Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DH wants MIL to come to us for Christmas

357 replies

Macmoominmamma · 29/11/2021 17:51

Hi all

Your opinions please!

For context - MIL went into nursing home Feb 2020 at age of 84. She's been incredibly independent for past 50 years but now can't cope living on her own. Diagnosed with dementia, which fluctuates. She is urine incontinent, can't go up or down stairs, doesn't walk far, can't work TV or mobile phone, despite being shown many many times. She lives 100 miles away from us and her other DS lives in same village as her.

DH asked me last night if she could come to ours for Christmas, coming 23rd Dec and leaving Boxing Day. We have 2 kids, aged 15 and 9. It is 9 year olds birthday Christmas Eve (will be 10 then). I have pointed out the distance for her to travel, that she is incontinent, has dementia, she can't walk up steps (our WCs are not on ground floor), but DH says he will take her to a hotel and they will stay there overnight and come to our home for feeding, present opening etc.
I honestly don't know how to feel about this - on the one hand, it would be nice to have her, and don't want her to spend Christmas at Nursing Home, but on the other hand I think it's a disaster waiting to happen, and just a bit miserable for the kids to have their dad away from them over Christmas Day and birthday.

DH appears to have thought this through and is pretty set on it.
AIBU to put a spanner in the works by saying no?

YANBU - yes tell him it's a no
YABU - she should come.

OP posts:
KosherDill · 29/11/2021 18:25

Will she enjoy it? How aware is she?

Could you all go stay in a hotel near her and do some festive things, then get back to your home (without her) for C Eve?

I commend him for being so devoted.

theleafandnotthetree · 29/11/2021 18:25

The only thing about this plan I wouldn't worry the slightest about is the inpact on your children or it being miserable for them their Dad not being around the whole time. Plenty of seperated, widowed families etc manage it and it really is not that big a deal, especially when the reason for it comes from a place of love and care. Indeed it is the very essence of what Christmas should be about, it's not like he's off boozing or something (my childhood). My only worries would centre on your MIL's welfare but if he ultimately decides to ahead with this not very good plan, I think you need to support him as best you can on this one.

FictionalCharacter · 29/11/2021 18:24

@toomuchlaundry

I wonder how many people who voted YABU have dealt with relatives with dementia
Yep. Especially dementia that’s bad enough for her to need nursing home care. It’s all very well PP saying it’s a nice thing for him to do. But it could be disastrous as per my relative’s experience. She was distressed and aggressive. Huge mistake. It’s not just Xmas for OP’s DH, it’s Xmas for OP and the kids too. It would be sad for them to have a difficult couple of days and remember MIL at her worst and most vulnerable (and possibly distressed and crying).
BornIn78 · 29/11/2021 18:24

I think the OP’s wording that she can “tell him no” won’t have helped the vote, that attitude stinks.

cptartapp · 29/11/2021 18:23

He's got to think whether his DM pre dementia would really want her son emptying her commode and possibly changing her wet or soiled clothes on Christmas Day with family around. God, give the poor woman some dignity.
Misguided intentions that focus on his wants rather than her needs.
I'be been nursing over thirty years and would never have taken either of my parents home in such circumstances. Not in their best interests IMO.

PerfectlyUnsuitable · 29/11/2021 18:23

Tbh I didn’t

Because I believe it’s impossible to know whether your MIL and your DH can cope with it or not from what you’ve described.

I totally get the fact might think it’s her last Christmas. Or the last one where she might still be ‘with it’ enough actually appreciate it.
But he really needs to have a chat with the care Home. I’d say actually he needs to a have trial and take her out for the day année how it goes. The way she is whilst at the care hoe might be very different to ow she would react in an unknown environment.
When is the last time she actually went out with someone?
How did Christmas go at his Dbro last year?
Has she deteriorated a lot since then?

ittakes2 · 29/11/2021 18:23

Does he know what she wants to do? It think with dementia she might find it stressful but he knows her better than anyone. If he thinks it will be her last I am not sure how you are going to say no to him, especially since he offered to look after her.
Bit random but have you considered going up to her for christmas? yes it would disrupt your children's birthdays but they will hopefully have many more while she is in the twilight of her life and sounds like it would mean a lot to your hubby.

DirectionToPerfection · 29/11/2021 18:22

@Shmithecat2

YAB a bit U. If he thinks it's doable, let him take care of it. He may not have many more Christmases with her. There's plenty ahead for your family.
I'm sorry but this is massively naive.

What about what's best for his mum? She has dementia, she won't have a clue what going on and will be stressed and confused.

I agree they should spent time with her, but go to her. It's not right to make her travel and take her out of her comfort zone.

Watto1 · 29/11/2021 18:21

My grandma had dementia. My dad wanted her to come for Christmas. He mentioned his plans to the nursing home and they very politely and kindly urged him to let her stay in the familiar surroundings of the nursing home. They knew it was best for grandma to stick to her regular routine in her regular surroundings.

gamerchick · 29/11/2021 18:18

She'll be very distressed I think. Why would he do that to her?

Cherrycee · 29/11/2021 18:18

@toomuchlaundry

I wonder how many people who voted YABU have dealt with relatives with dementia
Very few I imagine. It's not as simple as "oh let's all have a lovely family Christmas."
TeenMinusTests · 29/11/2021 18:17

I think this is a bad idea and could be distressing for your MIL.
If he wants to be with her on Christmas Day then it needs to be at the nursing home imo.
When my FIL had dementia and was in a nursing home, the fact it was Christmas Day passed right by him sadly.

ColleysMill · 29/11/2021 18:16

Ultimately it has to be what is best for MIL.

I totally get your dhs feelings and why he wants to do this but he has to take his own emotions out of this and really look at what is best for her.

Georgyporky · 29/11/2021 18:15

Leaving aside you & DH, this will not be a good idea for her.
She will be in familiar surroundings in the Care Home, & all her needs will be catered for.
Perhaps a family visit to her will be a better idea.

toomuchlaundry · 29/11/2021 18:15

I wonder how many people who voted YABU have dealt with relatives with dementia

DaphneDeloresMoorhead · 29/11/2021 18:15

It would be better all round for you to rent an air bnb over the festive period nearby so you can visit her on chrimstas day, depending on the quality of the home you may be able to have lunch with her and spend the day.

Cherrycee · 29/11/2021 18:15

My dad had dementia and the most we did was bring him out for a couple of hours on Christmas day, but the nursing home was only a 20 minute drive away. He would come and have dinner with us and then we'd drop him back. Anything more than that is too much, disrupting their routine is not a good idea and can really distress them.

Making his mum travel a long distance and having her stay in a hotel is going to confuse her massively. It's a terrible idea. If she gets distressed (which she will) it won't be possible to just drop her back.

Has your DH actually talked to the nursing staff in the home? I can't imagine they'd recommend this.

I understand that he has good intentions but it has disaster written all over it. Is there any way you could all visit her instead, sometime before or after Christmas? Stay nearby for a few days, maybe bring her out for short periods of time?

toomuchlaundry · 29/11/2021 18:14

How bad is her dementia? Could this be confusing and unsettling for her?

Sweetmotherofallthatisholyabov · 29/11/2021 18:14

I think this is one of those situations where it's so off the wall and impractical you can support it because it will never happen. I can't imagine the nursing home supporting the plan. I'd be supportive and suggest a meeting with the nursing home to make sure you're ready to meet all her needs, and with the hotel in advance too. There are so many ways it's not going to happen that I think you're safe supporting. And you can ask questions in the meetings that hopefully will bring him around to the idea that it's just not feasible

Artichokeleaves · 29/11/2021 18:13

Oh OP and DH Flowers

He hasn't thought this through, although I understand why. It's very likely a very bad idea to take her out of her familiar space, routine and staff, and add to her confusion and disorientation. The travelling will be disorienting. Your house. A noisy busy hotel at night. A lot of change and confusion. Her dignity in needing washing and changing, which she will especially with the bathroom upstairs and lack of equipment and safe trained handling for her. If she has a fall, becomes ill and needs hospitalising she may then have issues going back to her nursing home place.

He's trying to meet his own needs and grief, my heart goes out to him, but he's doing this for him, not her, and he needs to put her first. Her safety, her feeling safe and oriented and with the confusion minimised, her dignity. He'd do a lot better to go up and stay in a hotel and do several visits to her over a couple of days in her familiar place.

Gilly12345 · 29/11/2021 18:13

I wouldn’t of thought removing this person from a nursing home is wise for their well-being, COVID mixing and her routein, surely being somewhere familiar is for the best with staff she is used to, removing her will probably confuse her.

Can’t you all visit her just before Christmas and maybe visit again between Christmas and New Year?

IncompleteSenten · 29/11/2021 18:12

He should talk to the home. They will be able to tell him all about his mum's needs and give their opinion on how she is likely to cope.
It may be less stressful for her if you all go spend some time with her at the home instead.

JustALittleHelpPlease · 29/11/2021 18:12

I'd be having a serious char with him about how he feels about cleaning his mother "down there". She is urine incontinent, she will need regular washing and he will have to do it. Does he really want to put him self and his mother in that position? Same for wiping after a poo. Dressing/undressing?

I understand his thinking but being a carer is tough when it is an unrelated adult, dignity is a big issue. Doing it for a parent is much more tough.

DaphneDeloresMoorhead · 29/11/2021 18:12

I also wonder if your DH has an unrealistic expectation of the severity of her dementia given that presumably at the moment you only make occasional visits for short periods.
Another thing he may not have considered and nobody has mentioned yet - does she wander ? Lots of people with dementia do and care homes that offer dementia care usually have extra security to prevent residents from getting out. If your MIL was to wake up in the night she may get out of the hotel room as there won't be anything to prevent her. This may result in her getting outside and her absence not being realised for some time. I work for the police and elderly people with dementia going missing at night is an all too frequent occurrence. Sadly they have ended up in fatalities.

cadburyegg · 29/11/2021 18:11

YANBU I can't believe that your DH is considering this especially considering the distance involved. My dad died in March after battling Alzheimer's for a few years. He was in a home last Christmas and we weren't able to see him due to restrictions and covid cases in the home but I know that my mum would never have suggested him come out for the day. He would have been confused, disorientated by the whole experience and possibly aggressive. It's not a nice thing for them to do. Even the Christmas before when he was still at home with mum he still found it disorientating coming to our house.

My ex's Nan also had dementia and I remember his mum took her out for a BH weekend once and she never did it again because it wasn't a nice experience for anyone.