Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think there is often really terrible advice on here?

291 replies

Ahmadame · 30/11/2021 18:17

I mean, people suggest completely random shit and then get quite indignant if an OP says they won’t be taking it.

I don’t know if it’s just me but I regularly see weird suggestions on here, or suggestions that are clearly unworkable (like ‘home school your kids’) and I sometimes don’t know if they are serious or not.

What’s the worst bit of MN advice you’ve seen?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
sst1234 · 11/12/2021 10:05

And I sincerely hope no MNer will ever become a mother in law. Please make sure your kids, especially have your sons do not ever get married or have children. Because mothers in law are evil, remember? And you will inevitable turn into one, Judith by your reaction to your own. So many OM women on here outraged because the mother in law may have a slightly different idea on how to look after a baby and posters fly into a rage about she must never be left alone with a child.
Comedy gold was a thread where the father in law had given a sip of coffee to OPs toddler, OP was upset but poster were incandescent with rage as though a sip of coffee would kill a toddler. Honestly how these people get though the day.

sst1234 · 11/12/2021 09:58

There was one in here recently where OP had put her own £25k into a mortgage in husbands name. Her name wasn’t on the mortgage or the deeds, she didn’t work, full time SAHM to one child and her her other two from a previous relationship being raised by the new husband too. The amount of nasty comments about the husband were really so eye opening about how women here project their hatred of men. The guy was practically raising OP’s children for free while she chose not to work, yet he was the bad one. She was being financially naive but she certainly wasn’t getting a bad deal. Yet every other roost was trying to make him out to be evil and manipulative.

SSOYS · 11/12/2021 09:35

Not advice really but I’m struck by how often someone comes on here to report a falling out with a friend and receives a lot of replies along the lines “you sound really nice, OP, and your friend sounds horrible”. Of course they sound nice, they’re the ones telling the story from their own point of view. It’s basically:

“I’m really nice and lovely and I have fallen out with my friend, the arsehole”

“Oh wow, OP, you sound lovely. Your friend sounds like a total arsehole though, why are you even friends with her?”

Which I mean is fine- we all want a boost sometimes- but it’s not a meaningful assessment of the situation.

notacooldad · 04/12/2021 10:44

Save money by growing your own veg!
I can grow ( or should i say keep alive) supermarket potted herbs such as parsley and basil so that saves me a quid here and there!
I'm not so great with aubergines!

SSOYS · 04/12/2021 10:36

Save money by growing your own veg!

RealBecca · 04/12/2021 08:48

The amount of people that come on to say their relationship is shit, get a unanimous LTB and then stay with them, only to post about TTC less than a month later just makes me so sad.

Advice like show him the thread could be abusive behaviour- imagine a man posted on reddit and then showed his partner reems of pages saying she was abusive woth only a snapshot of behaviour.

ChrissyPlummer · 04/12/2021 08:42

@astoundedgoat that was me and I did explain that the savings are for both me & DH to decide what we spend them on. As he is older than me, he wanted to buy a property outright and have savings in case anything should happen to him, so that I would have a financial cushion. If we had stayed where we were, we could have bought a smaller property than the one we sold, but would have had no savings, due to the difference in prices. I work FT but earn under £23k and not really any prospect of being able to earn more.

If we were to move, it would use all our savings, which we couldn’t replace as DH is retired now and would rely on us being able to sell this house for more than we paid. Not many people want a nearly-new new build though.

On that….my favourite is “Just up your hours”, “get a better paid job”. As if it’s that easy, especially in areas like I live.

There was a thread a couple of weeks ago about sleeping and the majority of replies were “Co sleep! Just get a king size bed!”. I’ve lived in places where a small double, chest of drawers and a small TV is a squeeze. Plus, co-sleeping isn’t practical for some, if you work shifts, for example but it’s always trotted out on here.

notacooldad · 04/12/2021 08:27

The ones where advice is given out via a very middle class lens and loads of assumptions eg in 10 years your DC will be at University and you can return to your career then
Absolutely!
A lot of mn would be horrified at my children's choices. One left school at 16 and moved out at 17. No fall out or anything like that but equally no university. He got a job, rented a house. At the age of 22 was on a trainee management role, doing a degree paid for by his employer, moved into his new house last year and phones us every other day for a chat, socializes with us on a weekly basis. The other one was thinking about uni, dropped out of his A levels, got a job that he adores and branched out on his own 2 years ago in that field at the age of 20. He has plenty of customers and the business is doing well. He is in the process of buying his house which he is hoping to move to in January. Also we didnt save for deposits. I dont get why there's an assumption or expectation that children want to go to uni.
A lot of posters seem to think a mention of ‘anxiety’ will excuse them from doing anything meaningful about their problem
Unfortunately anxiety is being used as an excuse by more and more teenagers to get there own way.
I work with teens and there are some that genuinely have anxiety issues that cause them severe trauma and limit their life. Their anxiety puts a huge strain on their mental health. Then theirs thecteens who wont go to school but will hang round the mall all day and when I challenge why they haven't been I'm told ' it's my anxiety innit, I told my social worker and she says if it's bad I dont have to go'

slashlover · 04/12/2021 07:51

A lot of posters seem to think a mention of ‘anxiety’ will excuse them from doing anything meaningful about their problem, and they can instead just moan about it or receive suggestions on how others can help them.

I've seen peri menopausal become a lot more prevalent as an excuse for kicking off at people. Most recently the woman who had a rant at the customer service person because some fruit and veg was removed and crisps put in the space.

Glassofshloer · 04/12/2021 07:45

It's good that the stigma around mental health is beginning to lift but it sometimes becomes a bit of a get-out-of-jail-free card for people who can't be arsed to engage with negative patterns of behaviour or to lash out at others.

I agree.

A lot of posters seem to think a mention of ‘anxiety’ will excuse them from doing anything meaningful about their problem, and they can instead just moan about it or receive suggestions on how others can help them.

Also ‘co-sleep’ as the answer to EVERY sleep problem. It seems everyone on here starts co sleeping with their ‘terrible sleeping’ newborn, and says their ‘sleep is better now’ although it’s probably just because the baby is older.

SSOYS · 04/12/2021 07:40

@PinkKecks ha ha

bonfireheart · 03/12/2021 23:52

@walkingonthecracks yes! As soon as your kids are teengers you must never ever support them with anything anymore. And go NC with any child over 18 for daring to even ask for support. I was 28 when I left my abusive husband, and moved back with my parents, taking my two year old with me. Stayed got two years until I could afford my own place. Most of the posters here would have had me out.

KurtWildesChristmasNamechange · 03/12/2021 23:49

can’t you turn your dining room into another bedroom?

Ooh I hate that one 😂

PinkKecks · 03/12/2021 23:48

"My MIL wants to cuddle my 1 year old"

"What?! How dare she? OP, this sounds like you have a DH problem and you need to set clear boundaries with MIL and tell her in no uncertain terms that if she ever even looks at your DC again you will cut all contact. And mean it!"

FirewomanSam · 03/12/2021 23:45

The ones where advice is given out via a very middle class lens and loads of assumptions eg in 10 years your DC will be at University and you can return to your career then…..make your snoring DH sleep in the spare room etc etc.

I always think this on threads about children having to - horror of horrors! - share a room with siblings. A totally normal thing for millions of children everywhere but, on Mumsnet, an unspeakable crime against parenting.

My favourite was when a mum said she was sleeping on a sofa bed every night so her kids could have the bedrooms and more than one reply asked ‘can’t you turn your dining room into another bedroom?’

julieca · 03/12/2021 23:21

@stuckhere I agree. So many comments about don't take time out as you lose the chance to build up your career as much. I will remember to tell my neighbour who at 59 years old still works on a factory line.

WalkingOnTheCracks · 03/12/2021 23:20

Those ‘chuck the kid out’ replies really upset me.

People come here asking how to help a troubled child, and arseholes suggest abandonment as the best course of action.

It’s a version of ‘well, I was regularly beaten right up until my teens and it never did me any harm. In fact it made me the person I am today.’

Well, yeah. Obviously.

Jesus…

Stuckhere2021 · 03/12/2021 23:09

The ones where advice is given out via a very middle class lens and loads of assumptions eg in 10 years your DC will be at University and you can return to your career then…..make your snoring DH sleep in the spare room etc etc. Also - when people ask “why are you doing your DPs washing” as if people can’t work as a team and help each other. And advice to basically chuck DC out the second they turn 18 unless they are a cross between Mrs Hinch and Nigella Lawson.

FirewomanSam · 03/12/2021 22:53

Actually the truly worse horrific advice is on the weightloss boards and competitive under eating.

Oh yes yes yes. A million times this. Anything weight related gets a wide berth from me here, it just enrages and depresses me too much.

QuickSandSickSand · 03/12/2021 18:08

I completely agree about the advice about sassy replies.

Another thread recently a poster was worried about going to a wedding where the man who raped her as a child would be the best man and lording it up. The amount of ridiculous replies that either told her to go the the police (like it’s that easy to just have the mindset to go!) or to give a cutting reply. One person said go up to him with a piece of paper that says “Leave now, or I will announce to everyone here what you really are and I will go to the police”. Some people seem to think others live in Eastenders

BiscuitLover3679 · 03/12/2021 17:12

@bonfireheart

Actually the truly worse horrific advice is on the weightloss boards and competitive under eating, I stopped reading after a poster said she regularly went without food for three days, and was recommending it to others.
I second this. It's so messed up.
BookFiend4Life · 03/12/2021 17:08

@onceandneveragain
Ah I stand corrected! Yes cultural difference then. I don't actually know anyone that works part time! It would be nice if that were an option, I would do it in a heartbeat.

onceandneveragain · 03/12/2021 16:49

@BookFiend4Life

I see a lot of suggestions to "go part time" to solve various problems. No job I've ever had would have let me reduce my hours, and in many cases people usually need all their income? I'm in the US so maybe it's more common in the UK but part time jobs are not thick on the ground here.
I think this is a different countries thing then, as yes it is very usual in the UK to decrease your hours, and in fact all employees have the right to ask for flexible/part time working hours. The employer doesn't have to agree to it but they must explain (and give a good reason not just "we don't want to) if they don't. It's very very common everywhere I've worked for at least one parent to reduce their hours after having a baby.

As a PP has said it often can work out financially better after you've paid less tax, NI, student loan, childcare fees, travel costs etc, and sometimes get additional benefits. It's not a fix all but it's not a stupid suggestion for people to look into it, as until they do they won't know if they and their specific circumstances would benefit or not.

onceandneveragain · 03/12/2021 16:38

@hangrylady

When people say 'No is a complete sentence' if the OP is asking how to get out of doing something. It is not a complete sentence and just saying No, without any explanation will just make you look rude and weird.
technically agree but I think the thought behind it, e.g. not needing to provide an explanation is good. e.g. it's okay to just say "Oh I'm sorry no, I can't," and that's not rude. It's only a small minority that would be bolshy enough to then demand 'why,' and even then you can be vague and say "Ah it just won't work,' or 'I won't go into all the boring details.' If they press yet again they look a bit unhinged. So it's helpful for people like me who think others always deserve detailed explanations as to why you don't want to do x.

I think people here often give advice that is too insular. e.g. about weddings, 'Do whatever makes you happy it's your special day,' and Christmas 'Ignore MIL moaning Christmas is for you and your little family,' etc. A lot of the time it's good to put yourself first and women don't do that enough, but at the same time (TAAT, sorry), if you don't invite family to your wedding or see them at all over christmas, don't be surprised if they are then hurt/upset/annoyed at you!

I also once tried advice to condition then shampoo my hair - terrible idea!

PinkyPromises · 03/12/2021 15:20

So annoying.

I think if the OP had asked for lunch ideas that travel well she could have got some good answers. People just went nuts. Odd.