Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think there is often really terrible advice on here?

291 replies

Ahmadame · 30/11/2021 18:17

I mean, people suggest completely random shit and then get quite indignant if an OP says they won’t be taking it.

I don’t know if it’s just me but I regularly see weird suggestions on here, or suggestions that are clearly unworkable (like ‘home school your kids’) and I sometimes don’t know if they are serious or not.

What’s the worst bit of MN advice you’ve seen?

OP posts:
GetTheFlockOutOfHere · 30/11/2021 21:13

'Show them this thread' pisses me off too. I mean, (as has been said) how on EARTH can anything positive be achieved by doing that?

UnsolicitedDickPic · 30/11/2021 21:12

@DrSbaitso

Does anyone have a link to the melons and strawberries thread? My first thought was that there must be a context because even by MN standards that's a bit extreme...
There's slightly more going on than just forgetting some melon. In essence, woman carries entire burden of the home, man is largely useless. The melon was the tip of the iceberg lettuce.
GetTheFlockOutOfHere · 30/11/2021 21:11

Oh yeah 'JUST ADOPT' being said to people struggling to conceive makes me cringe. What a stupid and ignorant thing to say.

yamadori · 30/11/2021 21:08

There are some occasions when all the experts in the world would not be able to give the OP the correct advice. It usually starts with:

'Can anyone tell me what type of plant/tree we need to buy here?'

And then a whole list of totally impossible requirements - it must be fast-growing to cover an eyesore, but as soon as it reaches the required height it needs to stop growing immediately and never grow any bigger. It needs to be evergreen. It needs to have lots of lovely flowers (preferably pink or white) all year round. It must cast no shade whatever at any time of year. It must require absolutely no maintenance or watering. It must be strong and robust enough to withstand footballs, random intruders and dog attack, yet must also be feathery, delicate, without any thorns and definitely not poisonous. It should not produce the sort of berries which children like to pick. It needs to be able to grow in deep shade / full sun / and either bone dry or permanently boggy soil. It must never overhang the neighbour's garden and must not drop so much as a single leaf. Ever.

Good luck with finding all that on a plant app Grin

maybe build a brick wall and paint a tree on it instead

Teacupsandtrainers · 30/11/2021 21:02

There was a thread that got deleted a while ago about someone who was pregnant and an aspirin prescription which got pretty out of hand.

Simonjt · 30/11/2021 20:59

I was told to leave my partner because he asked me to iron a duvet cover, the same poster said this was a sure sign I was in a joyless and controlling relationship 🤣 poster then discovered that I’m a man and decided that I should do all the ironing, because I clearly don’t do anything else (despite being a single parent!) and he was clearly only asking me because I must be lazy.

On a thread about type one diabetes a poster (more than once) advising to give someone with low blood sugar insulin, I mean, I’m not sure ending up in prison due to manslaughter would be a great option.

DrSbaitso · 30/11/2021 20:57

Does anyone have a link to the melons and strawberries thread? My first thought was that there must be a context because even by MN standards that's a bit extreme...

Lndnmummy · 30/11/2021 20:57

The ones that entertain precious parenting kills me. "Call the head first thing and demand a meeting or "insist to speak to the chair of Gov" because little Edith didn't get a sticker or bla bla bla. No, how about tell Edith that she'll get a sticker next time and leave the school to get on with teaching.

lescompagnonsdeloue · 30/11/2021 20:56

@cherrypie66

Someone was told to leave their husband the other day because he went to the shops but forgot the melon and the strawberries. Classic Mumsnet
I don't think you can have read that thread at all.
lescompagnonsdeloue · 30/11/2021 20:55

I agree with "show them this thread". Has that ever been good advice? Did that ever work out for anybody?
Also, "you should just move". What?

ChicCroissant · 30/11/2021 20:51

The most irritating for me is people saying that employers are not allowed to give a bad reference - utter bollocks, yes they can. References have to be justified, but you can give a bad reference if it's justified. Jobs don't have to be advertised externally either, which is another one that crops up a lot.

The legal advice - you get a poster who doesn't want to pay a solicitor, and cherry picks the posts that agree with their (faulty) interpretation. That can't be fun further down the line.

cherrypie66 · 30/11/2021 20:46

Someone was told to leave their husband the other day because he went to the shops but forgot the melon and the strawberries. Classic Mumsnet

DrSbaitso · 30/11/2021 20:46

I presume it’s my thread you are referring to?

Yes, of course. And as I said there, don't allow yourself to continue to act outside of your best interests for fear of receiving the latest insult du jour. Especially from that person, although to be fair, you should dismiss that kind of crap wherever it comes from.

Constellationstation · 30/11/2021 20:43

@hotmeatymilk

A man has always done something for the worst possible reason and nothing is ever an innocent mistake. This is true, though. And not in a “magick is real” way.
Grin
hotmeatymilk · 30/11/2021 20:42

A man has always done something for the worst possible reason and nothing is ever an innocent mistake.
This is true, though. And not in a “magick is real” way.

Constellationstation · 30/11/2021 20:40

There was one where someone’s daughter of about 9 was upset that her friends were better off than her and it seemed almost unanimous that the family should move to a cheaper area and move schools because of it.

Also the suspicion of men is crazy at times. A man has always done something for the worst possible reason and nothing is ever an innocent mistake.

EnglishMuffins · 30/11/2021 20:39

@DrSbaitso

Nor the worst I've seen, but earlier today a charmer told an unmarried SAHM, who is not on the deeds or mortgage for her partner's home despite putting her £25k divorce settlement into it, that anyone who said this was a cause for concern and her relationship could fail was just "bitter".

User has a clear agenda, but OP might not have been familiar with that person's other pearls of wisdom.

I presume it’s my thread you are referring to?

Ive not been on MN long but absolutely anything in some people’s eyes is a reason to up and leave your partner/spouse. As if in real life it’s actually that simple.. like “my oh did xyz” and some people will be like “omg, leave/divorce them NOW”

hotmeatymilk · 30/11/2021 20:38

I enjoy the complete non-advice, usually in relation to life with a newborn and a lazy dickhead DH:

“I had one twin vaginally and one by emergency C-section. It was lambing season and DH HAD to go away for a month but I managed to get out in the fields at 6am, elbow deep in sheep, a twin in each armpit, and still make a roast for my in-laws, it’s just birth, why are you making such a fuss.”

Maireas · 30/11/2021 20:37

There's a hilarious one at the moment - woman wants to have her sons privately educated, but is worried about the cost -
"Start saving money by batch cooking"
😂😂😂

oldstudentmum · 30/11/2021 20:34

I agree in part but I think it’s more down to the individual is who offers advice. They might have a different lifestyle to someone posting. Eg I’m leaving an partner who hits me. Some will say phone police get ducks in a row grab passports anything important
Not thinking perhaps these people are in low paid jobs etc no family and just trapped by circumstances it’s always complicated and can be very diverse.
. However these people are probably (not always) in rented property probably don’t have “shared bank accounts “ shared anything.
I learned over 25 years ago DO NOT HAVE A SHARED ACCOUNT “ I learnt that the bad way. My advise no matter how good things are etc make sure you have an emergency account! Just in case

Moonface123 · 30/11/2021 20:32

Many kids are succesfully homeschooled so its a valid answer, unless you lack the courage or imagination to do something different.
Just because some of the advice doesnt fit into your own way of thinking doesn't mean its wrong, or of no value.
The intention behind the advice is to try and be helpful, thats the main thing.

hopingforabrighterfuture2021 · 30/11/2021 20:31

Oh yes, as PP said above, LTB when there is no DV or emotional abuse or anything else really major. Marriages are not perfect, but getting divorced is a HUGE deal, and not something to be done off the back of the husband not helping enough around the house or whatever.

FirewomanSam · 30/11/2021 20:28

To women struggling to conceive-
"Just relax!"
I've seen that a lot on here.

Or ‘just stop trying and it’ll happen’ or some variation on that. Ok but… basic biology dictates you have to ‘try’ a little bit, right?!

Maireas · 30/11/2021 20:17

To women struggling to conceive-
"Just relax!"
I've seen that a lot on here.

UnsuitableHat · 30/11/2021 20:14

Sometimes it’s not so much the advice itself as the indignation when it isn’t immediately taken. ‘OP, you were told to leave him yesterday and you haven’t. What’s the point of advice if you won’t take it?’