Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think there is often really terrible advice on here?

291 replies

Ahmadame · 30/11/2021 18:17

I mean, people suggest completely random shit and then get quite indignant if an OP says they won’t be taking it.

I don’t know if it’s just me but I regularly see weird suggestions on here, or suggestions that are clearly unworkable (like ‘home school your kids’) and I sometimes don’t know if they are serious or not.

What’s the worst bit of MN advice you’ve seen?

OP posts:
plieddried · 03/12/2021 02:06

I’ve seen a mix of bad and good advice. It’s up to you whether you take it or not.

mowly77 · 03/12/2021 01:20

Too many LTB over trivial things. Or things that might better be addressed in counselling first at least. Not talking DV or EA or infidelities etc of course.

And even if the LTB is possibly good advice it’s not that fucking easy - if you share a house; children; a mortgage/ tenancy & you are not wealthy enough to buy him out/ buy you and DCs a new place etc what are you supposed to do? Waltz out with your kids broke and homeless? It’s a long involved and very awful abs difficult process.

bonfireheart · 03/12/2021 01:09

@euromamaAussieKids yes! I get so annoyed when people snitch and get the thread deleted.

Atemyhat · 03/12/2021 00:12

Really terrible parenting advice for Troubled Teens. Variations of:

Take away everything
Lock them inside
Kick them out

So much #facepalm

EuromamaAussiekids · 03/12/2021 00:07

It's hard to tell. Most 'interesting' threads here get deleted anyway 😂 🤷🏾‍♂️

PinkKecks · 03/12/2021 00:00

No money? Give up takeaway coffees and you'll have saved up a deposit for a house by Christmas.

Stressed? Just get a cleaner so you don't have to worry about the housework.

Husband left the loo seat up? LTB, he sounds like a narcissist.

saraclara · 02/12/2021 23:32

I'm imagining the OP where someone's partner presented her with a thread from his blokes' forum where he'd OPd about a problem he was having with her.

"Here, look at these 500 posts from people who think you're an unreasonable bitch and I should leave you. Then you'll understand why you're wrong and I'm right"

VikingOnTheFridge · 02/12/2021 22:57

@BookFiend4Life

I see a lot of suggestions to "go part time" to solve various problems. No job I've ever had would have let me reduce my hours, and in many cases people usually need all their income? I'm in the US so maybe it's more common in the UK but part time jobs are not thick on the ground here.
That's often better advice than you'd think, especially when the poster isn't a particularly high earner and has higher childcare costs. Not particularly uncommon to be working for very little or a loss on the 5th day.
BookFiend4Life · 02/12/2021 17:36

I see a lot of suggestions to "go part time" to solve various problems. No job I've ever had would have let me reduce my hours, and in many cases people usually need all their income? I'm in the US so maybe it's more common in the UK but part time jobs are not thick on the ground here.

Nowomenaroundeh · 02/12/2021 16:50

@Bexxe

My pet peeve is whenever someone writes of an issue with their DP, even if its something that could clearly be worked on, there is atleast 20 people going 'sack him off' 'leave him now' ' get out of there as fast as you can' - a lot of the time just saying that without offerring any reason or explanation to their logic.

Like they want everyone to be alone for the sake of it instead of working on their relationship - drives me mad.

Yes this really bothers me, as if you just return the faulty goods and get a better item. And woe betide anyone who suggests trying to see his perspective or doing a little self reflection.

I'm not talking one sided or unhappy relationships at all. I mean when somebody wants to work out a relatively standalone issue.

It particularly boils my blood when there are children involved. I am not from the UK so I don't know if Mumsnet is a good representation but these complicated setups of various DC from previous relationships, shared DC are very unusual to me. I had some really aggressive poster one day basically abusing me for not packing my bags and charging out of the house with my child. I mean I'd rather work things out or at least try before having my child live between two houses for her whole life.

Maireas · 01/12/2021 18:56

@PeacheyPeach

I love the "grow your own vegetables" statement when people put on how they are struggling financially or worrying about how they can stretch their money So are these people suppose to just go hungry until their carrots and tomatoes have grown!!!
I know, it's bonkers! One woman was advised to go foraging.....
ABCeasyasdohrayme · 01/12/2021 18:54

There was one on here years ago about a woman in the supermarket with her baby.

Basically her baby was tiny, and was crying, the woman was pushing the trolley and so op offered to hold the womans tiny newborn as she shopped, the woman declined ops offer, and then her mum came along and took the trolley or the baby, I cant remember which.

The op followed this woman, and her baby and her mum around the shop, gossiping about her to staff members on the way and was then so concerned she posted a thread about it.

So many people came along to wind the op up which ended in the op deciding to go back to the supermarket, ask for CCTV footage of the carpark, to get the numberplate of this womans car, so she could then find out who she is and report her to social services in case she had PND and killed herself and the baby.

I was honestly gobsmacked, loads of people were agreeing with the op "just in case it was a missing piece of the puzzle".

It was bloody ridiculous.

bonfireheart · 01/12/2021 13:18

I love the "grow your own vegetables" statement when people put on how they are struggling financially or worrying about how they can stretch their money

I genuinely can't keep plants alive!!

WomanStanleyWoman · 01/12/2021 13:16

And where precisely are they meant to grow them? It boggles my mind the number of people whose advice will reference ‘the garden’ without actually asking if the OP has one. I’ve seen more than one thread from an OP at her wits’ end trying to entertain two children in a small flat with replies saying ‘Can’t you just stick them out in the garden for a bit to give yourself a break?’

A lot of MNers don’t understand a world where you don’t live in a three-bed semi in a mid-size town where everyone has a garden, travels everywhere by car and the most likely caller at 11pm at night is a poor lost pensioner with Alzheimer’s in desperate need of help.

percythewitch · 01/12/2021 13:14

I am always baffled by people who give advice about things that they clearly have no idea about.

I think it has already been referenced upthread, but there is a recent one about sellers not being moved out at completion.

Many of the responses are from people who have never bought or sold a property. "Oh, it's only one night OP, just let them stay" "they were probably busy" "just tell them you will be back in the morning" "they can't possibly be expected to pack/clean the house by 2pm".

Boggles the mind.

PeacheyPeach · 01/12/2021 12:36

I love the "grow your own vegetables" statement when people put on how they are struggling financially or worrying about how they can stretch their money
So are these people suppose to just go hungry until their carrots and tomatoes have grown!!!

GetTheFlockOutOfHere · 01/12/2021 12:28

@Jackthementalkitten

People been taken in by some complete arse, come here looking for advice. The brilliant phrase, oh give your head a wobble. What are they, a fucking weeble. How does that phrase help?
😂 A weeble!

Or a bobblehead eh?

AIBU to think there is often really terrible advice on here?
GetTheFlockOutOfHere · 01/12/2021 12:27

@thefourgp

The worst one I ever saw was someone complaining about a man who had wronged her (I can’t remember what he did - it was a few years ago) and another poster asked her to private message a screenshot of his Facebook profile so she could start an online rumour he was a paedophile (which he wasn’t) to ‘get back at him’. The OP definitely sent the stranger his profile because they were making jokes about photos of him and the new girlfriend on the thread. I was so shocked. I reported the thread and told the OP how wrong she was to do that. The two of them (who both sounded incredibly immature) had no remorse and it took Mumsnet ages to take the thread down. I’ve no idea if she followed through on her intention to do that to him - ruin the life of a complete stranger.
That's bloody awful! Shock
Eastie77Returns · 01/12/2021 12:14

@Darkpheonix there is a general assumption on MN that women always earn less than men so if you are in a relationship and live (unmarried) with your DP then the advice is you are leaving yourself financially vulnerable, he will eventually meet someone else leaving you homeless and you won't have a leg to stand on etc etc

Back in the real world, I know many women who earn more than their partners and have no interest in marriage. I earn more than 3x DP's salary and am buying a property solely in my name. The deposit is 100% funded by me. I'm not getting married. That might make me a 'financial abuser' according to some although that term is really only reserved for men on MN!

NCsobroke · 01/12/2021 11:54

I posted recently about being broke and asking for meal ideas on the cheap.

Someone suggested my husband and I survive off the kids leftovers… for 3 weeks.

DrSbaitso · 01/12/2021 11:53

I'm not a lawyer, but the "common law spouse" stuff drives me bonkers.

Nowomenaroundeh · 01/12/2021 11:50

I had not read much on MN when I posted initially. I asked for advice on a very specific issue around organising lifts and drop-offs for my DSD. I gave some background information. I was gobsmacked at the replies.

The one that sticks out the most was to move into an apartment immediately (because that is so straightforward) and see if my partner stations himself outside to woo me back.

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 01/12/2021 11:47

Almost all legal, insurance and consumer advice is utter bollocks on here.

Darkpheonix · 01/12/2021 11:43

I got told I was a walking red flag because I wont marry dp. Because I am a much higher earner and have far more in assets. I have 2 kids. He has non. We aren't having kids. I do pay a big portion of the bills (would be happy to pay more but dp insists on paying some) and pay alot more into our joint account. He has a lot more spare cash because of my earnings. I even said I would look at marrying dp if we were having kids and he was reducing hours or giving up work.

And apparently, I should marry him because loads of posters husbands had married them despite them being lower earners. Then when people realised I was the woman and Dp a man, they back tracked and said I was obviously prioritising my children's financial future 🙄

But, I was told it could really be a loving relationship unless I was willing to marry him and they felt bad for me that I wouldn't ever feel that joy again 🤣

KurtWildesChristmasNamechange · 01/12/2021 11:30

I remember The Script @BadLad literally anything a DP did .. oh they all follow the same script Hmm

Some of the dating ones are quite funny because of the conflicting advice. You get the 'definitely text him first because it's 2021' and the 'don't text him first because it appears needy'. Well great I'm even more confused now!

There was a thread where the OPs boyfriend had asked for a bit of space but he'd speak to her soon and OP kept pushing and pushing whilst saying they weren't in a relationship, but it was he clear from her post that he thought they were. Responses varied between he's a huge man child and he's messing with you, to run like the wind he doesn't want a relationship with you. Whereas I read it as he did want a relationship and the fact OP kept saying it wasn't one had sent him into a spin so he wanted to have a think. Seems some posters get a theme and run with it regardless of what's been said in the OP so the general consensus was to bin him off!