Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

No Religious Christmas cards

311 replies

mumofEandE · 28/11/2021 23:05

I was in one of those 'cheap card shops' and a customer asked if there were any Religious Christmas cards.
There weren't.
I am not a practising Christian/ or practising anything (!) but this really made me feel that this is wrong!

OP posts:
DeepaBeesKit · 29/11/2021 10:56

Christians do not say Jesus was born on 25th Dec, or try to hijack pagan Yule. Nobody knows his actual birthdate. We simply celebrate his birth at the time when the daylight is beginning to noticeably increase after the solstice on the 21st - because we regard Christ as the Light of the World. And Easter is held at the time of Jewish Passover, as that is the date of his crucifixion and resurrection.

I don't think anyone is picking holes in the fact that there is a Christian celebration of Christmas, simply pointing out there's an equally valid set of secular traditions too and expressing the opinion that in a largely secular society it's not a surprise that the secular festival may have a bigger role for many.

Chakraleaf · 29/11/2021 10:55

I don't have a problem with this!

Moonmelodies · 29/11/2021 10:55

Sorry I forgot, the bad stuff, floods etc, are merely allegorical.

Babdoc · 29/11/2021 10:43

moonmelodies, you have a wilfully negative view of God. The Jews addressed him as "Daddy" (abba), regarding Him as a loving parent figure.
They were not in the least afraid to complain to Him - try reading the psalms! God does not throw "tantrums" - and offered His own self, in the incarnation of Jesus, as a sacrifice in the ultimate act of love for His creation.
It was humans who tortured and murdered Him, not the other way around.
And many Old Testament stories attributing deaths to acts of God were simply allegorical, or down to the primitive tribesmen of the time seeking explanations for natural or human events.

Thousands of years ago, winning a battle = God must be smiting our enemies, whereas losing = God is punishing us.
It does not in the least follow that God shared their views or took any part in mass murder. One assumes He is more likely to have regarded it with revulsion and sadness.

ABCeasyasdohrayme · 29/11/2021 10:38

@Moonmelodies

For many people the Nativity element of Christmas can be distasteful, when you consider the coercive nature of Mary's impregnation, given the considerable power imbalance between a humble peasant girl and an omnipotent creator of universes with a history of violent tantrums.
I've never seen it put quite like that before... but you're not wrong 😂😂
ElvisPresleyHadABaby · 29/11/2021 10:36

@Moonmelodies

For many people the Nativity element of Christmas can be distasteful, when you consider the coercive nature of Mary's impregnation, given the considerable power imbalance between a humble peasant girl and an omnipotent creator of universes with a history of violent tantrums.
Grin they're not going to like this...
NovemberNovemberDarkNights · 29/11/2021 10:27

Supposedly being 'sad' because another customer couldn't find an item in the shop that's currently available in many shops is a massive over reaction & something we'd describe as attention seeking nonsense.

Moonmelodies · 29/11/2021 10:07

@Babdoc

moonmelodies, it is obvious you have never read the relevant Bible passage if you think Mary’s pregnancy was “coerced”. The archangel Gabriel explained God’s plan for her to conceive, and Mary gave her consent in the following words: “Behold the handmaid of the Lord. Be it unto to me according to thy word.” And Christians do not say Jesus was born on 25th Dec, or try to hijack pagan Yule. Nobody knows his actual birthdate. We simply celebrate his birth at the time when the daylight is beginning to noticeably increase after the solstice on the 21st - because we regard Christ as the Light of the World. And Easter is held at the time of Jewish Passover, as that is the date of his crucifixion and resurrection. HTH.
With the power imbalance, and God's reputation as a mass killer and tantrum thrower, she was hardly going to say anything different, was she?
Babdoc · 29/11/2021 10:04

moonmelodies, it is obvious you have never read the relevant Bible passage if you think Mary’s pregnancy was “coerced”.
The archangel Gabriel explained God’s plan for her to conceive, and Mary gave her consent in the following words:
“Behold the handmaid of the Lord. Be it unto to me according to thy word.”
And Christians do not say Jesus was born on 25th Dec, or try to hijack pagan Yule. Nobody knows his actual birthdate.
We simply celebrate his birth at the time when the daylight is beginning to noticeably increase after the solstice on the 21st - because we regard Christ as the Light of the World.
And Easter is held at the time of Jewish Passover, as that is the date of his crucifixion and resurrection.
HTH.

MrsSkylerWhite · 29/11/2021 09:57

Lots in the various charity shops. Presumably solely commercial ventures not also fulfilling a social need don’t stock them because there’s just not enough demand.

BewareTheBeardedDragon · 29/11/2021 09:56

@mustlovegin

What matters is we celebrate it at the darkest time of the year - and that's why they put the celebration around the time of other deep winter festivals

Some posters are bending over backwards to erase the fact that Christmas is a religious celebration.

If you bold the word 'fact' it makes it extra true.

I don't think anyone with any kind of critical thinking skills could argue that Christmas did not replace a similar existing festival - though of course these were also religious. Christmas is indeed a Christian festival, but many of the traditions do not have their root in Christianity, and these are largely the traditions which people seem to be holding onto most nowadays. Lights, trees, greenery, feasting. None of this is uniquely or originally Christian as part of the midwinter celebrations.

I watched Brian Cox's The Universe on iPlayer recently in which he pretty convincingly argues that the first gods were in fact the stars which are actually (fact) the source of all life in the universe, being the actual creators of all the elements other than hydrogen and helium, without which the universe would be nothing but a vast void with some gas floating around.

DeepaBeesKit · 29/11/2021 09:54

"Christmas" is a festival that encompasses several elements.

There's obviously a significant Christian element. But there are also strong midwinter festival elements which aren't really religious at all. Yule logs/Christmas trees, celebrations of seasonal animals/weather (Robins, snowmen etc). The oldest representations of Father Christmas are associated with midwinter feasting etc and are often secular rather than religious.

Given that most people in the UK aren't practising Christians/regular churchgoers, it's not really surprising that the secular aspects of the festival are more of a focus for most people.

CounsellorTroi · 29/11/2021 09:52

I’m not religious, but I still like to include Christian tradition in my Christmas. I have angels on my Christmas tree, a little crib on the hall table, listen to the carols from Kings……..

mustlovegin · 29/11/2021 09:47

For many people the Nativity element of Christmas can be distasteful, when you consider the coercive nature of Mary's impregnation, given the considerable power imbalance between a humble peasant girl and an omnipotent creator of universes with a history of violent tantrums

Ridiculous

echt · 29/11/2021 09:25

@Moonmelodies

For many people the Nativity element of Christmas can be distasteful, when you consider the coercive nature of Mary's impregnation, given the considerable power imbalance between a humble peasant girl and an omnipotent creator of universes with a history of violent tantrums.
I hope this is ironic.

Not least because the "many" claim.

Never heard or seen written one such objection.

Moonmelodies · 29/11/2021 09:15

For many people the Nativity element of Christmas can be distasteful, when you consider the coercive nature of Mary's impregnation, given the considerable power imbalance between a humble peasant girl and an omnipotent creator of universes with a history of violent tantrums.

mustlovegin · 29/11/2021 08:58

What matters is we celebrate it at the darkest time of the year - and that's why they put the celebration around the time of other deep winter festivals

Some posters are bending over backwards to erase the fact that Christmas is a religious celebration.

gogohm · 29/11/2021 08:38

I bought cards with a nativity scene from Asda last year, not bought any yet this year

supermoonrising · 29/11/2021 08:36

@WhatdoImean
The truth is... despite any claims to be Christian, I suspect the majority of people in the UK are secular
Most recent stats, including ONS, show that around 50% of Brits self-identify as “No Religion”.

WhatdoImean · 29/11/2021 08:24

The truth is... despite any claims to be Christian, I suspect the majority of people in the UK are secular. As a result "invasion" is simply people being born (you know, IN THE UK) and growing up with less deference to Church and state. If anyone wants to celebrate Christmas, Diwali, whatever, go ahead - knock yourselves out. Not for me to say you cannot.

The simple truth is that if people wanted to buy lots of religious cards, then shops would SELL lots of religious cards. Shops offer them, but they do not sell as well as more "neutral" cards.

Finally (and yes, this is a bit of a diversion :-) )- as noted, the early Christian church had a great habit of taking over existing festivals and "re-purposing" them - along with religious sites. Take somewhere where people had been meeting for the past couple of hundred years for the local druidic/wiccan faith and build a church there. Though... to be fair.... the Romans were the best at this kind of stuff, but that is another story.

MichaelMumsnet · 29/11/2021 08:16

Hi all. We've removed a post from this thread by a returning banned poster (and the posts which quoted it). We've banned them once again and hopefully they'll get the message this time.

TheCatWearsPrada · 29/11/2021 08:13

If you buy a card to celebrate a religious holiday and give to someone who follows the faith connected to that holiday then it's a religious card. Doesn't matter if it's a snowman or jesus

supermoonrising · 29/11/2021 08:10

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Quotes deleted post

MLMshouldbeillegal · 29/11/2021 08:01

You didn't look that hard then, there are religious cards being sold in many, many shops...

Yes I've just googled and in 2 minutes found them at Oxfam, Cancer Research, BHF, Tesco, John Lewis, Paperchase, WH Smith...

tallduckandhandsome · 29/11/2021 08:00

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Quotes deleted post