Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think parents shouldn't get preferential treatment when it comes to time off work?

993 replies

KwestTurkey · 30/11/2021 22:38

I just read an article on Facebook about this. A parent had asked a childfree colleague if she could have some of her saved holiday days and was refused (understandably).

That's obviously a CF request. But in general, what do you think about parents and holiday requests Vs childfree colleagues?

I don't believe parents should be given priority when it comes to time off on any holiday, be it summer or Christmas etc.. I think it should always, generally, work on a first come first served basis. The amount of times I was refused any sort of time off in the summer because every single parent in the office had booked off the summer and they were given first dibs on those dates used to annoy me.

I'm a parent now but my opinion hasn't changed on that. I think if someone childfree has gotten there with the request before you then that's tough.

Same with Christmas, if you work a job that requires Christmas working, I don't think it's fair to allow the same people off every Christmas year in year out.

It's definitely something I've experienced in my workplace before and after having DC and it feels very unfair.

I really don't think it's anyone elses responsibility to ensure you get time off during school holidays or things like Christmas and that a childfree colleague has as much right to book the time off as any parent.

So...

YANBU - parents shouldn't get preferential treatment or priority when it comes to time off work.

YABU - they should.

OP posts:
CounsellorTroi · 03/12/2021 15:40

Isn't there also escalators? I always thought signs like these were to encourage those who can to use them. I didn't think buggies are allowed on escalators

Escalators only up to the first floor shopping level. The lifts go up to the car parking level.

HardbackWriter · 03/12/2021 15:36

There’s a sign by the lifts in my local shopping mall saying “At busy times please give priority to the disabled and families with young children and pushchairs”. The first bit I get but why shouldn’t families with young children and pushchairs wait in line like everyone else?

Isn't that just saying 'let people who can't use the stairs go first', which doesn't seem unreasonable?

IntermittentParps · 03/12/2021 15:32

Christmas, again surely it's a nice thing to do to let parents spend xmas with their kids? But it is the one time of year I just think you need to do first come, first served.
Is it not 'a nice thing to do' to let (for example) my cousin's parents spend xmas with her as she lives overseas and only generally comes back for Christmas?
Or (for another example) my ex-boss spend Xmas with her mother when she was frail and didn't have many left?

First come, first served simply isn't fair. It's just a scrum.

womaninatightspot · 03/12/2021 15:26

@CounsellorTroi

Order childfree people to get off a full bus and wait for the next one, because a parent needs to make that journey at that time? Make non-parents move their cars from full car-parks when a parent needs to park there for school/child-related purposes? Let parents (whether out with their kids or not) permanently jump the queues on the supermarket, so that childfree people are only finally allowed to pay for their shopping and get on with their day once every single parent in the shop has finished, because their lives are more important as they have children?

There’s a sign by the lifts in my local shopping mall saying “At busy times please give priority to the disabled and families with young children and pushchairs”. The first bit I get but why shouldn’t families with young children and pushchairs wait in line like everyone else?

Isn't there also escalators? I always thought signs like these were to encourage those who can to use them. I didn't think buggies are allowed on escalators
FootieMama · 03/12/2021 15:01

I've never heard of parents being given preferencial treatment for holidays. In my over 20 years working,16 of them as parent. I have, however, taken full advantage of the first come first served rule and booked half-term and summer holidays we'll in advance. Usually as soon as available on my employer system. I think many parents do that as they can plan with their children's school calendar. So YABU for that reason. And if a colleague asks you for a swap you can always say no.

Volhhg · 03/12/2021 14:54

"There are plenty of jobs out there where you can either work term-time only or find an employer that shuts down completely on the bank holidays."

I would love this!! But it's sadly not at all true. It's very difficult to get a job like this

5128gap · 03/12/2021 14:47

Doesn't bother me. Now I no longer have young children to factor in I can take my holidays at times when it's cheaper and less crowded. The things I like to do as an adult at Christmas don't usually impact my work as they are at evenings and weekends. In the past I was very appreciative when I got time off in school holidays, and am happy to pay the perk forward.

AudacityBaby · 03/12/2021 14:34

@CounsellorTroi Agree. Leads to problems on buses with parents thinking they’re in the same category as wheelchair users. The increasing conflation of having a child (where neither parent nor child has a disability) and having a disability is really worrying to me.

CounsellorTroi · 03/12/2021 14:28

Order childfree people to get off a full bus and wait for the next one, because a parent needs to make that journey at that time? Make non-parents move their cars from full car-parks when a parent needs to park there for school/child-related purposes? Let parents (whether out with their kids or not) permanently jump the queues on the supermarket, so that childfree people are only finally allowed to pay for their shopping and get on with their day once every single parent in the shop has finished, because their lives are more important as they have children?

There’s a sign by the lifts in my local shopping mall saying “At busy times please give priority to the disabled and families with young children and pushchairs”. The first bit I get but why shouldn’t families with young children and pushchairs wait in line like everyone else?

PrincessPaws · 03/12/2021 14:25

@LivinginWFHlimbo

Not having appropriate childcare is a personal problem that can can taken into consideration but not at the expense of other people. I.e if your manager sympathises with your not having childcare that manager can swap shifts with you/take on your role responsibilities etc. It's not for your colleagues to pick up the proverbial slack. Your manager can't force someone without your issues/problems to cover for you all the time.

But this is just your opinion of how things should work. I actually agree with you that that's how it should work, but that isn't the law. It isn't discrimination if your manager denies you leave at a specific time because they give it to colleagues with children any more than it is if they deny you leave at a specific time for any other reason.

Technically it could be discrimination if someone was child free due to a disability and was being treated less favourably as a result.

Even if that wasn't the case, people could raise grievances on the basis of unfair treatment/bullying, which could ultimately lead to a claim for constructive dismissal

That's the problem, it isn't black and white at all so a manager playing favourites because someone has kids is not sensible

AudacityBaby · 03/12/2021 14:24

[quote CateJW]@AudacityBaby 🤣🤣 people on here, seriously!!
How am I benefitting from it now? I don't work there anymore. I am self employed and set my own hours.
My partner misses every other Christmas due to deployments. (He is in a different branch than when we were childless and there is no say on leave) that is still my opinion. You are entitled to your own. Jeez![/quote]
Doesn’t change the thrust of your view though does it? “I was happy to do it so everyone else should just be like me and be happy to do it.”

You’re entitled to your opinion but expecting others to be happy with something because you were is a bit self-centred.

CateJW · 03/12/2021 14:21

@AudacityBaby 🤣🤣 people on here, seriously!!
How am I benefitting from it now? I don't work there anymore. I am self employed and set my own hours.
My partner misses every other Christmas due to deployments. (He is in a different branch than when we were childless and there is no say on leave) that is still my opinion. You are entitled to your own. Jeez!

rookiemere · 03/12/2021 14:21

Yes @Nidan2Sandan I don't think DPs should get priority, but if the system is such that those who get their holidays in first are those who get their choice of days, then surely the issue is with the system rather than DPs who get in early to ensure they are off at the same time as their DCs.

Nidan2Sandan · 03/12/2021 14:14

I think it's nice to allow colleagues with kids to have the half term breaks etc because parents are at the behest of school holidays and most childless adults are not. So what is the harm in taking your leave the week after half term so the parent in your team can have half term off.

Summer holidays are different , there are 6 weeks to play with so I'm sure everyone can work it out between them fairly.

Christmas, again surely it's a nice thing to do to let parents spend xmas with their kids? But it is the one time of year I just think you need to do first come, first served.

I am a parent, and I dont expect people to prioritise my time off, but I will make sure I get in there first and book my time off in school holidays and too bad if the childless parents weren't as organised as me Grin.

AudacityBaby · 03/12/2021 14:14

@CateJW “I was happy to do this and am now benefitting from it so I think this is how it should be even if others aren’t happy with it. They should just be happy with it, like I was.”

bellinisurge · 03/12/2021 14:09

When I wasn't a parent it pissed me off that I was supposed to prioritise the needs of colleagues who were parents over my own. Now that I am a parent I wouldn't dream of inflicting that on other people.

CateJW · 03/12/2021 14:09

@PurpleDaisies so you are literally read the conclusion of my message and ignored everything else I said... I was literally talking about how we "volunteered" to let the military father's with kids have the leave when we didn't have kids and how we worked it out so everyone was happy when I worked in a restaurant I got Christmas off those who wanted to go out and party got new years eve off. So yes that it how I feel it should be, cos i tend to focus on the kids, I work with kids now. I prefer them to grown ups. Lol! so that is how my thinking goes. You are entitled to your own opinion, having children of my own hasn't made that my opinion, I have always felt that way.

LivinginWFHlimbo · 03/12/2021 14:07

@KaycePollard

Presumably no one has to volunteer if it's errrr voluntary?

The work is not voluntary, as I said in my post above, these are required duties.

So the person who organises these events first of all asks for volunteers to do the Saturday work. Parents rarely offer, while those without children do. The parents tend to rely on this, and feel they're doing their "fair" share by doing these duties when they fall on an ordinary week day working day.

But it's not actually fair, and we've had to start to record how many Saturdays everyone is responsible for.

This is a terrible system which is obviously going to cause resentment. If you actually want everyone to do an equal number of Saturdays then have a rota. Don't pretend it's voluntary and then get angry at people for not reading your mind and knowing that they're supposed to volunteer Confused
AudacityBaby · 03/12/2021 14:04

@Merlin3189 It wouldn’t need to be a single man. A single woman would be sufficient. The parent would just need to argue indirect discrimination on the basis of sex (women typically being primary carers) and job done. It seems it’s already been done (a previous poster has mentioned a successful employment tribunal case on this basis).

Parents aren’t low in the protection hierarchy. Not compared to those without kids, anyway, who have no protection whatsoever despite also being women.

(This is one of the reasons I don’t like this being described as a feminist issue. It is, obviously, but it involves placing one class of women above another, and that sits badly with me.)

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 03/12/2021 13:58

I don't understand why the claims that parents should always get priority, because of need, only applies to annual leave? Why don't we extend it to other areas too and make it clear that we believe non-parents should have fewer rights?

Order childfree people to get off a full bus and wait for the next one, because a parent needs to make that journey at that time? Make non-parents move their cars from full car-parks when a parent needs to park there for school/child-related purposes? Let parents (whether out with their kids or not) permanently jump the queues on the supermarket, so that childfree people are only finally allowed to pay for their shopping and get on with their day once every single parent in the shop has finished, because their lives are more important as they have children?

Yes, I know it's tough for us when we have to make sacrifices and juggle childcare - but we all knew that would be an issue before we decided to have children.

There are plenty of jobs out there where you can either work term-time only or find an employer that shuts down completely on the bank holidays. You wouldn't take a job working the night shift if your circumstances prevented you from being asleep in the daytime. You wouldn't consider a job that looked otherwise perfect but which was based 300 miles from where you live (unless moving was an option).

Nobody is saying that parents shouldn't work at all - just that the family has to consider the children's needs (and maybe preferences too) when looking for suitable jobs. Of course choosing to have children will limit you and your life choices - everybody knows this. Parenthood is wonderful, but like most good things in life, there is also a cost.

As for people saying that this almost always falls on mothers, it is the fathers of their children who also need to jointly step up, make sacrifices, pay for childcare and find the elusive solutions to ensure their joint children are appropriately cared for - it isn't incumbent on some random person who happens to work for the same employer as you.

As 'Linda' put it so well upthread, for the kind of parents who aren't team players and only ever care about what suits them and their children, it's not just a case of asking childfree people to let the parents go first and you take the second turn - there will always be somebody who believes themselves to be more deserving than you, so your turn will never come at all.

It just isn't good enough to lay claim to all of the best/popular days - even a quarter of the whole year - telling childfree colleagues that they can then choose from the leftover days and believing that to be fair. It's a bit like when everybody caught in a traffic jam curses all of the other 'selfish' drivers for 'deciding to travel' at the exact same time as they need to be on the road.

Cattipuss · 03/12/2021 13:57

@KaycePollard

Presumably no one has to volunteer if it's errrr voluntary?

The work is not voluntary, as I said in my post above, these are required duties.

So the person who organises these events first of all asks for volunteers to do the Saturday work. Parents rarely offer, while those without children do. The parents tend to rely on this, and feel they're doing their "fair" share by doing these duties when they fall on an ordinary week day working day.

But it's not actually fair, and we've had to start to record how many Saturdays everyone is responsible for.

Or others stop volunteering and insist on a rota or something. If people are offering it seems odd to be annoyed, I mean I wouldn't fancy trying to secure childcare at a weekend unless necessary and with notice. The longer people go on putting their hand up the longer it won't be done fairly.
Merlin3189 · 03/12/2021 13:48

I've said YABU for being so inflexible yourself, but YANBU if your employer and colleagues are equally inflexible.
People's particular circumstances should be taken into account and any hard and fast rule - like parents first, or first come first served - doesn't do that. That, of course, is v.difficult in practice, if everyone wants the same thing. I do see parents wanting a summer holiday with their children as a pretty high priority. And FCFS seems a particularly bad rule, except as a tie breaker.
Maybe if you got your preference last time, you should get less priority this time and vice versa. But nothing can satisfy everyone nor even be fair when a scarce resource is really overloaded.

Ultimately it is a nightmare for the employer to decide. As with customers, to keep in favour you have to please people all the time, but it only takes once to lose them. Fairness is almost illegal these days, as deciding against anyone with protected status could cost the employer a lot. Though parents are low in the protection hierarchy, mums could probably sue, if a single man got priority.

PurpleDaisies · 03/12/2021 13:32

[quote CateJW]@PurpleDaisies that certainly wasn't the tone of my reply.
That said, I can't think of many jobs, that someone who do for their whole life, that would require Xmas day working, except for parts of the armed forces, police and NHS, which people go into knowing that is one of the downsides of the job. (Still sucks I know) I was simply talking about my personal experience in one of the industries that does, which, even without kids I managed to choose not to work Xmas, by working other days that a lot of people wanted off, but I wasnt bothered about.
And of our experience with the military, another job that goes all round. Like I said our thoughts on the matter were for the kids not the grown ups.
If you don't want to work on Christmas, tell your boss so when you sign your contract.[/quote]
You weren’t talking about people volunteering. I was always happy to work my fair share of Christmases. You were taking about parents getting preferential treatment which means in practice, non parents end up working other people’s fair share as well.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 03/12/2021 13:28

It's not a personal choice whether to have children, like deciding whether to have a conservatory done. We are biologically determined to do this, just like as if we were aardvarks or peacocks. We're animals!

You must set your own personal bar extremely low as to how you function and exercise agency as a human.

I presume that, if your DH/DP were off having affairs and going to prostitutes all the time, you would be totally understanding about that? What about if your neighbour walked around naked in the street and pooed on your doorstep each morning, like a cat?

We're all just base animals following our biological impulses, right? No capacity, agency or responsibility to use our immensely superior human brains to function on a higher level than (other) animals and make conscious decisions?

Volhhg · 03/12/2021 13:18

I don't know what the answer is. But I do know that me and my other mum friends from a playgroup are all in the same situation where most jobs are completely out of the question because of the problem of finding childcare over school hols. The kind of level of salary we're all in means we couldn't afford long bouts of sending kids to holiday clubs too. Some people I know we're lucky to have their part time working request agreed but others not. If this pattern is the same all over the UK then that's a lot of women out of the workforce or in stagnant jobs until their children are grown. I think Christmas should definitely be shared, I don't know what the solution is. I'm guessing they have a good system in some Scandinavian country!