wouldn't be allowed any time off during that time of year (or any other school holiday), nevermind the occasion.

Obv they're entitled to summer, but if I hadn't got kids I'd be going away as much as possible in September to avoid the kids and the ridiculous price hike.

First come first served with reasonable consideration imo. DHs colleague puts in a years worth of AL request on Jan 1st for the whole school year. Only one off at a time. Its hard to beat and we end up trying to find a week here and there. This year DH will be sent to work with a list of dates to book

Swipe left for the next trending thread