Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Part time hours...

62 replies

blueberry12345 · 30/11/2021 15:03

Returning to work next year, and have requested to work 3 days a week with one from home.

Work have said that 3 days a week in my role won't work, they're happy to allow me to work 3 days for the initial return to work period of 3 months but then I will need to increase to 4.

In a global company like mine I'm sure someone else must be doing my role successfully on 3 days a week. Do they have to tell me if I ask this?

Also they are being very non committal about a day at home - saying it'll be dependent on performance etc etc.

I basically feel that it's a pain in the arse for them me returning part time and they'd rather keep my (male) maternity cover on in the post (full time).

Am I being unreasonable to request that I'm made aware of any other mums in the company doing my role on 3 day weeks?

OP posts:
LivinginWFHlimbo · 30/11/2021 18:57

Work have said that 3 days a week in my role won't work, they're happy to allow me to work 3 days for the initial return to work period of 3 months but then I will need to increase to 4.

Personally I'd accept this, try my absolute best to make it work in these three months and then apply again for the reduction from four to three days, pointing out the evidence that it works. At this point I think it becomes harder for them to argue against - three months is long enough that it's hard to see why it would be ok for then but not for longer.

HardbackWriter · 30/11/2021 18:51

I think it is reasonable to presume that the money the company save by only paying 3/5 of the OP's salary, will be used to pay others to pick up the work she won't be doing. Now, depends on the job, obviously, that could be another person of same level and skills, just taking on 2/5 of the workload, or in other cases, it might be to employ someone at a lower grade for more of the time, to support with a lot of admin or "less skilled" tasks that the OP currently does as part of her role.

It might be reasonable to presume that's how it should work, but it isn't how it does work in my experience. When people go part-time they either are expected to shuffle their work into less time or other team members pick it up (or both). Job shares are quite unusual in my personal experience. Obviously that will vary for different employers, sectors, etc. but it certainly isn't the case that an employer would always use the money 'saved' in the way you suggest. Quite often the employer would really rather the employee didn't go part-time and sees letting them do it at all as a big concession.

FlorenceWintle · 30/11/2021 18:44

You need to put a case to them as to how you will make a full-time role work as part-time with one day at home. The onus is on you.

Drunkpanda · 30/11/2021 18:41

I don't think we should accept that "that's just the way it is".
Employers may well not want to employ women due to risk of maternity leave. They may not want a woman who's had one child as likely they will have a second. They are more likely to want to work part time. We need a society that accepts that equality actually matters and that children (and the people who have them) are a social responsibility not just a personal one.

AndMatt · 30/11/2021 18:40

I agree recruiting 2 day posts is really hard. Actually 3 days isn't that easy either. It suits people while DC are very small and then they want more hours or school hours and you've already got someone to fill the other half of their FT job.. So it's short term and then one way or another you're recruiting again.

OP you need to concentrate on showing how your FT role can be done in 3 days and forget about wfh for now. Look at it from the employer's pov. You want to be paid for 3 days but actually you don't really want to be there for the third...Maybe you can make it work from home but I don't blame them for wanting to know you can make it work PT first.

LethargicActress · 30/11/2021 18:39

If you feel like they’d rather have the full time employee over the part time one, then you’re probably right and there will be a reason for it. Some jobs are just better done by a full time employee and there are valid reasons why it’s preferable for a company to want to employ one person instead of two.

It’s something that definitely contributes to the difficulties women often have when they have children and want to work, but it’s the way it is.

Drunkpanda · 30/11/2021 18:38

Isn't that pro rata? I don't know - but I know I make reduced NI and pension payments from my own salary so wouldn't it be the same for employers?

icedcoffees · 30/11/2021 18:35

I know we are all thinking of different jobs here, but it really isn't that difficult to imagine the company being able to find a solution if it wants to retain the OP, and also to attract other skilled, experienced people who, for a myriad of reasons don't want to work FT at the moment.

It costs more to have two PT workers, though, as the company has to pay two lots of NI, pension etc.

Drunkpanda · 30/11/2021 18:34

I have known someone win the right to flexible working on appeal due to being able to show other people in the workplace had been granted the same thing she'd just been turned down for. So I would be keen to know if other people do this, though I'm not sure who I could ask in your shoes (it was very obvious in our workplace who was part time).
I would ask your union for advice.

icedcoffees · 30/11/2021 18:34

In a global company like mine I'm sure someone else must be doing my role successfully on 3 days a week. Do they have to tell me if I ask this?

No. Other peoples' working arrangements are nothing to do with you. Besides, just because it works for Jane Bloggs, it doesn't mean that it's going to work for you as well.

Also they are being very non committal about a day at home - saying it'll be dependent on performance etc etc.

I suspect they're worried that you'll try and WFH with no childcare in place in order to save money.

I basically feel that it's a pain in the arse for them me returning part time and they'd rather keep my (male) maternity cover on in the post (full time).

Or you could go back full-time. Part-time work doesn't work for all roles and can often cost companies more money as they need to recruit someone else (and pay another load of NI etc.) to cover the days you're off.

Am I being unreasonable to request that I'm made aware of any other mums in the company doing my role on 3 day weeks?

Yes.

Kite22 · 30/11/2021 18:34

OP it’s not very clear why you think the role you previously did FT, and which has been covered FT during your leave, is actually possible to do 3/5 without any adverse impact on the business.

Not sure why this concept is so difficult for so many posters today.

I think it is reasonable to presume that the money the company save by only paying 3/5 of the OP's salary, will be used to pay others to pick up the work she won't be doing. Now, depends on the job, obviously, that could be another person of same level and skills, just taking on 2/5 of the workload, or in other cases, it might be to employ someone at a lower grade for more of the time, to support with a lot of admin or "less skilled" tasks that the OP currently does as part of her role.
I know we are all thinking of different jobs here, but it really isn't that difficult to imagine the company being able to find a solution if it wants to retain the OP, and also to attract other skilled, experienced people who, for a myriad of reasons don't want to work FT at the moment.

Boombastic22 · 30/11/2021 18:33

Exceptionally common for private employers to refuse to part time working requests. 3 days really is not very much if you were previously full time. And I can’t see how it’s relevant or even helpful if you find out if others have been granted 3 days per week. In my experience it’s only top talent that might get their approval granted and/or industries where it’s the norm (eg public sector). Perhaps look for another job.

Amberflames · 30/11/2021 18:26

The reason 3/5 roles can be very difficult is because if the role is really a FT role it is very difficult to find someone who wants to do the remaining 2/5 role. So for many it unfortunately doesn’t work commercially for the business.

OP it’s not very clear why you think the role you previously did FT, and which has been covered FT during your leave, is actually possible to do 3/5 without any adverse impact on the business.

We have some people who work PT doing project based roles for external clients and we allow it because we want to retain those individuals in the business and we think it’s hugely important to be a flexible employer. But the reality is either they end up dealing with work stuff on some of their non work days or their team members often end up picking stuff up on those days.

We have some support roles that are PT with varying degrees of success.

The point is I think it hugely depends on the specifics of the role so difficult to say if they are being unreasonable in turning down your request, but it’s not a huge leap to see that a previous FT role could be difficult to deliver in 3 days.

Kite22 · 30/11/2021 18:25

I think it's very unusual to advertise for another part timer to cover the vacancy left by a member of staff going PT but maybe some posters can tell me otherwise?

Very normal in my line of work. I presume it is industry dependent if it isn't something you have come across. Lots of people prefer to work PT for all sorts of reasons, not just parents of small dc.

Goldentimes · 30/11/2021 18:23

You can't have information about other employees hours and arrangements, absolutely none of your business.
No one has an automatic right to reduce their hours. You've asked and they've agreed. But now your shifting the goalposts again and insisting on reducing your hours in the office further? They've said no that won't work for them. There's not really much more they have to do.
Is it because of childcare you want to partly WFH?

Viviennemary · 30/11/2021 18:15

I meant to say asking for a full time role to be cut down to two days in the office and one wfh doesnt seem feasible to me.

peboh · 30/11/2021 18:10

You would unreasonable to request information on the other mums in the company, yes.

You're not unreasonable to ask about part time when you return, your company isn't unreasonable to deny the request if it doesn't work for your current position.
If you disagree you need to appeal, and give reasonable assurances that your job wouldn't suffer with the drop in hours, including the time you're at home.

NeverForgetYourDreams · 30/11/2021 18:04

@AndMatt

I wouldn't agree to a day at home for a parent with a new baby unless I had cast iron assurances that reliable childcare was in place.
This

Are you requesting to work one day at home and juggle your childcare with working because I can tell you now that it won't work. Young children and working all day at home just doesn't tally up.

Viviennemary · 30/11/2021 18:01

Well if this doesn't meet the companies rewui

AndMatt · 30/11/2021 17:58

@Kite22

We do quite a few school hours arrangements, but 3 days means someone's not there when you need them almost half the week.

Unless the company employs someone to do the other 2/5 of the week, which is what I assume the OP is assuming would happen. Then you have people to cover all the work. It really isn't that strange a concept. I presume the OP isn't saying "I normally only put in about 3/5 of the effort anyway, so it wouldn't matter if I am only there 3/5 of the time". The proposal is usually to have one person paid 3/5 of a salary to do 3/5 of the role and another to be paid 2/5 of a salary to do 2/ of the role. Obviously, it depends on the role as to how that is distributed.

I think it's very unusual to advertise for another part timer to cover the vacancy left by a member of staff going PT but maybe some posters can tell me otherwise?

The only time I've seen that done is for a formal job share, but I don't think they're as common as they used to be and unsurprisingly. You used to have to cover each other's leave and were contractually effectively one person (so if one left you both left unless you found a new partner) . You also were responsible for finding your own suitable partner.

Kite22 · 30/11/2021 17:53

We do quite a few school hours arrangements, but 3 days means someone's not there when you need them almost half the week.

Unless the company employs someone to do the other 2/5 of the week, which is what I assume the OP is assuming would happen. Then you have people to cover all the work. It really isn't that strange a concept. I presume the OP isn't saying "I normally only put in about 3/5 of the effort anyway, so it wouldn't matter if I am only there 3/5 of the time". The proposal is usually to have one person paid 3/5 of a salary to do 3/5 of the role and another to be paid 2/5 of a salary to do 2/ of the role. Obviously, it depends on the role as to how that is distributed.

ToykotoLosAngeles · 30/11/2021 17:04

Also agree you need to demonstrate how this will work, especially the additional layer of a day WFH. I went back on 2.5 days but had to change my job title and drop half my workload to do so. The other half was fortunately no longer essential to the business.

mybroomstick · 30/11/2021 17:03

Will the baby be in childcare the day you're at home?

JazzHandsYeah · 30/11/2021 16:51

Unless you can put forward a clear concise argument how your role can worth on such reduced hours, then no, I don’t think they’re being
Unreasonable.
The right to request flexible working is available to all, but if the company can demonstrate your role reduction in hours is detrimental to business and the wider the they don’t have to agree at all.

AndMatt · 30/11/2021 16:22

I wouldn't agree to a day at home for a parent with a new baby unless I had cast iron assurances that reliable childcare was in place.