Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think parents shouldn't get preferential treatment when it comes to time off work?

993 replies

KwestTurkey · 30/11/2021 22:38

I just read an article on Facebook about this. A parent had asked a childfree colleague if she could have some of her saved holiday days and was refused (understandably).

That's obviously a CF request. But in general, what do you think about parents and holiday requests Vs childfree colleagues?

I don't believe parents should be given priority when it comes to time off on any holiday, be it summer or Christmas etc.. I think it should always, generally, work on a first come first served basis. The amount of times I was refused any sort of time off in the summer because every single parent in the office had booked off the summer and they were given first dibs on those dates used to annoy me.

I'm a parent now but my opinion hasn't changed on that. I think if someone childfree has gotten there with the request before you then that's tough.

Same with Christmas, if you work a job that requires Christmas working, I don't think it's fair to allow the same people off every Christmas year in year out.

It's definitely something I've experienced in my workplace before and after having DC and it feels very unfair.

I really don't think it's anyone elses responsibility to ensure you get time off during school holidays or things like Christmas and that a childfree colleague has as much right to book the time off as any parent.

So...

YANBU - parents shouldn't get preferential treatment or priority when it comes to time off work.

YABU - they should.

OP posts:
shufflestep · 03/12/2021 06:31

I think that it is not always black and white - when I was a primary school teacher, my husband was told that he couldn't have any time off in the summer holidays, because it went to those with children first. He only wanted a week off, but others could take two or three weeks. Apparently as an adult I could book time off like anyone else - I don't know who they expected to teach their children then!

Mfsf · 03/12/2021 06:21

Going from a practical perspective the population is aging and parents need and should have a degree of protection , because after all it’s all ok to say “ it’s a choice “ but parents are creating the next generation of tax payers , the ones that will be paying yours abd said childless colleagues pension and care etc .
Of course from a personal perspective it’s harder but the reality is that accepting being or not being a parent comes with a degree of pros and cons and legal protection . So yes when I give permission to holidays with my team if there are requests for school holidays I will always give them to parents first , once more off course it’s not always black and white , like a example I have a team member that refused to work most of lockdown , because she has 2 children at home , now while I’m sympathetic , at lockdown I was a single mum myself with 2 children , one of who is severely autistic and I worked all of the lockdown non stop, same as most of the other tram members , so said person was at the bottom of the priority for holiday choice of dates last year because at the end of the day abusing a benefit is never ok .

Cattipuss · 03/12/2021 06:14

I've always worked places with a fair system for Christmas, often we would swap amongst ourselves if we wanted but everyone has an equal chance of getting christmas off, and annual leave around summer tends to be fairly approved. I do agree with some PPs though that its not always a case of someone just wanting time off, for many circumstances change so even with plans before having children, it doesn't mean you have a network of people that can look after your child whilst you work; especially on Christmas day! Its not colleagues' responsibility to shoulder that, or the employers, but there isn't really a solution either and the child cannot be left alone.

Anitarest · 03/12/2021 06:03

There should be some sort of rota-so the same people don’t get first choice every year, but would you believe that some aren’t happy with that either. A colleague liked to take the week before the school break every year because it’s slightly cheaper and was really annoyed when a parent booked it because it meant she could actually afford to go away, because even with the fine it cost less.

CounsellorTroi · 03/12/2021 06:00

@Iseestupidpeople

Well there’s a lot of child hating Karens on here.
I’ don’t hate children, just sanctimonious parents of which there are a fair few on this thread. Not all are like that though thankfully.
JakeyRolling · 03/12/2021 05:48

[quote julieca]@JakeyRolling I am not religious. My now dead Christian friend would have been very upset to miss a Christmas day service. She could have missed seeing family, but not missing church.
I assume your grandfather attended a church service on Christmas day on the boat? There will have been one.[/quote]
Sometimes but rarely. He spent more than one Christmas in the innards of the engine.

Miisty · 03/12/2021 05:45

I am a parent but luckily my children could be taken out of school to go on holiday when it was cheaper.I often work Christmas but m my husband then looked after the children .Schools have not caught up with most parents work and after school clubs etc very poor in Somerset always have been

Thermosplat · 03/12/2021 05:08

@MockneyReject

Is it really incomprehensible, that some parents wouldn't have an army of babysitters available for Xmas day? Can people really not comprehend that some parents are doing it all alone? That schools and nurseries and childminders are closed on Xmas day? That jobs requiring Xmas day cover tend to be the minimum wage type, with recruitment/retention issues that Jobcentre 'work coaches' push claimants in to? Like care work, which tends to be done by working class women. If these parents refuse to apply for, or take, these jobs, they are 'sanctioned' - being unlikely to have childcare in December just doesn't cut it, as a reason not to take a job, in April. Minimum wage, subsidised by Universal Credit, simply doesn't allow for the retention of an army of babysitters, ie, nannies/childminders. There is no childcare available on Xmas day to those (mostly) women. Boxing Day, NYE/day, Sundays, Bank Holidays, Easter are also very difficult.
Excellent post and an important point.
MockneyReject · 03/12/2021 04:39

Is it really incomprehensible, that some parents wouldn't have an army of babysitters available for Xmas day? Can people really not comprehend that some parents are doing it all alone? That schools and nurseries and childminders are closed on Xmas day? That jobs requiring Xmas day cover tend to be the minimum wage type, with recruitment/retention issues that Jobcentre 'work coaches' push claimants in to? Like care work, which tends to be done by working class women. If these parents refuse to apply for, or take, these jobs, they are 'sanctioned' - being unlikely to have childcare in December just doesn't cut it, as a reason not to take a job, in April. Minimum wage, subsidised by Universal Credit, simply doesn't allow for the retention of an army of babysitters, ie, nannies/childminders. There is no childcare available on Xmas day to those (mostly) women. Boxing Day, NYE/day, Sundays, Bank Holidays, Easter are also very difficult.

Thermosplat · 03/12/2021 04:22

I do agree, ultimately though my children come before my colleagues and my work for me, as I expect is the case for most parents.

Muchmorethan · 03/12/2021 04:19

I work in the NHS. In my department leave is agreed on a first come basis and we can book up to one year ahead.

But... Christmas and New Year weeks are done on a voluntary basis and everyone has to do a shift - no exceptions.

We find that due to the mix of child/childless plus multiple different religions we get it covered.

I am an organised person and do book my leave a year ahead, however l have also switched weeks if a colleague is desperate and l could accommodate.

BobISMyUncle · 03/12/2021 04:12

OH!! AND!! Because I was SO pissed off with the company allowing me to be verbally abused by this person, when the booking your days off time came around, I arrived super early (no school run stuff, etc.) And because it was first come, first served, I booked the whole of the coming year. Every single bank holiday. Plus, a day either side. Except for Easter. I booked 2 days either side for that. And because I had so much holiday left, I took 2 weeks for Christmas and New Year.
So there. Nur.

Catfog · 03/12/2021 04:10

it is incomprehensible to me that people cannot be bothered to recruit and cultivate an array of babysitters and cooperative arrangements with friends/neighbors so that childcare in December isn't dependent on coworker sacrifices.

Incomprehensible, really?

Yogaandcocoa · 03/12/2021 04:07

I mostly agree with you.

Parents shouldn't have priority.

Where I work Christmas etc are not FCFS either. Everyone puts in their request and it is supposed to alternate so if you don't get one year then tI get the next one.

BobISMyUncle · 03/12/2021 04:00

I completely understand why parents would like "extra" holiday time. Not even "extra" time. I used to gladly give up mine - my children are all grown and flown, doing their own thing. I willingly worked Christmas Eve, Boxing Day, etc. so other people could spend time with their children. Sadly, when I needed (not wanted) to actually take my days, I was met with verbal abuse.
No good deed goes unpunished. I haven't done it since, which I find very sad, to be honest. One person in particular, actually called me "a fucking selfish bitch" because I needed to take my days. Even though, for the last three out of five years, I'd quite happily let her have two of my holiday days.
I needed to take some time because I was losing my sister to cancer. Admittedly, it wasn't common knowledge, but even so. Sadly, the few ruin it for the many. I'm not sure I'd be willing to do it again. I didn't even "sell" my days. I was happy to do it.

sammylady37 · 03/12/2021 03:33

@Iseestupidpeople

Well there’s a lot of child hating Karens on here.
Oh dear.

At least you didn’t opt for ‘cool girls’ or ‘handmaidens’ when choosing your misogynistic insult, I guess.

If you can point out any child-hating posts, I’d be interested to see them. You’ll find plenty of people who are indifferent to the children of their colleagues, but i don’t recall any child hating on the thread.

sammylady37 · 03/12/2021 03:31

*It is incomprehensible to me that people cannot be bothered to recruit and cultivate an array of babysitters and cooperative arrangements with friends/neighbors so that childcare in December isn't dependent on coworker sacrifices.

I put more thought into finding backup care for my dog! Starting before I acquired him because i knew the need would arise. Isn't that bare minimum?*

Absolutely. I said something similar earlier. It’s basic common sense and it’s the responsible thing to do. But apparently I was being unfair to say that.
It’s also not as if Christmas is a surprise. It’s December 25th. Every. Single. Year. It doesn’t exactly sneak up on people out of the blue.

silentpool · 03/12/2021 01:49

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Quotes deleted post.

Iseestupidpeople · 03/12/2021 01:34

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

Ostagazuzulum · 03/12/2021 01:33

Out of curiosity OP (and I'm not being goading) how do you manage childcare in school holidays? I desperately struggle and have been known to stay awake for nearly 48 hours (give I'd take a couple of hours before shift starts when DHgets in at 7pm) to be able to do night shifts whilst DH is early shift and we simply can't find any family/ friends to help out and childminders wont do adhoc days. It's such a struggle I do wonder how others manage.

We factored this in when we chose to have a child but we are both emergency services and the nature of our job means that we can have our shifts changed and dictated to and cancelled days off with minimal notice. Hence why we have no choice but to take leave.

Kanaloa · 03/12/2021 01:28

Until you're in that predicament of needing to have holidays off to make sure your kids are looked after our of school, you can't really sympathize.

I’m in exactly that case. I have to carefully plan which jobs I can take and work it out with DH so that we can cover childcare between us. It means I have to mostly work evenings right now. When the children were small I worked at a nursery to cover this.

It’s life. Yes it’s hard but it’s not other people’s problem.

Ostagazuzulum · 03/12/2021 01:25

I sit on fence slightly here, I see your point. Child free people shouldn't be penalised however childcare is extortionate so I totally get why parents need that time off at peak times during holidays. Plus children do need that quality time with parents. For those that say you chose to have kids therefore pay childcare.... in last ten years the cost of living has exploded. Sadly salaries haven't risen proportionately to meet this. Those who say get a better Paid job to meet childcare costs? I think last year proved that we need the lower paid jobs like retail workers for society to function. We don't all have grandparents / friends/ family to help out. It's so different from generations ago when there were more stay at home mums and extended family to help etc. Until you're in that predicament of needing to have holidays off to make sure your kids are looked after our of school, you can't really sympathize.

But I do understand why those without kids feel it's unfair. Maybe some companies should look at balancing it out. If there's high demand for everyone to have peak time off, what about this who don't take leave in peak time get a couple of extra days leave each year to balance out the fairness...???

There's no right answer I guess, for me tho the needs of the child come first

DdraigGoch · 03/12/2021 01:21

At my workplace there are union agreements regarding annual leave which are scrupulously fair. Block weeks leave is done on rotation, if you want to change your weeks you need to either find a vacant block, or someone willing to swap.

Individual days are first come, first served, so a flurry of emails gets sent to the roster clerk at 12:00 on a particular day in the autumn with the first requests for the next year. The first one in the book is guaranteed their leave, everyone else must wait until three days before the shift to see if they can be spared. Being declined doesn't happen too often.

Other depots have ballots for Christmas Eve/NYE/NYD but they remain first come, first served for us.

Meh2020 · 03/12/2021 00:55

I don’t think it should be one or the other.

Being part of a team means you work as a team; do you not all discuss your leave requirements, cover arrangements and who worked last special family holiday before submitting your leave requests?

If not maybe try it as it will take away the divisiveness - it shouldn’t be pitted as no children against those with children

silentpool · 03/12/2021 00:44

In my workplace, the parents take plenty of flexibility - school runs 2x a day, school functions etc and I don't begrudge them that. In return, I will leave early for appointments etc. The expectation is that you do your work and that works fine, without inconveniencing others.

However, we do not have conflicts over holidays as it is acknowledged in our team that everyone has obligations of various kinds. I don't even factor in other people's obligations when I book leave and why should I? They don't worry about mine!

Our particular bit of the business will never run at popular holiday times - so they are downtimes for all. The whole business shuts for Christmas for 2 weeks. So, conflict is unlikely.