Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be fed up with the lazy graduates I work with....

236 replies

H0bnob · 30/11/2021 11:31

And I say this as an early 20s recent graduate myself! So many young people both in my immediate team and within my department seem to have such a shocking attitude to work I'm finding it really grating. Most of these people have just finished there degree/masters and have never had to work before now and the attitude it just shocking!

To add to this, everyone seems to have anxiety and depression to some degree. I am absolutely NOT dismissing mental health issues and having lived with several i know how debilitating they can be....but to use it as an excuse to get out of everything is just taking the piss....being too lazy to do your job is not the same thing as being depressed, grow up for Christ's sake and take some responsibility.

One of my colleagues (same age as me) has had almost 20 sick days in the last 6 months for mental health...and yet goes out drinking and taking drugs every weekend without failure. When said colleague is in they also do nothing but sit on their phone and complain about being bored and tired. My managers seem reluctant to do anything too with the worry of accidental discrimination and so the rest of us are forced to continuously pick up the slack. Its really doing my head in now, am I being hugely intolerant?? Fully prepared to be told I I as obviously you never know what's going on behind the scenes but christ this is relentless! Apologies this has turned into a proper rant im just so frustrated by society at the minute.

OP posts:
ChloeCrocodile · 30/11/2021 18:54

You aren't wrong, but I strongly suspect people like this exist in every generation. It is probably just that for many they get better at hiding laziness and they get older. Hard work is a habit and work ethic can certainly improve with proper management.

Speaking of which, people taking the piss regarding self diagnosed "anxiety" and other mental health problems should be properly managed too. That means referrals to occupational health and reasonable adjustments to enable them to work if they actually do turn out to have a MH problem. It certainly doesn't mean just blithely accepting "I have anxiety" as an excuse for underperformance, and other staff absolutely shouldn't have to cover additional work over a significant period of time.

Wheresmywoolyjumpers · 30/11/2021 18:51

[quote Babybooboodedoo]@Wheresmywoolyjumpers yes, it’s important to teach (young) people that achieving something should feel challenging and difficult. There is no success without effort and sometimes a challenge will feel insurmountable. But with the right support, training and self belief/ resilience, amazing achievements can be accomplished.

That’s why it’s so important to teach young people about the importance of grit and a good, consistent work ethic. This doesn’t mean working yourself into the ground. In fact, nourishing rest improves your performance at work.

We have really failed to teach young people the importance of these behaviours, that previous generations well understood.[/quote]
I agree but think it is also about tolerating boredom, discomfort and fear. And this is up to the parents and starts young - when your little one can't do something you keep encouraging them rather than doing it for them. If they fail something at school, unless it is totally outrageous, you ask them what they are going to do to pass next time. I remember getting my first job as soon as I was legally allowed to work - I went into all the shops in my little town until I found one which was hiring. I was terrified and embarrassed to ask and desperately uncomfortable. And scared on my first day. How proud I was when got a job. And even more when I learned that my (undemonstrative grandpa) had said he was proud of me for doing it. Over protective parents damage their kids so much by preventing them from having these experiences.

Myothercarisalsoshit · 30/11/2021 18:48

I'm a teacher. Anyone behaving like this would be managed out within about three months. It's not a public / private sector phenomenon. It's the commodification of education ... these young people have gone into shitloads of debt and have had it sold to them as leading to great things. The reality is always different. For balance, I have a 20 year old BEd student in my class at the moment and even though she has been let down over the last two years by COVID she is working like a trouper. I also have a 24 year old with schizophrenia who was badly let down by his uni to the point where he had a psychotic episode and had to be sectioned so you can piss off with your 'mental health' in quotes ...

willstarttomorrow · 30/11/2021 18:47

I work in the public sector in a role which is (yet) to be provided by the private sector. All jobs are graduate/post graduate because they have to be and when I started universities would not even consider you if you were under 25 and did not have considerable related experience. I am constantly in awe of my younger colleagues due to their maturity, professionalism and just bloody well getting on with a very difficult job.

The issue is now universities who have more than doubled their intake in the subject and put pressure on practice educators never to fail an obviously failing student. Even though there is a shortage of suitably qualified workers, many graduates are just not employable.

itsallgoingpearshaped · 30/11/2021 18:43

I'm not surprised, sadly.

I've never seen so many sc-called 'mental health' excuses in my life ... seems to be a luxury self-diagnosis in the west in public sector jobs.

Babybooboodedoo · 30/11/2021 18:42

@Wheresmywoolyjumpers yes, it’s important to teach (young) people that achieving something should feel challenging and difficult. There is no success without effort and sometimes a challenge will feel insurmountable. But with the right support, training and self belief/ resilience, amazing achievements can be accomplished.

That’s why it’s so important to teach young people about the importance of grit and a good, consistent work ethic. This doesn’t mean working yourself into the ground. In fact, nourishing rest improves your performance at work.

We have really failed to teach young people the importance of these behaviours, that previous generations well understood.

gettingolderandgrumpy · 30/11/2021 18:41

Agreed it’s a management issue have a similar issue where I work .

Wheresmywoolyjumpers · 30/11/2021 18:38

Hi @H0bnob - I work in mental health. I get a lot of younger people coming in talking about their anxiety and depression which, on investigation, turns out to be an unwillingness to accept that sometimes life is a bit shit and you don't feel great but have to get on with it anyway. It really annoys me as I believe it undermines people who have genuine MH problems and becomes an excuse for not doing what people don't want to do. I do believe that most of this group genuinely think they do have MH problems, but don't feel pandering to them is the way to go.

Babybooboodedoo · 30/11/2021 18:37

What a load of rubbish about people in the public sector working less than private sector.

I’ve worked extensively in both. Incompetent and lazy people exist in both. On balance if sat management is better in public sector because there is more investment in training.

It is true that it’s slightly easier to manage someone out of a private company. Often there are more robust metrics in place to measure performance against ie monetary targets in private sector v woolier targets in public sector.

Xenia · 30/11/2021 18:34

The solution is no sick pay until day 3 and then only SSP (that soon ensures people turn up!!) and sack them before the end of the probation period.

JuergenWasRobbed · 30/11/2021 18:31

I had a graduate sales person email me about six times recently trying to sell something. She hadn't looked at what my company does, mixed my name up and became increasingly persistent. I may have sent a pass agg reply

icelolly12 · 30/11/2021 18:26

Every generation X thinks they are going to be either a social media star or the next Steve Jobs/Elon Musk. Reality hits hard...

Ilady · 30/11/2021 18:25

I worked in a number of places and in a few different different industries. I agree about the mollycoddled youngsters and how much reality hits them in the world of work. I have seen places where grads were pushed up in work to low or mid management roles and they could not organise a piss up in a brewery. They looked good on paper and could talk the talk. Meanwhile other people in their team were trying to tell them their bright idea was not a runner, were left sorting their mess and then dealing with a lack of staff because people had enough of working their and moved on.

It now like that some younger people never have the word no said to them or are made to help out at home. They are let sit at home during the weekends/school holidays when some of their friends have part time jobs. Then they go into the world of work and can't accept they will be told off and seem to think they don't have to start at the bottom or do the less nice part of their job.
I know teenagers who have gotten work experience that helped them get PT jobs. The same teenagers are willing to listen to people explain what they are doing wrong or what they need to improve in work.

People are now more aware of Mh issues and I think that some times the lazy, work shy and I am a graduate crowd can say I have X or y to make life as easy as possible in work. If you have Mh issues you won't feel like going out at the weekend drinking ect. It unfair on the people who have Mh issues that they are working on to improve.

Then some managers just look at a CV and take on a graduate with none or very little experience and expect that they will know how to do everything on day one. For some jobs a bit of work and life experience is far better than a degree. I know some clever people who can be total trouble in the work place for either the company or its staff. Then it takes ages to manage them out because a company does not want an unfair dismissal case because of them.

icelolly12 · 30/11/2021 18:23

Ime it's mainly male graduates like this... females know they have to work harder to get ahead and have done so at school, college, uni etc.

H0bnob · 30/11/2021 18:22

@Octavia174

I ve worked in both public and private sector and poor management and laziness exist in both.

A new starter taking 20 days off, over a number of separate times, in 6months, would trigger a meeting to discus, followed by further action, this is pretty common in the public & private sectors now, new starters aren't on the sort of contracts of the past.

I think you don't like young people do you?

I'm 23!!! I am a young person 😂
OP posts:
Octavia174 · 30/11/2021 18:21

I ve worked in both public and private sector and poor management and laziness exist in both.

A new starter taking 20 days off, over a number of separate times, in 6months, would trigger a meeting to discus, followed by further action, this is pretty common in the public & private sectors now, new starters aren't on the sort of contracts of the past.

I think you don't like young people do you?

Marchingredsoldiers · 30/11/2021 18:20

Oh my god! Am i the only who recognises myself from 20 years ago Blush. In my defence i was in the wrong job and after a while i got into the right profession. (I work my arse now, so have made up for it!) I am cringing when I consider my work ethic in my twenties and reading this thread...

Kite22 · 30/11/2021 18:20

There seems to be an idea amongst lots of people (not just the young) that "normal" people sail through life without any problems and rarely, if ever, find any tasks stressful or anxiety-inducing. Therefore if they are not like this, and find situations like speaking to new people, talking over the phone, making appointments or driving to new places hard, they must have "anxiety" and shouldn't have to do those things.

Whereas in real life most people have different things they find stressful or worrying the first few times they do them, or even always, but have learnt that the best way to get over it is to just do it. And then do it again. And then again. And by the fifth or 20th time you've built up techniques and resilience to be able to do the difficult task, even if you never feel entirely comfortable.

There's a difference between feeling anxious about something (completely normal) and having anxiety but they seem to be conflated too often. Even if you are diagnosed with anxiety, there are so many coping mechanisms out there the aim should always be to manage it as much as possible rather than just "opting out" - as that then becomes a self-fulfilling prophecy.

Excellent post

Also another excellent point from @Feedingthebirds1

I too have experience of this at 16-18 level whre 2 people clearly weren't suitable, and didn't give a monkeys, but were "not allowed" to be failed. What's the point ?

Stripyhoglets1 · 30/11/2021 18:13

I wish I knew which part of the public sector is an easy life cos its not the bit I'm in! And I'm not frontline either.
Mind you it does take ages to get rid of people if they are not able to do the job - it is possible though as there's only a need to make "reasonable adjustments" and if your illness genuinely means you can't do the job eventually you do have to leave. And some people are lazy - but the majority work extremely hard and it's noticed and appreciated.
I've not particularly noticed an issue with younger staff - but we have had people join us from the private sector who've quickly gone back to the private sector as its so demanding, busy and low paid. They think the lower pay means it will be less demanding but it really isn't.

Feedingthebirds1 · 30/11/2021 18:11

As a recently retired uni lecturer, can I offer another perspective?

Universities used to be autonomous. They got on and did their own thing. Now they are inspected regularly and answerable to a number of different bodies for their performance. Two criteria on which they are always judged are retention (how many students who enrolled are still there at the end of the course) and achievement (how many students leave with the degree they signed up for). Poor retention and achievement threatens their funding, even their existence. That puts pressure on the universities to avoid any student either leaving or failing, and they do anything to avoid that. So if a student doesn't submit their work on the deadline, they are given a revised study plan with a new deadline...then another...and another. If they don't attend lectures, the lecturer has to give them the time to catch up. A colleague of mine in a different department was told that if any of his students failed his module he would be held responsible.

After the introduction of league tables for schools, and the pressure schools therefore put on their pupils, university used to be the last area of education where there was a consequence for doing no work. Not any more. The students are not allowed to fail. And they are absolved of any responsibility for actually getting their degree.

Of course, this isn't all students. Many are still hard working and want to succeed on their own merits and by their own efforts. And they get very pissed off by the students who are forever having allowances made for them when there are no issues, they are simply lazy and entitled.

The bodies to which the universities are accountable were introduced after tuition fees were brought in, and I fully get that it is necessary to ensure that the students who are paying a heavy price for their degrees deserve to have the quality of their education assured. But there have been unintended consequences which some students have been all too willing to exploit, who believe that paying for it entitles them to a degree without any further input from them, and who the system rewards. And it has undoubtedly led to a number of graduates believing that the world owes them a living.

lightisnotwhite · 30/11/2021 18:08

@Lotusmonster

I’m sorry but the small matter of a global pandemic meaning mainly online teaching, self isolation and no graduation ceremonies plus the same debts plus lecturer strikes has probably left its mark on the mental health of cohorts x 24 months!!! Are you really surprised at that as well as the pitiful access to MH referral services across the UK. Sorry OP I find your ‘snap out of it’ mentality a bit shit.
The pandemic had as many ups as downs though especially for the kids. Zero exam stress. Does anyway care what the kids got this year or last? Joggers and crap hair were acceptable. Teens didn’t have to worry about getting jumped in the park or who they were going out with Saturday. They could be rebels by just being out rather than smashing a bus stop. The biggest stress was being with their parents.
Happyhappyday · 30/11/2021 18:08

I was 23 and managing 70 staff in a busy London shop & one of the department manager I supervised was messing around, showing up late constantly, hungover, dramatic affairs with her staff etc. I went to my boss for advice on how to deal with her and he said something like “she’s only 25, so young etc” and I remember looking at him and saying I’m only bloody 23 and I have my shit together!!! I got so annoyed at “being young” as excuse for being a lazy sod. I wasn’t that lazy when I was 15!

MintyGreenDream · 30/11/2021 18:05

@Squashpocket I agree

Eleganz · 30/11/2021 18:04

My experience is that you can get these types in many places but in the public sector but line managers are given far less support, training and autonomy and paid much less than in the private sector - no surprise they are less effective really.

I suffer from GAD, fully diagnosed and managed with a combination of CBT and, at times, medication. I am supportive of colleagues and my staff who are struggling with their mental health of course, but there are always chancers and people who seem not to get that being anxious is not the same has "having anxiety". Being anxious is one of many totally normal human emotions that we all experience, this is quite different from the crippling experience of being in the middle of a genuine panic attack or highly destructive behaviour brought on by extreme anxiety.

Larryyourwaiter · 30/11/2021 18:04

I worked with a young man who was regularly off ‘depressed’ on a Monday and sometimes Tuesday.
He would go out Thursday, Friday and Saturday nights BIG TIME. He would then spend all day on Sunday in bed and eating takeaways ‘depressed’. He would perk up on a Wednesday and back going out on Thursday.
10 years on he has grown out of it though.

Swipe left for the next trending thread