Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think parents shouldn't get preferential treatment when it comes to time off work?

993 replies

KwestTurkey · 30/11/2021 22:38

I just read an article on Facebook about this. A parent had asked a childfree colleague if she could have some of her saved holiday days and was refused (understandably).

That's obviously a CF request. But in general, what do you think about parents and holiday requests Vs childfree colleagues?

I don't believe parents should be given priority when it comes to time off on any holiday, be it summer or Christmas etc.. I think it should always, generally, work on a first come first served basis. The amount of times I was refused any sort of time off in the summer because every single parent in the office had booked off the summer and they were given first dibs on those dates used to annoy me.

I'm a parent now but my opinion hasn't changed on that. I think if someone childfree has gotten there with the request before you then that's tough.

Same with Christmas, if you work a job that requires Christmas working, I don't think it's fair to allow the same people off every Christmas year in year out.

It's definitely something I've experienced in my workplace before and after having DC and it feels very unfair.

I really don't think it's anyone elses responsibility to ensure you get time off during school holidays or things like Christmas and that a childfree colleague has as much right to book the time off as any parent.

So...

YANBU - parents shouldn't get preferential treatment or priority when it comes to time off work.

YABU - they should.

OP posts:
KosherDill · 02/12/2021 10:04

@DameAlyson

it's the employer that should have contingency plans

But the employer is not supposed to ask prospective employees about their children, childcare responsibilities etc. How are they supposed to know what contingency plans they might need?

Exactly.

Can't have your cake and eat it, too.

Maverickess · 02/12/2021 10:03

@DameAlyson

it's the employer that should have contingency plans

But the employer is not supposed to ask prospective employees about their children, childcare responsibilities etc. How are they supposed to know what contingency plans they might need?

No, but they do know that people get sick, that people need time off for things that happen be that childcare failure or your roof caving in, at short notice and that Christmas and summer are always the times that people are going to want to have off regardless of their personal circumstances - it's not a new phenomenon. To that end they should have contingency plans that extend beyond those without child care responsibility doing it all, and make it clear that regardless of personal circumstances, Christmas/New year working is required as is during traditional summer holiday time by everyone, distributed fairly and stick to it. It's then up to the employee to accept or decline the terms based on their personal circumstances, not accept and then expect others to facilitate because they don't have children. If it's not acceptable to ask about dependants and childcare, because it's irrelevant, then it's also irrelevant why anyone wants leave/a fair amount of time off over popular holiday times.
sammylady37 · 02/12/2021 10:01

@sammylady37 your comments are unfair

What’s unfair about saying people should make contingency plans for their particular circumstances? It’s surely the responsible thing to do, rather than not doing so and expecting others to pick up the slack?

logsonlogsoff · 02/12/2021 09:51

We all need short notice time off now and again - some more than others. Not just parents. And good employers realise this. Reasons my colleagues have needed short notice time off recently - we’re not in a critical industry BTW, not medical or teachers etc- include : death of a pet, colleague was distraught, ill child, ill parent, relationship breakup, opportunity to go to a rare fun event, child given opp to do an audition for something.
All fine, all covered by willing colleagues because in our dept time off is given out fairly for life events, not just to parents.

wannabeamummysobad · 02/12/2021 09:49

YANBU. When I was single (living up north on a graduate program) someone tried to say I didn't "deserve" all of Xmas off because I didn't have children. I simply told the CF i) I booked it so am taking it ii) I'm someone's child and they want to see me iii) they see their kids every day, I can't get down south every weekend iv) their decision to have children shouldn't inconvenience me.

I'm now married and pregnant and feel the same way.

Personally the unreasonable ones are the parents who block book all their annual leave as soon as the calendar opens. Now I'm senior I don't allow it. My team knows everyone's need for leave is equal in priority. You can't book all of Xmas off and take the summer BH and the Easter holidays just because you are a parent. Everyone deserves to be able to make use of the BH to extend leave.

DameAlyson · 02/12/2021 09:48

it's the employer that should have contingency plans

But the employer is not supposed to ask prospective employees about their children, childcare responsibilities etc. How are they supposed to know what contingency plans they might need?

rookiemere · 02/12/2021 09:48

@sammylady37 your comments are unfair. I remember being a working DP when DS was young and I wasn't even a single parent, but sometimes it was hard enough to tread water never mind building up support networks through play dates. Even the best support network in the world is unlikely to want to have someone else's DCs on Christmas Day and aren't SAHM always cautioned on here about helping out working DPs with childcare?

Kanaloa · 02/12/2021 09:41

We all work set hours, the only way that me having a child impacts on my work is if I need time off last minute (which is thankfully rare), but I've made an effort to mitigate the impact that it has. What do you think I should be doing for others because occasionally when my child is poorly or hospitalised I've had to take unpaid or annual leave without much notice?

I don’t think you should be doing anything, but it doesn’t answer the question of when this flexibility is returned. The fact is it isn’t returned.

sammylady37 · 02/12/2021 09:32

I’m amazed at the number of single parents who apparently exist in a bubble, with no family, babysitters, or friends who could help out. Their kids must similarly exist in a bubble with no classmates or friends with whom they go on play dates etc. And so many of these people then have jobs which require Christmas cover. I mean, if you knew your support structure was so non-existent wouldn’t you look for alternative work that counsel accommodate your very specific circumstances or wouldn’t you try damn hard to improve your support network? It makes sense to have one for many reasons, including illness, not just to allow you fulfil your contractual obligations at work.

logsonlogsoff · 02/12/2021 09:31

‘ lollipoprainbow

@logsonlogsoff my mum is in a home with advanced dementia, she was amazing at helping out with my dd, maybe think before you make nasty comments about 'single working mums' you have no idea of their circumstances.’

Exactly. You’re making my point. No-one knows the individual circs of a colleague so holidays should be fairly organised or divided out. Otherwise it can cause massive resentment among colleagues- not a good thing. I did work with one single parent who basically refused to work in the run up to Xmas, Easter, told mge exactly which hols she would be taking over the summer at the start of the year and was totally inflexible. Leaving the rest of us to cover.
Not sure how she got away with it - think the boss was just scared of her- because she had her mum next door and extended family all around.

logsonlogsoff · 02/12/2021 09:25

In jobs where there needs to be cover the only fair way to do it is have a rota in place - so you might work Xmas eve but get NY eve off etc. And then swap with colleagues if you need to or they’re willing.
I used to work bank hols, Xmas as we got double pay and I volunteered. My ex worked over Xmas NY on rota as she was a doctor.
My dad worked shifts and in call and sometimes he wasn’t around, but we weren’t traumatised by him having to go out on Xmas day on a call.
Everyone has their own circumstances to deal with so being a parent or even a SINGLE parent doesn’t trump others private lives.

rookiemere · 02/12/2021 09:14

Christmas is different from say school summer holiday dates, where I think it's fair and right for a first come, first served policy to be in place.

Frankly if not everyone who asks for it can have Christmas off then the only really fair way of doing it is by lottery. Otherwise it's too hard to factor in all the different scenarios and many people move around in roles and departments these days so rotating may not work.

fakereview · 02/12/2021 09:09

I think it's very fair of your employers to check that leave at a popular time wasn't being monopolised by one person

I disagree. If someone is organised enough to jump in and book Christmas on Jan 1st every year why should they lose out to someone who whines in March or September that they have kids and should have priority? If you have kids and you need childcare you are organised and plan ahead. Same goes for any time you need for any reason.

TitoMojito · 02/12/2021 09:04

YANBU. The thing is family is not just your children. When I worked in retail, I was made to do evenings and weekends because "the parents need the weekday shifts". I get that, but my parents work full time during the week. When am I supposed to see them? Same goes for Christmas. Sure, children love Christmas. But what about my elderly and very ill grandmother? Doesn't she deserve people to come see her on Christmas Day? But if everyone who doesn't have little children is expected to work on Christmas, then no one will be able to go see her.

Reality is that you don’t know anyone's circumstances. Just because they don’t have children doesn't mean they don’t have other things affecting their lives.

lollipoprainbow · 02/12/2021 08:58

@logsonlogsoff my mum is in a home with advanced dementia, she was amazing at helping out with my dd, maybe think before you make nasty comments about 'single working mums' you have no idea of their circumstances.

Maverickess · 02/12/2021 08:58

Should we have better working culture generally in the UK for parents? Yeah, 100%. I work directly on raising awareness of how flexible working, job sharing, and parent-friendly workplaces are important, and will positively impact women especially.

Employers should do better. But that should not include disadvantaging people without children.

Yes exactly, this really is the responsibility of employers, not child free employees to deal with, many employers seem to take the attitude that it's not their responsibility, but that of their employees to organise that the work is covered when someone else is absent, be that due to childcare or sickness etc, and that filters down and is very present in the workforce judging by this thread (and others) and what I've seen in real life.
Parents are always going to need to put children first, I am a parent, and was a single parent (suppose I still am but my child is an adult now) and I get that, however it's the employer that should have contingency plans that extend beyond "You don't have kids" to those who don't to sort these situations out.
The pressure should be on the employer, not the colleagues.

sammylady37 · 02/12/2021 08:56

I do sympathise with your position and I'm not trying to make a point about your specific situation, but I think it's quite telling that as an example of giving, you've come up with "I make it easier for others to cover for me".

I know, I found that quite staggering in its audacity. Here, as an example of what a good colleague I am, and how much ‘give’ I’m willing to show in response to the amount of ‘taking’ I do, let me tell you how I make it easier for people to cover me when I’m doing the taking.

Greeneyedminx · 02/12/2021 08:55

Most people would be furious if, at interviews, they were asked what their child care set up is.
They would correctly state that is nothing to do with how they work, what wages they receive, or how they perform as an employee.
However... come holiday times, especially Christmas, the world and his wife suddenly need to know exactly how many children they have, all their issues regarding child care etc etc.
No... either you work to exactly the same principles as everyone else, regardless of how many children, grannies, cats, dogs or anything else you are responsible for, or you find employment where you take into account your child care responsibilities and not rely on other people sorting it out for you.
Where I worked for 18 years, everyone’s shifts were recorded, if you worked Christmas and Boxing Day one year, you didn’t the next, you worked New Years Eve and New Years Day. This was explained in detail at interviews and everyone in all areas were fully aware of this.
If people swapped shifts to cover for each other, that was fine and agreed by management.
No one ever had preferential treatment due to having children and it worked well.
One year one employee’s husband died suddenly in October and it was her turn to work Christmas, people were immediately offering to cover her shifts so she could be at home with her children over Christmas.
We never had a high turnover of staff and people on every level from the manager down understood the relevance of working as a team for the benefit of all the people we cared for.
It was an extremely fair system regarding all holidays for everyone.

Glassofshloer · 02/12/2021 08:50

@Darkpheonix but unless they have the power to sign off their own leave, then surely the issue lies with the management? And this is a case of general twattery like the child free lady example I used?

Darkpheonix · 02/12/2021 08:48

@Glassofshloer but you are saying that. When I was single parent I had to leave a job and decline jobs because or didn't suit with the kids. I didn't take them and then demand every Christmas off.

Everyone has emergencies. But knowing you don't have childcare over Christmas so expecting every Christmas off isnt an emergency.

Very few people can actually name how they support their colleagues who are having an emergency. Not even if those colleagues have kids which is very telling. If you expect people to jump in an support parents as a priority all the time, then you are expecting them to get the shitry end of the stick

A few twats in this thread have said it. Lots of posters have given examples where people have said these things in RL or thrown strops when they can't. There's examples of people working every Christmas for years and then parents kicking off because they get one off.

Its what the thread is about.

AudacityBaby · 02/12/2021 08:47

To be honest holidays aren't hotly contested where I work so no one is overly doing much giving. The one way being a parent affects my work is I'm more likely to be off unexpectedly last minute, ie when I've been in hospital with my child. I make it as easy as possible for the team by keeping a live spreadsheet of what's urgent, what can wait, where stuff is and I'll log in to pop my out of office on so they aren't fielding emails all day. I try and be a decent member of the team and mindful of others, my child will always be my priority though of course.

I do sympathise with your position and I'm not trying to make a point about your specific situation, but I think it's quite telling that as an example of giving, you've come up with "I make it easier for others to cover for me".

If workplaces want to retain parents, the more flexibility they offer (including as to when holiday can be taken), the more likely they are to do so, even if the flexibility comes at the expense of child-free workers. If they don't really care about losing workers who are parents (and their experience, then it will be much less important for them to offer flexibility. And of course, the less they pay their employees, the less likely it is that it will be financially viable for parents to use expensive holiday childcare.

I weirdly appreciate the bald honesty of this, because this is exactly how my workplace thinks. Their only concern is whether or not they want to retain parents. There is no concern about losing workers who aren't parents, because they've been given no flexibility. It's as if parents are the only ones with any value or experience - which (and I'm donning my hard hat here) is ironic, because where I work the parents have generally spent more time out of the office than their childless counterparts, what with multiple maternity leaves and then working basically part time hours for full time pay.

Glassofshloer · 02/12/2021 08:38

But as a follow up to my last comment, I don’t judge child free people for her actions 🤷🏼‍♀️

IloveRitaConnors · 02/12/2021 08:37

@KwestTurkey

Unless you’re lucky enough to have a retired grandparent who is happy & capable to look after the children, what is the alternative?

Well put very bluntly, it was your decision to have children, not your colleagues.

I'm a parent of 2 and agree with this. My choice, my responsibility. Yes it's hard but me being in this position doesn't make me more 'special' or important than my child free colleague's, they have just as much right to the leave as me. I Ieft a career so it would be more manageable with my decision to have kids I've now returned to it 15 yrs later best decision I ever made. We all have to be responsible for the choices we make and not expect others to accommodate them. I dis absorb a huge pay cut for this to but always understood that life could change so never got to used to a certain lifestyle, this did make my move easier.
Glassofshloer · 02/12/2021 08:36

[quote Darkpheonix]@Glassofshloer how are you accounting for those of us who are parents and still don't think it's our colleagues jobs to get the shitty end of the stick?

I was. I was a single parents for a good portion of it. Of course I needed a bit of flexibility and colleagues helped me out. But they helped me out because I would also help them out when they needed it to.

And again, I don't believe most parents want Christmas off because they don't have childcare. Most want it off to be with their family but seem to think them wanting to be with their family is more important than what anyone else wants to do.[/quote]

  1. I didn’t say they should get the shitty end. I said ideally people are nice enough to help each other’s out, and get the favour returned one day.
  1. Has anyone actually said they think their Christmas is more important than everyone else’s, besides the odd twat? Like I said the only woman in my team who actually said this was child free, her parents death anniversary fell the week before Christmas so she would insist she was too depressed to work each year & needed the time off 🤷🏼‍♀️
Smorgasborb · 02/12/2021 08:35

Surely the answer is everyone takes it in turns for Xmas? If you worked it last year you don't this year. If you don't want to then tough or find someone to swap with.