Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Pros and cons of being married?

57 replies

Wowwhatalife · 28/11/2021 22:57

I don’t mean in a romantic, emotional sense..just practical, money wise? What is there to be gained from being married? Especially if you have a child?
Are there and cons?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Hrpuffnstuff1 · 29/11/2021 17:51

www.brookings.edu/blog/social-mobility-memos/2017/03/27/in-europe-cohabitation-is-stable-right/

worldfamilymap.ifstudies.org/2017/files/WFM-2017-FullReport.pdf

Similar studies came to the same conclusion marriage is significantly more stable than cohabiting.

LuluBlakey1 · 29/11/2021 17:22

[quote RandomLondoner]So, our son won’t pass on British citizenship if he has children? He has a British birth certificate and two British parents?

I've just been googling this, as I know people in this position. (Two generations born outside the UK.) The second generation can apply for British citizenship if they do so before the age of 18 and have lived in the UK with their parents for three years.

They may also be able to apply until aged 18 if the first generation lived in the UK for at least three years before they were born, haven't digested the rules in detail.

www.gov.uk/apply-citizenship-british-parent/born-on-or-after-1-july-2006[/quote]
Thinking about it, it would be silly if people kept being able to pass it on (whatever country we are talking about) - there have to be some rules like must have lived in that country for x years as a child etc or you could be in a position where people could claim citizenship in countries because their great- grandparents were from there. For example my grandads' parents were Irish on both sides of the family- no one has lived there since. It would be silly if I could claim Irish citizenship.

thepeopleversuswork · 29/11/2021 17:14

I think it’s just saying that unhappy couples don’t get married and that creates selection bias.

That makes sense.

thepeopleversuswork · 29/11/2021 17:13

@Hrpuffnstuff1

Married people have relationship longevity. Co-habiting is 90 percent assured to fail.
hmm... what are you basing this 90% on?

Also the statistics don't bear out your assertion that married people have "relationship longevity". Nearly half of marriages fail.

I'm not saying people shouldn't get married but I'm questioning your assertion that being married automatically gives your relationship durability. Isn't it just that a marriage is harder to get out of than a cohabiting relationship? Doesn't necessarily mean the relationship is better, it often just means its too expensive and too cumbersome to untangle.

Hrpuffnstuff1 · 29/11/2021 16:41

Married people have relationship longevity.
Co-habiting is 90 percent assured to fail.

EmpressCixi · 29/11/2021 15:59

@thepeopleversuswork

Forget history, these studies are all done on men and women today. So the marriage contract where the Miller marries his daughter to the son of village baker so they can combine their business into a bread making family monopoly are long gone.

More generally, the common finding that married people are happier than non-married people is in part due to selection bias: happier people are more likely to get married.

You ask:
Why should happier people be more likely to get married?

I think this is obvious selection bias. You simply ask yourself who is most likely to get married....the couple that are miserable, or the couple that are happy? Doesn’t matter why the couple are unhappy...could be unemployment, health, or even they’re in abusive relationship. But point is that it makes perfect sense for unhappy couples to not get married and for happy couples to get married. I don’t think it’s saying that if a couple is happy, they are likely to get married. Because lots of happy couples never get married. I think it’s just saying that unhappy couples don’t get married and that creates selection bias.

thepeopleversuswork · 29/11/2021 15:48

@EmpressCixi

That's interesting.

But this in particular is interesting:

More generally, the common finding that married people are happier than non-married people is in part due to selection bias: happier people are more likely to get married.

Why should happier people be more likely to get married? Again I suspect this is ultimately about economics: historically marriage was about status and shoring up family wealth. People who were wealthier were more likely to attract a mate and to make a favourable marriage.

Nowadays marriage is still about economics albeit not as obviously.

But its still not clear to me why you would be considered more likely to get married because you were happier. If anything logic would suggest that a happier and more secure individual should be less likely to embark on something which severely curtails their freedom and (in the case of the higher-earning partner), their financial wellbeing.

EmpressCixi · 29/11/2021 14:50

@thepeopleversuswork
Found an interesting series from 2020. Apparently there is a gender gap where women are usually happier than men. Opening paragraph

“The research—based on the work of scholars around the world—finds consistent patterns in the determinants of life satisfaction across millions of respondents. These include income (yes it matters but not as much as you might think), health (matters a lot), employment, families and friendships, and age (there is a mid-life dip in well-being that holds across most people and countries around the world). A question that always comes up, though, is “are women happier than men?” The answer is “yes, but it’s complicated”—and at times in surprising ways.”

And a paragraph on marriage specifically that was interesting, though a bit obvious that if you’re a woman coerced into marriage by societal expectations, you’re not likely to be happy.

“We also found that the typically positive links between life satisfaction and marriage were much weaker in the same countries with compromised gender rights, where marriage is often an imposed norm rather than a choice. Indeed, it was the married men who were happier than the unmarried in these countries, not the married women. More generally, the common finding that married people are happier than non-married people is in part due to selection bias: happier people are more likely to get married. By construction most cross-section studies—which are at one point in time—are simply comparing the higher happiness levels of those individuals who married each other versus those who did not marry.”
www.brookings.edu/essay/are-women-happier-than-men-do-gender-rights-make-a-difference/

EmpressCixi · 29/11/2021 14:39

@thepeopleversuswork
Yes, think we can do better, interesting though the Men’s Health article did not compare men vs women. It says
“The study looked at 1,366 people who weren't married before participating in the survey, got married at some point during, and stayed married. Researchers compared the subjects to a control group who was demographically alike in every way other than being married.

The results: “People, on average, aren't happier following marriage than they were before marriage, but they are happier than they would have been if they stayed single,” says Stevie C. Y. Yap, a doctoral candidate in the Department of Psychology at MSU and one of the study authors.”

Of course, it’s only a small sample and they’re all American. Can’t assume marriage affects everyone the same everywhere in world! I will have a browse.

Bells3032 · 29/11/2021 14:16
  • For IHT it's not just the actual tax amount but also you get automatic access to all their finances as opposed to having to wait for the paperwork to clear
  • there can be tax breaks if one of you earns significantly more than the other
  • would also give you access to certain benefits at the point of death
  • For women having children whether you have an amazing career or not a woman's earning potential drops by around 40% by having children so marriage provides protection for her as otherwise the partner can walk away without having to provide financial support other than basic child maintaince (and even then that can be difficult).

Medically speaking

  • you have the automatic right to make medical decisions if the other one is incapacitated.
  • husband is automatically recognised as a child's father at birth - if not married and something happens to the mother he cannot make medical decisions for the child and will have to go to court to be put on the birth cert and gain legal rights (a very rare thing but could happen) or the mother can cause difficulties in having the name added to the cert if the relationship breaks up
thepeopleversuswork · 29/11/2021 13:49

@Minceandonions

My DH and I got married mainly because we don't want kids and felt that society might take us less seriously because of that. So we got married to cement ourselves, formally, as a 'proper couple'. We don't think like this, but I know others do.
genuinely curious... why do you care what other people think of your relationship?

I'm not having a go... but at some level I can't help thinking that this is one of the worst reasons to get married and if people steered clear of this approach they would be more likely to get married for the right reasons.

If it works for you fair enough, but I wouldn't want my daughter to get married just to keep up appearances. It's such a huge decision with such massive ramifications.

TractorAndHeadphones · 29/11/2021 13:15

Also to add next of kin , access fo partners stuff upon death etc etc.
Wills can be changed so not really a firm commitment.

TractorAndHeadphones · 29/11/2021 13:14

If you’re foreign (like me) makes a lot of admin etc easier in terms of rights across both countries.
No point if no children and both sides have own assets.

Minceandonions · 29/11/2021 13:14

My DH and I got married mainly because we don't want kids and felt that society might take us less seriously because of that. So we got married to cement ourselves, formally, as a 'proper couple'.
We don't think like this, but I know others do.

Simonjt · 29/11/2021 12:56

Finances really.

To be honest my husband would have been better off not marrying me, he doesn’t have children and he owned two mortgage free properties. Where as I have a huge mortgage and I’m a parent.

thepeopleversuswork · 29/11/2021 12:46

@EmpressCixi

Grin

That's quite funny.

I've definitely seen other data which suggests that overall married men are happier than single men but single women are happier than married women. Again, I don't think that controlled for finances, which is the most important variable in my view. But its not hard to make a reasonable hypothesis as to why that might be so....

I've found something from the highly reputable Men's Health Grin but sure we can do better than that.
www.menshealth.com/health/a19516451/why-married-men-are-happier/

I do think its ironic though that while women tend to be much more fixated than men are on getting married, there's an increasing body of evidence that marriage generally makes men much happier than women.

EmpressCixi · 29/11/2021 12:04

@thepeopleversuswork
Interesting. It appears the “study” I remember seeing in the news was really a book by someone called Dolan. And he got his facts wrong!
I found this article saying that he had misinterpreted happiness in marriage in the data. The surveyors recorded married women saying they were happy with “spouse present” and then married women saying they were “fucking miserable” when the survey listed “spouse absent”. Dolan apparently thought this meant the married women lied and said they were happy when their spouse was in the room, and then told the truth when their spouse was out the room. Unfortunately, spouse present means they are living together, and spouse absent means the spouse is away- long distance, military tour/deployment, sick in hospital etc.
www.vox.com/future-perfect/2019/6/4/18650969/married-women-miserable-fake-paul-dolan-happiness

So I don’t know anymore whether marriage makes women unhappy at all! I think I will need to go to the actual data...which they say is some American Survey of Time Use.

EmpressCixi · 29/11/2021 11:52

@thepeopleversuswork
From what I remember, the study was not very robust to begin with even though the news reported it widely. I do remember it had limitations on controls as you rightly suspected. You raise all very good points. I will go and find it and link it, so we can revisit it.

thepeopleversuswork · 29/11/2021 11:47

@EmpressCixi

So it’s clear if you are childfree, likely to be happier single. But if you have children, likely to be happier if married.

Interesting... but can't help feeling that doesn't tell the whole story.

I understand why "single women with children" would be near the bottom of the list but does that control for financial status? Presumably the main reason why "single women with children" is at the bottom is that generally they are women who have been cohabiting with someone who has walked off without giving them any money? (which may account for the majority in that category).

I'm technically single (in that I'm not married) with a child but am financially self-sustaining and I definitely think I've got the best of all possible worlds.

I'd hazard a guess that a lot of women who have done well out of divorce would not consider themselves to be that unhappy either.

The marital status of a woman is only relevant where it affects her financial wellbeing/security.

In and of itself I doubt being or unmarried has much bearing on happiness.

JustLyra · 29/11/2021 11:34

Marriage generally comes into its own when the shit hits the fan.

My DH was widowed young when his first wife died.

Being married made him entitled to Widowed Parents Allowance (it’s changed now, but is still worth £3500 in a lump sum, then £350 a month for 18 months) which really helped when he was taking time off work/changing hours/needing extra childcare etc.

It made a difference with inheritance tax. Also for them her solicitor made a cock up with her will and luckily things reverted to DH anyway or that could have been a proper nightmare.

It’s seemingly small things that can make the big difference

VikingOnTheFridge · 29/11/2021 11:27

It's also very dependent on priorities and individual circumstances. So eg a woman who has her own career and is the higher earner might still decide marriage or CP is in her best interests if her partner is several years older, to avoid a situation where IHT has to be paid after the death of the first partner rather than the second. If the family home is only worth 90k, probably not a concern. It really varies.

EmpressCixi · 29/11/2021 11:15

@WaterBottle123

No advantages for women with their own careers, makes them financially vulnerable and also married women are generally less happy.
Agree. But if you want children marriage is good protection. A lot of couples split up when the woman is pregnant or has a newborn, which means she is on low maternity pay.

In addition, the study regarding happiness in women found the following order for happiness
Single women no children
Married women no children
Married women with children
Single women with children

So it’s clear if you are childfree, likely to be happier single. But if you have children, likely to be happier if married.

PassingByAndThoughtIdDropIn · 29/11/2021 11:13

Civil Partnership is almost identical to marriage in the UK (there are a few minor differences, most notably that adultery isn't grounds for dissolution (but almost no one divorces for adultery on paper anyway)) but may not be treated the same overseas, so if you want to travel (especially to countries where sex outside marriage is a criminal offence) you should double check the rules.

The positive of marriage is that it unites your finances. That is also the negative.

The poster who said it's a financial zero sum game between the couple is right to some extent, but there are also Inheritance tax, married couple's tax allowance and bereavement allowance advantages.

WaterBottle123 · 29/11/2021 11:03

No advantages for women with their own careers, makes them financially vulnerable and also married women are generally less happy.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 29/11/2021 10:52

Civil partnership just avoids the label marriage nowadays I think

Swipe left for the next trending thread