Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think parents shouldn't get preferential treatment when it comes to time off work?

993 replies

KwestTurkey · 30/11/2021 22:38

I just read an article on Facebook about this. A parent had asked a childfree colleague if she could have some of her saved holiday days and was refused (understandably).

That's obviously a CF request. But in general, what do you think about parents and holiday requests Vs childfree colleagues?

I don't believe parents should be given priority when it comes to time off on any holiday, be it summer or Christmas etc.. I think it should always, generally, work on a first come first served basis. The amount of times I was refused any sort of time off in the summer because every single parent in the office had booked off the summer and they were given first dibs on those dates used to annoy me.

I'm a parent now but my opinion hasn't changed on that. I think if someone childfree has gotten there with the request before you then that's tough.

Same with Christmas, if you work a job that requires Christmas working, I don't think it's fair to allow the same people off every Christmas year in year out.

It's definitely something I've experienced in my workplace before and after having DC and it feels very unfair.

I really don't think it's anyone elses responsibility to ensure you get time off during school holidays or things like Christmas and that a childfree colleague has as much right to book the time off as any parent.

So...

YANBU - parents shouldn't get preferential treatment or priority when it comes to time off work.

YABU - they should.

OP posts:
Cattipuss · 03/12/2021 19:40

@WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll

There’s a sign by the lifts in my local shopping mall saying “At busy times please give priority to the disabled and families with young children and pushchairs”. The first bit I get but why shouldn’t families with young children and pushchairs wait in line like everyone else?

I don't get that (the families with children bit) either. Like with the annual leave - where there will be enough days for everybody to have their leave, just not all the same or their most preferred days - the lift will be available for everybody who needs it: it's not a case of a parent with a pushchair being unable to get upstairs at all, just that they may have to wait their turn.

I would love this!! But it's sadly not at all true. It's very difficult to get a job like this

I realise that it's not easy, but there are jobs out there. At one stage, I was looking for a PT job and, so that we could work childcare, I could only work on Mondays and Tuesdays. Of course, most of the jobs weren't suitable, and had to be discounted straightaway, but there were a fair few. I didn't apply for any that said '3 days: Mon/Tues/Wed', only to be ready to accept any offers and then say that I couldn't do any Wednesdays, because childcare.

Plenty of people have needs or preferences in employment, or find common requirements of the job that they can't do, and have to dedicate a lot of time to sifting through all of the job sites to find the small number of suitable ones; it's not just parents.

If a job ad says 'must speak fluent Arabic' and you don't speak Arabic at all, you instantly discount that one as a potential; similarly, if it's clear that you must be able to work weekends and/or bank holidays/Christmas etc. and your life circumstances mean you can't commit to that - or even if you could commit to that, but you just don't want to - you ignore that one and keep on scrolling.

Not sure if you're being purposefully obtuse but in any case I'll bite.

If a job ad says 'must speak fluent Arabic' and you don't speak Arabic at all, you instantly discount that one as a potential; similarly, if it's clear that you must be able to work weekends and/or bank holidays/Christmas etc. and your life circumstances mean you can't commit to that - or even if youcouldcommit to that, but you just don'twantto - you ignore that one and keep on scrolling.

Are you suggesting people in roles such as nursing, emergency services etc either leave their jobs once they have children, or even weirder don't train or do these roles in case they have children one day.

SleepingStandingUp · 03/12/2021 19:29

the lift will be available for everybody who needs it: it's not a case of a parent with a pushchair being unable to get upstairs at all, just that they may have to wait their turn the point of those notices or the more blunt ones is use the lift if you NEED it and if you don't NEED it use the stairs. So group of fit 15 year olds or fit couple in their 20s don't NEED the lift. If they don't use it then everyone who does NEED it can use it quicker. Instead of queues of people all waiting to use a lift whilst the empty staircase sits behind them

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 03/12/2021 19:14

There’s a sign by the lifts in my local shopping mall saying “At busy times please give priority to the disabled and families with young children and pushchairs”. The first bit I get but why shouldn’t families with young children and pushchairs wait in line like everyone else?

I don't get that (the families with children bit) either. Like with the annual leave - where there will be enough days for everybody to have their leave, just not all the same or their most preferred days - the lift will be available for everybody who needs it: it's not a case of a parent with a pushchair being unable to get upstairs at all, just that they may have to wait their turn.

I would love this!! But it's sadly not at all true. It's very difficult to get a job like this

I realise that it's not easy, but there are jobs out there. At one stage, I was looking for a PT job and, so that we could work childcare, I could only work on Mondays and Tuesdays. Of course, most of the jobs weren't suitable, and had to be discounted straightaway, but there were a fair few. I didn't apply for any that said '3 days: Mon/Tues/Wed', only to be ready to accept any offers and then say that I couldn't do any Wednesdays, because childcare.

Plenty of people have needs or preferences in employment, or find common requirements of the job that they can't do, and have to dedicate a lot of time to sifting through all of the job sites to find the small number of suitable ones; it's not just parents.

If a job ad says 'must speak fluent Arabic' and you don't speak Arabic at all, you instantly discount that one as a potential; similarly, if it's clear that you must be able to work weekends and/or bank holidays/Christmas etc. and your life circumstances mean you can't commit to that - or even if you could commit to that, but you just don't want to - you ignore that one and keep on scrolling.

LivinginWFHlimbo · 03/12/2021 18:55

@Mellowyellow222

MockneyReject In a circumstance where a single parent had absolutely no family or childcare arrangements for Christmas than I do think they would need to consider whether they were working in the right industry.

By saying it’s impossible for them to work Christmas shifts (I assume for 14 - 15 years) they assuming one or more of their colleagues will cover. That is simply not fair.

I don’t have children. But I do have a family and a life. I am more than happy to pull my weight - and I have on occasions volunteered to cover for colleagues who have small kids. But I resent the sense of entitlement from some parents. If you can’t arrange for childcare then it’s not fair to assume your colleagues have to cover for you.

Well, that often is what people do. I know a former midwife who had to quit when her ex stopped bothering with his overnight contact with their toddler because that then made it impossible for her to work outside hours where you can pay for childcare. What a win that was for a chronically understaffed unit.
PurpleDaisies · 03/12/2021 18:54

Whereas a younger child would be distressed, and the parent would really struggle to concentrate on their work, knowing their child had got up alone, on Xmas Day.

No one is saying children should be left alone on Christmas Day. Most parents who have to work find other options for childcare. I had some lovely Christmas days with my dad of grandparents while mum went to work. That was just the way it was. It wasn’t distressingx

MockneyReject · 03/12/2021 18:50

Mellow - jobcentre/Universal Credit 'work coaches' don't care whether claimants consider care work/hospitality/retail to be the right industry for them!

PeachyPeachTrees · 03/12/2021 18:43

MockneyReject.
You have completely misunderstood!!!
On Christmas Day it is usual that the other parent or grandparents etc are all gathered together so that one person can be at work. I am not saying a child can be left alone and unsupervised. For example my husbands parents were a nurse and policeman and they never both got Christmas day off but 1 had it off and the other had boxing day off and they made it work.
I sadly only have my Dad as my Mum passed this year, but if I couldn't have Christmas day off and neither could my brother, then he would be on his own for Christmas Day and it's going to be the worst Christmas of his life with his wife of 51 years not there.

Cattipuss · 03/12/2021 18:43

@Mellowyellow222

MockneyReject In a circumstance where a single parent had absolutely no family or childcare arrangements for Christmas than I do think they would need to consider whether they were working in the right industry.

By saying it’s impossible for them to work Christmas shifts (I assume for 14 - 15 years) they assuming one or more of their colleagues will cover. That is simply not fair.

I don’t have children. But I do have a family and a life. I am more than happy to pull my weight - and I have on occasions volunteered to cover for colleagues who have small kids. But I resent the sense of entitlement from some parents. If you can’t arrange for childcare then it’s not fair to assume your colleagues have to cover for you.

I mean lots of those industries do have a shortage of staff- care work, nursing etc and I bet shift work being tricky with family life Haa played at least a part in it.
fakereview · 03/12/2021 18:33

I am a parent, and I dont expect people to prioritise my time off, but I will make sure I get in there first and book my time off in school holidays and too bad if the childless parents weren't as organised as me

This is my view too. Once I knew when I wanted to take holiday I would book it immediately so I got in first. It did mean planning a long way ahead, but that's the way of things when you have kids. However, I had an office job so didn't have to work Christmas Day and could often work Christmas Eve at home, way before WFH became a thing.

Mellowyellow222 · 03/12/2021 18:30

MockneyReject In a circumstance where a single parent had absolutely no family or childcare arrangements for Christmas than I do think they would need to consider whether they were working in the right industry.

By saying it’s impossible for them to work Christmas shifts (I assume for 14 - 15 years) they assuming one or more of their colleagues will cover. That is simply not fair.

I don’t have children. But I do have a family and a life. I am more than happy to pull my weight - and I have on occasions volunteered to cover for colleagues who have small kids. But I resent the sense of entitlement from some parents. If you can’t arrange for childcare then it’s not fair to assume your colleagues have to cover for you.

KwestTurkey · 03/12/2021 18:27

A few posters have asked me about my personal circumstances when it comes to childcare, I'm assuming with the implication that I just must not understand how hard it is.

I do. I have DC. I have DC in school, primary and secondary and nursery. I've been there trying to juggle what feels like 100 balls during school holidays, I have actually ended up going self employed to help manage this and it has NOT been easy.

The irony is, I'd actually have more help if my mother, who is willing and would love to help, was allowed the time off during school holidays! People talk about being lucky to have family help. I have a family who help but they do still work themselves and if they can't get the time off then they aren't able to.

This wasn't about whether or not it's hard to cover childcare, I bloody know it is. The point still stands that it's not my childless colleagues problem to fix, they don't have to offer solutions. People have asked repeatedly on this thread what they expect parents to do, I don't know, but it's not up to them to tell us imo.

OP posts:
MockneyReject · 03/12/2021 18:22

Peachy - I'm guessing that your elderly parents would be fine, left on their own (together), while you're at work. Whereas a younger child would be distressed, and the parent would really struggle to concentrate on their work, knowing their child had got up alone, on Xmas Day.

NinjaPig · 03/12/2021 18:19

I'm a parent and I don't get angry if I can get Christmas off, I chose to have children and I chose to work for the NHS, knowing its have to cover these periods.

My brother gets angry on my behalf as he feels I should be allowed the time off — he doesn't understand why I'm so chilled about it

PeachyPeachTrees · 03/12/2021 18:10

While I can see taking half term week off can be because of childcare, I don't think it's the same for Christmas. That's about being together. As a parent, I understand the desire for parents and young children to spend Christmas day together...but what about a childless person in their 50s wanting to spend Christmas with their elderly parents?

PeachyPeachTrees · 03/12/2021 18:06

At my old place of work we had one guy who would book all his holiday first, literaly first day in the office at begining of January. He always got it because of first come first served.
When I spoke to my boss about it, I got nowhere. It really should be one gets xmas one gets Easter and vice versa next year or something to that effect.

AudacityBaby · 03/12/2021 18:05

@Rose40Berry This is comment of the thread.

Rose40Berry · 03/12/2021 17:38

@MuckyPlucky

How old is you DC op? And do you have a partner? When they’re toddlers you can keep them in nursery during parts of the hols but when they’re in infant school you don’t have that luxury.

When you’re a lone parent to primary school kids, and you’ve no family support and there aren’t hol clubs running in the xmas hols what you you expect we do with our children whilst out at work?

I don’t think it’s for individual child free people to give up their Christmas etc to cover for what is actually a lack of state provision (proper holiday clubs). This is a symptom of a fundamental issue with the way we live in the U.K. that can’t be sorted by depending on child free people to sacrifice themselves. I’d be happy to pay a share of my taxes for societal goods like free holiday clubs for those in need who don’t have a support network themselves, but I’m not willing to say that the things that are important to me living a fulfilled life without kids (my choice) like spending Christmas with my friends or even half term going away with my friends and their kids is less important than the life choices of others (including having kids). The solution is to press for a proper social safety net for those who are struggling rather than depending on a system of devaluing the well being of people who haven’t got children by saying we should give up on the celebrations and holidays which matter to us too. Workplaces should have systems to rotate who gets these in demand periods off.
SleepingStandingUp · 03/12/2021 17:00

@randomsabreuse

I'd assume the priority is because the shopping centre don't want to deal with people falling down the stairs, especially not children... Bad for business...
I sure some on MN would be happy to see buggy pushers confined to using the stairs just to reinforce that "back in the day Mothers had to cope with no help!"
randomsabreuse · 03/12/2021 16:56

I'd assume the priority is because the shopping centre don't want to deal with people falling down the stairs, especially not children... Bad for business...

SleepingStandingUp · 03/12/2021 16:53

And it's always a PA way of saying if you don't NEED a lift, use the stairs.

SleepingStandingUp · 03/12/2021 16:52

It’s putting families with young children and pushchairs on the same level of need as people with disabilities, which I don’t think is right. Of course the lift should be available to families with young children and pushchairs but why should they get priority? Why shouldn’t they wait their turn?
In this specific instance someone with a pram and someone in a wheelchair do have the same level of need for the lift though. Yes one of them, it serves them right, they did it to themselves and they should have thought about getting up and down stairs before they were so irresponsible. But if we assume that no one group in a shopping mall is more urgently in need of swapping floors than another, their need IS equal because they can't use the stairs.
Young children arguably can.

Cattipuss · 03/12/2021 16:44

It’s putting families with young children and pushchairs on the same level of need as people with disabilities, which I don’t think is right. Of course the lift should be available to families with young children and pushchairs but why should they get priority? Why shouldn’t they wait their turn?

Because it's not logistically easy to get a pram up and down stairs. It's not about not wanting children to wait, otherwise it would say children under x age, but it specifies in prams because that's what makes it tricky. I suppose if you want to find outrage in anything could equate it to them comparing to disabilities, but that's a reach. Also doubtful they enforce it with an iron fist, more just a courteous request.

Mrsmch123 · 03/12/2021 16:31

It used to really bug me when people at work would try and get out of working Christmas with the line ohh but I have children! Well I had family that I wanted to spend Christmas with so I never understood why their wants trumped mine?now I have a baby and still feel the same. I will either work every other Christmas or change to a Monday to Friday job.

MuckyPlucky · 03/12/2021 16:11

How old is you DC op? And do you have a partner?
When they’re toddlers you can keep them in nursery during parts of the hols but when they’re in infant school you don’t have that luxury.

When you’re a lone parent to primary school kids, and you’ve no family support and there aren’t hol clubs running in the xmas hols what you you expect we do with our children whilst out at work?

CounsellorTroi · 03/12/2021 15:44

@HardbackWriter

There’s a sign by the lifts in my local shopping mall saying “At busy times please give priority to the disabled and families with young children and pushchairs”. The first bit I get but why shouldn’t families with young children and pushchairs wait in line like everyone else?

Isn't that just saying 'let people who can't use the stairs go first', which doesn't seem unreasonable?

It’s putting families with young children and pushchairs on the same level of need as people with disabilities, which I don’t think is right. Of course the lift should be available to families with young children and pushchairs but why should they get priority? Why shouldn’t they wait their turn?