Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

School want to see covid result

131 replies

Poolhater · 30/11/2021 06:33

I’m just after a bit of perspective as not sure that I’m just being a bit blaze about it!

I’ve kids at three different schools. Neither of the senior schools want to see (PCR) covid result if the kids have to have a test but the primary school always asks.

To put this into context, the primary school has also said kids with cold symptoms must be tested and receive negative results before return to School. Whereas neither of the senior schools have said that - they only want covid tests if displaying the covid symptoms as set out by NHS (cough, high temp, change in smell/taste).

My sister, (a teacher at a different primary) also has children in the same primary school as my kids. She thinks that they are wrong to ask for us to email in the test results (to be clear, they aren’t asking for us to email in “Little Miss Poolhater has tested negative” but actually want us to forward on the test result that we receive). She thinks this breaches confidentiality. I’m of the view, if it keeps the cogs turning, I will do it.

So who is being unreasonable here, me - I will happily send it in, or my sister - why should they have it and not just take our word for it?

I should add, I think my sister is frustrated by their requirement to keep kids off with cold symptoms (who are otherwise well) but their refusal to provide any work for those same kids on day one of that absence.

OP posts:
Underparmummy · 30/11/2021 08:31

I think to check that you have done it, trying to weed out people saying they have when they haven't/have only done LFT. Happened at our schools after the kids told the teachers they hadn't done the PCRs requested as close contacts.

Poolhater · 30/11/2021 08:26

@Madmog

If you don't mind, just do it. Also, be glad your DC is at a school that are doing their best to protect everyone and hopefully keep quality in face quality education - on more than one occasion we've had a put what's left of a whole year together in the hall (due to lack of staff) and come up with art or studying music on the screen and writing about it. Whilst they're still be educational things, it's not their scheduled subjects.
Yes, I see it as the School door everything
OP posts:
caringcarer · 30/11/2021 08:22

My child's special secondary always asks kids to get tested but never asks to see results. I would happily forward text if they asked.

Poolhater · 30/11/2021 08:21

@nocnoc

Oh and as for symptoms we’ve got lots of kids off school this week with positive PCRs after going down with migraine and vomiting as symptoms. The Covid helpline said that Covid can develop as that so please stop thinking you know everything unless you’ve actually rung experts and spoken to them. It’s getting boring now everyone thinking they are scientists and experts. You’re not. Just do as you’re asked please
I’m not sure who the covid helpline are, but I do know the NHS website that lists the main covid symptoms. I assume they must have some of these experts you talk about!

My point about the cold symptoms is that they are NOT listed. I recall the last time I had to book a PCR for one of the kids I ended up lying about having symptoms as there was no other way I could get the bloody thing booked (the option for a School in England to request one had been removed).

OP posts:
Tumbleweed101 · 30/11/2021 08:19

We prefer to see the result because it means we know that the coughs and colds are just that and not Covid. If we get cases of covid it means unvaccinated staff have to isolate and we need to keep an eye on the other children and do all kinds of other admin. Knowing it is proven not to be Covid means we can relax a little.

AndMatt · 30/11/2021 08:18

Schools can ask but can't insist so it makes it all bit pointless IMO. Anyone "cheating" will refuse and there's nothing anyone can do.

Just an unecessary admin task when schools are always complaining they don't have time.

That said,as a parent, I wouldn't pick that battle and would comply if asked.

Chewbecca · 30/11/2021 08:18

I also don’t see how forwarding the result is any more confidential than informing them.

The only time you would have a problem is if you were lying.

OnlyFoolsnMothers · 30/11/2021 08:17

I don’t mind the showing of the test but testing ever cold and sniffle in primary age children is ridiculous!

Poolhater · 30/11/2021 08:17

@nocnoc

I think you’re being unreasonable to be honest. All my kids schools ask for a photo of the test stick. I don’t see how that’s breaching confidentiality and it’s a reach to be using that argument. They’re not asking for dick pics are they? At my kids school some of the TAs have had chemo and have low immune systems. I think it’s reasonable to ask everyone to be reasonable. You’re just being difficult. Please stop. If your kid is negative and has a negative test strip just send them a photo.
Please re read my OP and you will see I don’t have a problem with supplying the result.

I wouldn’t be sending in evidence of LFTs though (by photo). I do however record all the LFTs we do as a family via the NHS reporting site.

OP posts:
Dimondsareforever · 30/11/2021 08:15

People lie and will want to send children in anyway so they don’t have to take time off work. Schools have a duty of care to do their best to protect the staff.
The other option in is your child isn’t allowed in school with any cold symptoms and has to SI 10 days each time they get a cold …

Paquerette · 30/11/2021 08:14

@nocnoc

I think you’re being unreasonable to be honest. All my kids schools ask for a photo of the test stick. I don’t see how that’s breaching confidentiality and it’s a reach to be using that argument. They’re not asking for dick pics are they? At my kids school some of the TAs have had chemo and have low immune systems. I think it’s reasonable to ask everyone to be reasonable. You’re just being difficult. Please stop. If your kid is negative and has a negative test strip just send them a photo.
I agree. My DS currently has covid and there’s a big outbreak in his school. Most kids are testing positive with headaches, cold symptoms and sore throats. Some go on to develop fevers/coughs, but that’s days later. DS’s school are now asking everyone to LFT daily, instead of 2 times per week as many kids are developing these early symptoms within 24 hours of a negative LFT.
Madmog · 30/11/2021 08:07

If you don't mind, just do it. Also, be glad your DC is at a school that are doing their best to protect everyone and hopefully keep quality in face quality education - on more than one occasion we've had a put what's left of a whole year together in the hall (due to lack of staff) and come up with art or studying music on the screen and writing about it. Whilst they're still be educational things, it's not their scheduled subjects.

Wannakisstheteacher · 30/11/2021 08:07

They are 💯 right to ask to see proof. The number of people who lie about results or frankly don’t even test means they need to.

shouldistop · 30/11/2021 08:07

@RobotValkyrie

So, by forcing parents to test their kids for generic (non-COVID) cold symptoms, the school is requiring
  • parents to lie to the NHS (the form for booking free PCRs clearly says you must have "official" COVID symptoms)
  • young children to undergo distressing invasive tests they don't need
  • the NHS to waste testing resources that could be better used elsewhere

Completely unreasonable. I would whistle blow.
(note: requesting test results... A bit nosy, but not so blatantly wrong)

By the way, odds are a lot of parents will be testing themselves, and not the kids, if they're determined to cheat (and/or not to subject their child to useless painful tests)

I think the booking bit has a section for school requested test
Bingbong21 · 30/11/2021 08:07

Schools also can't enforce 10 days isolation for kids who can't tolerate testing

Catfog · 30/11/2021 08:04

@nocnoc

Oh and as for symptoms we’ve got lots of kids off school this week with positive PCRs after going down with migraine and vomiting as symptoms. The Covid helpline said that Covid can develop as that so please stop thinking you know everything unless you’ve actually rung experts and spoken to them. It’s getting boring now everyone thinking they are scientists and experts. You’re not. Just do as you’re asked please
To be fair though the official advice is still the main symptoms, any local guidance or requirements for testing aren't in line with government guidance, can schools really deny a child who hasn't had a test in those cases? I agree that the government should be adapting and expanding them as new things come to light, but seen as though accessing education is a fundamental right in this country curious as to how much power schools have to ask that.
RobotValkyrie · 30/11/2021 08:03

So, by forcing parents to test their kids for generic (non-COVID) cold symptoms, the school is requiring

  • parents to lie to the NHS (the form for booking free PCRs clearly says you must have "official" COVID symptoms)
  • young children to undergo distressing invasive tests they don't need
  • the NHS to waste testing resources that could be better used elsewhere

Completely unreasonable. I would whistle blow.
(note: requesting test results... A bit nosy, but not so blatantly wrong)

By the way, odds are a lot of parents will be testing themselves, and not the kids, if they're determined to cheat (and/or not to subject their child to useless painful tests)

Whinge · 30/11/2021 08:01

@nocnoc

I think you’re being unreasonable to be honest. All my kids schools ask for a photo of the test stick. I don’t see how that’s breaching confidentiality and it’s a reach to be using that argument. They’re not asking for dick pics are they? At my kids school some of the TAs have had chemo and have low immune systems. I think it’s reasonable to ask everyone to be reasonable. You’re just being difficult. Please stop. If your kid is negative and has a negative test strip just send them a photo.
Your child's school ask you to send photos of negative LFTs? That's a ridiculous waste of time. I understand asking for negative PCR results, but photos of negative LFTs is pointless, there's no way a school has the time to look through hundreds of photos of LFTs.
GlitteryApples · 30/11/2021 08:01

Sorry all the typos it’s still dark here !!

maddening · 30/11/2021 08:01

I just don't see why there is any issue in providing it? Why he so evasive?

GlitteryApples · 30/11/2021 08:00

Goodness that’s nothing our last school demanded to see bottles of antibiotics and for us to take dc in to the school for them t do temperature if we said they had one (we refused that as was ridiculous)

They even asked us to sign over permissions for then to talk to the go whenever they wanted they had an agenda trying to say I had Munchausens by proxy the HT kept calling social services saying that she ‘had a bad feeling she wouldn’t put her finger on ‘ and wanted that recorded as I fussed over ss too much and she didn’t believe he had allergies (luckily he had had them confirmed by bloods and skin test)

I think the guidance was thatschools don’t ask but that was before covid maybe it’s changed now , I can see why they would ask and I tbh would show it as it doesn’t seem intrusive like all the above was

nocnoc · 30/11/2021 08:00

Oh and as for symptoms we’ve got lots of kids off school this week with positive PCRs after going down with migraine and vomiting as symptoms. The Covid helpline said that Covid can develop as that so please stop thinking you know everything unless you’ve actually rung experts and spoken to them. It’s getting boring now everyone thinking they are scientists and experts. You’re not. Just do as you’re asked please

AuditAngel · 30/11/2021 07:59

DD2’s bubble burst in the summer and was sent home. When1 case became 3 we were asked to PCR all the kids, which we did. We never received any result, which I followed up, by this time DD2 had completed the 10 days isolation but I was told we had to do a missed results report and give them a further 48 hours, so I did.

Still no results, so I returned her to school for the last half day of the year. School demanded her results, so I pointed out that legally they are not allowed to ask for them, and since we had never received them, I couldn’t give them anyway. School did not challenge my assertion.

Either way, I pointed out that some of the kids hadn’t been tested but had gone back after 10 days, whilst DD2 had no symptoms but had been off for 12 days

nocnoc · 30/11/2021 07:58

I think you’re being unreasonable to be honest. All my kids schools ask for a photo of the test stick. I don’t see how that’s breaching confidentiality and it’s a reach to be using that argument. They’re not asking for dick pics are they? At my kids school some of the TAs have had chemo and have low immune systems. I think it’s reasonable to ask everyone to be reasonable. You’re just being difficult. Please stop. If your kid is negative and has a negative test strip just send them a photo.

WoodstockJ · 30/11/2021 07:57

As others have said, this is because people lie. The school is helping to protect the health and education of your children by insisting that they see evidence of the test.