Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be fed up with the lazy graduates I work with....

236 replies

H0bnob · 30/11/2021 11:31

And I say this as an early 20s recent graduate myself! So many young people both in my immediate team and within my department seem to have such a shocking attitude to work I'm finding it really grating. Most of these people have just finished there degree/masters and have never had to work before now and the attitude it just shocking!

To add to this, everyone seems to have anxiety and depression to some degree. I am absolutely NOT dismissing mental health issues and having lived with several i know how debilitating they can be....but to use it as an excuse to get out of everything is just taking the piss....being too lazy to do your job is not the same thing as being depressed, grow up for Christ's sake and take some responsibility.

One of my colleagues (same age as me) has had almost 20 sick days in the last 6 months for mental health...and yet goes out drinking and taking drugs every weekend without failure. When said colleague is in they also do nothing but sit on their phone and complain about being bored and tired. My managers seem reluctant to do anything too with the worry of accidental discrimination and so the rest of us are forced to continuously pick up the slack. Its really doing my head in now, am I being hugely intolerant?? Fully prepared to be told I I as obviously you never know what's going on behind the scenes but christ this is relentless! Apologies this has turned into a proper rant im just so frustrated by society at the minute.

OP posts:
EightWheelGirl · 30/11/2021 17:16

I’ve often found new graduates to be much more immature than those who went into trade apprenticeships at 16yo. The latter would have actually been out there working when the graduates were only just starting their degrees, which is often the first time they’ve had to do their own laundry etc.

peaceanddove · 30/11/2021 17:05

Oh it's the public sector? What a surprise Hmm

LowlandLucky · 30/11/2021 17:02

Too many people (of all ages) use the MH excuse these days and it make it so hard for those that do suffer MH issues. The shirkers know that MH issues can't be disproved. They also know how bad it looks if anyone calls them out on their piss taking ways. It is a ticket to a free rode. At the same time the slightest negative emotion is seen as a MH issue, a bit of stress, nervousness, being a bit fed up or down. These are normal everyday run of the mill emotions not MH problems.

IfNot · 30/11/2021 17:00

I work with several people in their early twenties and they are all admirably bright eyed, bushy tailed, intelligent and hard working. They amaze me actually. At 22 I could hardly get out of bed before noon. And why the “ public sector “ comments? It’s not all tea breaks and work to rule now you know! Public sector orgs like the NHS and the civil service squeeze the most work out of you for the lowest pay possible, it’s relentless ( and yes I have worked in the private sector extensively).
If I were you OP I would mind your own business.

Lotusmonster · 30/11/2021 17:00

I’m sorry but the small matter of a global pandemic meaning mainly online teaching, self isolation and no graduation ceremonies plus the same debts plus lecturer strikes has probably left its mark on the mental health of cohorts x 24 months!!! Are you really surprised at that as well as the pitiful access to MH referral services across the UK. Sorry OP I find your ‘snap out of it’ mentality a bit shit.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 30/11/2021 16:59

Yes it is public sector

Quelle surprise Hmm

Back with your original question, graduates vary like everyone else and you'll get slackers along with the countless excellent ones
Unfortunately, IME too many slackers are drawn to the public sector precisely because they know there's little chance of anyone taking the responsibility for dealing with them

PlumManor · 30/11/2021 16:52

I don’t think it’s generational either. I do work with some entitled graduates who aren’t prepared to start before 9 or finish after 5 and expect a top whack salary because they have a degree.

I also work with some people my own age and older who have managed 40
years in this business by being totally and utterly useless and when they weren’t useless they were off sick.

As a parent we need to build resilience in our children and prepare them for the realities of work as soon as they are able. Saturday jobs, paper rounds, part time work around uni if that’s where they end up. We should also be making it clear to our children That university is not necessarily the right route to a happiness, and a good well paid job.

There must be 1000s of people that would have been happier, more fulfilled and better paid if they done a vocational route to employment.

And I
Might be able to get a plumber Grin

Squashpocket · 30/11/2021 16:51

This has been driving mad recently, so I'm going to say it even though I'm sure I'll get my arse handed to me...

Say you lack focus at work (because it's mind numbingly fucking boring and your boss doesn't appreciate you) and you Google strategies to help you manage your lack of productivity - 99% guarantee Google will tell you you've got ADHD.

Or you're only 23 and you have to go to a networking event with 50 other 45 year old professionals who know their stuff and probably each other. You feel bone crushingly awkward. Google tells you you're autistic.

So rather than develop strategies to manage these totally normal, unpleasant life events you diagnose yourself with a disorder and bingo! Now you don't have to improve yourself and it's everyone else's problem.

VoluptuaGoodshag · 30/11/2021 16:50

It’s the L’Oréal effect. So many entitled folk nowadays who think a certain way of behaving is ok ‘because they are worth it’.

That said, I’m in my 50s and used to work in the public sector and there were always slackers pulling sickies who were carried by others who worked hard. It used to really piss me off that they always got away with it. I eventually moved into the private sector where hard work was rewarded and slackers got a boot up the arse.
Don’t know what it’s like now but a friend who works in HR says that in many cases where a line manager tries to pull someone up about slacking or whatever they’ll be accused of bullying and slacker goes off with stress.

Even during the first lockdown I felt I was being had. Our community pulled together to match vulnerable people with folk who could get their shopping/medicine/errands. I got a call from a lady that I never actually saw. She lived in a flat with a security door which I would buzz then she would leave her shopping list and money outside her door for me. Said she couldn’t go out because of her mental health issues. This arrangement went on for weeks but I started to notice that she wanted more and more stuff bought, and it had to be a certain brand of pizza coz that’s all her son ate. Then she was adding 8 cans of a certain type of beer coz that’s what her husband liked. I had assumed she was totally on her own but unless they all had mental health issues then surely one of them could have nipped to the shop. Instead of getting a few bits and pieces for her I was doing a huge family shop at shops I normally wouldn’t go to. When dog food and cat was added I realised that somebody must’ve been going out to walk the dog so her ‘I cannot go outside’ didn’t really ring true. I eventually stopped the arrangement when restrictions eased a bit and she said oh that’s fine I’ll just get the shopping delivered from Asda.

Brainstorm21 · 30/11/2021 16:46

I'd say the truth is somewhere in between hopeless staff and hopeless management. Where I work at least 2 of our team of 6 are genuinely hopeless at their jobs.

1 is a 'trier' and does his level best despite being completely unqualified for his job.

The other is permanently off ill with various ailments but has no problem going out every weekend. Has come into the office drunk, on customer calls drunk etc.

Management/HR really need to get a grip on them and try to diagnose whether there is a genuine health / mental health issue or whether they are just a lazy arsehole.

It's been 9 years so I'm not holding my breath..

Babybooboodedoo · 30/11/2021 16:44

Some people will always push against boundaries and see what they can get away with, but that’s not your problem to manage (I’m assuming you’re not a manager yet).

I think you should focus on the positives in this situation. Use this to your advantage and get yourself noticed as the dedicated hard worker. Forget about what they’re doing and be grateful that you are not facing stiff competition as you will climb the ranks faster.

Be careful not to get bogged down into the minutiae of your day job, gossiping and tittle tattle because it won’t make you look good- even if you’re right. Instead think long term and strategically. Remember that you have two jobs to manage- your day job and your career. For the former, set boundaries and keep communicating with your line manager. For the latter, a growth mindset and seeing learning opportunities from situations like these will make you stronger and progress faster.

DrSbaitso · 30/11/2021 16:43

@MintJulia

We have three new graduates. Two of them are really great, enthusiastic and hard working, the third keeps taking sick days, coming in late or taking long lunches. We had a group call out-day and she made herself self-appointed coffee monitor to avoid making any calls.

Not impressed.

Is she being managed over this?
JuicySatsuma85 · 30/11/2021 16:40

YANBU I’m 36, so not an “all millennials & gen z are snowflakes” person by any means since I’m a millennial myself, but I am astonished how many people don’t have a job now until they graduate at 21/22.

Everyone I went to school with had a PT job as soon as they turned 16 & continued with it throughout university. I don’t care what your degree is in or how much it cost, if you’ve never had a basic job before & think you can just swan into a professional environment and demand a high salary because you’ve got a degree you’re insane.

As for the MH stuff. I think it’s great that employers take it more seriously, however I agree with another poster who said that younger people especially seem to think they should never, ever been anxious or down about anything & if they are they have a condition of some sort. Feeling anxious or depressed at times is a sign that your aren’t a psychopath and you’re experiencing normal human emotions!

I have a colleague who talks about her anxiety condition a lot and she said, “Oh you know, I get really anxious if I have a first date, or a job interview & I really don’t like flying”. Well congratulations, looks like you aren’t a sociopath then!

TractorAndHeadphones · 30/11/2021 16:38

@dropitlikeitsloth small talk is very difficult over videoconferencing. A general question like ‘how is everyone’ results in everyone a) waiting for someone else to answer or b) Several people talking at once.

In a team that’s already worked together it’s Easy but not if you don’t know anyone. It’s not the grads fault

Sunshineandcoffee · 30/11/2021 16:33

However you are right Octavia it's not all, just a personally noticed increase over the last few years.

MadeItOut21 · 30/11/2021 16:33

You have some bad managers, not some new entitled generation of people. Lots of people are lazy and will do the minimum they can get away with.

Personally, in the private sector, in law, all I can see is graduates competing over who worked the longest hours and is on more projects. The competition for graduate schemes is so tough, none of them go home in the evening, ever. And they work like absolute dogs. So your experience has nothing to do with the age of the people, it's the organization's fault.

NeedAHoliday2021 · 30/11/2021 16:32

There’s a real confusion between feeling anxious about something - a normal emotion felt by 100% of people but not a reason to take a day off - and actual life limiting anxiety. I also worry about the keenness to medicate emotions.

Sunshineandcoffee · 30/11/2021 16:31

Oh yes. Also non acknowledgement of instructions etc so you are not convinced it's been heard or absorbed. Which means you then need to say annoying micomanaging things just to get a reaction to confirm you weren't just talking to yourself. Just a positive eye blink or head nod would do!....feels like parenting.

Octavia174 · 30/11/2021 16:30

What a load of tosh @H0bnob

Are you sure you are not in your 50s or 60s?

My DD has just finished her degree, before starting in the NHS, she has worked throughout in Domiciliary care, she started her shift at 7 this morning and will get home at 8pm.

ALL her cohort worked alongside their degree, manning test centres, care work, hospitality, admin and few worked in the NHS..

Shame on you for portraying ALL young people as a waste of space, instead of looking at your department, how they manage staff (or not) and their occupational health policies.
Your work place maybe poor but it is not "society"

Northernsoullover · 30/11/2021 16:28

@Legoisawesome

You literally just described someone with depression. Drinking and drugs are a sign they aren’t in a good place mentally. So is zoning out on their phones. Personally I think you are being unreasonable.
Its difficult. As a former fairly heavy drinker my mental health was a damn sight worse when I drank. You can't suffer from anxiety and drink. It causes anxiety. It causes depression. People who say they have poor mental health and drink or take drugs would find it gets a lot better once you stop using. Sadly it's not always easy to kick. What makes you unwell becomes your coping mechanism.
CityMumma78 · 30/11/2021 16:23

I know I sound like I’m 100 years old but honestly the younger generation have such a sense of entitlement and arrogance. Yes there are challenges in life and some people have genuine MH problems but jeez some people just can’t be bothered and take the absolute piss. I didn’t go to university but have worked my ass off for the last 25 years to get where I am today (private sector). Hopefully the shirkers will be performance managed out of their jobs and the opportunities given to more willing individuals.

dropitlikeitsloth · 30/11/2021 16:09

@HelplesslyHoping

YANBU. I worked online with graduates last year and they were terrible. They would tell everyone a disclaimer about their mental health before we started a meeting saying things like they might doze off or get distracted but to ignore them if they do. We also had the MH 'sufferers' on their phones and talking about their weekend plans which they weren't too depressed to do apparently.

I'm all for people having a grumble but trauma dumping and using MH as an excuse just puts a bad name on people who genuinely can't work because of their MH. In the end their managers basically told them if they're unfit for work they'll have to leave.

DP’s work have just recruited some graduates into his team and he says they just don’t engage at all. He’s not line management mire senior level technical but he says it frustrating. It doesn’t help the office is WFH but they just go on mute and don’t speak the whole meeting. Even if there’s a question, how is everyone? Anyone have any questions? Just silence. He says it’s like they’re asleep, so difficult to engage with in what should be an interesting technical field. Maybe COVID has meant they’ve forgotten how to communicate 😬but even if you have nothing to say a ‘no, nothing from me’ is better than silence 🙃
EatSleepRantRepeat · 30/11/2021 16:03

This is absolutely none of your business. If you're having to pick up slack, speak to your manager and refuse, giving them the reason that you're overloaded. I'm one of those people who struggle on to pay the mortgage every month despite autism and mental health issues, and busybodies sticking their oar in like this boils my piss

OnwardsAndSideways1 · 30/11/2021 16:01

There is a huge amount of support at university for students now. Most of that is good, so better mental health services. Where it starts to get over-egged IMO is when disability discrimination legislation is interpreted to mean that people don't have to do the same things as others- so if their essay is a bit incoherent, there's a reason for that (learning difficulty), if they can't speak in public, don't make them and so on, if they can't cope with an exam, let them do an assessment. It would be much much better for these students if their problems were accommodated by giving them some more time or helping them with their anxiety, but they were still required to perform the same standard tasks as everyone else. Unfortunately they don't realise the world of work isn't going to be like that, and if someone wants a report, they won't want your problems/lateness/issues to be the reason it isn't delivered.

I feel torn though, as I do think we have gone wrong as a society in not making school and university a truly great supportive place for young people, it's all very performance oriented around exams, and that's led to a whole culture of exceptions around that performance, instead of it being about genuinely learning and engaging. Hence once students get into the world of work, they struggle now they don't have these discounts; they don't realise they have to look within and find their own motivation/interest/need for money to keep going.

I hate the UK the uni system of making everyone 'pay' and then getting cross they behave like a customer and are rather demanding- then taking this attitude into work. Not sure of the answer.

Kite22 · 30/11/2021 15:54

YANBU to be annoyed with your colleague, but YABU to title your thread as if all graduates (except yourself) are the same.
YANBU to be annoyed with all the self diagnosing and trivialising of mental health issues. It happens a lot on here too.