Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think there is often really terrible advice on here?

291 replies

Ahmadame · 30/11/2021 18:17

I mean, people suggest completely random shit and then get quite indignant if an OP says they won’t be taking it.

I don’t know if it’s just me but I regularly see weird suggestions on here, or suggestions that are clearly unworkable (like ‘home school your kids’) and I sometimes don’t know if they are serious or not.

What’s the worst bit of MN advice you’ve seen?

OP posts:
Thecurtainsofdestiny · 30/11/2021 22:18

So much inappropriate medical advice, or people guessing at diagnoses.

There's almost never enough information given for this.

BadLad · 30/11/2021 22:17

@DrSbaitso

Can someone link to the "give them the house" thread? I remember it vaguely but can't find it.
www.mumsnet.com/Talk/property/2201323-I-want-to-evict-a-tenant-who-has-been-there-for-40-years

It's not a thread to cause anyone to sit open-mouthed at the number of posters suggesting giving the house away. It only comes up briefly and is mocked soon afterwards.

PurpleDaisies · 30/11/2021 22:16

Yes! And “no is a complete sentence”. In pretty much any real life situation, it isn’t!

WorraLiberty · 30/11/2021 22:15

@5128gap

The advice on 'witty' put downs to supposedly put people who've annoyed you in their place. When in reality if you used them you'd either have them laugh in your face, or punch you in it.
I often think of the cringeworthy "Did you mean to be so rude?"

Yes, of course I did. Are you thick as well as stupid? 🤔😂

5128gap · 30/11/2021 22:05

The advice on 'witty' put downs to supposedly put people who've annoyed you in their place. When in reality if you used them you'd either have them laugh in your face, or punch you in it.

KurtWildesChristmasNamechange · 30/11/2021 22:01

When OP is clearly in a dodgy situation with a volatile partner and posters tell her to do things that would likely put her in danger. Lost count of the amount of times I've had to say 'don't do this!!'

DrSbaitso · 30/11/2021 22:00

The number of people suggesting the OP should cause a huge confrontational scene in the meeting, or drop in hugely cutting remarks so that ex-bully wouldknowand be sitting their squirming was ridiculous. What senior professional reactivates a 20 year-old feud in the middle of a meeting with all their management team present?

There are a LOT of people on here who really overestimate the power of a "cutting" remark in an entirely inappropriate situation or a billion years too late. The hush you get, if you get it, isn't your old nemesis suddenly seeing the error of their ways and being cut to the quick with humiliation and remorse, nor is it the audience seeing the evil villain with new clarity. It's just a roomful of people wondering why you're being so incredibly inappropriate and wondering what to do now you've made everything so awkward.

It's telling how often this advice is followed by "and then walk away". So it's just a way of getting the last word? What if they answer back?

Darkpheonix · 30/11/2021 21:54

@WomanStanleyWoman that old school bully one was insane.

DrSbaitso · 30/11/2021 21:54

@Skysblue

Yes. The replies I most dislike are where the OP is a young mum with several young children and has a fairly petty argument with her husband, on whom she’s completely financially reliant, and hundreds of posters pile on to say she should divorce him immediately.
The thing is, with those threads, the petty argument that sparked them is usually just the latest manifestation of a relationship that's actually pretty deeply rotten. As the thread goes on, more and more background gets revealed. Very few people in healthy, happy relationships take to the internet about them when they have what truly is a minor tiff over nothing important.

I'm honestly more worried by the number of women living in truly horrible relationships but as soon as this starts to be made clear to them, suddenly insist that we've all got it wrong, they've been unfair and shown him badly, he's so lovely really.

And if there are so many unhappy women who can't leave because of money, that's also something we should be talking about.

5128gap · 30/11/2021 21:53

When an OP posts about her partner's unacceptable behaviour there is a chorus of 'you just need to tell him to...' As if he's only awful because the OP hasn't told him his to behave, and once she does he will immediately see the error of his ways.
A lot of the advice on dealing with extended family is over dramatic and disproportionate. In RL people don't want to cause family rifts by being rude and aggressive to MILs who buy a nursery rug without asking first.
Any advice that is based on projection with no attempt to empathise with the OP. Like LTB when the OP has stated she doesn't want to.
Employment, benefits, debt and legal advice based on zero knowledge of the law.

WomanStanleyWoman · 30/11/2021 21:53

@funinthesun19

When people say “You’ve got a DH problem”. I’m sure the poster’s husband is a problem but so is the person causing trouble in the first place e.g. an ex wife or in law.
Oh God yes. Yes, the husband should be more supportive when the MIL tells the OP she’s a slatternly whore who belongs in a sewer, but it’s not his fault she said it.
WomanStanleyWoman · 30/11/2021 21:47

There are too many examples to count Grin but one recent one that really sticks out for me is the thread where a woman in quite a senior role thought that, based on name, the sales rep coming to see her was her former school bully.

The number of people suggesting the OP should cause a huge confrontational scene in the meeting, or drop in hugely cutting remarks so that ex-bully would know and be sitting their squirming was ridiculous. What senior professional reactivates a 20 year-old feud in the middle of a meeting with all their management team present? Someone even suggested engaging the bully’s company and then deliberately making her life hell. When I suggested this would cause a lot of problems for the OP, I was told how laughably stupid I was, because anyone who complained about a client would be sacked on the spot. Yeah, that’s how professional businesses operate 🙄

I also remember a nice but very deluded woman who wanted to offer her top budget of £480k for her £630k dream house because ‘They might say yes, mightn’t they? I mean you never know?!?!’ Most people were sensible enough to tell her it was never going to happen - cue a response of ‘Awwh no!!! Sad Really?! I thought you’d all tell me to go for it SadSad’ Then some idiot weighed in saying ‘My aunt offered £120k under the asking price and got it, so you never know’. Of course, NiceButDeluded25 then ignores all the sensible advice she’s been given and gets her hopes right back up.

Teenagequeenwithaloadedgun · 30/11/2021 21:46

I remember a woman who was worried that her husband was having an affair with a school run mum that she knew.

Someone suggested that she 1) spread rumours about OW 2) steal her DH's phone and arrange a meeting 3) turn up at the meeting instead and say he wasn't coming because he was bored of her.

I still think of this advice often.

WorraLiberty · 30/11/2021 21:40

You don't see it so much now but in the Relationships topic - "Just pack his bags and change the locks".

Yeah, because it's totally legal to just tip someone out of their own home like that 🙄

Skysblue · 30/11/2021 21:39

Yes. The replies I most dislike are where the OP is a young mum with several young children and has a fairly petty argument with her husband, on whom she’s completely financially reliant, and hundreds of posters pile on to say she should divorce him immediately.

funinthesun19 · 30/11/2021 21:39

When people say “You’ve got a DH problem”.

I’m sure the poster’s husband is a problem but so is the person causing trouble in the first place e.g. an ex wife or in law.

Comingup · 30/11/2021 21:36

Really awful one on the thread where the OP is wanting to control her SIL pregnancy due to struggling with her own infertility.
She go told " her time will come, try to enjoy this stage"
The worst possible thing to say when there is no guarantee ever of success, just wow🙄

Chasingaftermidnight · 30/11/2021 21:36

And don’t get me started on this “free 30 minutes” bollocks. Many of us, in fact probably most of us, just don’t do that!

I’ve never understood that at all. In order to give advice solicitors need to onboard someone as a client - performing conflict checks, getting KYC etc. Then they need all the factual details and documents in order to be able to advise. Maybe there are some firms who advertise ‘30 minutes free’ to get people through the door, but where this idea came from that every solicitor ‘owes’ you a free 30 minutes I’ve no idea.

Smokeahontas · 30/11/2021 21:34

I’m not sure it necessarily counts as advice, but the people on the Christmas gift threads that like giving as little as possible to their kids at Christmas. Not for financial reasons etc.

Allthatglittersandgold · 30/11/2021 21:34

It amazes me. Not so much the crazy advice but there are actual human beings with these thought processes. Although I do read a lot of it with a pinch of salt.

VikingOnTheFridge · 30/11/2021 21:30

@DrSbaitso

Nor the worst I've seen, but earlier today a charmer told an unmarried SAHM, who is not on the deeds or mortgage for her partner's home despite putting her £25k divorce settlement into it, that anyone who said this was a cause for concern and her relationship could fail was just "bitter".

User has a clear agenda, but OP might not have been familiar with that person's other pearls of wisdom.

There's always at least one on those threads.
MrsPinkCock · 30/11/2021 21:28

@DelphiniumBlue

People with no legal training giving wrong legal advice, based on what they think should be the case in an ideal world, rather than based on actual law.
As an actual lawyer, this, 100%. Some of the “advice” given is appalling!

And don’t get me started on this “free 30 minutes” bollocks. Many of us, in fact probably most of us, just don’t do that!

GetTheFlockOutOfHere · 30/11/2021 21:27

@Simonjt Flowers Smile

Antsgomarching · 30/11/2021 21:24

Telling people not to go to a&e. It’s the worst thing to do, it makes people feel ashamed for using health services they are entitled to use. I’m thinking of the lady who had an excruciating lump and it turned out to be cancer.

Simonjt · 30/11/2021 21:18

@GetTheFlockOutOfHere

Oh yeah 'JUST ADOPT' being said to people struggling to conceive makes me cringe. What a stupid and ignorant thing to say.
Ha yes! I’m a parent through adoption, and soon to have number two arriving. It really isn’t for the faint hearted and you have to want to adopt, rather than just wanting to be a parent/have a baby, they’re two completely different things. The whole ‘just adopt’ also down plays the grief that poster will be suffering due to fertility problems.