Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think there is often really terrible advice on here?

291 replies

Ahmadame · 30/11/2021 18:17

I mean, people suggest completely random shit and then get quite indignant if an OP says they won’t be taking it.

I don’t know if it’s just me but I regularly see weird suggestions on here, or suggestions that are clearly unworkable (like ‘home school your kids’) and I sometimes don’t know if they are serious or not.

What’s the worst bit of MN advice you’ve seen?

OP posts:
Simonjt · 03/12/2021 15:17

@PinkyPromises

Yeah I remember one YEARS ago as the poster was asking for packed lunch ideas for her husband.

She liked doing it, had the time etc etc

But by the end of the thread she'd been told she was being abused and shouldn't do anything for the poor guy ever again.

Ha similar happened to me, after a few ‘interesting’ replies I pointed out that my partner has a severe physical disability that limits the use of both his hands and arms. I also love cooking, and actually I see me doing all the cooking as a bonus as its something I really enjoy I’m also a feeder
PinkyPromises · 03/12/2021 14:18

Yeah I remember one YEARS ago as the poster was asking for packed lunch ideas for her husband.

She liked doing it, had the time etc etc

But by the end of the thread she'd been told she was being abused and shouldn't do anything for the poor guy ever again.

notacooldad · 03/12/2021 14:10

The number of threads where someone asks for practical advice on a specific issue and instead receives a patronising lecture on why she shouldn't have that issue at all. There was a mad one recently where someone asked for recipe suggestions for a meal at her boyfriend's flat and received pages of patronising people yacking on about useless men, LTB etc etc, which were completely irrelevant to her situation
Oh God yes!!!
Years ago I mentioned something about cooking my husband's tea. Honesty you would have thought I was sleeping with the enemy.
No one seemed to realise that
1, I like making the tea
2 I dont have to make it. Dh will do it if I don't feel like it. He is never bothered if nothing is made.

3 I have loads more free time than he does
4 Dh does loads of stuff to make my life easier and as nice as possible.

I only wanted a bit if advice about cooking a piece of chicken or something because I dont normally cook chicken.
If I listened to the posters I would have thought Dh was a selfish, demanding arse who demanded tea on the table and I would question 'what exactly does he do for you' and taken myself of for a spa day after I've ltb!!!

MoonRiverLaLaLa · 03/12/2021 14:01

"Just talk to your GP/HV if you're feeling overwhelmed with your baby. The help is out there if you need it"

Like, that are they gonna do?

ABCeasyasdohrayme · 03/12/2021 13:54

@SSOYS

The number of threads where someone asks for practical advice on a specific issue and instead receives a patronising lecture on why she shouldn't have that issue at all. There was a mad one recently where someone asked for recipe suggestions for a meal at her boyfriend's flat and received pages of patronising people yacking on about useless men, LTB etc etc, which were completely irrelevant to her situation.
There was a book one a few months back, the poster was buying a book for her mum (I think) and said she likes X genre of books and there was a really angry poster who just couldn't accept these were the types of books ops mum liked at all, they got really annoyed about it.

There was another ages ago telling an anecdote about a funny incident at an operation, happened to mention the surgeon was male and loads of people had a go at op for even mentioning it "And what's the relevance of the surgeon being male??????" 🤣 some people just like a whinge.

SSOYS · 03/12/2021 13:45

The number of threads where someone asks for practical advice on a specific issue and instead receives a patronising lecture on why she shouldn't have that issue at all. There was a mad one recently where someone asked for recipe suggestions for a meal at her boyfriend's flat and received pages of patronising people yacking on about useless men, LTB etc etc, which were completely irrelevant to her situation.

Kinko · 03/12/2021 13:20

The amount of people who actively encourage people to leave their spouse because of one argument, or some character flaws, or because they did a bad thing. Or cut family members out because of a sarky comment.

MurielSpriggs · 03/12/2021 12:54

"No" is a complete sentence. Only if you want to seem rude and weird it is.

And even then you've totally misunderstood English grammar and the meaning of "sentence".

QuickSandSickSand · 03/12/2021 11:30

I'm a paramedic and the amount of medical threads with posters advising totally inappropriately to call 999 (as if the ambulance services nationwide aren't screwed enough at the moment)

Further to my post about my exH, I mentioned because he’s a genuine suicide risk I was checking in with him via text every day to basically check he isn’t dead! I was told that would result in my Children’s removal and if I was worried he’d committed suicide to call an ambulance Hmm

FirewomanSam · 03/12/2021 11:06

@sonjadog yes to all of these! Also the advice to give a ‘head tilt’ (whatever the fuck that is) and say ‘did you mean to be so rude?’ I would love to meet someone who does that in real life, it sounds hilarious.

And the advice to ‘block, delete and move on’ on every dating thread. Sounds good in theory but we all know nobody actually does that.

sonjadog · 03/12/2021 11:02

"No" is a complete sentence. Only if you want to seem rude and weird it is.

The cutting exchanges where the OP will come out on top. Those will only work if you give if you hand the other person their lines in advance. Otherwise you will most likely seem like a complete fool.

Blocking people. I know no-one who goes around blocking people like posters on MN seem to.

Kebabandchipsplease · 03/12/2021 09:55

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

QuickSandSickSand · 03/12/2021 09:51

..

YANBU

I posted a thread the other day (now deleted as there ended up being quite a lot of identifying info) asking for advice on changing social worker - long story short, exH has been accused by a member of his family’s child of showing her a naked picture of a woman. Initially he was accused of doing this at a particular party, first I heard of it was when 9yo DD said “Lucy said dad showed her a rude picture at Beth’s party last year”. Bearing in mind I was driving, I nearly crashed the car but my immediate panicked and confused instinct was to say “he wasn’t even at Beth’s party last year as it was also YOUR party that day”. I also gave a statement to police saying the truth which was I never had any previous concerns about exH. Since then, there’s been no arrest but exH went for a voluntary interview, and social services have imposed conditions whereby he has his usual EOW contact but with MIL present and no overnight visits.

Anyway fast forward to now and my SW is thick as pig shit, gets SO many things wrong, doesn’t listen at all and is saying it’s a ‘concern’ that I have ‘defended exH’ in my statement (I haven’t, I just stated facts as I knew them at the time) and used the above 2 examples - even though I’ve complied with everything, made it clear that I am supportive of their imposed supervised-only contact and that depending on the outcome of all this I am happy to withhold contact if he is proven to be a risk. My AIBU asked about how to change social workers, and I mentioned that I had a child protection conference coming up.

Cue oodles of posters telling me “STOP CONTACT NOW” - even though I said that could damage me further down the line if no further action was taken but exH then took legal action against me saying I was alienating the kids (look at the active threads at the moment whereby this exact thing from problem men is rampant in a system that doesn’t support women). Not to mention it would be genuinely distressing for my kids when a safe alternative arrangement was in place. I was told I was minimising and therefore I’d absolutely have my kids taken off me in the very near future, some people told me I’d deserve to lose them if I didn’t cut exH out RIGHT NOW (aka go against social services plans) and some said to basically say to SW that I believe his guilt and that I never want him to see the kids ever again. Some told me that my children had DEFINITELY been sexually abused and I was failing them by not coaxing a confession from them (I’ve had the conversation and I know my kids and believe them when they say he’s never hurt them). One prick of a poster even said “Go on then just lose your fucking kids” when I stated that I wouldn’t be refusing to send them to supervised visits. Other posters with alleged experience of the family court said “go to court [not even going to fucking court over this] and INSIST to the judge on contact centre only contact” (ha as if it works like that) and another poster said, when I mentioned I was worried exH was a genuine suicide risk due to past MH issues, that my kids would be better off if he was dead. Bear in mind, no arrest had been made, the only time they could pinpoint him being around this child since she was a baby was a time he wasn’t even present as he was with me and I’d had no suspicions at all, ever, about him and he’s whilst he may have done it he also may NOT have.

Someone also amusingly said - after I pointed it was SS themselves who imposed the supervised-contact plan until the investigation is either over or something is found - - “social workers aren’t your parents, they don’t tell you what to do, you have to figure out what’s best for your kids and if you get it wrong then they WILL be removed from you.” Confused so basically saying if the plan social services made doesn’t work it’s MY fault?!!!?!

Anyway it’s a good job that I’m thick skinned and didn’t cave into the insane scaremongering of “you WILL lose your kids even if you cut contact with exH and no further action is taken, they may as well be gone now” and listened to a few amazing posters who were actually social workers and have me some brilliant advice (and told the scaremongers onto STFU). Honestly it’s like people want others to suffer.

Anyway had the conference on Wednesday and kids are on a child in need plan - the ‘lowest’ possible outcome. No intention whatsoever to move to the stage to remove kids, I think the IRO in the meeting wondered WTF I was going on about when I asked about that. All agencies happy with me and confident my children are safe wherever they go.

So many catastrophisers on here who need a hobby.

WalkingOnTheCracks · 03/12/2021 09:34

“OP, your husband is having an affair.”

“There’s no reason to think he’s having an affair.”

“Then he’s very good at it.”

Bluntness100 · 03/12/2021 09:29

@WomanStanleyWoman

Oh, and "always trust your gut" is terrible advice.

Any mention of ‘spidey senses’ also makes me mentally dismiss a poster.

Me too. I never understand the whole trust your gut thing.

We all know plenty of people have mental health issues, jealousy, paranoia, anxiety , intrusive thoughts etc, and the last thing they should do is trust their gut. Yet people post it like if you think it it must be true.

PurpleDaisies · 03/12/2021 09:17

@bonfireheart

Actually the truly worse horrific advice is on the weightloss boards and competitive under eating, I stopped reading after a poster said she regularly went without food for three days, and was recommending it to others.
I agree. I think there are a lot of posters with eating disorders who like to have their disordered eating validated or enjoying encouraging others in a really unhealthy way of eating.
bonfireheart · 03/12/2021 09:03

Actually the truly worse horrific advice is on the weightloss boards and competitive under eating, I stopped reading after a poster said she regularly went without food for three days, and was recommending it to others.

WomanStanleyWoman · 03/12/2021 09:02

Not exactly bad advice but it does irk me when people whose only experience of the US is 2 weeks on a Virgin Holidays package to Disney think they know everything about living here. Healthcare, politics, guns, education, Trump, you name it….they are an expert on an absolutely everything here. I am particularly amused by the “everything’s cheaper in America” type comments. Aside from petrol and fast food (and occasionally housing, depending on which cities you are comparing), everything here is more expensive than the UK. But, yeah, you’re an expert on the whole country because you’ve been to Florida once….

The same goes for Canada, albeit from a different perspective. If you believe what you read from some MN posters, Canada is some kind of Utopian paradise.

I remember a thread from a Canadian woman moving to the UK who wanted advice on places to live near Alfreton. People were aghast. ‘No way would I swap Canada for Alfreton! You’re MAD!’ was the general gist. It was the most ridiculous comparison. You don’t swap an entire country for one town (to which most of the posters probably also hadn’t been). Even making a ‘Canada vs. UK’ comparison is much more complicated than that. How did they know she didn’t live in some complete dump? You’re not telling me the second biggest country in the world doesn’t have less salubrious parts somewhere!

WomanStanleyWoman · 03/12/2021 08:49

Oh, and "always trust your gut" is terrible advice.

Any mention of ‘spidey senses’ also makes me mentally dismiss a poster.

MurielSpriggs · 03/12/2021 08:46

Oh, and "always trust your gut" is terrible advice. And it seems to be code for never trust men or anyone or anything that your children might come into contact with. It's part of the "anything-could-happen" philosophy.

Posters who think their partner is just fine, or their ten-year-old child could go to school on the bus never get told to trust their gut!

MurielSpriggs · 03/12/2021 08:39

Several times on the legal board I've seen advice starting: "I am not a lawyer, but I would imagine that ..."

Why on earth the vivid imagination of someone who by their own admission knows nothing about it will help is beyond me. At least they're honest Grin

WalkingOnTheCracks · 03/12/2021 08:12

A happily pregnant woman with a toddler posted because she was understandably cross the her husband had gone out and got pissed and missed something they’d arranged.

The usual LTB responses came in. But the one that really shocked me was ‘he’s an alcoholic abuser - get an abortion now and leave the bastard’.

Briarshollow · 03/12/2021 07:49

@DeepaBeesKit

Fucking hell bluntness you've literally posted while I was typing. Ha!
I wouldn’t fangirl too much about certain posters, when much of the time their MO is just to berate an OP, wherever they stand in any situation.
bathsh3ba · 03/12/2021 07:12

For me it's the advice to just ghost people. It's so rude. There are occasions It's warranted but there aren't many of them.

BritWifeInUSA · 03/12/2021 06:04

I thought the armchair lawyers were the worst offenders for bad advice. But along came COVID and suddenly people who’ve never completed even an hour at medical school are diagnosing people and using all the latest terms that they picked up from the Boris Briefing that morning. What really made me laugh was the number of people who fell in love with using anti-bac hand sanitizer at every opportunity like this would save the entire human race. It’s a virus. Anti-bac won’t be much use.

And don’t get me started on the “essential item” experts.

Not exactly bad advice but it does irk me when people whose only experience of the US is 2 weeks on a Virgin Holidays package to Disney think they know everything about living here. Healthcare, politics, guns, education, Trump, you name it….they are an expert on an absolutely everything here. I am particularly amused by the “everything’s cheaper in America” type comments. Aside from petrol and fast food (and occasionally housing, depending on which cities you are comparing), everything here is more expensive than the UK. But, yeah, you’re an expert on the whole country because you’ve been to Florida once….