Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to loathe the people here?

735 replies

OnenessWithAllStrife · 30/11/2021 10:06

Some people say that feeling a negative emotion or having unpleasant feelings about something shouldn't define you, that you should let the thoughts flow and then let them go. OK. I hope this to be true :(

But i have lived somewhere for the past 6 years that has brought me to conclusions and created feelings in me that I am not proud of. For the first time in my life I have actually come to loathe people and feel a sense of terror about being stuck with them. This is not particularly politically 'correct' when put into words, unfortunately, but I can't think of any other way to express it.

I moved to a town6 yrs ago in which I don't have much in common with the residents. It isn't unusual, just an ordinary large town which at one time contained more diversity, but in recent years has become very insular and homogenous. Everyone is angry, anti social, or depressed. If you don't openly discuss some sort of prejudice (racism, sexism, anti-intellectualism) you're 'soft in the head' or a 'bloody weirdo'.
Wherever I go here, in any direction, you will either see kids or drunk adults destroying property, or else screaming at each other in the street. There are a few select areas that are less challenging and rough, but the vibe is somehow the same.

Education or reading is a mugs game, football is the only passion, kids are yelled at for merely existing. Any conversation with a seemingly friendly stranger results in them wishing all the foreigners to go home. There is a general air of brutality to everything, a leathery, hard resistance to any kind of sensitivity whatsoever. Art, creativity and self reflection are suspicious, and the only permissible clothing is black or sport branded. Every damned street is choked with the fumes of endlessly revved up vehicles with ear splitting exhaust modifications. The environment is filthy, full of dog shit and bordering on dereliction.

I would once have considered all of this a problem of poverty, but it isn't quite that easy to determine, having witnessed it. There is no seeming variation in behaviour across income brackets here, it looks to be more cultural than income related, although the attitude towards learning, etc will obviously have the effect of creating more poverty regardless. It is like a self perpetuating cesspit of no hope and hard hearts. I thought i was a leftie, a socialist, but when I leave here I will be fucking marked by this and hope to never exist within it ever again.

We moved here for DP's work and are set to leave this coming year. I also appreciate that the residents and I have experienced very different upbringings and we do not share much in common, but even so, I think that you have to endure this to really, really see it, to come to fear it. It is easy to sit in a comfy armchair miles from it and 'defend' this stuff because you haven't truly sampled the existential sickness of it on your own doorstep.
I wish i didn't feel it, but it is difficult to lie to oneself, and the fear has probably evolved from having felt 'stuck' in it for so long. I wfh and DP does part time (some here regard us as 'pretentious' for this and have suggested we ought to do some 'real' work). It all feels very dated and odd, to be surrounded by values that repulse me and contain so little diversity. I mean, this is the type of place where you'll get side-eyed for cooking from scratch or having the audacity to flavour a dish with pesto.

Does this mean I loathe them? I don't know. I imagine I will chill with it when we have moved, as it all becomes a distant memory, but it has certainly left a mark. It feels wrong to state these feelings and observations, but I bet I am not the only one who has thought them....

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Pipsquiggle · 03/12/2021 10:51

@TheseBootsWereMadeForSitting

In all my years on here, I have never come across a set of posts from one poster that displayed so much obvious stereotyping and been allowed to stay up.

Everyone in Wigan is in possession of every bad aspect a high class outsider might garner from binge watching Shameless and similar middle class poverty porn, both fiction and "ooh, look at the scummy poor people" documentaries?

No area is completely filled with identikit humans for a start.
That is impossible.
OP speaks as if someone too that Frank person from Shameless and photocopied him 400,098 times,

I am actually surprised that OP left out the fucking everything that moves, including their own underage relatives. Although, I am pretty sure that would have been there if they did not reckon on it getting their thread deleted.

I have lived in several areas, post industrial shit holes to use OPs parlance, where I certainly came across some with traits attributed to what OP like to call "shit bags" but not all in the same person and not a large number of such individuals. Those that did display some of it were universally frowned upon by their other working class neighbours, not copied.

While I am making zero allegations of outright dishonesty here, I am highly suspicious of either embellishments or just plain seeing only what one wants to see, from a distance without bothering to engage with their local townfolk.

@TheseBootsWereMadeForSitting - OP was talking about where she lived and her experience She revealed she was talking about Wigan and then in a later post she said she lived near the centre of Wigan.

Have you ever been to the centre of Wigan? It is a shit hole. And OP accurately describes the lack of ambition and drive of this specific cohort which have under-invested in for generations.

Of course - there are more affluent parts of all these post industrial towns - Wigan, Blackburn, Burnley etc. however, affluent relative to the town - we're not talking Guildford or Sandhurst.

I don't think it helped that OP had moved from Kendal - which is just beautiful and a real community town (I have relatives that live there)

TopCatsTopHat · 03/12/2021 10:22

Well said TheRigatonini

5128gap · 03/12/2021 09:48

The OP has included just enough genuine issues, crime, child neglect, animal cruelty to trigger empathy and outrage, and these function as a smokescreen for her unpleasant attacks on a less affluent culture. The colourful language and controversial nature of the post (in a week where class appears to be a bit of a theme) suggest someone looking for 15 minutes of fame/attention. Anyone with a modicum of intelligence (or even an ability to Google Wigan) will know that an entire town cannot be like this. Certain areas, yes, but the whole place? Insulting to the intelligence to expect people to take it seriously.

TheRigatonini · 02/12/2021 18:26

@TheseBootsWereMadeForSitting

In all my years on here, I have never come across a set of posts from one poster that displayed so much obvious stereotyping and been allowed to stay up.

Everyone in Wigan is in possession of every bad aspect a high class outsider might garner from binge watching Shameless and similar middle class poverty porn, both fiction and "ooh, look at the scummy poor people" documentaries?

No area is completely filled with identikit humans for a start.
That is impossible.
OP speaks as if someone too that Frank person from Shameless and photocopied him 400,098 times,

I am actually surprised that OP left out the fucking everything that moves, including their own underage relatives. Although, I am pretty sure that would have been there if they did not reckon on it getting their thread deleted.

I have lived in several areas, post industrial shit holes to use OPs parlance, where I certainly came across some with traits attributed to what OP like to call "shit bags" but not all in the same person and not a large number of such individuals. Those that did display some of it were universally frowned upon by their other working class neighbours, not copied.

While I am making zero allegations of outright dishonesty here, I am highly suspicious of either embellishments or just plain seeing only what one wants to see, from a distance without bothering to engage with their local townfolk.

The local townsfolk? 🤣🤣

I grew up living and hanging out on a council estate and there are plenty of people like the people in Shameless – that is why it‘s funny. And I know a lot of people who live (or grew up on it have lived) on those type of estates who liked it for that reason. So much of it is recognisable, but it’s affectionate.

every bad aspect a high class outsider might garner from binge watching Shameless and similar middle class poverty porn

I don’t think you’re speaking as an insider somehow.

And of course the OP is making generalisations, her post is about the aspects of her environment that she’s feeling fed up about – what’s she going to do, paste a diary of events from the last 4 years and leave us to work out what she’s getting at.

The OP also clearly says that she’s grappling with how she feels as before she lived where she does she did not have such a negative impression and perhaps even judged people a bit who did. Her whole post is about feeling uncomfortable that she is now observing evidence for some of the stereotypes that she previously prided herself on not buying into.

DottyHarmer · 02/12/2021 17:34

I too am surprised that the posts haven’t attracted much criticism. Everyone likes their own tribe. But to sound so full of vitriol about others who are not very naice is rather unsettling. I hope the neighbours pass muster in the OP’s next abode. Woe betide anyone who fails to be “diverse” , or is “dated”. I hope the new neighbours don’t knock on my door and demand to know if I’m sensitive and creative. And pesto… so 15 years ago.

TheseBootsWereMadeForSitting · 02/12/2021 17:15

In all my years on here, I have never come across a set of posts from one poster that displayed so much obvious stereotyping and been allowed to stay up.

Everyone in Wigan is in possession of every bad aspect a high class outsider might garner from binge watching Shameless and similar middle class poverty porn, both fiction and "ooh, look at the scummy poor people" documentaries?

No area is completely filled with identikit humans for a start.
That is impossible.
OP speaks as if someone too that Frank person from Shameless and photocopied him 400,098 times,

I am actually surprised that OP left out the fucking everything that moves, including their own underage relatives. Although, I am pretty sure that would have been there if they did not reckon on it getting their thread deleted.

I have lived in several areas, post industrial shit holes to use OPs parlance, where I certainly came across some with traits attributed to what OP like to call "shit bags" but not all in the same person and not a large number of such individuals. Those that did display some of it were universally frowned upon by their other working class neighbours, not copied.

While I am making zero allegations of outright dishonesty here, I am highly suspicious of either embellishments or just plain seeing only what one wants to see, from a distance without bothering to engage with their local townfolk.

ThousandsOfTulips · 02/12/2021 16:24

@Peregrina

I can agree about technical education - the very good Tomlinson report of the early 2000s wasn't implemented.

I just don't agree about grammar schools - they were not all havens of excellence for one thing - girls schools especially didn't encourage too much ambition. There were never enough places anyway and even so, it is not really possible to sort people into academic sheep and non academic goats by the age of 10. Witness large numbers of people who didn't have the education they deserved who went on to get OU degrees when that came into being.

Kent has I believe effectively opened at least one new grammar school by making it an extension of an existing one, but it's in a town some miles away!

That was a new policy introduced by TM was it not? Even expanding the existing ones was prohibited for decades. So obviously there are nowhere near enough places because population has increased enormously since the 1960s/70s!!

I'm not saying it was a perfect system. No system is. Instead of being destroyed it should have been modernised with good non-academic options available, and also a system for late bloomers to move to grammar school later, not ab absolute cut-off at 11.

But to deny the huge benefits of a system aiming to make an academic education available based on the ability of the child rather than money is just dogmatic in my view and doesn't do anybody any favours.

TheRigatonini · 02/12/2021 16:14

@mustlovegin

You sound bigoted, smug, melodramatic and hard work OP.

Also 'fear' is a too strong an emotion for the context you describe. You would benefit from getting some help

And you sound just lovely.
Peregrina · 02/12/2021 16:03

I can agree about technical education - the very good Tomlinson report of the early 2000s wasn't implemented.

I just don't agree about grammar schools - they were not all havens of excellence for one thing - girls schools especially didn't encourage too much ambition. There were never enough places anyway and even so, it is not really possible to sort people into academic sheep and non academic goats by the age of 10. Witness large numbers of people who didn't have the education they deserved who went on to get OU degrees when that came into being.

Kent has I believe effectively opened at least one new grammar school by making it an extension of an existing one, but it's in a town some miles away!

mustlovegin · 02/12/2021 16:03

You sound bigoted, smug, melodramatic and hard work OP.

Also 'fear' is a too strong an emotion for the context you describe. You would benefit from getting some help

ThousandsOfTulips · 02/12/2021 15:56

But no new grammar schools have been allowed to be built for decades, have they? And population has massively increased. That is why many children capable of managing a grammar school education can't get a place even in those counties.

If the system had been built upon rather than deliberately vandalised, so that it had an appropriate proportionate balance of places which meant that every child could get a place in the right school for their abilities, then it would work perfectly well still. Aside from the total lack of Government investment in technical/ manual skills and apprenticeships for those not suited to an academic education but that's a whole other thread in itself.

Peregrina · 02/12/2021 15:51

In Kent and Bucks (and I think Lincs, although I don't know that area well), there are not small pockets - the Grammar school system is the norm.

Now since a lot of bright children don't pass the 11 plus in those counties some of the Sec Mods do have enough children to make top sets who are as academically able as many of the children in grammar schools. But they try not to call them Sec Mods - because no one actually wants to bring that system back - too many perfectly capable children failed.

But in places like Bucks if your nice middle class daughter fails the 11+ there will be a little private school which she can go to.

ThousandsOfTulips · 02/12/2021 15:39

As I said they don't function in the same way anymore because it's not a universal system, there are only small pockets of them left which has distorted the entry process.

Peregrina · 02/12/2021 15:37

Grammar schools were a key mitigation to that. A lifeline for poor, bright kids.

For some, I don't doubt. But 'huge' numbers - no not. Poor areas tend to have poor schools. Even in the old days, better areas could have good secondary moderns. But I look forward to someone coming on and telling me how Kent, Bucks and Lincs which are still grammar counties are havens of social mobility. Or how existing grammar schools in Lancashire are full of bright working class children.

ThousandsOfTulips · 02/12/2021 15:03

@Peregrina

This is why getting rid of grammar schools and streaming etc was a huge mistake: they were huge engines for social mobility for bright kids from poor backgrounds.

Some people have asked if the town in question is a Medway town or Dover. Kent still has grammar schools. I don't see Kent as being a huge engine of social mobility, or an engine of much social mobility at all.

Besides which, grammar schools were got rid of in the sixties and seventies because they were vote losers for the Tories - nice middle class children were failing.

I have a number of family members who grew up in incredibly poor backgrounds for whom grammar school transformed their life chances. Very intelligent people who would have had no chance whatsoever of reaching their potential without those schools, which have now been closed down. If they were born now they'd spend their whole lives stuck in those hell holes they were born in. So yes, they absolutely were engines of social mobility.

Now that there are hardly any left they're subject to the prosperity effect, so you can only move into catchment if you are affluent and even then because there are so few it's so competitive that people feel the need to use tutors etc to gain entry.

That wasn't the case when they were everywhere, even in the poorest areas where my family lived. I've seen first hand how that opportunity transformed lives.

Much of this thread describes a hopelessness, a lack of opportunity that leads to poverty of aspiration. Grammar schools were a key mitigation to that. A lifeline for poor, bright kids.

5128gap · 02/12/2021 14:59

@Peregrina

This is why getting rid of grammar schools and streaming etc was a huge mistake: they were huge engines for social mobility for bright kids from poor backgrounds.

Some people have asked if the town in question is a Medway town or Dover. Kent still has grammar schools. I don't see Kent as being a huge engine of social mobility, or an engine of much social mobility at all.

Besides which, grammar schools were got rid of in the sixties and seventies because they were vote losers for the Tories - nice middle class children were failing.

Or alternatively a way of giving 11 year olds one shot at an exam which would seal their educational and career future. While bright WC did obviously pass, the vast majority ended up at the secondary modern schools with girls learning secretarial and childcare skills and boys being kept in a holding pen until they were released into manual work at 15. For all the failings of the comprehensive school system at least there was mobility between the streams, and an attempt to give some equality of access to academic subjects.
Peregrina · 02/12/2021 14:44

This is why getting rid of grammar schools and streaming etc was a huge mistake: they were huge engines for social mobility for bright kids from poor backgrounds.

Some people have asked if the town in question is a Medway town or Dover. Kent still has grammar schools. I don't see Kent as being a huge engine of social mobility, or an engine of much social mobility at all.

Besides which, grammar schools were got rid of in the sixties and seventies because they were vote losers for the Tories - nice middle class children were failing.

inferiorCatSlave · 02/12/2021 13:11

[quote tarasmalatarocks]@inferiorCatSlave. Did you live in Mansfield or Sutton in Ashfield by chance?? Your comments fit well with it— not particularly deprived in my opinion but closed minded and full of middle aged Male know it alls — I[/quote]
@tarasmalatarocks - no - midland town got this vibe from was near Leicestershire border - very odd as surround area wasn't like it at all.

Though IL aren't far from that area - Derby/Notts and I could see areas near them being like this.

I think if we'd ended up other side of that midlands town it would have been more a dormer town for nearby cities. It was no where near as bad as OP paints Wigan - in fact local council was actually very good keeping local shopping bit going. It did have the vibe the OP is talking about though low level hostile.

While we were there then Education Secretary listed 5 worst secondries at the time and it had two including our then catchment school but many families put huge effort into trying to avoid sending their kids there.

We've since moved to South Wales - which is absolutely lovely - secondary school here had been doing well for a while and was fine first few years DD1 was there but that head was forced out, they struggled to find a replacement experienced staff have moved on in large numbers - governors have changed - it's a very different school and it's gone downhill so quickly.

I think it's now rapidly getting to position where families more like us are looking to try and avoid for their kids - which will make it even harder to bring it back up - you can see the spiral downwards - kids like our with home support and resouces it can be countered and we can get them somewhere better post 16 but many of their peers don't have that.

moofolk · 02/12/2021 12:52

Was going to guess Wigan btw.

It is a shithole but still a lot going on. Get involved in political / feminist groups.

It's all there

GlamorousHeifer · 02/12/2021 12:49

I understand this, I live in a small town with areas even the police try to avoid Sad it's so bad sometimes we get the mounted police just to deal with antisocial teenagers! However I am lucky to live just on the outskirts on a genuinely beautiful street and people are always surprised when they visit for the first time!
I'd move OP, if you can manage it get out as soon as possible because people like that don't have a hope in hell of changing and the communities they live in will remain shit holes as no one has the impetuous to do anything about it.

moofolk · 02/12/2021 12:48

The shittiest places often have the best pockets of brilliance.

People you'll get on with are there, you need to work out how to find them.

RantyAunty · 02/12/2021 12:31

OP I get it. Some places truly are depressing and shit.

Where I live is insular, racist, anti-everything. I'll be glad to leave soon.

ThousandsOfTulips · 02/12/2021 12:27

@MrsBobDylan

This thread reminds me of 'An inspector Calls'.

When you are scared you might loose your home or can't feed your family, art and culture becomes something of a luxury. Sometimes morals and a liberal opinion is also a 'nice to have' in order to survive.

Many Northern towns became rich off the back of the exploitative mill industry. The rich got richer, but the poor stayed poor. Once the mills shut down and the mining went, the rich moved out.

I live in a place where our local secondary is always underperforming, there are drug deals at the back of our house and many of the houses nearby are bedsits let to alcoholics and drug users.

My son is one of the very lucky ones, with a stable family, a parent in secure employment and he is clever. But I worry about County lines and some of the people in the bedsits. My son joined the local boxing club, I think mainly to protect himself. A boy at his school had his nose broken a few weeks ago in the school corridors.

Money = social mobility. In the UK, those who can afford houses near outstanding state schools, do, and those who can't, end up at schools like my son's.

There is research to suggest that attending an underperforming school lowers a child's IQ.

Another awful statistic is that, kids born to deprived parents who are in the top 10% intellectually at 2 years old, will drop to the bottom 10% by the age of 7.

This is why getting rid of grammar schools and streaming etc was a huge mistake: they were huge engines for social mobility for bright kids from poor backgrounds.
CaptSkippy · 02/12/2021 11:58

Yes, but with the rise of social media it has been getting worse.

MsTSwift · 02/12/2021 11:42

I disagree. Nothing to do with social media. The behaviour I described predates social media.

Swipe left for the next trending thread