Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think parents shouldn't get preferential treatment when it comes to time off work?

993 replies

KwestTurkey · 30/11/2021 22:38

I just read an article on Facebook about this. A parent had asked a childfree colleague if she could have some of her saved holiday days and was refused (understandably).

That's obviously a CF request. But in general, what do you think about parents and holiday requests Vs childfree colleagues?

I don't believe parents should be given priority when it comes to time off on any holiday, be it summer or Christmas etc.. I think it should always, generally, work on a first come first served basis. The amount of times I was refused any sort of time off in the summer because every single parent in the office had booked off the summer and they were given first dibs on those dates used to annoy me.

I'm a parent now but my opinion hasn't changed on that. I think if someone childfree has gotten there with the request before you then that's tough.

Same with Christmas, if you work a job that requires Christmas working, I don't think it's fair to allow the same people off every Christmas year in year out.

It's definitely something I've experienced in my workplace before and after having DC and it feels very unfair.

I really don't think it's anyone elses responsibility to ensure you get time off during school holidays or things like Christmas and that a childfree colleague has as much right to book the time off as any parent.

So...

YANBU - parents shouldn't get preferential treatment or priority when it comes to time off work.

YABU - they should.

OP posts:
KosherDill · 02/12/2021 12:42

@biscuitsforcheese

What I've actually said is it would be kind of people who have no need for particular dates let people who do need them have first refusal. Whether that need is social, care-based, political, religious or logistical

And if my need is to spend a week in the sun in my garden in August?

You say you aren't saying childless people are worth less, but if you create a hierarchy of needs, and put their needs lower down the hierarchy you are literally saying their needs are worth less

Exactly.

Who gets to define "need"???

julieca · 02/12/2021 12:40

I think she is differentiating between needs and wants. But the truth is of one person needs a particular date off, then other peoples wants can work around that. In most workplaces though there are multiple people with specific dates they need. So those who have just wants would have to take whatever is left. Which may not be great times for anyone to take a holiday.

biscuitsforcheese · 02/12/2021 12:37

What I've actually said is it would be kind of people who have no need for particular dates let people who do need them have first refusal. Whether that need is social, care-based, political, religious or logistical

And if my need is to spend a week in the sun in my garden in August?

You say you aren't saying childless people are worth less, but if you create a hierarchy of needs, and put their needs lower down the hierarchy you are literally saying their needs are worth less

Thecurtainsofdestiny · 02/12/2021 12:19

I agree with you. In my places of work I've not had preferential treatment because of having children. One memorable year I worked every public holiday bar one. And most of my colleagues had no children at that point. So I think some workplaces obviously don't pay any regard to who has children and who doesn't, it's just how the rota falls any particular year.

KosherDill · 02/12/2021 12:12

My longtime workplace has a system where length of tenure at the employer gives rights to select days off, if you book by April 1.

I missed many a family moment including my grandmother's last Christmas, due to that system. Now that I am senior and have my pick of days, we get newcomer parents clamoring that it's "unfair!" "Little Evvie and Angus will be so disappointed!"

One spineless manager was cowed by one of the more aggressive parents and tried to make some of us senior childfree switch to work Christmas & Christmas Eve (we are a 24/7 industry.)

She got an earful and we escalated to the director, who enforced the existing policy. She didn't help her career by trying to discriminate against non-parents.

Goldbar · 02/12/2021 12:11

@slashlover. Many people I know have negotiated additional time off/certain holidays off as part of returning to work after maternity leave or remaining in a job. I have one friend who takes the whole of the summer holidays off (unpaid). That's the deal she's negotiated with her employer.

I agree that just turning up having accepted a job and saying 'I want Christmas off because I'm a parent' is entitled and unreasonable.

julieca · 02/12/2021 12:09

@CatOfTheLand and people who have no need should take whatever is left presumably?

CatOfTheLand · 02/12/2021 12:04

[quote wannabeamummysobad]@CatOfTheLand before you had children did you have no friends, partner or family?
I ask because surely you'd want to spend Christmas with them?

Also, just because a person doesn't have kids doesn't mean they don't need summer, Easter, half terms off... what if they are friends with teachers? Ultimately we all have plans and priorities which aren't less important that those with school age kids. [/quote]
That's a need though, isn't it? If you need to go on holiday during school holidays because your travel companion can only go then.

My point was, if you don't need to go at times when other people do need to go then it would be kind to give them first refusal.

I hate having these conversations with childless people. I've been both sides of it - I wasn't born a parent, my Christian name isn't 'mum', but whatever I say it gets twisted to me saying that childless people are worth less and should be put in forced labour camps from July-sept and again at Christmas and Easter (but are allowed out again and get first dibs for Valentine's Day).

What I've actually said is it would be kind of people who have no need for particular dates let people who do need them have first refusal. Whether that need is social, care-based, political, religious or logistical

slashlover · 02/12/2021 11:36

The difficulty comes at the point that having certain holidays off is a condition for the parent employee in taking or continuing in the job. Parents (and indeed anyone else) are perfectly entitled to say, 'I won't work in a job where I have to work over Christmas'. Employers can then accept that or not, depending on their workforce needs. It is up to them then to manage relations with other employees, which may include pushing back on parents' requests for holidays and saying 'maybe this isn't the job for you if you need every Christmas off'.

Do parents actually say things like that when they're interviewed though?

julieca · 02/12/2021 11:23

I know someone with 5 kids including a disabled child. Not a blended family, they chose to have these children. She is constantly going on about how hard it is.
I do understand that even if you have chosen something you still want to be able to vent. But it is almost constant. I have come to the conclusion she just likes moaning.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 02/12/2021 11:05

AudacityBaby

Good point, actually!

The parent martyrs who only ever had children altruistically 'because who else was willing to do it?' - and never actually wanted the joys of parenthood for themselves.

Especially those with particularly large families, who seem to be constantly surprised at how much more work and stress it is to look after a lot of children than one or two (or none). I'm not talking about those who had sextuplets or who have been widowed, fled latterly-abusive relationships, later become severely disabled etc.; but just those who seem unable to realise that everybody would find it tough looking after 5+ children - and that's why most of us actively decide not to have that many (or indeed any).

We know somebody with 11 children who is always complaining about money being a struggle, the council not giving them a 'big enough' house etc. (for some strange reason, they don't have many 12-bedroom homes in their portfolio). Sometimes, it's like they want a medal. If you want a massive family, absolutely fine, go ahead - but own your choice and don't be doing the whole 'woe is me' thing 24/7.

peboh · 02/12/2021 10:55

Pre child days when I worked, it was always assumed that out of several colleagues I would work certain days so they could have time off with their children, and honestly it sucked. I still had children in my family I wanted to see during their holidays, friends who worked like I did and had those times off. I still had a life.
I'm now a sahm, but I absolutely wouldn't expect non parents to have to work holidays so I could have the time off. I chose to be a parent, they have either chose to currently be child free, or cannot have children for a number of reasons. Why are they any less entitled to those dates?

biscuitsforcheese · 02/12/2021 10:50

@catoftheland

You clearly understood that and didn't for one second think I meant only parents could go to music festivals and scout camp.

No no actually as a childless person who has been criticized by parents for attending both festivals and scout camp in summer holidays I absolutely did not clearly understand you were not one of those people who think that.

It's a philosophy I've used with my work colleagues pre DC - I always volunteered to work holidays, Christmas Day, people's birthdays and anniversaries etc so that people with children or caring responsibilities for ageing parents could have a bit less stress in their lives. I did it to be kind so would appreciate it if other people did the same.

And thats very lovely of you, I have in fact done the same countless times. However, the issue is for people who are never going to have children, there is an expectation they are going to do this their entire working lives, because there is always another parent expecting first dibs at Christmas and summer etc. Its not, I will do all the Christmases for your child's first 7 years, for example, and then you will do the next few for me. That would be reasonable. But in 7 years there is another parent demanding the same etc etc and then suddenly its been years and years and your reasons are never quite worthy enough. So you only had to be kind until you had children, but I have to be kind until I retire, not quite the same thing. I've literally had parents of adult children tell me their need to spend Christmas with their children outweighs my parents need to spend Christmas with me (their child) and I couldn't possibly understand because I don't have children.

The fact is that even without children or caring responsibilities my needs for time spent with my family at Christmas, or some time off in the sun in summer is as worthy as yours. And you don't have the right to create a hierarchy of needs that places me at the bottom.

I will be flexible, I wont be a doormat, and I certainly wont be kind to anyone who thinks kindness only runs in one direction.

wannabeamummysobad · 02/12/2021 10:46

@CatOfTheLand before you had children did you have no friends, partner or family?
I ask because surely you'd want to spend Christmas with them?

Also, just because a person doesn't have kids doesn't mean they don't need summer, Easter, half terms off... what if they are friends with teachers? Ultimately we all have plans and priorities which aren't less important that those with school age kids.

CatOfTheLand · 02/12/2021 10:40

[quote biscuitsforcheese]@catoftheland

I do think it would be kind of non-child carers to aim to book holidays outside of school holiday time if possible though

I think it would be kind of parents not to expect non parents to never have a holiday in the summer, attend a festival etc, but as demonstrated multiple times on this thread be kind only seems to work in one direction.

How do scout, guide, cadet, and other youth organisation volunteers fit into this, who often use their own holiday to take children away, and a fair number don't have children themselves, fit into this. Or people married to teachers etc etc. Everyone has their own reasons for wanting holiday when then want it and usually if people without parents when holiday in the school holidays its for a good reason, but even if its not, thats not for them to be told they aren't 'kind'[/quote]
I meant that if you don't have a specific need for those dates then it would be kind of you to let people who do need those specific dates to have first refusal. I had a boss who would book off every 'good' date the morning the holiday calendar became bookable, just before telling us it was bookable, so I believe that people should try to be kind and fair about these things.

It's a philosophy I've used with my work colleagues pre DC - I always volunteered to work holidays, Christmas Day, people's birthdays and anniversaries etc so that people with children or caring responsibilities for ageing parents could have a bit less stress in their lives. I did it to be kind so would appreciate it if other people did the same.

You clearly understood that and didn't for one second think I meant only parents could go to music festivals and scout camp.

Goldbar · 02/12/2021 10:36

I once worked with a nurse who had a child and demanded every Christmas off. She then went on to have another child with her ex partner - not actually together - and continued to demand every Christmas off and refused to do the shift if she was on the rota. I had two children and still did my fair share.

I find this very odd. Ill people need to be cared for all year round. Maybe don't become a nurse if always having Christmas off is so important to you. I hope she was disciplined for missing her shift.

biscuitsforcheese · 02/12/2021 10:30

@catoftheland

I do think it would be kind of non-child carers to aim to book holidays outside of school holiday time if possible though

I think it would be kind of parents not to expect non parents to never have a holiday in the summer, attend a festival etc, but as demonstrated multiple times on this thread be kind only seems to work in one direction.

How do scout, guide, cadet, and other youth organisation volunteers fit into this, who often use their own holiday to take children away, and a fair number don't have children themselves, fit into this. Or people married to teachers etc etc. Everyone has their own reasons for wanting holiday when then want it and usually if people without parents when holiday in the school holidays its for a good reason, but even if its not, thats not for them to be told they aren't 'kind'

Forion · 02/12/2021 10:27

I once worked with a nurse who had a child and demanded every Christmas off. She then went on to have another child with her ex partner - not actually together - and continued to demand every Christmas off and refused to do the shift if she was on the rota. I had two children and still did my fair share.

Goldbar · 02/12/2021 10:24

@Goldbar

I suspect it's a supply-demand issue in many cases.

I work in a job where I can take most holidays off or work flexibly from home. It's not hugely well-paid but I'm not particularly interested in moving to a different job that pays more if it means I lose that flexibility. I know people who work in better-paid jobs with zero flexibility and they hire holiday nannies (at least the very well-paid ones!) or use holiday childcare.

If workplaces want to retain parents, the more flexibility they offer (including as to when holiday can be taken), the more likely they are to do so, even if the flexibility comes at the expense of child-free workers. If they don't really care about losing workers who are parents (and their experience, then it will be much less important for them to offer flexibility. And of course, the less they pay their employees, the less likely it is that it will be financially viable for parents to use expensive holiday childcare.

For those saying that this demonstrated 'sneering superiority' that parents are better workers, it wasn't intended to.

On average, parents may be worse workers due to days off, childcare commitments, illness, emergency leave etc. Whether the employer has to put up with this depends on whether, if you remove the parent pool of employees, they can find sufficient workers to do the job. It is absolutely clear that some jobs are incompatible with being a primary carer for children. City law firms, for example, expect you to be available 24/7 and work beyond your set hours without any notice when required. So you can never be sure of leaving in time to care for your children. The result is to exclude those who have primary care of children (unless they are willing to hire a 24/7 nanny). Because the pay is high enough, there is still a sufficiently large pool of workers that they don't have to change their working model.

In my job, the pay is relatively low but it's quite specialised so there's not that many people who could do it without substantial training. People do it because it offers the flexibility to essentially set your own hours to a large extent. And no one is expected to work Christmas or New Year. In other jobs, obviously working over Christmas and New Year is necessary and expected - I wouldn't have thought anyone becomes a hospital doctor, a nurse or a carer, for example, without being prepared to work some holidays, even if they become a parent.

The difficulty comes at the point that having certain holidays off is a condition for the parent employee in taking or continuing in the job. Parents (and indeed anyone else) are perfectly entitled to say, 'I won't work in a job where I have to work over Christmas'. Employers can then accept that or not, depending on their workforce needs. It is up to them then to manage relations with other employees, which may include pushing back on parents' requests for holidays and saying 'maybe this isn't the job for you if you need every Christmas off'.

AudacityBaby · 02/12/2021 10:23

Can you imagine if, every single time a parent came in to work in a new car, with a shop-bought lunch, new coat, fancy handbag, expensive suit or whatever, all of their non-parent colleagues made a big issue about how they should have bought something cheaper for themselves and used the money for presents for their kids - "as a parent, you would be expected to have different priorities with your finances" ? Assuming that nobody would find behaviour like that appropriate, what difference is there in principle in telling people how they should be expected to value/spend/plan their spare time?

It's funny, because I find that some people do think behaviour like this is appropriate. Reversed, obviously. I've seen people come into the office with a new fancy outfit or what have you, and heard comments like, "oh gosh I wish I could afford that, but that's what happens when you have kids, I haven't bought anything for myself since 1842 - how the other half live eh!" or what have you.

(Don't get me started on the colleague I have who likes to scold the rest of us for poor environmental decision-making, as her 5 kids are going to inherit our choices.)

I remember a thread on here where OP was upset that a colleague without kids had said that she'd hate to have kids as it sounded so boring. I found that such a staggeringly mild comment to get upset about, compared to the rubbish that childless women are told all of the bleeding time.

Just observations, really.

CatOfTheLand · 02/12/2021 10:21

I think whoever has the most need - so carers of any form, someone getting married, someone moving house etc should get their needs met as far as possible. However, parents shouldn't get first dibs on plum holiday dates just by virtue of being parents. I do think it would be kind of non-child carers to aim to book holidays outside of school holiday time if possible though

biscuitsforcheese · 02/12/2021 10:19

Not that long ago there was a thread on here where people were talking about how childless people who were willing to look after other peoples children, or even childless people who had toys in their house for nieces and nephews, were weird, strange, untrustworthy and quite probably paedophiles. Now obviously not everyone on the thread were saying that but there were a fair number who were absolutely determined that if you didn't have children you were definitely up to no good if you looked after anyone elses.

I would love to know the cross over between those posters and the:

"Childless people dont understand how hard it is to look after children"
"There is no one else to look after my children"

Posters on this thread. Because I have a feeling there probably is a cross over.

There are plenty of lovely parents who don't take the piss, and who don't expect or demand unlimited flexibility just because they are a parent

But there are also a subset of parents on this thread and in real life who seem to think their ability to have unprotected sex overrides anyone elses right to be fairly treated.

And apart from the one childless person who has been brought up countless times on this thread who kept requesting christmas off because of grief/mental health, the reality is this behaviour tends to go in one direction.

So if you are feeling got at by this thread as a parent maybe have a think about whether your requests are really reasonable.

Because whilst most of us parents or not, are willing to be flexible to peoples lifes circumstances, if more than one person isnt being flexible with you, you may have reached the limit of taking without giving.

I once asked for Christmas off because it was the due date of my baby I lost. I was turned down because Christmas is more important for live children than dead children. I left that job as soon as I could, and when they asked why I was leaving they didnt understand what the problem was.

I don't put myself last any more. I'm flexible but not to the point of it actually being detrimental to me. I am now in a work place that is flexible for parents, we have actually had people join the team specifically for the flexibility. But my boss is amazing and the flexibility is there for everyone, not just parents and thats lovely too.

He makes it work by making sure the teams workload is never overloaded, that way there is always some spare time if someone needs to do a school run or pop out to pick something up, without it adding to others workload. Which means if something comes in which does overload us we are all willing to go the extra mile because its unavoidable. And if no one needs the spare time we just move on to the next task and get ahead of ourselves.

To those asking how employers can fix the problem - employing enough people that everyone isnt constantly expecting to work over and above all the time, so that one person popping out for half an hour causes massive impacts to everyone else actually really helps.
To many work places cut staff, expect people to pick up extra work when people leave and aren't replaced etc and then that in turn means the workplace is inflexible because everyone is working at speed with no time to breath, its unhealthy and breeds resentment when people do then have to leave for a school run etc because someone has to pick up the extra work because there is no time to leave it.

Darkpheonix · 02/12/2021 10:18

[quote Glassofshloer]@Darkpheonix but unless they have the power to sign off their own leave, then surely the issue lies with the management? And this is a case of general twattery like the child free lady example I used?[/quote]
Of course it is, if its being allowe

Buy its also a problem with people's expectation that their lives should be more important than everyone else's.

Even if the manager doesn't allow it, but the parent in question is then trying to convince, guilt and strop to get their own way its a problem with them.

Its about attitudes. And there is a problem with alot (not all) of parents thinking everyone else has a responsibility to work around them.

So back to what I said, that an expectation that your colleagues will pick up the shirty end because you have kids isn't ok. And nor all parents agree. So your comment about 'I would have thought the same before kids- doesn't sit right. Because that's assuming people just dont understand. However, plenty of us parents agree, our kids are not everyone else's responsibility.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 02/12/2021 10:08

And heron lies the problem.
It’s absolutely nobody’s business what you use annual leave for.
It really isn’t.
You have as much right to take 2 weeks off in August as anyone else.
Most employees role along fine. See my point regarding Christmas though. Christmas is the same date for everyone, regardless of if you have 15 kids or none.

Precisely this. People are different and it's not for anybody else to make a value judgment as to how they prefer to spend their time off. There's a man in Melksham known as 'Mr Christmas' who celebrates Christmas every single day. None of the features I've read about him seem to mention him having children/family, but it's obviously a massive part of his life. Can you imagine him being told point-blank that he can never have actual Christmas off, because he doesn't have children and so it's not important to him? I'd find his life dull, but I'm sure he'd find many aspects of my life dull - different strokes for different folks.

Can you imagine if, every single time a parent came in to work in a new car, with a shop-bought lunch, new coat, fancy handbag, expensive suit or whatever, all of their non-parent colleagues made a big issue about how they should have bought something cheaper for themselves and used the money for presents for their kids - "as a parent, you would be expected to have different priorities with your finances" ? Assuming that nobody would find behaviour like that appropriate, what difference is there in principle in telling people how they should be expected to value/spend/plan their spare time?

KosherDill · 02/12/2021 10:06

@sammylady37

I’m amazed at the number of single parents who apparently exist in a bubble, with no family, babysitters, or friends who could help out. Their kids must similarly exist in a bubble with no classmates or friends with whom they go on play dates etc. And so many of these people then have jobs which require Christmas cover. I mean, if you knew your support structure was so non-existent wouldn’t you look for alternative work that counsel accommodate your very specific circumstances or wouldn’t you try damn hard to improve your support network? It makes sense to have one for many reasons, including illness, not just to allow you fulfil your contractual obligations at work.

I wonder the same things.