Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think there is often really terrible advice on here?

291 replies

Ahmadame · 30/11/2021 18:17

I mean, people suggest completely random shit and then get quite indignant if an OP says they won’t be taking it.

I don’t know if it’s just me but I regularly see weird suggestions on here, or suggestions that are clearly unworkable (like ‘home school your kids’) and I sometimes don’t know if they are serious or not.

What’s the worst bit of MN advice you’ve seen?

OP posts:
slashlover · 01/12/2021 11:20

Some people don't even try to give advice and reply just to add their oh so witty comments.

Did you ever visit the Sistine Chapel OP?
*Did you snap and fart OP?"

Followed by lots of LOL!!!!!!11!! replies.

DrSbaitso · 01/12/2021 11:02

He could have cut his nose off and shoved onions up his own bottom

I'd read that thread.

gannett · 01/12/2021 10:55

@WellBuggerMeSideways

"Red flags" can be hilarious, too. These were some of the ones mentioned over the last few dating threads I browsed/ participated in:

-being overweight (must be lazy)
-earning less than the woman (must be after her money)
-not being the first to drive to a date a distance away (a sure sign she will do all the work in the relationship)
-splitting the food bill (must be tight)
-not wanting to take a stranger back to their place on a first date (must have something to hide)
-answering a phone call (wrong priorities)
-not texting back immediately (clearly isn't into the OP)
-feeling too comfortable too soon (must be love bombing/ future faking)
-not suggesting a place to meet after date 1 and leaving it up to the OP (can't be much into her)
-any kind of trying to have some privacy (must be having an affair)

I've been on the receiving end of a fair few Red Flag questions in my most recent thread. The guy I am with was fascinated this morning when I told him to stop worrying about not ringing last night, because he was caught up in a hobby, and that he, too, was entitled to his own space. Because in past relationships he always felt he had to be at the women's beg and call every second of the day, for fear of being labelled uncaring/ cheating/ smothering.

MNetters, this is what some of these threads are doing to relationships (not that I'm complaining too much, he think's I'm the bee's knees because I have reasonable expectations Grin).

It's always funny when I read about surefire Red Flags that described my own behaviour in the early days of my relationship with DP to a tee.

That's 10 years ago so obviously the flags can't have been that red!

The "if he hasn't texted you in 90 minutes he's just not that into you" ones are the craziest but I'm also relieved that the constant messagers are taking themselves out of the dating pool, for the sake of everyone else in it.

BadLad · 01/12/2021 10:45

@WellBuggerMeSideways

"Red flags" can be hilarious, too. These were some of the ones mentioned over the last few dating threads I browsed/ participated in:

-being overweight (must be lazy)
-earning less than the woman (must be after her money)
-not being the first to drive to a date a distance away (a sure sign she will do all the work in the relationship)
-splitting the food bill (must be tight)
-not wanting to take a stranger back to their place on a first date (must have something to hide)
-answering a phone call (wrong priorities)
-not texting back immediately (clearly isn't into the OP)
-feeling too comfortable too soon (must be love bombing/ future faking)
-not suggesting a place to meet after date 1 and leaving it up to the OP (can't be much into her)
-any kind of trying to have some privacy (must be having an affair)

I've been on the receiving end of a fair few Red Flag questions in my most recent thread. The guy I am with was fascinated this morning when I told him to stop worrying about not ringing last night, because he was caught up in a hobby, and that he, too, was entitled to his own space. Because in past relationships he always felt he had to be at the women's beg and call every second of the day, for fear of being labelled uncaring/ cheating/ smothering.

MNetters, this is what some of these threads are doing to relationships (not that I'm complaining too much, he think's I'm the bee's knees because I have reasonable expectations Grin).

You don't see it mentioned so much now, but a few years ago The Script found its way onto nearly every affair thread. No matter what a suspected adulterer did when confronted, someone would say it was all part of the script. He could have cut his nose off and shoved onions up his own bottom and another poster would still pipe up about how predictable he was, following The Script.
WellBuggerMeSideways · 01/12/2021 10:29

"Red flags" can be hilarious, too.
These were some of the ones mentioned over the last few dating threads I browsed/ participated in:

-being overweight (must be lazy)
-earning less than the woman (must be after her money)
-not being the first to drive to a date a distance away (a sure sign she will do all the work in the relationship)
-splitting the food bill (must be tight)
-not wanting to take a stranger back to their place on a first date (must have something to hide)
-answering a phone call (wrong priorities)
-not texting back immediately (clearly isn't into the OP)
-feeling too comfortable too soon (must be love bombing/ future faking)
-not suggesting a place to meet after date 1 and leaving it up to the OP (can't be much into her)
-any kind of trying to have some privacy (must be having an affair)

I've been on the receiving end of a fair few Red Flag questions in my most recent thread. The guy I am with was fascinated this morning when I told him to stop worrying about not ringing last night, because he was caught up in a hobby, and that he, too, was entitled to his own space. Because in past relationships he always felt he had to be at the women's beg and call every second of the day, for fear of being labelled uncaring/ cheating/ smothering.

MNetters, this is what some of these threads are doing to relationships (not that I'm complaining too much, he think's I'm the bee's knees because I have reasonable expectations Grin).

theelephantinthegroup · 01/12/2021 09:41

I hate it when people who clearly have no understanding of the OPs financial position come on to tell her she's basically brought all her problems on herself and if she could just try harder everything would be fine. Eg. One of the first threads I remember was a single mother of 3, doing a minimum wage job around school hours, children's father was useless and she was feeling overwhelmed with juggling work, child-care, cooking, washing, cleaning etc. Loads of posters told her she should work longer hours and pay a cleaner. She was also berated for having children with such a useless man (not something she can change, and I'm guessing part of the reason he was an ex).

The double standards make me laugh. Eg. 1) I need to work extra hours to work towards a promotion but can't find child care and don't have family nearby. Answer= Surely there must be a friend who would help you out, why not ask some of the other school mums? 2) Someone I don't know that well has asked me to take their child to school whilst their car is at the garage, should I agree. Answer= No! You will end up being expected to take them everywhere for ever. This person is a CF of the highest order

DrSbaitso · 01/12/2021 09:24

There was a thread on here the other day about quiet people and a lot of posters came on to basically say "I can't be bothered to engage with people so why should I?"

Interestingly, I find a lot of those people engage very much online via forums and social media. I think what a lot of them mean is they've lost the skill of actual voice-based conversation, or maybe they never had it. It is a skill, and it can be learned and polished, but in our digital world it probably is easier not to if you can't be bothered.

But it's still a useful and sometimes necessary skill...

KurtWildesChristmasNamechange · 01/12/2021 09:22

'Dodged a bullet' when OP has been on one date and isn't sure if there was chemistry and he hasn't texted her back immediately. Like ffs give the bloke a chance, it's been ONE date!

When an OP is encouraged to give her partner the silent treatment (for whatever misdemeanour) but when an OP posts that her partner is giving her the silent treatment it's LTB he's abusive.

thepeopleversuswork · 01/12/2021 09:16

I'm not sure the nature of dialogue around mental health is the most helpful. Obviously it depends on the condition and the situation, but I do think there's too much focus on what you should expect other people to do to support your mental health, and not enough on techniques for managing it yourself.

I agree. It's good that the stigma around mental health is beginning to lift but it sometimes becomes a bit of a get-out-of-jail-free card for people who can't be arsed to engage with negative patterns of behaviour or to lash out at others.

You routinely see posters come on here talking about a man who is chronically unemployed and won't lift a finger in the home but has to be cut slack "because of his mental health" for example.

By the same token there is a lot of very militantly selfish behaviour by people who use "mental health" as a refusal to engage in any way with the outside world and indulge in a sort of militant antisocialness. There was a thread on here the other day about quiet people and a lot of posters came on to basically say "I can't be bothered to engage with people so why should I?"

Drivingmisspotty · 01/12/2021 09:13

Not advice really but I hate it when a poster comes on upset with their partner, thinking about LTB but they have two kids and one on the way and replies come back ‘why on earth did you have three kids with him?’

A logical question, if human beings were totally logical, but we all know that there are many reasons someone might stay in a bad relationship including grooming, societal expectations of women, hope that somehow things will get better/he will change. And the question only serves to make an already vulnerable poster feel even shittier.

dottiedodah · 01/12/2021 09:13

YABU I think .Most advice on here has been very good .Obv there are a few niggles ,but generally helpful and kind IMO

5128gap · 01/12/2021 09:10

I've noticed that the advice and tone directed at OPs whose language, grammar and spelling does not conform to the MN 'house style' can be particularly judgemental. Any OP who dares to use 'was' for 'were', the wrong to or there, or a colloquialism is very quickly addressed as though she is some sort of stupid, feckless undesirable, with children to be pitied, and a miscreant for a partner.

Littleants · 01/12/2021 09:08

Marry your abusive partner so you can divorce him for his money. In what world does it help someone to get even more intertwined with an abuser? There is no guarantee of money and if he is abusive, the likelihood of you getting any is fat chance.

Bexxe · 01/12/2021 09:07

My pet peeve is whenever someone writes of an issue with their DP, even if its something that could clearly be worked on, there is atleast 20 people going 'sack him off' 'leave him now' ' get out of there as fast as you can' - a lot of the time just saying that without offerring any reason or explanation to their logic.

Like they want everyone to be alone for the sake of it instead of working on their relationship - drives me mad.

bonfireheart · 01/12/2021 09:05

People on MN pretend to care about mental health, but then thinking nothing off ripping into someone or behaving like a playground bully to make fun of them.

astoundedgoat · 01/12/2021 09:05

@ICanSeeARainbow123

How about "if you don't like where you are, move". Okay the OP can just pack up a Wendy House and start again tomorrow.

Fuck off.

That said, there was a lady yesterday who hates where she lives with a fiery passion, and when someone suggested she move somewhere else, she said "no, we'd have to dip into our savings." Confused
Rissole · 01/12/2021 09:02

I think you have to read it through a lens of hoping there is a nugget or two of information you didn't know and that might be helpful and try not to take any of it to heart.

A superficial interaction only and the vital info will lodge.

gannett · 01/12/2021 08:58

I'm not sure the nature of dialogue around mental health is the most helpful. Obviously it depends on the condition and the situation, but I do think there's too much focus on what you should expect other people to do to support your mental health, and not enough on techniques for managing it yourself. There is plenty of focus on comparing it to physical health, but there's also an expectation that you'll make time to do your physio exercises.

IMO the bit everyone avoids talking about is professional mental health services and the funding of them. It's a political issue.

But I've also seen that people who take steps to pre-emptively protect their own mental health are also castigated (especially when this mildly inconveniences others).

HailAdrian · 01/12/2021 08:56

Anytime someone composes a message for OP to send. Always makes me cringe.

5128gap · 01/12/2021 08:55

@Darkpheonix

One thing I also do not really understand is why here it's all the married men who have affairs? In real life I know many more married women who had affairs than men. Is that because if women admitted to that they'd be flamed here? Or maybe my evidence is skewed.

I think its a few things. If a husband cheats on his wife, she is the injures party and is more likely to go to a women centered forum and post anonymously. Lots of people dont feel ready to talk to the in RL, so this is a good place.

Less people, who are cheating will come looking for advice here.

I also think in Real life, women cheating is talked about less. Men, are less inclined to tell everyone she cheated and the women are less likely to brag about it in public.

Whenever a woman posts that she is cheating she is bullied mercilessly. Either directly or insidiously, with 'advice' that will effectively punish her for her misdeeds. I understand people have strong views on this, but if its such a trigger it would be better not engaging rather than turning the OP into a proxy emotional punch bag, when she is generally already at a low point to be posting in the first place.
LakieLady · 01/12/2021 08:51

Telling people to claim housing benefit or tax credits when claimants haven't been able to make new claims (apart from in a couple of very specific scenarios) for ages isn't that terrible, but it makes me chuckle and could cost people a few quid if it means they delay starting a UC claim.

DrSbaitso · 01/12/2021 08:49

@gannett

The posters who think they're in a soap and queue up to tell OPs in delicate situations to make it worse with passive-aggressive (or just aggressive-aggressive) words and actions - the worst.

The genre of awful advice that does my head in is the hypocrisy around mental health. Most of MN talks a good game about the importance of protecting your own mental health ("I need my husband to go to the office... because of my mental health", "I need to go trailing around shopping centres for leisure in the middle of a pandemic... for my mental health"). The minute someone else's mental health mildly inconveniences or upsets you? They're a cheeky fucker, they're making it up, you shouldn't take them seriously, you should bin them off, and if they're your husband then he's a pathetic unmanly wuss and you couldn't possibly be attracted to that.

Well, 'twas ever thus.

I'm not sure the nature of dialogue around mental health is the most helpful. Obviously it depends on the condition and the situation, but I do think there's too much focus on what you should expect other people to do to support your mental health, and not enough on techniques for managing it yourself. There is plenty of focus on comparing it to physical health, but there's also an expectation that you'll make time to do your physio exercises.

thefourgp · 01/12/2021 08:46

The worst one I ever saw was someone complaining about a man who had wronged her (I can’t remember what he did - it was a few years ago) and another poster asked her to private message a screenshot of his Facebook profile so she could start an online rumour he was a paedophile (which he wasn’t) to ‘get back at him’. The OP definitely sent the stranger his profile because they were making jokes about photos of him and the new girlfriend on the thread.
I was so shocked. I reported the thread and told the OP how wrong she was to do that. The two of them (who both sounded incredibly immature) had no remorse and it took Mumsnet ages to take the thread down. I’ve no idea if she followed through on her intention to do that to him - ruin the life of a complete stranger.

gannett · 01/12/2021 08:39

The posters who think they're in a soap and queue up to tell OPs in delicate situations to make it worse with passive-aggressive (or just aggressive-aggressive) words and actions - the worst.

The genre of awful advice that does my head in is the hypocrisy around mental health. Most of MN talks a good game about the importance of protecting your own mental health ("I need my husband to go to the office... because of my mental health", "I need to go trailing around shopping centres for leisure in the middle of a pandemic... for my mental health"). The minute someone else's mental health mildly inconveniences or upsets you? They're a cheeky fucker, they're making it up, you shouldn't take them seriously, you should bin them off, and if they're your husband then he's a pathetic unmanly wuss and you couldn't possibly be attracted to that.

slashlover · 01/12/2021 08:20

If a couple split and the guy doesn't want to see the kids then he's an arsehole (rightly), if he wants EOW then he's out having fun while the OP toils, if he wants 50/50 then he's taking the kids away from their mother, if he wants full custody then he's an arsehole.