Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Part time hours...

62 replies

blueberry12345 · 30/11/2021 15:03

Returning to work next year, and have requested to work 3 days a week with one from home.

Work have said that 3 days a week in my role won't work, they're happy to allow me to work 3 days for the initial return to work period of 3 months but then I will need to increase to 4.

In a global company like mine I'm sure someone else must be doing my role successfully on 3 days a week. Do they have to tell me if I ask this?

Also they are being very non committal about a day at home - saying it'll be dependent on performance etc etc.

I basically feel that it's a pain in the arse for them me returning part time and they'd rather keep my (male) maternity cover on in the post (full time).

Am I being unreasonable to request that I'm made aware of any other mums in the company doing my role on 3 day weeks?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
VanGoghsDog · 01/12/2021 11:49

@LivinginWFHlimbo

You can only make a statutory request once every twelve months. You could make an informal one though.

Oh fair point - I'd completely forgotten that rule. Do you know whether the clock starts ticking from when the first application is made or from when it's implemented or denied? If OP made the request a while ago she might not have very long left until the year's up once she's back and has done three months.

Pretty sure it's from the request . But the .gov website will have the details.
LivinginWFHlimbo · 01/12/2021 10:02

You can only make a statutory request once every twelve months. You could make an informal one though.

Oh fair point - I'd completely forgotten that rule. Do you know whether the clock starts ticking from when the first application is made or from when it's implemented or denied? If OP made the request a while ago she might not have very long left until the year's up once she's back and has done three months.

Mary46 · 30/11/2021 23:00

Part T great if you can get it. I hated full t just constantly chasing tails. I did school bus run for bit which gave good balance but we only had it during covid. I had 20 hours

Thatsveryniceofyou · 30/11/2021 22:52

I feel you. I remember returning after number 2 requesting part time hours (4 days a week) but was told it wouldn't work in my role and they offered me a lesser role with less money of I wanted 4 days a week
Soon after returning I found out 2 managers (exact same role as me) were working 4 days a week doing the role I was before maternity and wanted to return too. One of the people at the top who I get on well with helped me pay for a solicitor and I settled out of court (signing a non disclosure) as I made a claim for constructive dismissal (I did generally feel forced out as I couldn't do the role I wanted / was successful in at that place)

PrincessPaws · 30/11/2021 22:44

Sorry really tired! Considering their wants and needs and are less bothered about the needs of the business

PrincessPaws · 30/11/2021 22:41

The 'Senior Manager' piece actually makes it harder. Trying to job share a strategic or management position is pretty much a nightmare for everyone else that works with or for them (if the two parties have different views/styles, who do team members actually report to, how to manage it if people prefer to wait for one manager to come in rather than speak to the person there, people feeling undermined if their decisions are overturned on days they don't work, other stakeholders getting mixed messages etc ) so your application will most likely be viewed through that lens. It explains why 4 days is fine but 3 days/job share is seen as a no. Job shares tend to work better for admin/individual contributor/SME roles

I think fundamentally it will come down to how you answered the 'impact on the business/colleagues' question, in my experience a lot of people scrimp on that section as they are considering their wants and are less bothered about the needs over the needs of business

startingtheengine · 30/11/2021 22:38

I haven't read all the comments so apologies if already mentioned.
Have a look at Pregnant then screwed and Mother Pukka (Anna Whitehouse) who are fighting for flexible working for all www.instagram.com/p/CVvOf7BMRNR/?utm_medium=copy_link
www.instagram.com/tv/CWp74pBDMCV/?utm_medium=copy_link

VanGoghsDog · 30/11/2021 22:30

@LivinginWFHlimbo

Work have said that 3 days a week in my role won't work, they're happy to allow me to work 3 days for the initial return to work period of 3 months but then I will need to increase to 4.

Personally I'd accept this, try my absolute best to make it work in these three months and then apply again for the reduction from four to three days, pointing out the evidence that it works. At this point I think it becomes harder for them to argue against - three months is long enough that it's hard to see why it would be ok for then but not for longer.

You can only make a statutory request once every twelve months. You could make an informal one though.
HardbackWriter · 30/11/2021 22:01

For context - most of the company does at least one day - if not more - at home. They will argue it is performance related for everyone, but it does seem to be a bit inconsistent on this front e.g I know people who are not performing well who are still doing frequent days from home.

In that case I think they'll let you do it informally too, but don't want to commit to it as a permanent arrangement in writing. How much that matters to you depends on how far you're going to plan around it (I think they want to be in a position where they can withdraw WFH if they want to in the future), but I wouldn't make this the hill I died on.

Kite22 · 30/11/2021 21:51

I have pitched the idea of a job share and was told it wasn't something the business likes to do. My maternity cover would be very interested in doing a job share with me, and there is actually another role he could do 3 days a week so it could work out perfectly. My boss wouldn't even consider it - conversation closed.

I think this strengthens your position then.
When I did my first jobshare, someone else who had also been doing the same role as me wanted to go PT, and we made it clear in our application that we would be sharing the role (and yes, they wanted 2 days) so our two roles became one, and there was then a FT position to recruit to.

However, I'd be interested to know if the people saying that people don't want 2 days a week, have ever tried advertising. I think you'd be surprised.

As I've said all along, this is bound to be specific to each individual job.....none of the reasons listed as having a jobshare costing more, here, for example have ever applied in my role
Double the uniform costs. Always worn my own clothes to work
Double the time spent training (and double the costs involved, as we sent people away on training courses - so 2 x travel costs, 2 x hotel rooms, 2 x food allowances) I could already do the role before being appt'd and there is little training since (also the case for OP, in that both her and her maternity cover have both done the role), and, where I have had training, I've never been set up in a hotel or given a food allowance in 40 years in the workplace.
People wanting a certain number of days per week - recruiting for a 2x day a week position was next to impossible as it wasn't enough money for most people to make it worth while. Not my experience - and, again, it isn't the case for the OP.

SarahProblem · 30/11/2021 20:23

As a manager I really don't like job shares it rarely works well and the two colleagues spend more time handing over between each other it rarely equates to 1 FTE. Does your role have a clear split of responsibilities?

Are you in a union OP?

Cobiemakesmesmulder · 30/11/2021 20:06

@Kite22

OP it’s not very clear why you think the role you previously did FT, and which has been covered FT during your leave, is actually possible to do 3/5 without any adverse impact on the business.

Not sure why this concept is so difficult for so many posters today.

I think it is reasonable to presume that the money the company save by only paying 3/5 of the OP's salary, will be used to pay others to pick up the work she won't be doing. Now, depends on the job, obviously, that could be another person of same level and skills, just taking on 2/5 of the workload, or in other cases, it might be to employ someone at a lower grade for more of the time, to support with a lot of admin or "less skilled" tasks that the OP currently does as part of her role.
I know we are all thinking of different jobs here, but it really isn't that difficult to imagine the company being able to find a solution if it wants to retain the OP, and also to attract other skilled, experienced people who, for a myriad of reasons don't want to work FT at the moment.

But it costs the company more. 2 people doing 1 ft role costs more that 1 person because of how the NI etc is calculated plus recruitment costs. It's not as simple as that.
blueberry12345 · 30/11/2021 20:02

Thanks everyone SO MUCH for the response on this.

For context - most of the company does at least one day - if not more - at home. They will argue it is performance related for everyone, but it does seem to be a bit inconsistent on this front e.g I know people who are not performing well who are still doing frequent days from home.

I have pitched the idea of a job share and was told it wasn't something the business likes to do. My maternity cover would be very interested in doing a job share with me, and there is actually another role he could do 3 days a week so it could work out perfectly. My boss wouldn't even consider it - conversation closed.

I absolutely would not be looking after my child on my day from home but it would save me commuting, give me a better work life balance, enable me to spend more time with DC in the evening, there are so many reasons I would like a day WFH.

Not to mention the fact I ran a very successful operation before having my baby entirely from home during a global pandemic. I feel like WFH suited them then - but not now, so they're making it difficult.

I'm a senior manager in a global company with a small number of employees beneath me. Someone asked what I did - hopefully that gives more context

OP posts:
SarahProblem · 30/11/2021 19:58

You have to show how the business need can be met by your requested change.

The fact they asked for 4 instead of three sounds like they wouldn't replace the hours and work can be moved elsewhere?

Can you offer 2.5 days a week? Means they could get someone to do exactly the other half? This would potentially be more attractive to recruit to

rainyskylight · 30/11/2021 19:51

I also agree that it’s a bit unfair to assume the OP is trying to save on childcare. Conversely, she could be intending to spend the time she would have spent on commuting on putting in a couple of extra hours work.

PrincessPaws · 30/11/2021 19:48

@Kite22

We do quite a few school hours arrangements, but 3 days means someone's not there when you need them almost half the week.

Unless the company employs someone to do the other 2/5 of the week, which is what I assume the OP is assuming would happen. Then you have people to cover all the work. It really isn't that strange a concept. I presume the OP isn't saying "I normally only put in about 3/5 of the effort anyway, so it wouldn't matter if I am only there 3/5 of the time". The proposal is usually to have one person paid 3/5 of a salary to do 3/5 of the role and another to be paid 2/5 of a salary to do 2/ of the role. Obviously, it depends on the role as to how that is distributed.

It's quite hard to get people to do 2 days, most people want at least 3. Not to mention a lot of people requesting 3 days flex working don't want to do Mondays/Fridays. So a Monday/Friday contract is often not attractive
icedcoffees · 30/11/2021 19:46

@Drunkpanda

Isn't that pro rata? I don't know - but I know I make reduced NI and pension payments from my own salary so wouldn't it be the same for employers?
It is, but it still costs more overall to have two PT employees on your books than it does to have one FT employee, both in terms of money and time.

When I recruited in retail, some of the issues we had were:

Double the uniform costs.
Double the time spent training (and double the costs involved, as we sent people away on training courses - so 2 x travel costs, 2 x hotel rooms, 2 x food allowances)
People wanting a certain number of days per week - recruiting for a 2x day a week position was next to impossible as it wasn't enough money for most people to make it worth while.

PinkPlantCase · 30/11/2021 19:44

Also I think the assumption on here that wfh is so that the OP can save on childcare is unfair. OP may be very committed to her job but just wants more flexibility.

I’m going back FT after maternity leave and will have 2 days a week wfh.

The wfh days mean that my baby doesn’t need to be dropped off a nursery until 8.45 on those days instead of 7.45 AND it means it can be me who collects him. I won’t save any money on the start time it’s just nicer for baby to have a less rushed morning.

Nursery shuts at 6pm and my job finishes at 5:30, I physically can’t get home fast enough to collect unless I work from home.

Aprilx · 30/11/2021 19:43

@AndMatt

I was at risk of losing my job once because the "other half" of my PT role left and they basically CBA to try and find a replacement. I was offered the choice of going FT or redundancy (which was apparently OK because the PT role was redundant, they needed someone FT).

Anyway, when I asked for data on the number of women employed at my level in the company (which was very poor at the time) they backed right down and decided I would keep the PT role. They actually appointed a FT man to fill the gap left by my PT colleague.

I think just letting them know I wasn't going quietly was enough.

That said, you have no automatic right to have your flexible working request met, you need to show how it will work for the company (and one reason may be to retain women). Part time is still a discrimination issue because it overwhelmingly affects women.

You didn’t need to go into the stats on women workers. You cannot legally be made redundant because there is an abundance of work and you work insufficient hours. Redundancy relates to a lack of work, so that would have have been an unfair dismissal.
Aprilx · 30/11/2021 19:39

Yes you are unreasonable to ask for the working arrangements of other mums, not least why just mums and not other part time workers! In any case it is none of your business and furthermore not relevant to your request for part time hours. Just because an organisation can accommodate one request doesn’t mean they have to accommodate every request. Even within the same team, maybe I have a team of ten and agree that one person can go part time, it doesn’t mean I can (or must) agree the other nine all go part time too.

You need to focus on your own request and how it would work for the business. There are eight legitimate reasons a business can turn down a request so I would look them up and then base your business case around them, effectively eliminating all as reasons to decline your request.

Truthfully, I think you have asked a lot of many employers though. Going from five days in the office to two days in the office and one at home would be a large adjustment and I am wondering if you have made it clear you will have childcare in place for the at home day too. If not, I would make sure you have done this.

PinkPlantCase · 30/11/2021 19:38

@LivinginWFHlimbo

Work have said that 3 days a week in my role won't work, they're happy to allow me to work 3 days for the initial return to work period of 3 months but then I will need to increase to 4.

Personally I'd accept this, try my absolute best to make it work in these three months and then apply again for the reduction from four to three days, pointing out the evidence that it works. At this point I think it becomes harder for them to argue against - three months is long enough that it's hard to see why it would be ok for then but not for longer.

This is a really useful post!
FlorenceWintle · 30/11/2021 19:38

@LivinginWFHlimbo

Work have said that 3 days a week in my role won't work, they're happy to allow me to work 3 days for the initial return to work period of 3 months but then I will need to increase to 4.

Personally I'd accept this, try my absolute best to make it work in these three months and then apply again for the reduction from four to three days, pointing out the evidence that it works. At this point I think it becomes harder for them to argue against - three months is long enough that it's hard to see why it would be ok for then but not for longer.

Agree 100% with this. You have a chance to show them you can make three days work. Come back to the WFH later.
PrincessPaws · 30/11/2021 19:35

It depends on your specific role and the circumstances of it. Even if someone else does it in 3 days, it isn't a case of 'they can do it, so you must let me', because each request has to be looked at on its own merits eg in a simple example - if you have 4 in a team, one drops their hours to 3 days, and a year later person 2 also requests 3 days. Person 2 could be declined because person 1 doing it means that they can't reallocate the work of 4 full time roles amongst the team with 2 part timers. Yes they have to consider job shares etc but they can't force person 1 to change to accommodate person 2, so it may be a no

NerrSnerr · 30/11/2021 19:12

You need to be clear why you want the WFH day. If it's so your child can be with you it won't work. I'm guessing that's why they're saying it's dependent on performance.

Wheresmywoolyjumpers · 30/11/2021 19:08

@DreamerSeven

You can’t use the fact someone else works part-time to justify how it will work for your particular role. And someone else’s flexible working arrangements shouldn’t be disclosed without their consent. You need to focus on countering the business reasons your employers must provide to explain why their decision is wrong.
In my experience this is the only way to get adjustments at time - they have allowed someone else to do xyz so why are they refusing for you to do it?