Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to loathe the people here?

735 replies

OnenessWithAllStrife · 30/11/2021 10:06

Some people say that feeling a negative emotion or having unpleasant feelings about something shouldn't define you, that you should let the thoughts flow and then let them go. OK. I hope this to be true :(

But i have lived somewhere for the past 6 years that has brought me to conclusions and created feelings in me that I am not proud of. For the first time in my life I have actually come to loathe people and feel a sense of terror about being stuck with them. This is not particularly politically 'correct' when put into words, unfortunately, but I can't think of any other way to express it.

I moved to a town6 yrs ago in which I don't have much in common with the residents. It isn't unusual, just an ordinary large town which at one time contained more diversity, but in recent years has become very insular and homogenous. Everyone is angry, anti social, or depressed. If you don't openly discuss some sort of prejudice (racism, sexism, anti-intellectualism) you're 'soft in the head' or a 'bloody weirdo'.
Wherever I go here, in any direction, you will either see kids or drunk adults destroying property, or else screaming at each other in the street. There are a few select areas that are less challenging and rough, but the vibe is somehow the same.

Education or reading is a mugs game, football is the only passion, kids are yelled at for merely existing. Any conversation with a seemingly friendly stranger results in them wishing all the foreigners to go home. There is a general air of brutality to everything, a leathery, hard resistance to any kind of sensitivity whatsoever. Art, creativity and self reflection are suspicious, and the only permissible clothing is black or sport branded. Every damned street is choked with the fumes of endlessly revved up vehicles with ear splitting exhaust modifications. The environment is filthy, full of dog shit and bordering on dereliction.

I would once have considered all of this a problem of poverty, but it isn't quite that easy to determine, having witnessed it. There is no seeming variation in behaviour across income brackets here, it looks to be more cultural than income related, although the attitude towards learning, etc will obviously have the effect of creating more poverty regardless. It is like a self perpetuating cesspit of no hope and hard hearts. I thought i was a leftie, a socialist, but when I leave here I will be fucking marked by this and hope to never exist within it ever again.

We moved here for DP's work and are set to leave this coming year. I also appreciate that the residents and I have experienced very different upbringings and we do not share much in common, but even so, I think that you have to endure this to really, really see it, to come to fear it. It is easy to sit in a comfy armchair miles from it and 'defend' this stuff because you haven't truly sampled the existential sickness of it on your own doorstep.
I wish i didn't feel it, but it is difficult to lie to oneself, and the fear has probably evolved from having felt 'stuck' in it for so long. I wfh and DP does part time (some here regard us as 'pretentious' for this and have suggested we ought to do some 'real' work). It all feels very dated and odd, to be surrounded by values that repulse me and contain so little diversity. I mean, this is the type of place where you'll get side-eyed for cooking from scratch or having the audacity to flavour a dish with pesto.

Does this mean I loathe them? I don't know. I imagine I will chill with it when we have moved, as it all becomes a distant memory, but it has certainly left a mark. It feels wrong to state these feelings and observations, but I bet I am not the only one who has thought them....

OP posts:
ThousandsOfTulips · 30/11/2021 21:58

@ChurchofLatterDayPaints

Who mentioned anything about MEPs? Total irrelevancy.

An irrelevance, yes. My point exactly. Why would people vote for keeping something they see as irrelevant?

Not everyone is as enlightened and rational as you, Tulips. Leave 'em to stew, the ignorant peasants. Ignore and scorn them a bit harder. That'll solve it.

Hahaaa I am not "enlightened", anymore than anyone else who has a functioning brain and can read.

Sadly that seems too much to ask of some.

Perhaps you're right. Based on OPs description and another posters astute description of the "reverse sieve" effect, maybe all of the shitbags smashing up cars and windows, setting fire to stuff, racially abusing people and beating each other unconscious etc will wipe each other out eventually.

buntybanana · 30/11/2021 21:58

Having made us all poorer and having stripped us and our children and grandchildren of lots of important rights and protections, don't expect me to cry for you now the EU is no longer providing development grants to your area and good luck getting the Tories to replace that money.

@ThousandsOfTulips yes, unfortunately the political divide that existed before has been deepened irreparably by the Brexit vote. The irony that most of the furious xenophobic Brexit voters are the ones that will suffer the worst consequences of their decision would almost be laughable if it wasn't so tragic.

Yes, the people who chose to do this are responsible. If they didn't understand the implications of the vote they could have researched. If they couldn't be bothered then they shouldn't have voted at all. Voting is a right but with it comes the responsibility for owning the consequences.

^ and this is why I sometimes find it hard to see them as the victims. Yes they were manipulated and yes they wouldn't be in this position if it wasn't for Tory austerity decimating the country, but there was available free information out there to research before this vote. They got so caught up in revenge seeking & immigrants instead.

RobertaFirmino · 30/11/2021 21:54

@KrakowDawn

At least you have pies! Could be worse, could be Knowlsley.

The outcomes for children born there are horrific. Possibly worst in England Sad

That's where I was born! I live in Hull atm so yes, horrific outcomes indeed! I honestly thought OP was describing Hull at first, had no idea Wigan was that bad!
ChurchofLatterDayPaints · 30/11/2021 21:54

Who mentioned anything about MEPs? Total irrelevancy.

An irrelevance, yes. My point exactly. Why would people vote for keeping something they see as irrelevant?

Not everyone is as enlightened and rational as you, Tulips. Leave 'em to stew, the ignorant peasants. Ignore and scorn them a bit harder. That'll solve it.

ThousandsOfTulips · 30/11/2021 21:48

@ChurchofLatterDayPaints

We were discussing the Brexit vote. That wasn't FPTP.

Why do you think the two are separate?

Politicians don't listen to us, they don't care, so they can all fuck off at the first available opportunity. Not a possibility?

What do people in Wigan care about MEPs swanning off to Brussels on large salaries? It's an irrelevance to them.

Who mentioned anything about MEPs? Total irrelevancy. The EU membership was important for economic and geopolitical security, food security, energy security, cyber security, combating issues that cannot be dealt with at a national level such as international crime, climate change, tax avoidance by multinationalw or wealthy and mobile individuals etc.

It's no coincidence that all other developed countries around the world are forming large trade and political alliance blocks, not leaving them.

The people of the UK showed themselves on the international stage to be incredibly thick by failing to grasp these basic facts, and so the country is now far more vulnerable in many different ways than it was 5 years ago.

Yes, the people who chose to do this are responsible. If they didn't understand the implications of the vote they could have researched. If they couldn't be bothered then they shouldn't have voted at all. Voting is a right but with it comes the responsibility for owning the consequences.

ChurchofLatterDayPaints · 30/11/2021 21:41

We were discussing the Brexit vote. That wasn't FPTP.

Why do you think the two are separate?

Politicians don't listen to us, they don't care, so they can all fuck off at the first available opportunity. Not a possibility?

What do people in Wigan care about MEPs swanning off to Brussels on large salaries? It's an irrelevance to them.

ThousandsOfTulips · 30/11/2021 21:41

@buntybanana

ThousandsOfTulips but people Who are manipulated to vote a particular way because they can see no better way forward in their current circumstances are victims in a way

@shinynewapple21 This is the big question though. Were they victims of government manipulation (which absolutely did exist) or was it marginalised people putting two fingers up to the political elite, which ultimately ended up in them being worse off than before. Probably a mixture of both. Xenophobia and racism were definitely among their reasons to vote for Brexit. Yes they're is angry and yes they have a right to be - but now Brexit and the coming fallout is a consequence we'll ALL have to live with now.

Yep. Hence all sense of solidarity or sympathy in people I know - who have generally grown up in poor backgrounds but escaped - has evaporated. If you screw over your fellow citizens, put your fingers in your ears when they point out how obviously stupid what you are doing is, and insist that you understood the full ramifications and made this choice deliberately, then.... well. Having made us all poorer and having stripped us and our children and grandchildren of lots of important rights and protections, don't expect me to cry for you now the EU is no longer providing development grants to your area and good luck getting the Tories to replace that money. 😆
ThousandsOfTulips · 30/11/2021 21:37

@ChurchofLatterDayPaints

Victims don't have a choice about what happens. What an offensive post

What makes you think FPTP gives anyone a valid choice?

As a pp said, the North is angry. I think it has every right to be.

We were discussing the Brexit vote. That wasn't FPTP.
buntybanana · 30/11/2021 21:37

ThousandsOfTulips but people
Who are manipulated to vote a particular way because they can see no better way forward in their current circumstances are victims in a way

@shinynewapple21 This is the big question though. Were they victims of government manipulation (which absolutely did exist) or was it marginalised people putting two fingers up to the political elite, which ultimately ended up in them being worse off than before. Probably a mixture of both. Xenophobia and racism were definitely among their reasons to vote for Brexit. Yes they're is angry and yes they have a right to be - but now Brexit and the coming fallout is a consequence we'll ALL have to live with now.

ThousandsOfTulips · 30/11/2021 21:36

[quote shinynewapple21]@ThousandsOfTulips but people
Who are manipulated to vote a particular way because they can see no better way forward in their current circumstances are victims in a way .

[/quote]
Shhhh we're not allowed to say that. They hollered "WE KNEW WHAT WE WERE VOTING FOR, DON'T PATRONISE US!"

So we'll hold them to that.

ChurchofLatterDayPaints · 30/11/2021 21:32

Victims don't have a choice about what happens. What an offensive post

What makes you think FPTP gives anyone a valid choice?

As a pp said, the North is angry. I think it has every right to be.

AppleCrumbleForBreakfast · 30/11/2021 21:32

I believe you and don't know how you've coped so long. I definitely wouldn't. Our surroundings are so important and it's not snobbery. Its not about money etc. It's about the vibe. Can you access nature? I find my whole body relaxing when I'm in nature. Whereas tired urban sprawl kills me very quickly. That's not snobby, it's scientific fact that humans do better surrounded by trees etc. Perhaps if those people you're describing are like they are because they're disconnected from this fundamental truth.

shinynewapple21 · 30/11/2021 21:28

@ThousandsOfTulips but people
Who are manipulated to vote a particular way because they can see no better way forward in their current circumstances are victims in a way .

ThousandsOfTulips · 30/11/2021 21:17

And quite honestly saying that people in these circumstances deserve what they get for voting for Brexit is akin to victim blaming.

Victims don't have a choice about what happens. What an offensive post.

Viciousrooster · 30/11/2021 21:16

@lazylinguist

Essentially OP is stating that she has a visceral loathing of the white working classes

No she isn't - well, not unless you believe that all white, working-class people display the attitudes and behaviour that the OP describes in her first post. I hope you don't believe that, because that would be a very prejudiced point of view.

Read the post. The reference to the dislike of outsiders, specifically foreigners, is an explicit admission that the town referred to is majority white. The overwrought references to a tired, dirty and brutal air mark it out as a working class town that has fallen on hard times. The inhabitants of said town are therefore, by definition, predominantly white working class. It is the OP who has then gone on to ascribe to them a preference for various dismal behaviours, preferences and prejudices. Clear as fucking day.
Unihorn · 30/11/2021 21:16

None of these places were uniformly bad. There are areas where criminals specifically take over entire streets though, so it's entirely possible to live in an area completely immersed in crime. It's a pretty shit situation, even if a few streets over there are perfectly nice parts.

AngelDelight28 · 30/11/2021 21:04

Some interesting observations but also lots of hyperbole and stereotyping going on on this thread. I've lived in places that many consider "rough" and that are regularly featured in "crap towns" type of lists.
None of these places were uniformly bad. Yes they had some of what the OP describes, in certain areas, but there were always nicer areas too - lively student-y neighbourhoods, cul de sac type places with young families, nice suburbs and villages on the outskirts. Surely if the OP is such an intellectual and so educated, she can afford to live in one of the nicer areas. Even in the most deprived towns there are teachers, doctors, nurses, small business owners, college lecturers, trades people, hairdressers, nursery workers...in other words normal people, living normal lives in normal areas.

Actually the OP strongly reminds me of a former colleague who moved up to my neck of the woods for work...she too was very left wing, in theory. But the entire time she was here she moaned about how rough it was, how the locals are too narrow minded/racist/sexist/anti-intellectual for her liking and how the place is 20 years behind London and wherever else she'd lived. How she felt lonely and people were unwelcoming (unsurprising as she so obviously looked down on them), she was bored as the place was "too quiet", blah blah. She never actually made any effort to get to know the place properly or join any clubs, or to do a bit of research on the different neighbourhoods, which all have their own "vibe". She was adamant that she was looked down on for being educated and well spoken.
It really is a case if you see what you want to see. I too am a graduate with a professional job and was able to meet similar people, mostly through work and hobby related clubs. I was never bored or lonely as I sought out things to do and groups to join. Made plenty of friends who aren't racist/sexist/whatever -ist. Some of them are incomers to the area too and are happy and settled here. There's a lot of deprivation too, I'm not saying that everything's rosy, but I don't really get people who write off entire cities and towns as "shit holes".

shinynewapple21 · 30/11/2021 21:02

@Viciousrooster Essentially OP is stating that she has a visceral loathing of the white working classes.

Do you really believe that it is the norm for white working class people behave like the people described in the OP? She is not stating she hates WWC people - just the behaviour of a certain percentage of them who live in her neighbourhood .

Honestly, the deniers on this thread are part of the problem that is faced by people in areas where poor housing, crime, drugs, violence, lack of aspirations and hope are the norm . You need to accept that is some people's reality before you can get behind any solution . The posters who recognise there are areas where traditional industry has gone and there has been lack of infrastructure funding going back for several years are correct . Add the additional problems of Covid and Brexit . And quite honestly saying that people in these circumstances deserve what they get for voting for Brexit is akin to victim blaming .

I don't think it's as simple as north vs south either .

Baluchistan95 · 30/11/2021 21:00

Wow, just wow. I had absolutely no idea that Wigan and its residents were so bad. Sorry, but I still struggle to believe that there aren't any decent people, with interests, culture, and aspirations living there. Having said that, looking at the responses on here, it would appear that those in the know, actually agree with op.

OhMyCrump · 30/11/2021 20:54

Brilliant advice @EllieLucy.
Very thoughtful post.

prawntoastie · 30/11/2021 20:51

Sounds like my exes family in a town I feel for you

RainbowBriteUk · 30/11/2021 20:40

OP why don't you move to one of the more decent areas in the vicinity?

tarasmalatarocks · 30/11/2021 20:37

@EllieLucy. Some great posts— as I’ve mentioned above do I see exactly what the OP is getting at— yes, I grew up till 31 in a similar place — could I live there now— yes using the kinds of tips you talk about— would I choose it- not on your Nellie- . I do think people thinking the OP is hating on the white working class maybe just are different people— my own view having grown up in a similar place is that it isn’t necessarily a money thing or even a working class thing- - going on about having an issue with the undeserving poor is a bit simplistic— plenty of people in towns like this aren’t poor materially, plenty do have just as much disposable income as what on the surface seem more prosperous places— it’s more an attitudinal thing— and yes Its ‘not me’ i— thing is with Wigan though , it’s between two rather excellent cities in my opinion- so I would just get out - a lot!! There really are way worse places too that don’t have that advantage. It is to be honest each to his own— I see people posting they hate London— I was lucky and lived for a while in Richmond/kingston area and loved it — .

RainbowBriteUk · 30/11/2021 20:33

I like Wigan. Lovely people and a decent town centre. Haigh Country Park is a delight.

ThousandsOfTulips · 30/11/2021 20:32

@Sn0tnose

I did indeed grow up in an underprivileged background, an appalling and abusive one. And I don't agree with what you are saying, at all. That doesn't make me a "dick"

Yeah, me too. And you’re absolutely right, it doesn’t make you a ‘dickhead’. Getting snarky with me because you’ve responded to the wrong person does though.

And I believe you were misquoted by another poster earlier when it was something I’d said. I did post earlier this afternoon to confirm it was me who’d said it and not you.

Apologies for replying to you in error.
Swipe left for the next trending thread