Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think parents shouldn't get preferential treatment when it comes to time off work?

993 replies

KwestTurkey · 30/11/2021 22:38

I just read an article on Facebook about this. A parent had asked a childfree colleague if she could have some of her saved holiday days and was refused (understandably).

That's obviously a CF request. But in general, what do you think about parents and holiday requests Vs childfree colleagues?

I don't believe parents should be given priority when it comes to time off on any holiday, be it summer or Christmas etc.. I think it should always, generally, work on a first come first served basis. The amount of times I was refused any sort of time off in the summer because every single parent in the office had booked off the summer and they were given first dibs on those dates used to annoy me.

I'm a parent now but my opinion hasn't changed on that. I think if someone childfree has gotten there with the request before you then that's tough.

Same with Christmas, if you work a job that requires Christmas working, I don't think it's fair to allow the same people off every Christmas year in year out.

It's definitely something I've experienced in my workplace before and after having DC and it feels very unfair.

I really don't think it's anyone elses responsibility to ensure you get time off during school holidays or things like Christmas and that a childfree colleague has as much right to book the time off as any parent.

So...

YANBU - parents shouldn't get preferential treatment or priority when it comes to time off work.

YABU - they should.

OP posts:
Hoolahupsaresquare · 01/12/2021 12:54

The thing is - with it not being the problem of those without children problem - the onus is not on them to find a solution - it is on those who decided to have them either as individuals or via societal change. Oh

RealBecca · 01/12/2021 12:48

Firstly the article was based on USA where there is far less paid leave.

Most parents taking the whole summer off are taking it unpaid and every year - not as annual leave. Employers are well aware of term times and annual leave is always granted based on business needs. So get on to the employer about reducing clients over that period or employing more staff.

Actual annual leave shouldnt be granted based on whether people have children. But in America the article implies there isnt parental leave as well as holiday leave.

If people want every summer off, even those without kids, you can ask your employer to reduce your hours.

Noone who has kids actually wants six bloody weeks off in a row with them so petition your employer for subsidised childcare.

If there is no other childcare, i apreciate it "isnt your problem" but what is your solution? A non-working parent in each house for 16 years? Are you going to pay extra tax for that? Part time employees pay a good wedge, what % of tax increase would be needed for it? Or would you rather only the wealthy breed?

Hoolahupsaresquare · 01/12/2021 12:48

Ofcourse they shouldn’t. People who don’t have children have lives too. They may have caring responsibilities, animals, personal issues that you may not be aware of, Heath conditions or they may simply not want to have to facilitate other people’s life choices - and there is no reason why they should.
Confused

Slothkin · 01/12/2021 12:43

One company I worked for didn’t give bank holidays automatically, so it was much much easier to amicably sort out cover within the team without the Christmas/New Year bunfight. I didn’t have kids so I used to cover easter and the summer hols for the other team members then have my main holiday over Christmas to visit family abroad and they sorted those days between them. That was a really lovely team though.

NorthSouthcatlady · 01/12/2021 12:41

@Kanaloa the problem is people don’t want to recognise that they have made choices. They act like they just woke up and had no input or influence into anything Confused Then try to make it someone else’s problem, in this instance their colleagues or managers

Toomanyradishes · 01/12/2021 12:34

I will and have swapped when someone is desperate but I refuse to never have time off at christmas or in the summer due to a congenital issue which means I cant have children. I am worthy of celebrating christmas and having a summer too

I have been less of a doormat since I was slagged off by a colleague for daring to take 3 days off in the entire summer holiday, to travel to a funeral and back, apparently thats far less worthy of time off than ability to have unprotected sex

Plus you know that family childcare thats needed? Thats me over there in the corner doing childcare for a family member who cant get enough time off in the holidays whilst simultaneously being bitched at by collegues because I dont understand how hard it is to find childcare

Tink626 · 01/12/2021 12:31

It's a tricky one. I have to have Christmas week off as I am a lone parent, and no holiday clubs or childminders are open and I've no family. Luckily I'm in a standalone role so this hasn't been a problem in my current role, but if I couldn't take that time off I would be absolutely stuck.

AudacityBaby · 01/12/2021 12:28

@zafferana

I think a good boss will be flexible on this and yes, prioritise workers who need to be off at this time because they have small DC and/or childcare issues. Those without DC can take holidays at other times of the year and many workplaces are closed on Christmas/Boxing day so it's not like those without DC never get to be with their families at Christmas. I think we all need to be considerate and kind and face the fact that most people do have DC at some time in their lives, so if 20-somethings are fed up of working around Christmas, their time will come.
OK. How are you as a parent who is prioritised going to be considerate and kind to your colleagues?

Genuine question.

Because in addition to having priority for annual leave at any time of year in which childcare issues might arise, my colleagues who are parents are also using flexi-time to do the school run twice a day, refusing to work outside of 9-5, refusing to work weekends, and refusing to provide any kind of emergency cover. All on the basis that the workplace needs to be kind, considerable and flexible to them.

They are doing absolutely no giving whatsoever.

So whenever parents use the kindness buzzword, what I hear is: I need to get everything I need, because I have kids, and you need to be kind and give way to me.

And don't say that kindness means it'll be my turn one day - I'm infertile.

slashlover · 01/12/2021 12:21

@zafferana

I think a good boss will be flexible on this and yes, prioritise workers who need to be off at this time because they have small DC and/or childcare issues. Those without DC can take holidays at other times of the year and many workplaces are closed on Christmas/Boxing day so it's not like those without DC never get to be with their families at Christmas. I think we all need to be considerate and kind and face the fact that most people do have DC at some time in their lives, so if 20-somethings are fed up of working around Christmas, their time will come.
I'm 43, I've never had kids so when would my time come?
Kanaloa · 01/12/2021 12:17

@zafferana

I think a good boss will be flexible on this and yes, prioritise workers who need to be off at this time because they have small DC and/or childcare issues. Those without DC can take holidays at other times of the year and many workplaces are closed on Christmas/Boxing day so it's not like those without DC never get to be with their families at Christmas. I think we all need to be considerate and kind and face the fact that most people do have DC at some time in their lives, so if 20-somethings are fed up of working around Christmas, their time will come.
And those whose time don’t come? Who can’t have children, or don’t for any reason?

They should just work every Christmas to cover for those who have kids?

Kanaloa · 01/12/2021 12:16

[quote RedWingBoots]@Kanaloa the nursery my DD goes to shuts for 2 weeks over Christmas exactly following the school holidays. Her CM also closes over Christmas but doesn't follow the school holidays.

We both take time off over Christmas anyway, but luckily have family and friends who could look after her if we couldn't. School is going to be more of a problem as half-term dates vary around the country.[/quote]
But you chose that nursery and that childminder. You knew you had to work at that time and chose a nursery and childminder that didn’t provide the childcare you need.

That’s the issue. People making choices (taking certain jobs, choosing certain childcare) that don’t fit their lifestyle, then expecting that colleagues should of course pick up the slack for them.

I have kids myself so I’m not oblivious to how hard it is to juggle work and childcare. It’s very hard indeed, but it’s not my colleagues fault.

IntermittentParps · 01/12/2021 12:15

@zafferana

I think a good boss will be flexible on this and yes, prioritise workers who need to be off at this time because they have small DC and/or childcare issues. Those without DC can take holidays at other times of the year and many workplaces are closed on Christmas/Boxing day so it's not like those without DC never get to be with their families at Christmas. I think we all need to be considerate and kind and face the fact that most people do have DC at some time in their lives, so if 20-somethings are fed up of working around Christmas, their time will come.
Those without DC can take holidays at other times of the year Have you not read or not understood the many posts pointing out why people can't always do so? Or are you deliberately ignoring them?

if 20-somethings are fed up of working around Christmas, their time will come.
How about people whose time hasn't come and won't come because their partner died/they are single long-term/they are not able to have children?

IntermittentParps · 01/12/2021 12:13

@FateHasRedesignedMost

I think it’s sensible to give priority to parents of young children in school holidays. Most parents use a combination of holiday clubs, childminders and annual leave to cover holidays and half terms, why shouldn’t they take some annual leave to spend time with their children? It’s hard enough working FT and managing a young family without being told you can’t use some of your leave in school holidays.

Other parents may not be able to afford full childcare fees the entire school holiday and end up leaving their job. Bosses have to be sympathetic to individual needs, especially in jobs like healthcare where qualified staff are leaving in droves. Many nurses, doctors, physios, cleaners, HCAs, kitchen assistants and allied health professionals balance work with the demands of a young family. The NHS is promoted as being family friendly and offering flexible working or term time only contracts to parents.

Likewise, if a person without children wanted a particular week off in term time or school holidays (partner’s birthday, dog having surgery, a holiday, caring responsibility, house move etc) it would be kind and sensible of the team to try and accommodate their wishes.

why shouldn’t they take some annual leave to spend time with their children? Why shouldn’t I take some annual leave to spend time with my DP/my parent who's a teacher/my friends who are getting married in August/my other friend who is terminally ill and asks people to visit in times that fit around treatment and recuperation etc?
zafferana · 01/12/2021 12:12

I think a good boss will be flexible on this and yes, prioritise workers who need to be off at this time because they have small DC and/or childcare issues. Those without DC can take holidays at other times of the year and many workplaces are closed on Christmas/Boxing day so it's not like those without DC never get to be with their families at Christmas. I think we all need to be considerate and kind and face the fact that most people do have DC at some time in their lives, so if 20-somethings are fed up of working around Christmas, their time will come.

NorthSouthcatlady · 01/12/2021 12:11

Having children is a lifestyle choice so no parents shouldn’t have first dibs on annual leave. Most places l have worked then annual leave is first come, first served. Apart from Christmas when all requests are reviewed together, if someone has had the last Christmas / New Years off and they want it again then it’s unlikely they would get it again. It’s unreasonable to give certain groups preferential treatment with annual leave and would be grounds for a grievance. People with elderly patents or friends / family far away may wish to travel or visit over Christmas, New Year or summer. Or be bored of holding the fort for the last x amount of years

PinkSparklyPussyCat · 01/12/2021 12:04

@VashtaNerada

As a manager I have always worked on the basis that anyone with a good reason for time off gets priority. That includes childcare need, but other reasons too such as caring for an elderly relative, weddings, funerals etc. I get Christmas off anyway but this year DH is working across Christmas and I have no relatives available for childcare so if I had a job where I was expected to work, I would hope that either DH’s or my employer would give one of us the time off as the DC would otherwise be alone. It’s the human thing to do as an employer. I’d equally expect priority for time off if I was caring for an elderly or disabled relative, it’s not just about being a parent. I think part of being a manager is understanding your team’s personal circumstances and supporting them if they need it.
So going by your logic because I have no children and my parents are dead I should be expected to just fit in around everyone else. I'm glad I don't work for a manager like you!
Drunkpanda · 01/12/2021 11:59

@theemmadilemma

Parents need to remember that non Parents are still the children of someone. Someone that may need them as much as they want to be with their own children.

That's why parents who work can't expect to be given preferential entitlement to holiday times.

Doesn't that apply to parents too, they have (or had) parents themselves? Absolutely caring responsibilities are important, and the desire to be with older relatives makes sense when it comes to Christmas. I can't see it applying so much to needing time off during the school holidays to be able to take your dc away without a fine.
theemmadilemma · 01/12/2021 11:55

Parents need to remember that non Parents are still the children of someone. Someone that may need them as much as they want to be with their own children.

That's why parents who work can't expect to be given preferential entitlement to holiday times.

julieca · 01/12/2021 11:52

@senorafridgidaire Yes exactly. I will always help people when they have genuine issues. But wanting to spend time with kids is a want. Just as some want to spend holidays with nieces and nephews or grandchildren.

Darkpheonix · 01/12/2021 11:52

If parents start only working term times, in jobs that are all year round. They will also lose out in a lot of career progression. They will be missing for about 13 weeks a year.

And, as usual, it will be usually women who do the term time working, damaging their career more.

You can't expect to not be in work for a quarter of the year, but not fall behind. Especially if you are missing for 6 weeks in summer.

FateHasRedesignedMost · 01/12/2021 11:52

I think it’s sensible to give priority to parents of young children in school holidays. Most parents use a combination of holiday clubs, childminders and annual leave to cover holidays and half terms, why shouldn’t they take some annual leave to spend time with their children? It’s hard enough working FT and managing a young family without being told you can’t use some of your leave in school holidays.

Other parents may not be able to afford full childcare fees the entire school holiday and end up leaving their job. Bosses have to be sympathetic to individual needs, especially in jobs like healthcare where qualified staff are leaving in droves. Many nurses, doctors, physios, cleaners, HCAs, kitchen assistants and allied health professionals balance work with the demands of a young family. The NHS is promoted as being family friendly and offering flexible working or term time only contracts to parents.

Likewise, if a person without children wanted a particular week off in term time or school holidays (partner’s birthday, dog having surgery, a holiday, caring responsibility, house move etc) it would be kind and sensible of the team to try and accommodate their wishes.

senorafridgidaire · 01/12/2021 11:50

@julieca exactly. It's bonkers that someone believes that when I want time off for any reason, I'm supposed to consider the feelings of someone else's kids who most likely I've never even met ?!

Darkpheonix · 01/12/2021 11:49

@RobotValkyrie

Parent VS child-free is a dumb way to look at it.

Employers have a legal duty to consider protected characteristics when dealing with such matters. That include things like disabilities, whether someone is a carer (e.g. for an older relative), and yes, whether someone has children to look after.
I repeat: employers have a legal duty to consider the needs of all their employees, and discuss reasonable adjustments accordingly. That can include flexiwork, paid or unpaid leave, and first dibs on certain holiday slots. Whether you think it's "fair" or not is neither here nor there. You're not an employer, and you're not HR. Not your call to make.

Employers are nor obliged to let parents have first pick of holidays. Do they be ridiculous.

Clearly you aren't an employer or HR, either.

senorafridgidaire · 01/12/2021 11:48

@PinkTonic we have someone at work who was given a term time working contract when her kids were small...it was before I worked there so I don't know the history of why she is the only one with this arrangement. They are both at Uni now and she refuses to change it as she likes having all the holidays off!

julieca · 01/12/2021 11:47

@BeardyButton

I don’t care about the parents. It’s not the parents that are getting preferential treatment. It’s the children!!!!!

Children in some societies do better than in others. Some societies are more focused on child well being. This generally means - investment in education, child care, shared parental leave etc.

But in other societies, children are not the focus. So you get under investment in the above.

When it comes to this thread.... imagine not thinking from a child’s point of view about parents holidays during school holidays. Of course, parents should get priority - chn deserve to spend time with parents. We should work for a society that supports that time.

I take a job for its pay and benefits, not to support society. So I don't want less perks based on my home life.