Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DH wants MIL to come to us for Christmas

357 replies

Macmoominmamma · 29/11/2021 17:51

Hi all

Your opinions please!

For context - MIL went into nursing home Feb 2020 at age of 84. She's been incredibly independent for past 50 years but now can't cope living on her own. Diagnosed with dementia, which fluctuates. She is urine incontinent, can't go up or down stairs, doesn't walk far, can't work TV or mobile phone, despite being shown many many times. She lives 100 miles away from us and her other DS lives in same village as her.

DH asked me last night if she could come to ours for Christmas, coming 23rd Dec and leaving Boxing Day. We have 2 kids, aged 15 and 9. It is 9 year olds birthday Christmas Eve (will be 10 then). I have pointed out the distance for her to travel, that she is incontinent, has dementia, she can't walk up steps (our WCs are not on ground floor), but DH says he will take her to a hotel and they will stay there overnight and come to our home for feeding, present opening etc.
I honestly don't know how to feel about this - on the one hand, it would be nice to have her, and don't want her to spend Christmas at Nursing Home, but on the other hand I think it's a disaster waiting to happen, and just a bit miserable for the kids to have their dad away from them over Christmas Day and birthday.

DH appears to have thought this through and is pretty set on it.
AIBU to put a spanner in the works by saying no?

YANBU - yes tell him it's a no
YABU - she should come.

OP posts:
Stuckhere2021 · 29/11/2021 22:10

@krustykittens

I really feel for your DH - his mum is slipping away and he wants a last, perfect Christmas with her. But having had two relatives succumb to dementia, I have to agree with PP. This has disaster written all over it. He may need to make peace with the idea that there will be no more chances to be with the woman she was, even though she is physically still here. My grandmother had dementia and my parents were visiting her regularly while I lived in a different country. She was admitted to a specialist home and when I flew over to see her, having not seen her for 8 months, my mother tried to warn me how much she had deteriorated but it was still a shock. She had no memory of me, at all, and while she was happy and chatty, it killed me that she didn't know who I was and was making small talk with me like a polite stranger. I had to excuse myself, locked myself in a toilet and cried. One of the staff members heard me sobbing and brought me a cup of tea. It is awful to see that person sitting right in front of you but you can't tell them all the things you want to say now that you are running out of time or share a memory. Never mind if they are confused, scared, angry and then the physical demands of their body. Whatever your DH is imagining Christmas will be like, it won't. It will break his heart. I would talk to the care home and combine forces to gently talk him out of this house and give him an alternative plan with her that will ease his heart a little.
👆100%.

The other thing is that a huge % of people with dementia have extreme noise sensitivity. You’ve got DC, it’s Xmas, there’s a birthday ….. there will be tonnes of noise. Your DH sounds lovely and caring for his mum but I think he’s being naive and looking through rose tinted glasses. What he is proposing is could cause his mum harm - the polar opposite of what he wants.

AcrossthePond55 · 29/11/2021 22:08

Here's my experience I hope @Macmoominmamma 's DH will take it to heart.

My darling mum had dementia and was in a home. Having her come for Christmas dinner worked for the first two years BUT her home was nearby, it wasn't overnight, and we have a ground floor WC. And my brother did the transport.

But the time came when even coming to our house (a 3 minute drive) for dinner and presents was too much for her. She was confused and fretful at the 'bustle' and the disruption of her routine and being away from her familiar surroundings. She was anxious about toileting and incontinence, even with 'pads'. She didn't say anything, but you could see and feel it in her.

I am ashamed to say that I kept it up a year longer than I should have. My dear brother gently pointed out to me that I was doing it for ME, not for Mum. That it was not a kindness to her, it was in fact stressful and unsettling. And that I had no reason to feel guilt or shame about her being in a home. She was safe, secure in her surroundings, and treated with respect and care by the staff. Staff that was well trained and knew how to care for dementia patients.

The home did a luncheon every Christmas for patients and their families. So instead of bringing her to ours, we had a little bit of lunch with her and spent a few hours in her 'home' then came home for our Xmas Dinner and party. It was so much more peaceful and restful for her, and for us.

We lost her to Covid this past February. Even though she didn't know who I was for the last couple of years and couldn't communicate, I still miss her terribly. Just sitting with her and holding her hand was enough to give me a feeling of security and love that only a mother can give.

So, @Macmoominmamma 's DH, if you read this, as much as you may want your Mum with you at Xmas, do stop and think if you're really doing it for her, or for you.

DaphneDeloresMoorhead · 29/11/2021 22:06

Because visiting in a nursing home fir a couple of hours will have given him absolutely no idea at all

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 29/11/2021 22:04

@Muchmorethan

The car journey alone sounds terrifying. When was she last in a car for that length of time. What if she panics and tries to get out?
OMG, this reminded me of when dh had Fil with dementia in the car - he was taking him across London to stay with BiL and SiL for a few days, to give me a break. He tried to get out in the middle of heavy traffic!
DaphneDeloresMoorhead · 29/11/2021 22:04

The other thing to consider is that 24/7 caring is fucking exhausting, mentally and physically. Even if you are used to regularly caring for the person. I spend one day a week with my DParents to give dad a break plus usually 2 hours 3 days a week. So I know mums care needs and how to look after her. Even so I find overnights absolutely draining - and I don't have to worry about mum doing something risky.
Your DP has never cared for her in 2 years. It's a very naive idea

PinkKecks · 29/11/2021 21:58

@Macmoominmamma, if you are considering an Airbnb, could you consider a larger one nearer to where she lives for you to all stay in together? Less travelling for mil and DH won't miss out on birthday/Christmas moments. BIL might be able to join you too.

krustykittens · 29/11/2021 21:56

I really feel for your DH - his mum is slipping away and he wants a last, perfect Christmas with her. But having had two relatives succumb to dementia, I have to agree with PP. This has disaster written all over it. He may need to make peace with the idea that there will be no more chances to be with the woman she was, even though she is physically still here. My grandmother had dementia and my parents were visiting her regularly while I lived in a different country. She was admitted to a specialist home and when I flew over to see her, having not seen her for 8 months, my mother tried to warn me how much she had deteriorated but it was still a shock. She had no memory of me, at all, and while she was happy and chatty, it killed me that she didn't know who I was and was making small talk with me like a polite stranger. I had to excuse myself, locked myself in a toilet and cried. One of the staff members heard me sobbing and brought me a cup of tea. It is awful to see that person sitting right in front of you but you can't tell them all the things you want to say now that you are running out of time or share a memory. Never mind if they are confused, scared, angry and then the physical demands of their body. Whatever your DH is imagining Christmas will be like, it won't. It will break his heart. I would talk to the care home and combine forces to gently talk him out of this house and give him an alternative plan with her that will ease his heart a little.

Muchmorethan · 29/11/2021 21:55

The car journey alone sounds terrifying. When was she last in a car for that length of time. What if she panics and tries to get out?

DaphneDeloresMoorhead · 29/11/2021 21:46

@Akrotiri1

I understand his sentiments and must be so hard to have a vunerable parent 100 miles away at Christmas

However, from someone who works on a dementia unit of a nursing home, none of our residents would cope with the change in routine, let alone understand it is Christmas.......also don't forget the added complications from Covid.

Our residents are only allowed one visitor on Christmas day as the visiting area has to be sanitised after each visit, and that is after they have had a lateral flow test, so to take someone out of a nursing home will no doubt create additional issues.

Also wouldn't they have to isolate for 10 days when they got back ? DM spent 2 weeks isolating in a nursing home when she was released from hospital after a wrist fracture in March. It's definitely not worth that.
reallyalurker · 29/11/2021 21:46

I'm generally on the not a good idea side, but it depends how severe your MIL's dementia is. My father has had dementia for six years since diagnosis and in many ways functions very well. But he masks what he doesn't understand and I think sometimes he's in distress and not showing it. For instance, he can get lost and disorientated even in my house, which he's spent quite a lot of time in. He also struggles to remember who younger members of the family are, but hides this well. So I wonder what your MIL's levels of anxiety would be like and whether she would enjoy the trip or be confused about where she was and who all of you were. My guess is it wouldn't be a great experience for her.

iloveheater · 29/11/2021 21:38

@Macmoominmamma

Thank you so much for all your opinions and suggestions ladies. I have read every single one and thank you for taking time to comment.

DH is SO well intentioned but, as observed, is speaking emotionally, rather than considering practicalities. My initial response was it’s unworkable but I failed to see that he’s come up with this unworkable plan because it is SO important to him that he spends Christmas with his mum.

You have offered great insights. I think I will show DH the thread so that he can understand how difficult for his mum it will be for her with dementia. We are still getting used to it tbh. We need to put her at the centre of our plans and reconsider her new needs rather than assume she will be able to cope with what we would usually do at Christmas pre-Covid with her, when she would regularly travel to Scotland with us and the kids. She had a stroke Jan 2020 and went into a Nursing Home as couldn’t look after herself at home. It’s very sad to see her so debilitated and dependent after being so fiercely independent and a bit of a social butterfly.

We will definitely be speaking with the Nursing Home and if appropriate we will definitely speak with any hotel involved. More likely we will rent an AirBnB if we can over Christmas and visit her for the day. That seems more workable.

For the person who pointed out that one day I will be wanting my son to visit me on my last Christmas🥴 you do epitomise that urge that some people have to say something just a little bit shitty to people in difficult circumstances.

I'm really glad you've come to this landing - I hope you find a way to make Christmas with MIL happen, but even if you don't, your DH will be able to rest easier knowing that you both genuinely tried everything.

As for the one comment - there's always one, isn't there? You haven't said no to spending Christmas with MIL, you've just said no to an unworkable plan that will stress her out rather than make her happy. You're going to look into a much more sensible alternative.

Take care, OP. I sense Christmas is going to be more stressful than usual this year, and I hope you manage to find that balance between supporting your family and not neglecting your own needs.

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 29/11/2021 21:34

I can only relate our experience with FiL, who had dementia.

For his first Christmas after he moved into a care home (he had lived with us for a while but I couldn’t cope any more) we brought him home for a couple of nights for Christmas, thinking he’d enjoy it, since he’d always enjoyed Christmas with us before.

It was a bad mistake, and I will admit that the care home staff had warmed us that it would not be the best idea.

So we ignored their advice, not having realised that dementia would make such a difference. By then he was used to the care home routine - and familiar routine is so important with dementia - that he was confused and worried for much of the time. E.g. he was thinking it was his own house and that there were jobs he should be doing, but he couldn’t remember what. Also, for the first time he started asking where MiL (dead 10 years) was.

For subsequent Christmases we left him where he was, in his safe, familiar routine, but would visit on Christmas Eve or soon after the 25th.

TBH from experience, once someone has dementia Christmas ceases to hold much importance - the person may not even be aware of it, or only vaguely. (My mother also had dementia, so I was very familiar with 2 cases.)

While I understand absolutely the feeling that it’s ‘wrong’ to leave someone in a care home at Christmas, since we felt exactly that with FiL, it honestly may not be in the person’s best interests.

Please feel free to show this post to your dh.

Cyberworrier · 29/11/2021 21:34

To echo PP, this sounds well intentioned but potentially hugely upsetting and disorientating for your MIL.
We have had a similar situation in my family and thankfully Covid has meant we will no longer do this- the forced break has made us realise how strange it was for everyone to be put in this stressful and upsetting situation.
I would suggest getting an Airbnb near her home and visiting her on Christmas Day- or at the very most taking her out for the day either to your Airbnb or to the house of the relative who lives locally to her home. That way she wakes up where she is used to, has breakfast as normal, and goes to bed as normal. Not at a strange place!
I do also think it's a lot for your children, your husbands plan. I had grandparents with Alzheimer's and we spent a lot of time together at our house, but they never stayed the night and I am aware in retrospect how frightening or uncomfortable some moments were. I'm very glad we had all that time together, but I also think it could have been much more difficult if my dad had insisted on plans like your husbands suggestion.
Regular safe routine visits to her nursing home surely would be more appreciated by your MIL than one extended one that leaves her and your family vulnerable in many ways.

Justmuddlingalong · 29/11/2021 21:33

DH spending some time with his mum, in familiar surroundings will leave him with better memories than looking back on her possibly last Christmas as a fraught time. Christmas is always taunted with sadness for loved ones no longer here, but if her visiting your home is truly awful for her and in return him and his family, the guilt he might feel in years to come will make his memories of this Christmas upsetting.

DaphneDeloresMoorhead · 29/11/2021 21:33

@loveandkindness

Wouldn't your children want Granny there to see them open their presents?

There are four of you in your family. Have you asked your children what they want?

My DD (11)utterly adored my mum, loved spending time with her. Then mum had a stroke. She is now paralysed and can't speak. DD finds it very distressing to be with her now and feels huge guilt because she feels like that. DM has brain damage and, so cruelly, isn't really that interested in DD any more. Before she was th apple of DM's eye. Dd also finds this very difficult to deal with.

You may be right however maybe ops children feel the same as my DD

CrocodilesCry · 29/11/2021 21:27

Bear in mind that the home may say she needs to self-isolate when she returns there, especially after being in a hotel which the home could consider to be high risk.

They may even consider an extended visit to family (especially with unvaccinated children) high risk and require her to self-isolate - especially as you're some distance away and your local case rates could be much higher.

The rules on this can be found here: www.gov.uk/government/publications/visiting-care-homes-during-coronavirus/update-on-policies-for-visiting-arrangements-in-care-homes#when-different-visiting-arrangements-are-needed

The home has to individually access these risks on residents leaving their care home and, like I say, if your case rates are much higher than where she lives it could have consequences.

diddl · 29/11/2021 21:27

@Coronawireless

And yes, I do know what it’s like to care for someone with dementia! The point here though is that it’s the DH who will be doing everything.
That doesn't mean that it's the best thing for his Mum!

She might not want him to do personal care/get him dressed.

He might not even be able to lift/support her properly!

GooseberryJam · 29/11/2021 21:25

[quote lololololollll]@saraclara wow defensive much. What I meant is that's just what I would do, don't think you need to be so aggressive. I appreciate others have different ways of looking at things, hence why I said "just me". No sarcasm involved. Don't judge me by your own standards as I guess that's how you came up with that one[/quote]
What you would do? So you're not cleaning up your dad's numerous times a day everyday at the moment, you just think that you would in order to have a nice Christmas? Run along, you have no idea. People who do are talking sense here.

23MinutesfromTuIseHill · 29/11/2021 21:25

The OH's idea was a fucking stupid one, but so were the suggestions that a whole family troop in and out of the care home multiple times. Clearly those people have no skin in the game. As for those who asked 'what the children wanted'. It really, really isn't all about the children.

Oh and what is this magic thing that happens to transform a woman, once dementing and in a care setting, into a 'lady'?

One thread, so much utter bollocks.

ChotaPeg · 29/11/2021 21:25

Also, some great information / resources online, OP, (e.g. dementia uk, alzheimer's society) if your husband is in a place to be able to look at them Flowers

myrtleWilson · 29/11/2021 21:23

No @Coronawireless the point is - is it a good idea for his mom. Will it distress her? That is the starting point - the DH's wants come way down on his mother's needs.

ElephantOfRisk · 29/11/2021 21:18

That all sounds good OP, speak to the care home and take it from there. Especially as she has been there for a while, even given her potentially deteriorating health, they should be able to give good guidance as to what would be a good plan for you all. You can incorporate all that with your own celebrations. I know that my DM in similar circumstances loved us to visit but she couldn't cope with much longer than an hour even if it was just me or me and DH, she just got so tired. I think being up there for a few days and having short but more frequent visits might be a plan. Even if you are not all allowed in, she might enjoy a short walk in a chair or to watch the DC running about outside, maybe take a ball or something they can play with.

CPL593H · 29/11/2021 21:18

For all the reasons in previous posts, this is a terrible idea. Also, if she is taken out of her care home and is then around Heaven knows how many other people in a hotel and at your house, will they be prepared for her to go back there (because Covid) ? How would that work

I hope a sensible way can be found for your DH to spend time with her that is safe and minimises the impact on her.

Coronawireless · 29/11/2021 21:17

And yes, I do know what it’s like to care for someone with dementia!
The point here though is that it’s the DH who will be doing everything.

Coronawireless · 29/11/2021 21:16

Gosh your DH sounds lovely and it sounds as if yes, he is prepared to do everything for her, even staying with her in the hotel so as not to make any extra work for you. Imo it’s not your place to stand in his way. I would go out if my way to help if this was my DH, regardless of my own preferences on this occasion.