Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be fed up with the lazy graduates I work with....

236 replies

H0bnob · 30/11/2021 11:31

And I say this as an early 20s recent graduate myself! So many young people both in my immediate team and within my department seem to have such a shocking attitude to work I'm finding it really grating. Most of these people have just finished there degree/masters and have never had to work before now and the attitude it just shocking!

To add to this, everyone seems to have anxiety and depression to some degree. I am absolutely NOT dismissing mental health issues and having lived with several i know how debilitating they can be....but to use it as an excuse to get out of everything is just taking the piss....being too lazy to do your job is not the same thing as being depressed, grow up for Christ's sake and take some responsibility.

One of my colleagues (same age as me) has had almost 20 sick days in the last 6 months for mental health...and yet goes out drinking and taking drugs every weekend without failure. When said colleague is in they also do nothing but sit on their phone and complain about being bored and tired. My managers seem reluctant to do anything too with the worry of accidental discrimination and so the rest of us are forced to continuously pick up the slack. Its really doing my head in now, am I being hugely intolerant?? Fully prepared to be told I I as obviously you never know what's going on behind the scenes but christ this is relentless! Apologies this has turned into a proper rant im just so frustrated by society at the minute.

OP posts:
claretblue79 · 01/12/2021 01:17

@Preech. Great post. What I have taken from this thread is that unless you have been diagnosed with a anxiety disorder which is somehow worse than anxiety, not sure why, then basically you are not resilient, therefore your fault. I don't actually think attitudes towards mental health have moved on very much at all. That's the trouble with the world now, too little understanding and too many people deciding whether your problems are worthy or not. Will leave it there as it just makes me really angry.

Preech · 30/11/2021 22:58

Does one have to wind up hospitalised before their mental health problems "count"?

If not, when do they count?

I appreciate there is a discussion here about a lack of perceived resilience and responsibility among some young people, but some of the chat also seems to be leaning towards mental health stigma, and implying that mental health problems are typically just made up by the work-shy, rather than genuine.

FWIW, it took me years to work up the courage to finally treat my shitty mental health. I didn't know what to expect until a kind colleague of mine explained exactly how the treatment process worked, step by step. Until then, I was petrified that admitting I regularly wrestled with suicidal ideation would land me ... in a hospital (my impressions of which were informed by Requiem for a Dream and One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest).

My pre-diagnosis anxiety drove me to work to the point of burnout. After burnout came decision paralysis. In both cases, the response was driven by the belief that my work couldn't possibly be good enough.

My colleagues thought the former was great: I was a performer. They thought the latter was not so great: now I was no longer performing. The colleague who took the time to ask if I was okay, and probably helped save my life, worked in a completely different department. The colleagues in my own department who worked with me every day, and my managers, only had criticism for me.

If your colleagues are citing their mental health as a reason they're not working to your standards, why don't you try asking them if they're ok? It doesn't have to be hospital-worthy for it to count.

Wheresmywoolyjumpers · 30/11/2021 22:22

@Babybooboodedoo - how scary to hear little children are talking like this. I don't think I had every heard of anxiety at that age.

@Kite22 - yes I think you are on to something. Sometimes kids have to sort things out themselves.

@Confuciusornis- your post made so much sense to me. Pathologizing people, or letting them pathologize themselves ultimately hurts them. Instead of 'I can't do this' we should be encouraging children and young people to ask themselves 'how can I do this?'. And for the people in these age groups who have not gone down to route of over sensitivity to emotions, what must life be like? No wonder OP (and many others) are so frustrated.

Babybooboodedoo · 30/11/2021 22:22

Wow great post @Confuciusornis you hit the nail on the head.

Although the intention may come from a place of kindness, the result is not so kind to many graduates. Unintended consequences and all that.

scarpa · 30/11/2021 22:18

@scarpa

Agreed.

50% of our employees are recent grads (21-26). Every single one of them works their arse off and is lovely to be around.

But then we also create a workplace environment where being hardworking is rewarded and they're not treated like shit... having worked in the public sector as a graduate I reckon that's probably half the problem here!

Oop, my post was in reply to a PP who said the young people on graduate law schemes they know work really hard.
scarpa · 30/11/2021 22:17

Agreed.

50% of our employees are recent grads (21-26). Every single one of them works their arse off and is lovely to be around.

But then we also create a workplace environment where being hardworking is rewarded and they're not treated like shit... having worked in the public sector as a graduate I reckon that's probably half the problem here!

PrincessPaws · 30/11/2021 22:06

[quote honeylulu]@PrincessPaws
I agree wholeheartedly with the substance of your post.
I would just demur that "anxiety" itself is not a disorder but an entirely normal feeling in circumstances that provoke it. It is simply a state of feeling anxious (worried, agitated etc) It does not mean the same as an anxiety disorder. The trouble is that this error is common and many people seize on the word "anxiety" to imply that they have an actual anxiety disorder.

I am anxious/ have anxiety (genuinely) at times but I am confident that I do not have an anxiety disorder. I just get worried and stressed when I have challenges or time pressures with no obvious outlet.[/quote]
As someone who was diagnosed with and medicated for GAD as a teen (a LONG time ago now) I know exactly what you mean, however 'anxiety' has very much entered the lexicon and is now freely used for everything from feeling a bit worried to an actual diagnosed and treated anxiety disorder - what you are saying is exactly my point, anxiety is used for anything worrying or uncomfortable. But IME an awful lot of young people will take an uncomfortable experience and cling on, then talking about their (often self diagnosed) 'illness', posting memes about anxiety etc

Confuciusornis · 30/11/2021 22:05

@1967buglet

I’m not sure why, but the past five years teaching university has been like this…loads of MH issues, and we of course have had to accommodate (and gladly, because the vast vast majority are quite genuine). I acknowledge there are a few that may be taking the piss, but there have been increased numbers of student suicides, and there is some real suffering out there. It is a difficult situation, and COVID didn’t help. I guess I would ask us all to think about growing up in a recession with housing prices out of reach, going to uni in a pandemic, and starting a first job in a pandemic. It isn’t great for young people today.
I also teach in a university and whilst I’d agree that we ought to be compassionate given all the challenges faced by the current generation of undergrads/grads, I’m also somewhat sympathetic to OP’s complaints. And honestly, I worry that we in HE are partly responsible. Some MH problems are real and need treatment. No question. But I worry that in our (mostly laudable) eagerness to ensure that all those who need that help get it, we’re increasingly pathologising perfectly normal emotional experiences and persuading young people that they are sick and incapable when actually they’re not. People don’t build confidence and resilience if they’re told that being a bit worried about an essay is a symptom of GAD and that they need a long extension and CBT, they do it by facing their fear, writing the essay for the deadline, and learning that yes, they can do it, and no, the world won’t end if this particular piece of work is a bit below their usual standard. As it is, we’re pushing a lot of students out into the workforce who consider themselves fragile and helpless and who think it’s anyone’s responsibility but theirs to address these problems. This is not good for them, never mind their bosses and colleagues. I really worry about it.
Kite22 · 30/11/2021 22:05

I agree but think it is also about tolerating boredom, discomfort and fear. And this is up to the parents and starts young - when your little one can't do something you keep encouraging them rather than doing it for them. If they fail something at school, unless it is totally outrageous, you ask them what they are going to do to pass next time. I remember getting my first job as soon as I was legally allowed to work - I went into all the shops in my little town until I found one which was hiring. I was terrified and embarrassed to ask and desperately uncomfortable. And scared on my first day. How proud I was when got a job. And even more when I learned that my (undemonstrative grandpa) had said he was proud of me for doing it. Over protective parents damage their kids so much by preventing them from having these experiences.

I do agree with this.

There are so many threads on here where parents are encouraged to "phone 101 and report it to the police" or to march into the school to sort out some minor issue or to speak to the parent of their dc's friend because of some fall out or to report it to OFSTED as soon as there is a disagreement with the school. Before we get on to the ludicrous number of times people advise posters to leave their husband or longstanding partner over something that can almost always be worked through.

Babybooboodedoo · 30/11/2021 22:05

@Wheresmywoolyjumpers Wow, this speaks volumes:

after 20 years in MH I did not expect to end up helping so many young people learn lessons that their parents should have taught them.

Thanks, this has made me think about how I model resilience with my DC. My KS1 child’s teacher said she’s never heard little kids use the word anxiety so much. She wondered if they have been listening to parents talk about their MH during lockdown. We need to be so careful about how we talk about MH in front of children, so that we outline the difference between normal human emotions and what mental health conditions.

Babybooboodedoo · 30/11/2021 21:59

20 years into my career, with the benefit of hindsight I now realise I should have been concentrating more on MY career rather than worrying about other people I worked with and their behaviour. It’s so easy to get dragged into the minutiae at work and lose sight of the bigger picture, but it’s worth strategically thinking about how best to protect yourself (ie as previous posters have said, being clear about your capacity to take on additional work with your line manager). This will allow you the time/ space to work on higher impact/ profile work that will get you further. In my experience, women are more likely to get bogged down and held back.

If this resonates with you, I highly recommend checking out the book How Women Rise (assuming you’re a woman!). I wish I’d read this book or got similar advice early in my career. Also the squiggly career podcast is very good for women.

Wheresmywoolyjumpers · 30/11/2021 21:56

I think it's a shame that some people on here seem to be so dismissive about depression and anxiety

On the whole people here are differentiating between having feelings of depression and anxiety and having a disorder. And those things are very different. But it seems that there are increasing numbers of younger people feel anything which causes distress is a disorder and warrants special attention and adjustments. This is what is not helpful. And yes, if people are struggling to cope they deserve support but only in order that they can do what is expected of them, not get out of doing what they don't want to do. Not sure if the comment about people getting into mental health as a power trip is a dig at anyone in particular, and I sure you are right. Personally I got into it to help alleviate suffering and be of service. But after 20 years in MH I did not expect to end up helping so many young people learn lessons that their parents should have taught them.

Babybooboodedoo · 30/11/2021 21:50

@H0bnob don’t worry, I didn’t think you were bashing public sector workers- my comment was directed at other posters. Also please don’t take all these comments to heart, mumsnet can be great, but also feel pretty harsh when you’re the OP. I don’t think you have said anything to imply mental health issues are not serious for many people.

H0bnob · 30/11/2021 21:47

@Mickarooni

I’m sure you have better things to do on your annual leave than to name change and criticise other young people. If you’re a graduate too, you’re also learning. Be more humble, you’ll go far.
I'm sure I do but this post was sparked by a conversation with my boyfriend and I wanted to gather opinions on the matter and see if i was alone. I'm sure spending 5 minutes out of my day to type it up, and then following up through the afternoon in between activties as I am generally interested in replies, isnt considered a waste of annual leave.

I know I am still learning...hence I am trying hard to better myself at my job and gain as many new skills as I can. Its just a shame others don't seem to be too, which is sort of my whole point...

OP posts:
H0bnob · 30/11/2021 21:44

@Octavia174

The OP was scrupulous in saying her remarks were about graduates in her work, not generalising, so not bashing, and has been back to say her intention was not to hang public service out to dry

Thats not quite the case though is it... the OP said after lambasting young people, went onto to say Apologies this has turned into a proper rant im just so frustrated by society at the minute

To me that means he/she clearly means all young people.... apart from miraculously themselves....

I also say again, any public sector organisation will deal with repeated sickness due to MH in exactly the same way they deal with any other repeated time due to illness.

It means the young people I work with...and the general use of self diagnosed mental health issues as a scapegoat for laziness across society (not limited to any one generation)
OP posts:
honeylulu · 30/11/2021 21:42

@PrincessPaws
I agree wholeheartedly with the substance of your post.
I would just demur that "anxiety" itself is not a disorder but an entirely normal feeling in circumstances that provoke it. It is simply a state of feeling anxious (worried, agitated etc) It does not mean the same as an anxiety disorder. The trouble is that this error is common and many people seize on the word "anxiety" to imply that they have an actual anxiety disorder.

I am anxious/ have anxiety (genuinely) at times but I am confident that I do not have an anxiety disorder. I just get worried and stressed when I have challenges or time pressures with no obvious outlet.

Mickarooni · 30/11/2021 21:34

I’m sure you have better things to do on your annual leave than to name change and criticise other young people. If you’re a graduate too, you’re also learning. Be more humble, you’ll go far.

Octavia174 · 30/11/2021 21:23

The OP was scrupulous in saying her remarks were about graduates in her work, not generalising, so not bashing, and has been back to say her intention was not to hang public service out to dry

Thats not quite the case though is it... the OP said after lambasting young people, went onto to say Apologies this has turned into a proper rant im just so frustrated by society at the minute

To me that means he/she clearly means all young people.... apart from miraculously themselves....

I also say again, any public sector organisation will deal with repeated sickness due to MH in exactly the same way they deal with any other repeated time due to illness.

PrincessPaws · 30/11/2021 21:18

It really is odd how young people seem completely unable to differentiate between 'anxiety' and 'feeling worried'. The amount of young people (friends and family) that I've heard say 'I can't go to that meeting, I have anxiety', 'I've cancelled my driving test, I'm too anxious', 'I decided no to go to the interview as I have anxiety so it's obviously not the right job for me' when it is perfectly reasonable for be nervous/worried/scared about all of those activities!

Sadly a lot of people seem to think that they shouldn't have to do anything that has them feeling at all out of their comfort zone, and it gives 'anxiety' a bad name. This only hurts people that genuinely have anxiety as it's become the new 'stress' or 'back pain' and is used as an excuse, so it's starting to get an eye roll at work rather than being taken seriously

I think (an awful lot of a) generation has been failed by being mollycoddled/helicopter parented, where mummy and daddy remove any potential obstacle or protect from any possible upset. This then goes into education where you can't fail

As a result some people entering the world of work are getting a huge and very nasty shock. It isn't their fault though, if you've been sheltered from any remotely unpleasant experience while you grow up, you really can't be expected to have built any resilience.

The worst bit is seeing people in the office in tears/having a tantrum because they don't want to do something, and the dawning realisation on their faces that crying isn't going to get them their own way/out of the task....

vickyp0llard · 30/11/2021 21:15

TBH, I'm not excusing pulling sickies, but I find the attitude of older people laughable sometimes....."I worked at the same company for 35 years, I did loads of boring grunt work, I worked 70 hours a week!". Like a weird race to the bottom.

OK, great.....good for you? I however do not want to be treated like shit. There are millions of companies and jobs out there - why shouldn't you move if elsewhere is offering more money or more interesting work? Also, you only get one life - I do not want to work 70 hours a week. For what? A huge house? I have a nice life, a house and everything I want on a more modest salary working 37.5 hours a week - and time for my friends and hobbies too.

EightWheelGirl · 30/11/2021 21:09

Going back to the OP, I think it's also increasingly common for youths to not be particularly money focused. In fact I read an article a while back which said exactly this.

EightWheelGirl · 30/11/2021 21:08

The highest suicide rates are 40 - 44 and 45- 50 years olds. 75% higher that of young people. The rate doesn’t reduce to that of 18-25 year olds until you reach 60.

It's odd because this is also the demographic which many seem to view as privileged/gammons/etc, when from what I can see there are many more men than women of this age bearing sole financial responsibility while the partner doesn't work.

lightisnotwhite · 30/11/2021 21:01

The high suicide rate and sectioning rate amongst the 18 - 25 year old bracket obviously passed you by then?

The highest suicide rates are 40 - 44 and 45- 50 years olds. 75% higher that of young people. The rate doesn’t reduce to that of 18-25 year olds until you reach 60.

DontBeCatty · 30/11/2021 20:57

It’s good that so much more effort is put into mental health awareness.

Suicide rates for teens are still less than they used to be 20,30 and 40 years ago albeit higher than a few years ago. It tends to be males in their 40’s and 50’s who are by far the most likely to commit suicide. They don’t get called snowflakes and people don’t go around suggesting they should be taught more resilience.

JohnDee007 · 30/11/2021 20:46

Well you sound quite aggressive and angry. You need to speak with your manager if you think you’re doing more than your fair share.

As a general rule I can understand young people suffering increasingly with poor mental health. They grow up in a largely boundaryless environment, feeling not 100% masculine/feminine? Have you thought about swopping sex? If you’re female, you should be scared of being raped every time you leave the house. If you’re a person of colour, you’ll struggle to get anywhere because every white person hates you, work hard enough you’ll get what you want, if you don’t you want get that perfect job so you can afford all the necessary stuff which will make you happy, you’ll never get a house, you must be the best performing student ever, you need to inject shit into your face to look even remotely ok, your life must be instagrammable, you must be online all the time, the only person who matters is you, don’t worry about wider consequences of actions. Quite frankly I’d be surprised if you find many young people without some mental health problems against the backdrop we make them measure themselves. It creates nihilism.

People with mental health issues are encouraged to do social things.

Having said this I do understand and it’s long been an issue. When I first started work in a professional services firm, I would be photocopying, filing etc, for the last 20 years though new grads see themselves as consumers, is the employer offering them the right service? Is the job interesting enough etc. it’s unrealistic expectations set both in the educational system, by parents and the employers themselves on the milk rounds.

Swipe left for the next trending thread