Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not give Calpol/Nurofen for a fever in a 5yo?

64 replies

coffeepleeease · 29/11/2021 16:23

5yo DD gets a high temp with every virus/illness, but will not take Calpol/Nurofen. Can't pin her down to get it in, nor a suppository. Offe it in squash but she only has a few sips. When her temp is high she vomits. I try to keep her as cool as possible and let her body do its job, but is there any danger in not bringing a fever down with meds? Her temps often hit 39.5, can reach 40, then gradually come down and sit at 38-38.5 until the fever goes.

OP posts:
BadgerWatch · 29/11/2021 18:13

DD1 was a medicine refuser, moved tablets as soon as possible and she was fine with them. I've never felt as vindicated as when she was sick over the incredibly smug nurse who told me I wasn't forceful enough in getting medicine down her.

Bunnycat101 · 29/11/2021 18:00

If she’s ok in herself then I wouldn’t force it in at that age. Both of mine have generally been quite unwell once they’ve hit 39.5 and my medicine refusing 2yo can be rationalised with that medicine will make her feel better. Yours might just cope better if she’s quite happy to deal with the fever rather than taking the medicine.

The only time I’ve seen medics be wary of the actual number was when my 2yo was hitting 41 despite calpol. They were actively treating the fever in A&E then and not just the symptoms.

coffeepleeease · 29/11/2021 17:59

[quote PaperMonster]@coffeepleeease my daughter’s a medicine refuser - I’ve syringed it down her throat and she’s brought it straight back up. The last time she had a high temp, the GP said just to keep her cool and make sure she had plenty of fluids. He was an older chap and said that everything goes in circles and that this was what they used to recommend when he was a young GP and that he was happy that they were being advised to recommend that treatment again.[/quote]
Thank you 😊

OP posts:
PaperMonster · 29/11/2021 17:58

@coffeepleeease my daughter’s a medicine refuser - I’ve syringed it down her throat and she’s brought it straight back up. The last time she had a high temp, the GP said just to keep her cool and make sure she had plenty of fluids. He was an older chap and said that everything goes in circles and that this was what they used to recommend when he was a young GP and that he was happy that they were being advised to recommend that treatment again.

coffeepleeease · 29/11/2021 17:52

I will just say to all those saying "find a way", "be firm", etc, I am! She has had to be pinned down by 3 or 4 nurses for various hospital procedures- catheters, having blood taken, etc, and had to be sedated for a heart scan because she got herself that distressed she vomited everywhere and couldn't be pinned down. So if she doesn't want to be pinned down for Calpol, when there's only me to do it by myself, it's not happening!

OP posts:
coffeepleeease · 29/11/2021 17:48

@RoomOfRequirement

A high (less than 40) temp where she's fine in herself? I wouldn't stress about medicine.

But you say it is so high it makes her vomit and you still won't give her anything? That's really not great.

Not that I wont, believe me I've tried!
OP posts:
coffeepleeease · 29/11/2021 17:47

@OnlyFoolsnMothers

If she had a condition that required daily medicine you would find a way, you couldn’t give in. Just treat this the same way
She does have a condition where she has to take daily meds actually, and over time has got used to these meds. Sometimes she still puts up a fight about taking them, difference is she's not unwell so is more interested in bribery. When she's unwell with a high temp and has been vomiting, the Calpol comes back up anyway on the occasions I have managed to pin her down.
OP posts:
Kayjay2018 · 29/11/2021 17:43

@coffeepleeease calpol have brought out calpol melts so not a liquid you need to squirt in. They are age 6 plus so might be something to try once she is 6

RoomOfRequirement · 29/11/2021 17:33

A high (less than 40) temp where she's fine in herself? I wouldn't stress about medicine.

But you say it is so high it makes her vomit and you still won't give her anything? That's really not great.

Scrunchies · 29/11/2021 17:32

Some very uninformed people on this thread.

The degree of the fever does not correlate to the severity of the illness.

Having a fever of 39/40 doesn’t specifically put the child at risk of febrile convulsions- it’s actually the speed of onset/increase of the fever that risks febrile convulsions, alongside other factors. not just the number

Metallicalover · 29/11/2021 17:25

I'm always under the impression of treat the child not the temperature. Not everyone has thermometers, some aren't accurate etc so I always go by how the child is.
For antibiotics etc that's a different kettle of fish and they need to complete the course etc

SwanShaped · 29/11/2021 17:25

God no, don’t hold her nose and pump it into her mouth. That’s a horrible thing to do, to whoever suggested that. Like the other person wrote, high temps are not dangerous in themselves. It’s the speed at which a child changed temp that can cause a convulsion. And that includes temps coming down too. Follow the NICE guidelines about temps, which is that they are not dangerous. It’s a misconception. You only need to give calpol if she is distressed and in pain.

quinin · 29/11/2021 17:23

Just let the fever run if they are comfortable. It's not dangerous and an important part of a normal immune response.

One of my DC's gets super high fevers but copes well and I'll only give antipyretics if quite out of sorts.

OnlyFoolsnMothers · 29/11/2021 17:22

If she had a condition that required daily medicine you would find a way, you couldn’t give in. Just treat this the same way

OnlyFoolsnMothers · 29/11/2021 17:21

A 5yr old is not a toddler, surely she should understand it will make her feel better- it’s one spoon of sugar and that’s it.

Shuffleuplove · 29/11/2021 17:16

Calpol meltlets can be useful “you don’t have to swallow it but show me how strong your teeth are by biting it” and then it’s almost gone.

DontWantTheRivalry · 29/11/2021 17:15

I don’t treat high temperatures if my child is otherwise well. I treat the symptoms, not the fever.

If my child has a temp of 38.5 but is playing happily with toys, eating and drinking and generally being his usual mischievous self I just leave him.

Whereas if he had a temp of 38.2 and was lethargic, tired, disinterested in doing anything, just seeming generally unwell then I would give paracetamol/ibuprofen.

Chocolatewheatos · 29/11/2021 17:12

@EasyLikeSundays

Wow surprised at these responses. Temps of upper 39s or 40+ leave the child at high risk of fitting and potential brain damage. Using paracetamol etc to reduce the temp doesn't hinder the body's ability to fight a virus. Every time I've called the doc/111 etc with my daughter having temps as high as that they've taken it really seriously and investigated thoroughly.
Yes this. High temps are seriously dangerous, and you don't always know when you need treating. Even as an adult my husband has had to wrestle bedding off me because I have a high temp but feel cold and wrap myself up. A 5yo is not able to identify and understand the risks of a high temp. If I can get liquid codeine down my rottweillers throat you get it down your 5yo.
yikesanotherbooboo · 29/11/2021 17:05

It is horrible having this sort of struggle with a distressed child.I wouldn't necessarily give calpol/ nurofen for a fever but I would start to prepare your child for if she ever does need to take medicine. In a year or two ( possibly now) she wil be able to take tablets which might make her feel more in control. Minor illnesses , even if painful, such as tonsillitis, middle ear infection, bronchitis etc don't need antibiotics so with luck she will get away without this trauma until she is older. Giving a child medication can feel like an assault but there are times when it just has to happen and as a parent in that situation you just have to get on with it.

coffeepleeease · 29/11/2021 17:03

@willingtolearn

These are the NICE guidelines for treatment of fever in children :www.nice.org.uk/guidance/ng143

It is wrong to state that a high fever is always dangerous - the evidence shows that the height of a fever does NOT correlate to the severity of illness. Often viral throat infections and ear infections lead to very high fevers, but these are self limiting illnesses that need minimal treatment.

In terms of febrile convulsions, these present in a small percentage of children, usually at the start of an illness and are not prevented by using antipyretics (Ibuprofen/paracetamol)

Using antipyretics can be necessary in children with cardiac/renal disease or if a child is in pain. Their pain relief effect is also useful to help encouraging drinking or to promote comfort.

That link was really helpful, thank you
OP posts:
coffeepleeease · 29/11/2021 16:58

@OinkPinkPonk

It's bitter outside but opening a window is the best way to get it down. Have you tried Calpol in yoghurt?
I've tried it in everything I can think of. She's always off her food when she has a fever so isn't interested unfortunately
OP posts:
coffeepleeease · 29/11/2021 16:58

@EasyLikeSundays

Such differing opinions. I've done the nose hold to get antibiotics into my DD once. Zero guilt because otherwise she would have got seriously ill and admitted to hospital so it Was the lesser of 2 evils. If OP feels strongly enough she could do this with calpol etc but it's up to her how far she wants to go and how important it is. In all honesty I've never met a child who dislikes calpol it tastes lovely but OP if she really hates it that much and will actually vomit it up etc its probably not worth it and just let the fever run its course like others have said. Not something I'd be comfortable with but then my DD loves calpol so it's not usually a problem.
That's my thought, if I do on the rare occasion manage to get it into her she vomits anyway. She's had lots of hospital stays and procedures and I'm tough when I have to be!
OP posts:
OinkPinkPonk · 29/11/2021 16:57

It's bitter outside but opening a window is the best way to get it down.
Have you tried Calpol in yoghurt?

coffeepleeease · 29/11/2021 16:57

@DeepaBeesKit

The bit that would be bothering me is the vomiting when her temp is very high.

Is she otherwise lucid, alert, able to stay awake when like this?

Yes she's alert, just seems to be her body's reaction to a fever. She's done it since she was a baby!
OP posts:
DeepaBeesKit · 29/11/2021 16:52

Notmenotme
Not all children feel unwell at the same point. DS doesnt start feeling really poorly til he hits 39, DD can be miserable at 38.

I think febrile seizures in children are quite rare aren't they?