Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think parents shouldn't get preferential treatment when it comes to time off work?

993 replies

KwestTurkey · 30/11/2021 22:38

I just read an article on Facebook about this. A parent had asked a childfree colleague if she could have some of her saved holiday days and was refused (understandably).

That's obviously a CF request. But in general, what do you think about parents and holiday requests Vs childfree colleagues?

I don't believe parents should be given priority when it comes to time off on any holiday, be it summer or Christmas etc.. I think it should always, generally, work on a first come first served basis. The amount of times I was refused any sort of time off in the summer because every single parent in the office had booked off the summer and they were given first dibs on those dates used to annoy me.

I'm a parent now but my opinion hasn't changed on that. I think if someone childfree has gotten there with the request before you then that's tough.

Same with Christmas, if you work a job that requires Christmas working, I don't think it's fair to allow the same people off every Christmas year in year out.

It's definitely something I've experienced in my workplace before and after having DC and it feels very unfair.

I really don't think it's anyone elses responsibility to ensure you get time off during school holidays or things like Christmas and that a childfree colleague has as much right to book the time off as any parent.

So...

YANBU - parents shouldn't get preferential treatment or priority when it comes to time off work.

YABU - they should.

OP posts:
randomsabreuse · 01/12/2021 10:20

DH works in a field where Christmas Day and weekend working is an unavoidable thing. Totally stuffs up my ability to work in certain sectors because we don't have local family (and grandparents are too old and now too paranoid about Covid to be remotely reliable for even occasional planned weekends).

Either way the rota for Christmas in his industry is generally shared depending on different needs/ wants of those involved. Generally younger single people working away from parental homes want a decent chunk of time to travel home which might not necessarily be actual Christmas itself but sometime in the festive period - travelling on peak sucks... Older people with local family (or big houses) wanted to work scattered individual days over the festive period (and might just invent call outs to escape the in-laws for an hour or 2...)

SerendipitySunshine · 01/12/2021 10:20

I spent years working for a manager who insisted that Christmas was for families, and those of us without kids were put down to work all over Christmas Day, Boxing Day and the days between off, but given New Years' Eve and Day off, with the idea that when we had kids it would be our turn. When some of us had kids, she changed departments and our turn never came!

Mellowyellow222 · 01/12/2021 10:19

@BeardyButton

The responses on this thread are so sad. Shows how little regard chn are held in the UK.
That’s an interesting perspective. It’s not how I see it.

We should have good quality affordable childcare which is accessible to working parents. I don’t think anyone on this thread has argued against that.

If people work in an industry where working over holidays is expected it’s unfair for them to not do their fair share simply because they have children. We are all paid the same to work the same hours.

Employers should absolutely be flexible where they can, and many people including myself will offer to cover to allow parents time at Christmas. But it’s not fair that non parents should take on extra burdens in the work place to allow parents extra time off.

We absolutely need to have better childcare available - that is the answer. Not expecting others to work extra hours to cover.

IntermittentParps · 01/12/2021 10:19

@BeardyButton

I don’t care about the parents. It’s not the parents that are getting preferential treatment. It’s the children!!!!!

Children in some societies do better than in others. Some societies are more focused on child well being. This generally means - investment in education, child care, shared parental leave etc.

But in other societies, children are not the focus. So you get under investment in the above.

When it comes to this thread.... imagine not thinking from a child’s point of view about parents holidays during school holidays. Of course, parents should get priority - chn deserve to spend time with parents. We should work for a society that supports that time.

Won't someone think of the children...

We should work for a society that supports EVERYONE as fairly as possible.
Would you really say 'Of course, parents should get priority' to someone who has been unable to have, or has lost, children?

IntermittentParps · 01/12/2021 10:17

if you didn't have kids, why would you want to have holidays in the school hols when everything is more expensive and crowded?

I think where holidays have to be carefully scheduled and allocated to employees then its good/nice to allocate the school holiday time to parents, and those without children allocated to non holiday time. Can't imagine many people would be unhappy about this anyway - I'd much rather go on a child free holiday outside of school holiday time!
Several posters have explained their reasons as to why this assumption should not be made.

Wexone · 01/12/2021 10:16

Totally agree. It should be on a fairly based rota. Who works last year should get this year off etc. I don't have children( can't have them) but one year we decided to do a huge xmas everyone come to our house. I booked my holidays early as the way it was in my workplace - xmas eve was one of them. Got pulled in two days before xmas eve asking can i come in as the lovely whatsherface who covered when i was off wanted the time off and that as she had children my boss said she got preferential over me. I lost it with him , i had 40 people coming for dinner xmas day and had asked for xmas eve off so i could prepare for it along with my partner. And that i had put my holiday request in time and it had been approved. Even more annoying she didn't come to me to talk about it (which we would have come to a compromise) she went straight to the boss with wheepy tears etc There was no reasoning with them and i ended coming in for half the day xmas eve. Shortly in the new year i found a new job and handed in my notice, explained to HR that this was one of the reasons i was leaving. They didn't value that i needed time off as does everyone else. I now work for a company that shuts down for two weeks in summer and a week at xmas so there is no issue with cover required etc. No issues when i want to take time of either - just make sure my work is done which is fair enough in my opinion

BackInBlackAgain · 01/12/2021 10:12

I have never worked anywhere that gives parents preferential treatment, its always first come first served.

BeardyButton · 01/12/2021 10:08

The responses on this thread are so sad. Shows how little regard chn are held in the UK.

Sittingonabench · 01/12/2021 10:05

Having children is a choice - no one is forced to have to have them and when making that decision factors such as childcare, working and likely holidays would/should be discussed. Yes circumstances change for everyone but that is not your employers responsibility. It’s interesting that people would be up in arms if asked at interview about whether they have kids and their childcare (me included) as they feel they would be discriminated against but once in post expect the manager to give them priority due to childcare needs. As a rule - parents should not have priority. First come first served is a good general practice except at Christmas, Easter etc. Where a rota works best. As for keeping women in the workplace - while I agree this needs further thought (and my own experience is challenging in this regard), priority over annual leave would not help in the long term as the child-free would leave to somewhere they could actually have a Christmas off and so there would be an even bigger divide. Child free people pay taxes to educate and support children, they also pay into their own pensions and will pay (have paid) for the services they need in old age. People don’t have kids for the benefit of society, that have kids because they want them and that comes with consequences (which is why some people choose not to have them).

BeardyButton · 01/12/2021 10:04

I don’t care about the parents. It’s not the parents that are getting preferential treatment. It’s the children!!!!!

Children in some societies do better than in others. Some societies are more focused on child well being. This generally means - investment in education, child care, shared parental leave etc.

But in other societies, children are not the focus. So you get under investment in the above.

When it comes to this thread.... imagine not thinking from a child’s point of view about parents holidays during school holidays. Of course, parents should get priority - chn deserve to spend time with parents. We should work for a society that supports that time.

Mellowyellow222 · 01/12/2021 10:02

I don’t have kids. But I go on holiday with family members including children.

I have spent the last two years being told how lucky I am that I don’t have to home school, so lucky me I got to work 18 hour days to cover for people who were gone schooling.

I know it wasn’t their fault but now the kids are back at school I am still covering because they need to nip out for half an hour twice a day to do the school run.

Working from home saves parents a fortune on child care and I think it’s great people are getting a better work life balance. But you can’t work and care for young children.

There is a balance to be struck, and childless/free and parents both need to understand life from each other’s perspectives.

Employers also should ensure that everyone is treated equally and the flexibility offered to parents is also extended to non parents. We all have personal lives

monotonousmum · 01/12/2021 10:01

I think where holidays have to be carefully scheduled and allocated to employees then its good/nice to allocate the school holiday time to parents, and those without children allocated to non holiday time. Can't imagine many people would be unhappy about this anyway - I'd much rather go on a child free holiday outside of school holiday time!

But...if someone requests time off during school holidays it shouldn't be denied based on whether or not they have kids.

I'm a manager and would never deny a request based on whether someone was a parent or not. My team have to be 'available' to work every other Christmas, but we only need a couple of staff to cover that week so it's likely most people can get every Christmas off if they want to.
School holidays...its mostly those with kids that book this time, and those that haven't its usually just long weekends etc.

What I've seen though (other companies/departments) is those without kids complaining they can't get any time off during holidays because it's all been booked by parents already. Never come across a company that refuses requests where the dates haven't already been booked.

randomsabreuse · 01/12/2021 10:01

Weather is generally better in June/early July rather than English school holidays... so pre kids we definitely didn't want school holidays off... Also very much like late/early season holidays to the med/canaries over peak season (way too hot for me in August!).

I'd have the most sympathy about time between Christmas and New Year as most childcare is closed and would expect a couple to share those days so both would need some time off - obviously an issue for single parents though.

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 01/12/2021 09:55

Personally dh and I were only too pleased when we could finally take leave and go away outside school holidays - fewer crowds and cheaper!

KwestTurkey · 01/12/2021 09:54

@Rhythmisadancer

There's usually a bit of a balance because if you didn't have kids, why would you want to have holidays in the school hols when everything is more expensive and crowded? It's not as if the whole summer is a no no for non-parents, but it would be odd to looking for a fortnight to spend with other people's young families. But at Xmas everyone wants the time off. I'd work round a colleague who had little "Christmas aged" kids if i could
People have given several examples of why.
OP posts:
KwestTurkey · 01/12/2021 09:53

You know I genuinely don't mind and didn't mind when I was childfree covering when someone had a genuine childcare issue.

But what I can't stand, and has been said already on this thread, is the whole "oh but Christmas is so special for the children especially years 1-10, you don't want to miss that".

I think that's bullshit, and no I don't think a parent should get 9 years of Christmas leave over someone else because they don't want to miss their children's Christmas. A childfree colleague may not want to miss their Christmas with their family. Neither is more important.

So if someone came to be genuinely stuck for childcare I'd probably agree, if someone came to me with this "oh but it's more special with children" crap I'd say sorry nope.

OP posts:
Rhythmisadancer · 01/12/2021 09:53

There's usually a bit of a balance because if you didn't have kids, why would you want to have holidays in the school hols when everything is more expensive and crowded? It's not as if the whole summer is a no no for non-parents, but it would be odd to looking for a fortnight to spend with other people's young families.
But at Xmas everyone wants the time off. I'd work round a colleague who had little "Christmas aged" kids if i could

ClaudiaJ1 · 01/12/2021 09:51

@VashtaNerada

I also find the reasoning “well you chose to have children” laughable. Reproduction is a fairly basic part of humanity, and without it the species is fucked. It’s not like it’s some mad hobby a few of us have chosen on a whim. We’ll all need the next generation when we’re old FFS!
Really @VashtaNerada our species is not going to die out anytime soon! In fact, if we skip a generation or so it would be good for the planet. We are over-populated as it is. I'd like to see an encouragement for people get get sterilised or not procreate for say 20 years, to get the population level considerably down. And less people means less demand for resources. Many of our problems would sort themselves out if we skipped breeding for a generation at least.
IntermittentParps · 01/12/2021 09:51

But other the times of the year such as the summer hols it’s nice toe show a bit of courtesy… Non parents have a good few months of nice weather to choose from.
I'm imagining someone telling my several friends who are involuntarily without children (due to being long-term single/fertility issues/multiple MCs etc) to 'show a bit of courtesy' if they suggest they'd like summer holiday time off...

And as for non parents, we have lives and people in them too. What if I need a specific time because of my or my DP's work? Or because a friend/family member I'm taking holiday to see only has that time available or I'm attending a wedding/christening/memorial? Should I just 'choose' not to see them and to go away at some other time and oh, it's OK because it's nice weather? Hmm

arootintootingoodtime · 01/12/2021 09:49

I was made to work five Christmas's in a row in my previous position. My family is all a flight away and we only got Christmas day as a bank holiday. I was also the last one to be approved for a week's leave in August, when my DH has an enforced two weeks off when the factory shuts.

I was explicitly told "Well, you don't have children so you're not a priority".

I am unable to have children.

PrincessPaws · 01/12/2021 09:49

@Darkpheonix

The problem is working in small organisations where it matters who gets leave when. If people have a major problem with it they should go to a larger employer and problem solved.

Well yes, if you can't organise childcare while you work, you do need to look for another job. Not expect colleagues to even it out.

And employers won't be held over a barrel by parents threatening unpaid leave. You do realise unpaid leave isn't an endless well you can pull from, don't you.

Also unpaid leave has to be approved, and can be declined
bumblingbovine49 · 01/12/2021 09:49

@JazzyBBG

Hmmm on the fence here as a parent, you have to accept to a degree that people will want that time off at certain ages. Equally as someone who pays for a lot of childcare in holidays it shouldn't be all the time. But what I don't understand is why people without kids would want to take holiday when the kids are off! I'd be avoiding it like the plague ;)
Well I used to want time off in the school holidays before I had my own child because my sister died and my BIL appreciated the help with my niece and nephew during the holidays which I always gave. I also used to help my parents at their house when they had the DNs to stay and also and spend time abroad with them all to help out.

I spent ten years having holidays in the school holidays before having children. Then I had my own children so I've never really had a time in my working life when I haven't wanted/needed to take most of my leave during school holidays.

I haven't always been able to have the leave when I wanted it but I didn't feel like my need was less before I had children.

Nomorefuckstogive · 01/12/2021 09:44

Definitely shouldn’t be taken for granted. You’re lucky if you have easygoing colleagues that don’t mind working school holidays. If I were child free, I’d be happy to take time off in September, rather than August. Christmas, again, depends on individuals.

ExConstance · 01/12/2021 09:42

One of the few) good things about where I work is tat we have a very diverse workforce, particularly in relation to age - 20's up to 70's. We don't have any problems with holidays and Christmas/new year as everyone wants different things in relation to leave. The older ones like a bit of winter sun, the parents want school holidays and the rest of us want anything but the school holidays. Christmas and new year are on a strict rota and if it is your turn you work it, though usually people can work fewer hours ( less demand) and still earn the same due to double time. Maybe greater diversity in the work place is the answer. I'd certainly not want to work anywhere that parents got priority for leave, I've two grown up sons myself and would never have asked for this, we always managed to cobble together a plan that just about worked with a combination of odd bits of leave, one granny and a student in an au pair type role some summers.

AvocadoOrange · 01/12/2021 09:42

I don't think preferential treatment is fair, but at the same time maybe the answer is to try and change working practices and culture? Some parents book time off because they don't have childcare - and saying 'well it's their choice to have children so tough' isn't exactly being friendly to working parents - is it? But also people who don't have children should be able to get time off in summer too.

When my child goes to school I would want to have time off during the holidays to spend time with him. I don't think that should mean that none of my childfree colleagues should ever be able to get the same time off- but I'd be upset if I couldn't get some of it. Life is not just about work.
Luckily most of my colleagues don't have children (so far) so if I am in the same job I don't think it will be a major issue- oh and no one works over Christmas.

Swipe left for the next trending thread