Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

No Religious Christmas cards

311 replies

mumofEandE · 28/11/2021 23:05

I was in one of those 'cheap card shops' and a customer asked if there were any Religious Christmas cards.
There weren't.
I am not a practising Christian/ or practising anything (!) but this really made me feel that this is wrong!

OP posts:
GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 29/11/2021 14:58

It’s just a shop, not the world authority on Christmas cards.

They can do what is commercially right for them

Classica · 29/11/2021 14:57

@BeaMends

I've just looked on the Tesco website. 41 different and none of them have a religious theme. Even the ones that show a snowy village scene don't have a church on them anywhere. In fact, the church is almost conspicuous by its absence.
Did you look though or are you fibbing?

www.tesco.com/groceries/en-GB/products/309141400

pastypirate · 29/11/2021 14:51

@DismantledKing

I never buy religious Christmas cards. The nativity is a nice story, but I don’t believe a word of it.
This
brieislife · 29/11/2021 14:41

@BeaMends

I've just looked on the Tesco website. 41 different and none of them have a religious theme. Even the ones that show a snowy village scene don't have a church on them anywhere. In fact, the church is almost conspicuous by its absence.
I’ve also looked. The 11th result has a star, the 14th has a dove and angels, and the 24th is specifically called ‘Tesco Traditional Religious Cards 10 Pack’ and features the nativity scene.

So I call bollocks.

steppemum · 29/11/2021 14:41

@beautifullymad

This year there are hardly any proper packs of Christian Christmas cards. I looked with my mum who always sends nativity cards. We looked hard. The only place we could find doing them and we got the last pack on the shelf was WHSmiths.
try asda. plenty in there!

Seriously, I alwyas buy ones with a link to nativity/3 kings/star of bethlehem etc rather than a robin and there are loads around.

bustersword · 29/11/2021 14:39

@BeaMends

I've just looked on the Tesco website. 41 different and none of them have a religious theme. Even the ones that show a snowy village scene don't have a church on them anywhere. In fact, the church is almost conspicuous by its absence.
Oh the horror!
ErrolTheDragon · 29/11/2021 14:33

@BeaMends

I've just looked on the Tesco website. 41 different and none of them have a religious theme. Even the ones that show a snowy village scene don't have a church on them anywhere. In fact, the church is almost conspicuous by its absence.
There is one religious pack, angels and doves. (Presumably you know the symbolism of the dove?)

www.tesco.com/groceries/en-GB/products/309141417

DH has taken over card-buying in our house - he makes sure they're totally non-religious, 'Seasons Greetings' rather than 'Happy Christmas' etc, so a lot of the tescos ones wouldn't pass muster with him.

BeaMends · 29/11/2021 14:20

I've just looked on the Tesco website. 41 different and none of them have a religious theme. Even the ones that show a snowy village scene don't have a church on them anywhere. In fact, the church is almost conspicuous by its absence.

DismantledKing · 29/11/2021 14:19

I never buy religious Christmas cards. The nativity is a nice story, but I don’t believe a word of it.

Ellen888 · 29/11/2021 14:17

"Are they wise because their lateness meant they could pick up bargain gifts in the January sales?(not wise though because they appear to have gone to lush and h Samuels for a newborn)"

GrinGrin

Blossomtoes · 29/11/2021 14:15

@mustlovegin

I don't understand how a Christmas card can be non-religious
Yet almost all of them are …
WorriedMumsDontSleep · 29/11/2021 14:09

Are they wise because their lateness meant they could pick up bargain gifts in the January sales?(not wise though because they appear to have gone to lush and h Samuels for a newborn)

Ellen888 · 29/11/2021 13:59

And what's the craic about the 3 Wise Men? They weren't around at Christmas - they didn't come until Epiphany which is a week or so later !

MadeOfStarStuff · 29/11/2021 13:54

You do rather sound like you’re trying too hard to be offended especially since you weren’t even the one looking for them!

Ellen888 · 29/11/2021 13:49

Plenty of Religious Cards on-line;

acnuk.org/shop-landing-page/

www.shrineshoponline.co.uk/collections/christmas-cards

WorriedMumsDontSleep · 29/11/2021 13:30

As Dave Gorman points out, everyone wants penguins and noone wants the three wise men.

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 29/11/2021 13:15

@Cryalot2

Surely Christmas is about the birth of Christ. I don't know of any church that sells anything . Most are places of worship. Online is a good place . The faith mission tends to sell such .
Our town centre church has a shop selling charity cards and other Christmas bits from late October every year. There are always some cards with the Nativity or 3 wise men, etc. It also has a cafe, which is usually a haven of peace after busy shops.
PlanktonsComputerWife · 29/11/2021 12:49

We live in a Muslim-majority area and no one has told us Christmas is being erased. Magnificent giant nutcrackers surrounding Santa's grotto, and trees going up everywhere. I am planning out a front garden display and it will be bright and it will be obnoxious!

Blackmagicqueen · 29/11/2021 11:38

'Aren't Christmas cards by their nature religious? People who don't celebrate a Christmas don't send them'

Hmm some Christians don't celebrate Christmas

depremesnil · 29/11/2021 11:36

@mustlovegin

that in a largely secular society it's not a surprise that the secular festival may have a bigger role for many

The UK is not a majority secular society, repeating this over and over will not make it true

Yes, sadly we still have a state religion.
BiBabbles · 29/11/2021 11:13

I've seen several religious looking Christmas cards just going past shops.

I'm with those who said it's likely a misunderstanding or the employee just didn't want to get into it what that customer meant by a religious card. That might be sad, but I can understand wanting to move things along quickly particularly if it was a small shop where what's on display is pretty self evident and leaving the counter may cause other customers to leave.

What matters is we celebrate it at the darkest time of the year - and that's why they put the celebration around the time of other deep winter festivals

While there are some theories that fusing Christian ideas with celebrations already going on in winter (though which celebration varies by theory), the earliest references to that date are largely more focused on when Jesus was conceived and then doing over-rudimentary maths that I think don't really understand how pregnancy works. There was some ideas that he must have been conceived either on the same date he died (this is said of a few Biblical and similar figures) or around the Spring Equinox and then just counted from there. I don't really think the early church that fixed the date had much purpose of ensuring it was in the darkest time of year, at least I've not seen much evidence for that, anymore than I think the move of All Saints Day from May to October really had much care for what season it was in.

Never heard or seen written one such objection.

Wrestling with the Bible has a long tradition, both in content and - even more in recent years - how the history of how they were created, copied, translation shifts, and such that made them into their current forms and how that is used by modern churches. The Christian deconstruction movements which have been growing for the last couple of decades both from devout Christians - possibly in response to the vocal issues with those who go on about it being literal and inerrant - and those who were raised in and either question aspects of or have left the religion.

The discussion around whether a child can really give consent to a deity is a common talking point, particularly in how that idea is used in some modern churches with how children of that age are viewed (that and whether Paul was one of the false prophets Jesus warned about as he practically ticks every box, that might actually be the most common talking point in recent years with more recognition of the denominations that exclude works attributed to him and some being of the opinion that certain churches follow Paul more than Jesus).

The archangel Gabriel explained God’s plan for her to conceive, and Mary gave her consent in the following words

Quoting the gospels as evidence of consent makes sense if you think they're literal and inerrant & that a deity can never be wrong.

If you consider they were anonymous for centuries before the church put 'as written by' on them, are currently thought to have been written at least decades if not longer after the events, that they were written in a language the apostles were unlikely to speak and that they were largely illiterate and the Luke excludes himself as an apostle (he knew Paul, not Jesus), that literacy in that time was often just knowing how to read and write one's name and be able to copy and that any manuscript study of the texts is a copy of a copy...of one of those copies, that even in those copies we can see changes that were made - thing written over - quoting scripture is the start of a discussion into the concept, not the end.

And there is nothing in early church history I've seen that suggests that the dating had anything to do with Christ being a light to the world. That's a nice modern interpretation which I think is lovely, but there is little evidence that the early church thought that when it fixed the date.

many Old Testament stories attributing deaths to acts of God were simply allegorical, or down to the primitive tribesmen of the time seeking explanations for natural or human events.

Many New Testament stories can be viewed as allegory as well - including Mary's consent.

It does not in the least follow that God shared their views or took any part in mass murder.

There are several mass murders attributed to his direct action along with those that were his direct command. Treating all of the bad things as allegory of natural phenomenons and 'primitive' people (like Jesus?) and all the nice things as real is part of why the deconstruction movement has been growing. Many can see how harmful it has been to the church to continuously erase and push aside the problems in the text - in content, creation, and on-going changes and uses - when it's still used as the standard and an icon of faith.

MaggieFS · 29/11/2021 11:13

I don't disagree but sadly it's the way of the world. My employer does cards for clients but makes sure they only say 'Season's Greetings' so as not to offend anyone who doesn't celebrate Christmas. Go figure.

mustlovegin · 29/11/2021 11:01

that in a largely secular society it's not a surprise that the secular festival may have a bigger role for many

The UK is not a majority secular society, repeating this over and over will not make it true

yellowflowersintherain · 29/11/2021 11:00

I usually try and get a mix of religious and non-religious Christmas cards. I haven't noticed any issues finding the religious ones. Maybe it depends what you class as religious? Some of mine have angels on them this year...

DeepaBeesKit · 29/11/2021 10:57

Moonmelodies don't know know? You are allowed to choose which bits of the Bible are factual and which allegorical/symbolic to suit your religious purpose. Grin