Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think parents shouldn't get preferential treatment when it comes to time off work?

993 replies

KwestTurkey · 30/11/2021 22:38

I just read an article on Facebook about this. A parent had asked a childfree colleague if she could have some of her saved holiday days and was refused (understandably).

That's obviously a CF request. But in general, what do you think about parents and holiday requests Vs childfree colleagues?

I don't believe parents should be given priority when it comes to time off on any holiday, be it summer or Christmas etc.. I think it should always, generally, work on a first come first served basis. The amount of times I was refused any sort of time off in the summer because every single parent in the office had booked off the summer and they were given first dibs on those dates used to annoy me.

I'm a parent now but my opinion hasn't changed on that. I think if someone childfree has gotten there with the request before you then that's tough.

Same with Christmas, if you work a job that requires Christmas working, I don't think it's fair to allow the same people off every Christmas year in year out.

It's definitely something I've experienced in my workplace before and after having DC and it feels very unfair.

I really don't think it's anyone elses responsibility to ensure you get time off during school holidays or things like Christmas and that a childfree colleague has as much right to book the time off as any parent.

So...

YANBU - parents shouldn't get preferential treatment or priority when it comes to time off work.

YABU - they should.

OP posts:
DockOTheBay · 01/12/2021 00:53

The school holidays are basically the whole summer, by the time schools go back in Sept, the nights are drawing in

What about the first 3 weeks of May, all of June and 80% off July. Most years the weather is much nicer in June and July than August anyway

Dasher789 · 01/12/2021 00:48

I don't think it should be an actual rule that parents get preferential treatment but on the whole I'd hope most people were flexible. I'm not taking time off this Xmas to let others in my team with kids have the whole week off. When I was a child I liked to have my parents around over Xmas. If I had something on then fair enough a bit of flexibility both ways but I don't want to stand in the way of a family Christmas to watch re runs of Jingle all the Way every day Grin

ruinedalready · 01/12/2021 00:47

I hate when people think they have more dibs than others with holidays.
I used to work every Xmas day and it really annoyed me as I still had family! Just because I didn't have children at the time didnt mean I wanted to spend year after year alone Xmas night.
Now when taking leave I try to be as fair as possible when requesting even though it's kinda my turn to be the asshole 🤣

amusedbush · 01/12/2021 00:47

But what I don't understand is why people without kids would want to take holiday when the kids are off! I'd be avoiding it like the plague

I don't have children but I've worked in a university for the last ten years, which is very restrictive. I can't take time off in September or most of October, then there's exams in December. Semester starts again in mid-January so that's hectic, then exams in April and May, exam boards in June, resits and the corresponding exam board in August, then it all starts again in September.

That leaves me the option of going on my main holiday in November, February or July. Add in the fact that DH's work operates a rota system for annual leave (whereby you move up your group of ten people each year until you get first choice of the weeks, then you go back to the bottom of the list) and it's slim pickings.

PyongyangKipperbang · 01/12/2021 00:36

As a parent who had only had the last 2 Xmas days off thanks to Covid and redundancy I do not understand the concept of parental preference!

But I agree. My DD works in the NHS and its her turn to have Xmas day off and got told "but as you havent got kids we put you on anway" and got no end of shit when she said no.

As for summers off, well when my lot have all finally buggered off I shall do what my best friends do and sod off to somewhere hot in the winter for a month each year! Summer holidays are for those who have no choice imo

BashfulClam · 01/12/2021 00:30

Everyone should be treated fairly in the workplace. Childcare is not the responsibility of your colleagues or employer to manage for you. I had a colleague ask me to cancel my wedding as she had a childcare issue…my fucking wedding! I was off circa week but we were eloping so hadn’t told bc anyone. After being badgered by her fid 2 weeks I finally had to tell her ‘I will be 3 hours away from home, I’ve actually booked my wedding for that day!’ She then said ‘well can you cancel’ when I said no it is my WEDDING and bc everything was booked, paid and arranged she still saif ‘I’m sure you could shuffle it around a bit..,’

ViolinAndGuitar · 01/12/2021 00:30

I’m a parent and YANBU. Holidays should be on first come first serve basis.

Grayskelly · 01/12/2021 00:28

@BiBabbles that sounds like a nightmare. What happens if you have DC at different schools? The 9/3 +5 schedule means you'd be spending more than a third of your year on holiday too. In Australia it's 10/2 + 5.
I really don't see how this would solve anything.

VioletRose91 · 01/12/2021 00:25

Should be first come first serve.

Just because someone’s not a parent doesn’t mean they don’t have other commitments in their personal lives.

BiBabbles · 01/12/2021 00:21

I don't think parents should have automatic priority and I find the whole 'but Christmas is about children/you wouldn't understand' rude to others, but I also think caring responsibilities and wider social needs and issues need to be considered particularly around this time of year.

My spouse has had the most time off for caring for other relatives and some of the people he works with are caring for parents. It's very difficult to get most types of care in late December to early January. I think that has to be considered, ethically. It's part of my why my spouse has worked the last 7 Christmases and has already put himself forward for it this year - we can cover if either or both of us work that time & we know others who value Christmas far more than we do (which is not at all) can't, whether they chose to be in the position or not, that's their reality now of needing to consider that care now.

However, some schools here in the USA (and not nearly enough of them, in my opinion) have started going year round. They go six weeks, then have two weeks off. After some initial mumbling and grumbling, parents found it easier to schedule holidays, and opened up things for them that they could never do before, such as skiing trips and such.

I went to a year round elementary school in the US, though it was 9 weeks on, 3 weeks off with 5 in the summer, and yeah - those breaks were delightful, if only for seeing older relatives without my cousins around. I've read mixed opinions in terms of learning, but it's interesting to read it's getting more popular - that school district had a lot of experimental things going on, some that's taken off and some that's been quietly replaced since.

Grayskelly · 01/12/2021 00:20

@Ylvamoon seriously? Grow up.

If my DC is in a caring profession they should refuse to care for childless people because no one covered for their mum on school holidays?

We have DC because we want to, not to provide services to future old people on a quid pro quo basis.

Summerfun54321 · 01/12/2021 00:18

I think the rigid structure of set term times and holidays is just shit for everyone. Everyone with kids rushing to have a holiday in only certain weeks of the year, with astronomical holiday prices where you’re surrounded by millions of other families and kids. If there was more flexibility for everyone, there would be a lot less competition for holiday approval at work.

Bellie710 · 01/12/2021 00:14

If I didn't have children I would never book time off in school holidays. The prices are ridiculous especally in England! Personally I would let parents have the summer/easter etc but Xmas is slightly different as most people want that off.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 01/12/2021 00:08

@KwestTurkey

Unless you’re lucky enough to have a retired grandparent who is happy & capable to look after the children, what is the alternative?

Well put very bluntly, it was your decision to have children, not your colleagues.

Which is exactly the sort of response I got from people when I needed time off work to actually look after my children because the childminders took the Christmas week off and there weren't any holiday clubs.

I only ever requested a couple of days before Christmas, thinking that as I was available for the rest of the time (the ex would take them on condition I gave up Christmas day from 9am until New Year's Eve when he wanted to go out), it wouldn't be too much to ask - but it was an outright 'we don't give parents time at Christmas because it's not fair on those of us who don't have children'. Naturally as it was NHS, this bit was never written down, it was always refused on the grounds of need. But the need was that all but the other member of staff who had children were off on holiday/having Christmas with their Mum.

Never did get a holiday with my children, either. Not once in the 10 years, as I couldn't take them out of school and wasn't allowed leave in the holidays.

It did feel pretty shit, but they seemed to enjoy their time off whilst we sat in empty departments with no patients or medical staff, just waiting for the phone to ring, which it never did, because there wasn't any clinics running.

Hawkins001 · 01/12/2021 00:05

Just noticed your user name too, @EgonSpengler2020 what's your view on the new film ?

Ylvamoon · 01/12/2021 00:04

Great, I hope none of you need the next generation for any kind of service... no nursing in old age, no tax payments to support your health care & pensions, no delivery driversfor your online shopping, to name a few things you might need or simply want.

Naturally parents want to spend time with their children... best time for that is during school holidays. So while I agree holidays should be first come first served, in some circumstances parents should have preferential treatment. Especially if there isn't any childcare available like at Christmas and Easter bank holidays.

Hawkins001 · 01/12/2021 00:04

@EgonSpengler2020

I'm a paramedic and the fairest system I've come across for summer holidays was 13 people on rota, 2 allowed off at any time, 6 weeks summer holiday, names would get drawn out of a hat, and assigned a week each, so one person each year would not get a week during the summer holidays. It then got put on the noticeboard for a period of time so that we could negotiate and do any swaps before being finalised. Generally if someone with kids landed the week outside the school holidays, someone without kids would swap (it's a tourist area, so being off in September is better if you don't have kids).

Sometime childfree staff would give up their week completely to a colleague with childcare issues, but there was never any pressure to do so. I think once a fair and transparent system is in place, staff are more inclined to help each other out.

Christmas on the other hand..... It's an annual battleground!!

The last bit about Christmas being a battle ground, suddenly the theme mortal kombat came to mind.
RobertaFirmino · 30/11/2021 23:56

I had an issue around ten years ago - I didn't get any time off over Christmas but I had covered a few shifts for a colleague to help him out with Ramadan and Eid. He ended up having a few days off rota over Christmas and immediately offered to cover some of my shifts. Well, the murders it caused! He was called all sorts for not offering to cover a childed colleague, I was called all sorts for refusing to let this colleague have the free time instead of me. It's worth pointing out that my Dad was dying at the time! Moral of the story? Never give in and always do favours for colleagues of different religions.

IWouldntHavetoWorkatAll · 30/11/2021 23:53

YANBU. My life is not less important because I don’t have children.

Absolutely.

But what I don't understand is why people without kids would want to take holiday when the kids are off! I'd be avoiding it like the plague

My family don’t live near me so if I didn’t take a decent chunk of holiday off over Christmas I’d be spending it in my house on my own. I need the holiday so I can go and stay with them and as there’s no trains on Boxing Day I wouldn’t be able to get back in time to work or spend a decent amount of time.

I have always been a bit worried that preference would be given to those with children but fortunately that’s never happened. If anything I think at least a parent could have a partner or family or at worst pay someone to look after their children and they would still get to see them at the end of each day. Whereas I would literally have to spend the whole Christmas holiday period on my own. Boo hoo poor me !

MiddleParking · 30/11/2021 23:51

*I once had someone work for me like this, always getting in first and booking the best dates (including Christmas) on the first day the coming years holiday system opened.

He wasn't happy when I told him it didn't work like that and we had to be fair to everyone and allow people the same chance to take Christmas off.*

But surely that is how it works if you have a holiday system that ‘opens’ on a certain day? That’s the downside of a first come first served system, if you’re not the first to come you’re not the first served.

I think it should be allocated fairly and decently rather than FCFS - in my work we can mostly all be off at Christmas but we need one person working remotely on each of the non-bank holiday days (nothing proactive, just keeping an eye), and we generally just discuss our Christmas plans as a team and work out who can cover when. I’m one of the only ones with young children currently but I’m also on the management team, so I’d be first in line to volunteer to be on duty at Christmas because I get paid more/am more responsible for things being covered than my direct reports. Admittedly it’s easier with remote working, hopefully the new prevalence of that will help lots of people cover Christmas where they’d have struggled before. My other team member with young DC is Muslim but I don’t think she’s any keener to work at Christmas for that - it’s still the only time you get a decent cluster of bank holidays that might allow you to see family further afield and so on (also, she seems wildly excited for Christmas anyway! I think most people enjoy it as a secular celebration these days.)

timeisnotaline · 30/11/2021 23:45

I’m not in the uk so Xmas = summer I should say!

timeisnotaline · 30/11/2021 23:44

@Coldilox

Glassofshloer people don’t need to not have babies, they just need to organise and pay for childcare. It’s what most working parents do.
Well sure. We do. No idea what you’re supposed to do at Christmas though or early January. I have my younger child in childcare for reliability compared to a nanny. They shut for almost 3 weeks over Christmas. My older child is at holiday programs, but these don’t take 3 year olds. It’s not parents fault the system is designed on the basis that they will have time off at this point in the year and if they don’t there are options. I’ve put out queries to find a nanny to cover it for a few days between dh & I taking some leave. Not everyone can pay for that, and I haven’t found one yet!
Hawkins001 · 30/11/2021 23:40

Reading with intrigue

CreamFirstThenJamOnTop · 30/11/2021 23:39

I don’t think parents should get preferential treatment but nor does first come first serve always seem fair.

I didn’t mind working Christmas Day etc when I didn’t have kids if somebody really wanted it off with their kids. I definitely prefer not working Christmas Day but if I am then I just get on with it and don’t assume I have any more right to be off than anyone else

Mamanyt · 30/11/2021 23:36

Once my kids were grown, I volunteered to work EITHER Christmas Eve or Christmas day each year. I garnered a lot of good will doing that.

Summer holidays are a bit different, and yes, EVERYone wants off in a short period of time. For those with children, it is the ONLY time to book a holiday, so there is that. However, some schools here in the USA (and not nearly enough of them, in my opinion) have started going year round. They go six weeks, then have two weeks off. After some initial mumbling and grumbling, parents found it easier to schedule holidays, and opened up things for them that they could never do before, such as skiing trips and such.